Skip to content
Atlas of Saints
Writings · Written by this author8 sections

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters

By Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Complete 8-chapter distillation of Saint Anselm’s Preface, Books I and II of Cur Deus Homo (Why God Became Man), and 89 monastic and archiepiscopal letters from Bec and Canterbury.

Who wrote it
Written by this author
Date
1098 (Letters 1060–1109; 1909 Edinburgh edition)
Edition
Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909) · Public domain
Read section 1Every section is free to read

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Book summary

Book overview

Saint Anselm of Canterbury (1033–1109) united rigorous rational inquiry with unyielding fidelity to God's law across both his theology and his thirty-year ministry as monk, prior, abbot, and archbishop. In his dialogue Cur Deus Homo (Why God Became Man) and his eighty-nine letters from Bec and Canterbury, a single moral and metaphysical principle governs both heaven and earth. Every rational will owes total obedience to God. God's supreme honor cannot be violated without either voluntary restitution or just punishment. Anselm set aside historical appeals to Christ so as to answer unbelievers by necessary reason alone. Then he demonstrates that because even the smallest sin steals infinite honor from God that no debt-bound human creature can repay, human salvation required the Word of God to assume true human nature from Adam's race in one Person. In addition, he can offer an unowed, infinitely precious bodily death whose merited reward is bestowed upon His human brothers. The same rule of the upright will animates Anselm's letters. This involves forming monks by patient kindness rather than blows. It also involves extinguishing intrusive temptations by quiet mental redirection, and enduring two exiles under Kings William Rufus and Henry I rather than surrender the Church's spiritual freedom to royal custom.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters: book overview” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm#atlas-answer

Section guide

Choose a section.

Every section is open to read
  1. 01

    Why God Became Man: Unbelievers' Objections, the Devil's Claim, and Christ's Free Obedience (Preface and Book I, Chapters I–X)

    Anselm and Boso reasoned as though nothing were known of Christ. Then they clear the ground for proving the necessity of the Incarnation by showing that poetic parallels fail without rational necessity. No creature could redeem humanity. The devil held no just claim over sinners. The sinless Christ died freely through steadfast righteousness.

  2. 02

    Sin as Stolen Honor, the Debt of Justice, and the Fallen Angels (Book I, Chapters XI–XVIII)

    Sin robs God of the honor of an upright will. Moreover, cosmic justice cannot leave sin unpunished without satisfaction (lest wickedness be freer than righteousness). Therefore, every sin requires either punishment or superadded restitution. In this way, redeemed humanity may complete the heavenly city and outnumber the fallen angels.

  3. 03

    The Weight of Sin and Human Inability to Repay God (Book I, Chapters XIX–XXV)

    Humanity cannot enter heaven without paying full satisfaction for sin. Yet no mere human can ever pay that debt. This is because every good work is already owed to God, a single sin against God's will outweighs infinite created worlds. Human helplessness is self-inflicted guilt. This proves that salvation is impossible without Christ.

  4. 04

    Humanity's Purpose and the Necessity of a God-Man From Adam's Race (Book II, Chapters I–XI)

    The aim here is to fulfill His unchangeable plan for rational human nature to enjoy Him forever in soul and body. God freely binds Himself to save humanity through one Person who is both perfect God and perfect man (God the Word born of a virgin of Adam's race) who cannot sin and owes no penalty of death. Yet he can freely lay down His life as an unowed gift greater than all creation.

  5. 05

    The Infinite Worth of Christ's Voluntary Death and the Harmony of Mercy and Justice (Book II, Chapters XII–XXII)

    The sinless God-Man's voluntary death is a good infinitely outweighing all human sins. Therefore, it pardons even His ignorant executioners, and purifies the Virgin Mary beforehand through faith without compulsion. In addition, she earns a reward from the Father that the Son freely transfers to humanity, uniting mercy and justice.

  6. 06

    Letters From the Cloister: Friendship, Monastic Counsel, and Service at Bec (Letters, Parts I–II, Nos. 1–16)

    Anselm's letters as monk and Abbot of Bec reveal his spiritual theology of friendship, gentle monastic pedagogy, Augustinian defense of Latin and Greek Trinitarian terms. Urgent calls to renounce worldly warfare and harsh severity for humble obedience and perceptible kindness.

  7. 07

    The Burden of Canterbury, First Exile, and Appeals to Pope Paschal II (Letters, Part III, Nos. 17–42)

    Anselm's archiepiscopal letters defend his tearful submission to Canterbury against charges of greed, and explain his refusal to surrender Church lands or papal obedience under William Rufus and Henry I. Moreover, they contrast sevenfold pride with indivisible humility.

  8. 08

    The Investiture Struggle With King Henry I, Church Reform, and Final Counsel (Letters, Part III, Nos. 43–89)

    During his second exile and final years at Canterbury, Anselm defends episcopal jurisdiction and Canterbury's primacy against King Henry I and Thomas II of York, urges rulers from Ireland to Jerusalem to govern justly. Teaches how upright will and quiet redirection defeat temptation. Moreover, he reconciles Greek and Latin Christological terms.

Whole-book summary

Across the two books of Cur Deus Homo and the three parts of his correspondence, Anselm's thought and pastoral life form one continuous causal arc. Anselm is formed at Bec in the conviction that faith must precede and guide rational inquiry into divine mysteries. Then he first governed souls as monk, prior, and abbot by inner love, gentle persuasion, and the upright intention of the will rather than servile fear (Chapter 6). Called to the archiepiscopal throne of Canterbury in 1093. In response, he confronted Norman royal customs under William Rufus and Henry I that treated bishoprics, abbeys, and church revenues as royal property. Anselm had promised at baptism and ordination to obey God's law rather than earthly custom. Therefore, he refused simoniacal payments, defended Canterbury's tenants, appealed to the Roman See at Rockingham. Twice went into exile rather than consent to lay investiture, royal homage for church offices, or royal fines on clergy (Chapters 7 and 8).

During his first exile, Anselm completed Cur Deus Homo in the province of Capua (Chapters 1–5). Anselm rejects the older view that God owed the devil a legal ransom. Then he marked out sin as stealing the honor due to God's will. God's justice cannot leave disorder unaddressed and humans already owe God all future obedience. Therefore, humanity stood like a servant who threw himself into a pit. Wholly unable to pay an infinite debt yet wholly guilty for that inability. Only a God-Man (true God possessing infinite worth and true man of Adam's virgin stock owing no debt of sin) could freely give His bodily life to God's honor. Moreover, he could transfer His merited reward to fallen humans. Finally, in his letters to monks, nuns, bishops, and rulers from Ireland and the Orkneys to Jerusalem, Anselm applied this theology of the upright will and the one Person of Christ to monastic conversion, cognitive mastery over temptation, metropolitan unity, and the harmony of Greek and Latin Fathers (Chapters 6–8).

Edition and source notes
  • **Primary Admitted Source Edition**: Saint Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury, *Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters* (*The Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature*, Edinburgh: John Grant, 1909; digitized University of Toronto copy `curdeushomo00anseuoft`, lines 827–9974).
  • **Chapters 1–3 (`827..3115`)**: *St. Anselm's Preface* (`pp. xxvii–xxviii`) and *Cur Deus Homo*, Book I, Chapters I–XXV (`pp. 1–60`), establishing the dialogue with Boso, the method of reasoning with Christ set out of sight as though nothing were known of Him, the refutation of the devil's legal claim, sin as stolen honor requiring superadded satisfaction or punishment, the replacement of fallen angels from humanity, the infinite gravity of opposing God's will, and human inability to repay the debt of sin.
  • **Chapters 4–5 (`3116..4936`)**: *Cur Deus Homo*, Book II, Chapters I–XXII (`pp. 61–110`), demonstrating humanity's creation for immortal blessedness, the necessity of a God-Man born of a Virgin from Adam's race uniting two complete natures in one Person, Christ's voluntary unowed death of infinite worth, the retroactive salvation of even His ignorant executioners, the transfer of the Son's merited reward to human sinners, and the irredeemability of the fallen angels.
  • **Chapter 6 (`4937..5878`)**: *Selections from the Letters of St Anselm*, Part I (*Written when a Simple Monk*, Letters 1–14, `pp. 111–130`) and Part II (*Written when Abbot of Bec*, Letters 15–16, `pp. 130–135`).
  • **Chapter 7 (`5879..7766`)**: *Selections from the Letters of St Anselm*, Part III (*Written when Archbishop of Canterbury*, Letters 17–42, `pp. 136–185`).
  • **Chapter 8 (`7767..9974`)**: *Selections from the Letters of St Anselm*, Part III (Letters 43–89, `pp. 186–244`).

Passages from the work

“You have not yet considered of what weight sin is.”

Cur Deus Homo, Book I, chapter XXI (lines 2595–2596) · verified

“To sin is nothing else than not to render to God His due.”

Cur Deus Homo, Book I, chapter XI (lines 1661–1662) · verified

“Let his whole body be clothed from the crown of his head to the sole of his foot with the skin of your Anselm, and his mouth is mine.”

Selection from his Letters, Part II, Letter 16 to Prior Henry (lines 5855–5857) · verified