Section VIII · Location 8 of 8
Section 8 · Open to readFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury
Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)
The Investiture Struggle With King Henry I, Church Reform, and Final Counsel (Letters, Part III, Nos. 43–89)
Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 8 summary
During his second exile and final years at Canterbury, Anselm defends episcopal jurisdiction and Canterbury's primacy against King Henry I and Thomas II of York, urges rulers from Ireland to Jerusalem to govern justly. Teaches how upright will and quiet redirection defeat temptation. Moreover, he reconciles Greek and Latin Christological terms.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 8 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “The Investiture Struggle With King Henry I, Church Reform, and Final Counsel (Letters, Part III, Nos. 43–89)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/8#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
During his second exile in Normandy, Archbishop Anselm learned that King Henry I was demanding money from the prior and monks of Canterbury. Those monks already owed money to creditors and lacked bare daily needs. Anselm begged Bishop Gondulph of Rochester to warn the king that monks own nothing, not even themselves. Furthermore, Anselm dared not let a custom of taking money from monks begin. Anselm recorded courteously to King Henry before leaving Bec prior to the feast of the Assumption of the Blessed Mary. Then he prayed that the king might rule on earth so as to reign among the angels. In addition, he asked him to leave Canterbury's property untouched. To Prior Ernulph and the Canterbury monks, Anselm explained that he had to wait for the king's reply. He urged the monks and young boys to guard their hearts according to their monastic rule. Moreover, he asked that his young nephew, also named Anselm, stay with them to study theology.
While abroad, Anselm also settled a dispute between two monasteries over a single monk. That monk had bound himself by an earlier clerical promise to Abbot Gerontius and by a later monastic vow to St. Peter's at Carnotes. Anselm warns both abbots not to destroy the monk's soul by pulling him in two directions. Then he reminded Gerontius of King Solomon's judgment between two mothers claiming one living child. The true mother preferred to see her son live in another woman's arms rather than die in her own. Anselm therefore urged Gerontius to prove himself a true spiritual mother by letting the monk live in peace at Carnotes.
King Henry soon wrote that he would rather have Anselm in his kingdom than any man on earth, if only Anselm would live with him as Archbishop Lanfranc had lived with Henry's father, William the Conqueror. Anselm answered plainly that neither at his baptism nor at his ordinations had he ever promised to keep the customs of Henry's father or Archbishop Lanfranc. Instead, he promised to obey the law of God and his sacred office. Henry restored all property seized from Canterbury since Anselm left and allowed him to live by God's law. In that case, Anselm would gladly serve him above every prince on earth. Otherwise, Henry would have to answer to God for carrying both the royal power and the primacy of the Church. There Scripture warns that "mighty men shall be mightily tormented." Slanderers claimed that Anselm acted on his own authority, allowed bad clergy to ruin churches, and gave churches to laymen. In response, Anselm instructed the monk Orduvinus to reply that they lied. Anselm obeyed the Roman council's excommunication against lay investiture, suffered exile precisely to stop clerical abuses, and leased manors to laymen only as bailiffs and stewards with no power to appoint or remove priests.
From exile, Anselm continued to guide converts, bishops, and restless monks at home. Anselm heard that severe illness had driven the learned scholar Warner to become a novice at Canterbury under Prior Ernulph. Then he assured him that a conversion begun through fear of death is no less precious to God when pursued with fervent love. In the same way, Saint Paul was converted by force. He urged Warner to turn his secular learning to God's glory and to read the letter Anselm had once written to the novice Lanzo. To Rainald, who had bravely refused an uncanonical bishopric for the sake of truth, Anselm wrote that a clean conscience in poverty is far better than longing to regain as an earthly reward what he had spurned for righteousness. The Canterbury monks Farman, Orduvinus, and Benjamin begged to travel across foreign lands to join him. In response, Anselm forbade them because robbers on the roads were stripping English monks of their horses and goods. Anselm directed them to consult Prior Ernulph (whom he had sent as another self) and Bishop Gondulph. He also forbade Farman to move elsewhere lest he scatter the flock. He also rebuked Benjamin for rashly claiming his soul would perish without speaking to Anselm face to face. In addition, he assured Orduvinus that he stayed away not from fear of death or bodily injury. However, to avoid setting a slavish precedent for future archbishops.
Even after King Henry received Anselm into peace in Normandy and promised to restore his archbishopric, a new royal abuse arose in England. Priests had broken the decrees of the Council of London. Which forbade clergy to marry or keep wives. King Henry began punishing those priests by taking money fines from them. Anselm protested that such a practice was unheard of in God's Church. By divine law, judging and punishing spiritual offenses belongs strictly to each bishop in his diocese or, if bishops neglect their duty, to the archbishop and primate. Anselm warned Henry that money taken through such a sin would harm his earthly kingdom far more than it helped. Anselm met Henry at the Eagle's Castle. Then he recorded again because months had passed without the king sending his promised ambassador to Rome. Anselm warned that keeping the Church separated from its shepherd displeased God even more than seizing revenues. Then he asked Henry to set an early date. In addition, he declared that he dared not delay sending his own envoy past Christmas. Meanwhile, he warned the monk Guarnerius that a lukewarm novice rarely becomes a fervent monk. Moreover, he urged him to live each day as if preparing to die and give account to God. At Henry's request for a trusted go-between, Anselm sent his close friend Brother Gislebert, a monk of Bec, reported that his envoys Baldwin and William had already left for Rome. In addition, he assured the king that Pope Paschal II was canonically elected and accepted by the whole Catholic Church. By contrast, a rival antipope at Rome was a plant not planted by the Heavenly Father that would soon be rooted up.
As the English suffragan bishops (the diocesan bishops under Canterbury's authority) suffered royal pressure, they finally wrote to Anselm promising to stand with him in God's cause. Anselm rejoiced at their newfound courage, and explained that he had to wait for his messengers to return from Rome before crossing to England. Declined their offer to send delegates to him. Declared that he would not consent to evil even to save his life. Anselm sends his Rome-bound envoys through Lyons. Then he asked Archbishop Hugh of Lyons to advise them and Pope Paschal II on the remaining dispute. Even if King Henry gave up investing bishops and abbots with their churches, he still insisted on taking feudal homage from elected prelates and keeping clergy who had already been uncanonically invested and consecrated.
During this wait and after his return, Anselm balanced strict canon law with pastoral care. Anselm thanks Abbess Eulalia and her daughters for their prayers. Then he reminded them that true obedience wills what a superior desires even when unseen, so long as it does not oppose God. He also warned them not to ignore small faults. Indeed, "he who contemneth small things shall fall by little and little", and disobedience alone drove humanity from paradise. King Henry asked through the Bishop-elect of Winchester whether Bishop Hervey of Bangor could be moved to a bishopric in the province of Lyons. This is because that bishopric where he had been consecrated was ruined. In response, Anselm replied that canon law forbids transferring a consecrated bishop to another province without long joint deliberation, the consent of the archbishops and bishops of both provinces, and the authority of the Pope. He warned the nun Mabilia not to leave her cloister to visit worldly relatives who neither needed her spiritual help nor aided her vows. This reminded her that relatives could visit her at the monastery if they wished. A disgraced man brought Queen Matilda's seal and letter asking Anselm to testify to his excuse before the king. In response, Anselm gently refused, explaining that he could not bear witness to what he had neither heard nor seen or vouch for a stranger's character. Soon after returning to England amid universal joy, Anselm wrote to Abbot Helgotus of St Andaenus confirming the report that King Henry had entrusted the whole kingdom and royal possessions to Anselm's care. As a result, Anselm's word was obeyed like the king's own. Even so, Anselm added that he used this power sparingly while growing weak in body.
Alexander I succeeded his devout late brother to the throne of Scotland. In response, Anselm promised Canterbury's prayers for his brother's soul. He also commended the Canterbury monks sent to Scotland at his late brother's request. He also urged the new king to rule himself first like King David. In doing so, he showed strict justice to the wicked and gentle kindness to the good.
In a long pastoral letter to a guardian named Robert and his six spiritual sisters and daughters (Seit, Edit, Hydit, Luveris, Virgit, and Godit) Anselm explained how the human will and memory work in spiritual warfare. Every action deserves praise or blame before God solely from the intention of the will, which is upright when it submits to God's will. Bad thoughts or sudden impulses of lust, anger, envy, or pride enter the mind. In response, a Christian must neither argue directly with the bad thought nor grieve gloomily over its presence. The human mind remembers whatever pleases or grieves it far more than what it treats with indifference. Therefore, grieving over a bad thought only fixes it deeper in memory. Instead, one should immediately turn the mind to a good, useful thought or prayer and treat the bad suggestion with quiet contempt. In doing so, he knows that unconsented impulses do not count as sin. In companion letters, Anselm warned Turold, a monk of Bec, that worldly honors only increase the soul's thirst. By contrast, the cloister is a paradise on earth for those who never look back. He also reminded the Lady Basilia that every choice in life takes a step either upward toward heaven or downward on the much faster road to hell. In addition, he advised Abbot Lambert of St. Bertinus neither to seek the Archbishopric of Rheims on his own nor to resist if the Abbot of Cluny (to whom alone Lambert owed monastic obedience) commanded him to accept it.
Looking across the Irish Sea, Anselm wrote twice to Muriardachus, the King of Ireland. Anselm praises the peace Muriardachus had established. Then he reminded him that God holds kings accountable not only for the wrongs they commit. However, also for the public evils they fail to correct. He urged the king to abolish two grave abuses in Ireland. First, men were divorcing their lawful wives without cause. In doing so, he lived incestuously with close relatives, and trading wives with other men just as people trade one horse for another. Second, bishops were being ordained at random without any fixed diocese or flock. Moreover, he consecrated by a single bishop like an ordinary priest rather than by at least three bishops as canon law requires. Anselm also explained that the monk Brother Cornelius could not travel to Ireland. This is because he had to care for his very elderly father.
At home, Anselm combined kindness toward aging or zealous monks with firm defense of Canterbury's primacy—its chief authority over all bishops in Britain. The elderly, frail cellarer Odo asked to resign his stewardship before dying. In response, Anselm told him that while people must abandon bad deeds before death, they must persevere in good service to the end. Indeed, God asks only what his weakened strength allows. Juhel reported that his uncle Godfrid practiced severe fasts, vigils, and bodily hardships. In response, Anselm advised Godfrid to moderate them if they caused sickness and never to look down on those who fasted less. This is because God prizes a humble, loving heart above bodily exercises. Meanwhile, after Archbishop Gerard of York died. The newly elected Thomas II of York delayed coming to Canterbury for consecration. Tried to let the Bishop-elect of St. Andrews in Scotland be consecrated at York before Thomas himself was consecrated. Moreover, he sent envoys to Rome seeking the pallium (the woolen band symbolizing an archbishop's authority) without professing obedience to Canterbury. Anselm ordered Thomas to appear at Canterbury on September 24. Moreover, he forbade the St. Andrews consecration, since Thomas could not give pastoral authority he did not yet possess. Anselm recorded to Pope Paschal II. Then he asked him to withhold the pallium from Thomas until he submitted at Canterbury. He also noted that the Bishop of London's separate request for a pallium had no historical basis. He also warned Paschal that King Henry was threatening to resume royal investitures. This is because Paschal reportedly allowed the King of Germany to grant church investitures without excommunication. Speaking as Archbishop of Canterbury and Primate of all Britain, Anselm then formally forbade Thomas to act as a priest. Moreover, he placed all bishops of Britain under perpetual anathema (solemn exclusion from the Church) if they consecrated him or recognized him before he made the same profession of obedience that his predecessors Thomas I and Gerard had made. In a brief note to King Henry on behalf of a monk from M., Anselm also warned the king not to anger God. He did this by appointing unworthy pastors through bad advisers.
Anselm recorded with fatherly grief to a noblewoman who had thrown off her religious habit to live in sin with a mortal lover. Then he contrasted the pure peace of Christ, her immortal Royal Spouse, with the fear and shame of carnal lust. He dismantled the excuse that she had never been consecrated by a bishop or read a formal vow before witnesses. This involves wearing the religious habit in public and private was itself an undeniable profession that had made thousands of women and men saints before the newer ceremony existed. Casting it off made her an apostate. Anselm promised that Christ still waited to welcome her back as a chaste penitent spouse. At the same time, her earthly lover would soon despise or abandon her. Then he begged her to trample her worldly clothes underfoot. In addition, he put her religious habit back on before the Church punished her.
Across his remaining letters to bishops and rulers, Anselm addressed diocesan discipline and Christian kingship from Winchester and Dublin to Jerusalem and the Orkney Islands. Anselm sent word to William, Bishop-elect of Winchester. In doing so, he offered to ordain him priest at the next Ember days and consecrate him bishop the following day. Later protested to King Henry when the king banished William from England for refusing uncanonical consecration by the Archbishop of York, warned Henry that banishing William robbed Canterbury of its metropolitan right. Anselm learns that Bishop Samuel of Dublin had expelled monks from their monastery, given away church goods bestowed by archbishops. Had a metropolitan cross carried before him on journeys against canon law. Then he asked Bishop Malchus of Waterford to deliver a written rebuke to Samuel in person. To King Baldwin I of Jerusalem, Anselm wrote that ruling the holy city where the prophets spoke and Christ redeemed the world required Baldwin to shine as a model of God's law for all earthly kings. To a canon named G. of St. Quintin, whose brothers at B. wished to elect him in place of their deposed Abbot O. with the consent of the Bishops of Carnotes and Paris, Anselm explained that keeping inward contemplation. At the same time, actively serving brothers in charity is better than choosing quiet contemplation alone. He also warned Queen Matilda to act as a mother and nurse rather than a despoiler toward the churches under her control. In addition, he urged Count Hugo to free a captured monk of Cluny and make amends after his men seized and buried a dead monk. Moreover, he encouraged Count Haco of the Orkneys to obey his new bishop and lead his people to the Christian faith.
In his final letters on monastic discipline and Church reform, Anselm sharply rebuked Richard, a monk of Bec. Indeed, repeatedly breaking promises to moderate his extreme fasting as his abbot commanded. At the same time, this warns that simple obedience saves a monk without unusual fasting whereas fasting without obedience brings condemnation. He reminded Willermus that he best kept Anselm's love by keeping his own soul free from sin in God's sight. Bishop Herbert of Thioford asked what to do with married priests who chose to give up their priestly ministry rather than their wives in defiance of the Council of London. In response, Anselm ordered that nothing of the council's law be relaxed. Chaste priests—or if there were too few, monks. This includes elderly ones—must celebrate Mass and consecrate the Lord's Body for the parishes. At the same time, other appointed clergy carry communion to the sick, hear confessions, and bury the dead. In addition, he lay Christians help drive the rebellious priests and their women off church lands. The archbishop recorded to his nephew Anselm. Then he grieved that although the Abbot of Cluny and the nuns of Marcinneus had agreed to receive his nephew's mother Richera, the local Cluniac abbot and nuns where she lived angrily refused to let her go. He promised never to stop helping her and instructed his nephew to study grammar diligently, practice writing daily in plain, clear Latin words rather than an artificial style, and speak Latin. This also serves to listen quietly rather than talking too much.
Finally, Anselm answered a theological question from Prior Bernard and the monks of St. Alban. Their messengers asked why the Catholic Fathers sometimes write that in Christ God and man are united in "one substance" and elsewhere write that "two substances" (divine and human) form "one Person" in Christ. Anselm explained that Scripture commands Christians to confess one God, yet also names the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost without providing a single common plural noun for the three. Early writers needed a word to guard against those who confused the three into one. In response, the Greeks chose to say "three substances" while the Latins chose to say "three persons." Both churches meant the exact same faith. This is because the Greeks used the word "substance" in the very sense in which the Latins used "person". By contrast, the Latins also used "substance" to mean "nature." Therefore, when the Fathers say that two natures in Christ are united in "one substance", they use "substance" in the Greek sense of "one Person". When the Fathers state that "two substances" are united in one Person, they use "substance" in the Latin sense of "two natures", expressing one harmonious truth.
The story inside
Robert asked how the six consecrated women under his care (Seit, Edit, Hydit, Luveris, Virgit, and Godit) should fight intrusive temptations of lust, anger, envy, or pride. In response, Anselm uncovered a trap in human memory. People often try to defeat a bad thought. He does this by arguing directly against it with all their strength or by grieving in fear and sadness that it entered their mind. Yet the human mind remembers whatever brings it strong pleasure or strong grief far more vividly than what it treats with indifference. Therefore, wrestling anxiously with a bad thought or sorrowing over its arrival actually stamps the image deeper into memory and keeps reviving it. God judges every action solely by whether the will consents. Therefore, an unwanted impulse that one rejects is not counted as sin. The aim here is to extinguish a bad suggestion at its root. A person must stop fighting it directly, refuse to grieve over its intrusion, and immediately occupy the mind with a good, useful thought or prayer until the ignored impulse fades away.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Refusing royal usurpation of spiritual courts and custom. Anselm refused to promise loyalty to Lanfranc's or William the Conqueror's customs where they conflicted with God's law. In addition, he rebuked King Henry I for taking money fines from married priests because punishing synodal offenses belongs strictly to bishops and the primate.
- 2
Extinguishing unwanted thoughts by turning attention elsewhere. The human mind remembers whatever pleases or grieves it more than what it ignores. Therefore, fighting or mourning over an intrusive temptation keeps it alive in memory. By contrast, calmly occupying the mind with a good thought extinguishes it without sin.
- 3
Reconciling Greek and Latin Christological terms through usage. When the Fathers call Christ 'one substance' in two natures, they use 'substance' in the Greek sense of 'person', and when they speak of 'two substances in one Person', they use 'substance' in the Latin sense of 'nature.'
Test your recall
Why does grieving over or arguing directly against an unwanted bad thought fail to drive it out of the mind, and how should a person extinguish it instead?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
8 notesFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 7926–7958
“you for your kindness and good-will. To what you say”
- 2.Lines 8215–8244
“with me for my silence. I hear that your excellency”
- 3.Lines 8773–8806
“you, and hold it fast. Do not struggle with wrong”
- 4.Lines 9044–9077
“for it is entirely contrary to the Christian religion.”
- 5.Lines 9271–9296
“To thee I speak, Thomas, in the sight of Almighty”
- 6.Lines 9403–9427
“For it is impossible for thee by any means to be”
- 7.Lines 9805–9838
“As to the priests about whom your prudence asks”
- 8.Lines 9953–9974
“man's nature. When therefore we find in the writings”
