Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters

Section 7 · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Section VII · Location 7 of 8

Section 7 · Open to read

From Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)

The Burden of Canterbury, First Exile, and Appeals to Pope Paschal II (Letters, Part III, Nos. 17–42)

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 7 summary

Anselm's archiepiscopal letters defend his tearful submission to Canterbury against charges of greed, and explain his refusal to surrender Church lands or papal obedience under William Rufus and Henry I. Moreover, they contrast sevenfold pride with indivisible humility.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 7 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Burden of Canterbury, First Exile, and Appeals to Pope Paschal II (Letters, Part III, Nos. 17–42)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/7#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Anselm records to the monks of Bec after being seized in England for the Archbishopric of Canterbury. Then he assures them that their words of love are deeply graven upon his heart. Never before had any sorrow wrung such groans and tears from him as the day the heavy lot of Canterbury fell upon him. Bishops and abbots dragged him protesting into the church. In response, onlookers could hardly tell whether madmen were leading a sane man or sane men a madman—save that they were singing. At the same time, Anselm looked paler than a corpse. Afterward, friends who heard him weeping from afar feared he would lose his life or his senses. Moreover, he sprinkled him with holy water and gave it to him to drink. Yet after resisting the violent election with all his strength, Anselm sees that God's decisions oppose his efforts and that resisting any longer would bring grave spiritual and temporal harm. Echoing Christ's prayer in Gethsemane ("Nevertheless, not as I will, but as Thou wilt") he reminds the monks of Bec that both he and they belong more to God than to each other. He warns them not to kick against the goad of God through obstinate delay. In doing so, he calls God to witness that no desire for earthly riches or dignity draws him to Canterbury.

Anselm addresses Prior Baldric and the community of Bec as sobs choke his throat and interrupt his scribe. Then he answers both the loving grief of his monks and the false whispers of critics who claim that secret greed drew him to the rich primacy. He invoked God's Truth as witness over his soul. Then he points to his thirty-three years in the monastic habit (three years without office, fifteen as prior, and fifteen as abbot) during which no one ever saw him delight in power. Some monks argue that he had become their servant "in the name of the Lord" and could never leave them. In response, Anselm replies that serving them in the Lord meant serving them according to God's will, never swearing to disobey God or the Church placed over him. Saint Martin was taken from his monastery to govern monks, laymen, and women, and Saint Peter left his chair at Antioch to seek a larger harvest at Rome, and Peter first refused to let Christ wash his feet before yielding in obedience. In the same way, Anselm could not rebelliously resist God's command. Though many monks came to Bec because of Anselm, none became a monk for an earthly reward from him. They must cast their burden on the Lord and hasten to elect a new abbot. At the same time, Anselm retains his lifelong love and pastoral care for them.

Anselm records to his friend Bishop Fulk. Then he reflects that although many new friends show him affection in England, nothing can uproot his old love for Bec. Scandal injures weak brethren when a church leader is suspected of greed. Therefore, he solemnly declares before God to Fulk—and to all who read his words—that he would far rather live in monastic poverty and obedience under an abbot than reign as a secular prince or hold any archbishopric, bishopric, or abbey in great wealth. Archbishop Anselm answered a tender letter from the youths and young men of Bec. Then he assures them that reading their words over and over brought tears down his cheeks. God disposes otherwise than they wish. Therefore, he urges the young monks to soften his grief by submitting patiently to God's will. In doing so, he looks forward to eternal joy together in heaven. Receiving the absolution and blessing he sends both to those who wrote and to those who remained silent.

Soon after his consecration, however, Anselm writes to Archbishop Hugh of Lyons to ask counsel in his growing conflict with King William Rufus. Openly before his consecration, Anselm had stated that he recognized Pope Urban II against the antipope Guibert and had struggled for six months to be dismissed before yielding at his archbishop's command. Soon afterward, when the king needed money for an expedition to Normandy, Anselm on the advice of friends offered a large sum, which the king rejected as too small in order to force him to pay more. Anselm thanked God for that refusal, lest accepting the gift should look like a wicked simoniacal purchase of office. Anselm asked leave to fetch his metropolitan pallium (the woolen band of papal authority) from Pope Urban II. In response, the king refused because he had not yet acknowledged any pope. Anselm begged him to summon a church council after many years and correct crying abuses. In response, the enraged king declared that Anselm had lost his favor. Worse still, lands that Archbishop Lanfranc had held in peace until his death the king gave or prepared to give to his soldiers under a pretext of military tenure. Specifically, this claims that because English soldiers before the Norman Conquest had held those lands under the Archbishop. In addition, he died without heirs, the king could appoint whatever heirs he pleased. Anselm tells Hugh that because any future king or successor will hold the see only as Anselm leaves it at his death. In doing so, he consents to this seizure would make the loss irreparable. He would rather live poor like the apostles as a witness to the violence done—or be driven from the archbishopric altogether—than despoil his church or betray the Apostolic See.

Anselm endures the king's hostility. Then he records affectionately to his collaborator Boso. This shows that he dare not send frequent letters lest the king visit violence upon Bec or the messenger. He reports that Master Eadmer (a monk of Bec and the staff of Anselm's old age) is copying his newly written book, Cur Deus Homo. Moreover, he asks Boso to care for Anselm's exiled cousin, Master Fulk. Abbot Lanfrid of Saint Ulmar urgently begs Anselm to obtain leave from his bishop to resign his abbacy. In response, Anselm replies after careful reflection that advising so unusual a step would be dangerous. Even if Lanfrid's presence does nothing more than check wickedness and waste from reigning freely without a head, Lanfrid is not living uselessly. It is the pastor's task to plough and sow while leaving the harvest to God. He weighs a shepherd's patient labor and grief even when he cannot improve his flock as he wishes.

Anselm recorded from exile at Lyons to the newly elected Pope Paschal II. Then he shows why he left England and why he has waited in Hugh of Lyons's household for three years after spending the little he brought and borrowing more. King William Rufus had forbidden any appeal to Rome without royal leave. In addition, he allowed no church council during all thirteen years of his reign, given church lands to his men. Moreover, he ordered Anselm either to swear never again to appeal to the Apostolic See or to leave the realm immediately. Anselm chose exile and laid his case before Pope Urban II at Rome. In response, the king stripped Canterbury of everything except bare food and clothing for the monks. Some less discerning people ask why Anselm does not excommunicate the king himself. Even so, wiser counselors warn that the same man should not be both accuser and judge, and friends in England report that the king would only ridicule Anselm's sentence. Anselm therefore begs Paschal never to order him back to England unless the king restores the Church's lands. In addition, he allows him to put God's law and apostolic decrees above the will of man. Anselm recorded at the same time to the prior and brethren of Canterbury. Then he forbids them to pay his revenues willingly to the king, promises to cry to God for whatever the king extorts by force, reports through Master Baldwin that the Pope will bring their cause before the coming Lenten council. Asks them to have a clear, distinct copy of Cur Deus Homo made in one volume to send to the Pope.

Metropolitan Anselm answered Bishops Donald, Donatus, and other bishops in the island of Hibernia (Ireland). Then he recounts how he was dragged violently to the episcopal throne after Lanfranc's death. How his efforts to repress abuses turned his subjects against him. Finally, he shows how he needs their compassionate prayers. He exhorts the Irish bishops to restrain uncanonical teaching with pastoral vigor. Moreover, he directs them to refer any difficult disputes over the consecration of bishops or church business to his metropolitan judgment. King William Rufus dies and his brother King Henry I recalls Anselm from three years of exile with great joy. In response, Anselm reports a new crisis to Pope Paschal II. Anselm published the decree he had heard Pope Urban II proclaim at the Roman Council (that no layman may confer church investitures and no bishop or abbot may become a layman's vassal by homage). In response, King Henry and his nobles flatly refused to accept it. Anselm also protests to Paschal that transferring the Roman legation over England from Canterbury to the Archbishop of Vienne is impossible across the long, perilous seas and kingdoms of France and Burgundy. In addition, he asks direction regarding Ranulph Flambard (a cruel rent-collector irregularly made a bishop under Rufus, imprisoned by Henry for embezzlement, and now escaped to Normandy where he commands pirates at sea). At the same time, he asks Paschal to send the pallium to the learned Bishop of Rochester, newly elected Archbishop of York. In a follow-up appeal to Paschal, Anselm reports that the king's envoy William of Warelwast demanded that he become the king's man and consecrate royal investees just as Lanfranc had done under Henry's father. In doing so, he left Anselm deprived of his revenues and called the king's only adversary.

While standing firm on the Roman decree, Anselm maintains wide pastoral and family correspondence. He thanks Queen Matilda of the English for her devotion to the Church. Moreover, he prays that God may use her to turn King Henry's heart away from the bad counsel of his nobles. When Abbot Roger and the monk Robert (son of Count Hugo) of Saint Ebrulf break into the monastery of Saint Edmund by lay force to control its abbatial election, Anselm rebukes them sharply. Even if the king appoints a man over earthly lands, only those holding the power of binding and loosing can set a pastor over souls, and monks who resist God rather than men show themselves to be neither Christians nor monks. Anselm records to his loyal friend Bishop Gondulph of Rochester. Then he instructs him to greet the king, deliver Anselm's seal, show a copy of Anselm's letter secretly to William of Warelwast and the prior before giving it to the king, and report the king's answer. At the same time, he urges his beloved nephew Anselm in England to waste no time in idleness, master Latin grammar through declining, parsing, and dictation. In addition, he read prose rather than verse. This also serves to guard his heart before God.

Queen Matilda complains that Anselm's letter disturbed the equanimity of King Henry and his nobles. In response, Anselm replies that an unbiased reader will find nothing intemperate in his words. He spoke nothing against Henry's father or Archbishop Lanfranc when he pointed out that neither in his baptism nor in his ordinations had he promised to obey their customs. By contrast, he had heard the Roman council's prohibition with his own ears and could not defy God's law. Someone with a spiteful intention had twisted his meaning after the king first received his letter kindly. Anselm recorded again to Gondulph. Then he refutes the rumor that the words of a single clerk kept him from England. He also asks Gondulph to send the king's promised Michaelmas answer quickly through his servant Vulgarus of Lyminge if Master Everard cannot bring it on time. He also condemns the small-minded slanderers who claimed he accused Lanfranc of living wickedly. In addition, he commends Robert's family to Gondulph's care. To his friend Adruin, Anselm denies malicious reports that he allows laymen to usurp priestly offices in his churches or neglects his flock, and to Pope Paschal II he sends his envoys alongside the king's bishops. In doing so, this declares that just as it is not his place to loose what the Pope binds, neither is it his to bind what the Pope looses.

Anselm learned that his brother-in-law Burgundius wishes to go on pilgrimage to Jerusalem with Anselm's and his sons' consent. Then he rejoices in his good intention and counsels him to confess every sin from childhood one by one, and leave his wife Richera (Anselm's sister) secure in her home, rank. This also serves to support whatever happens to him, and arrange all his affairs as if he were dying today. Anselm recorded afterward to Richera herself as her only brother. Then he assures her that her only son, young Anselm, has recovered from a long, grave illness. He also is now in perfect health. At the same time, the Archbishop himself lives in daily agitation in England. This is because he dare not flee through fear of God yet cannot dwell in peace. He urges Richera to turn her heart wholly to God and adds that if her husband returns, he should by no means come to visit Anselm.

A startling diplomatic contradiction soon prompts two urgent letters from Anselm to Pope Paschal II. King Henry's envoys (the Archbishop of York and two other bishops) returned from Rome along with Anselm's messengers. In response, the king refused to look at the Pope's letter to Anselm or show his own letter. Instead, the Archbishop of York and the two bishops publicly declared on their faith as bishops that Pope Paschal had privately told them by word of mouth that so long as King Henry acted as a good prince in other respects, he could confer church investitures without excommunication. Furthermore, Paschal had kept this off parchment only lest other princes complain. Caught between the Pope's written command and the bishops' solemn oral testimony. Moreover, he warned by the king and nobles that if he did not join them in seeking relief, all resulting evils would be blamed on him and he would be driven from the realm—Anselm obtained a truce to ask Paschal directly, refusing to consent to anything against the Roman council while begging the Pope—since Anselm fears neither exile, poverty, torture, nor death—to state without ambiguity whether the ban stands or is relaxed for England.

Amidst these storms, Anselm writes with overflowing tenderness to Abbot William and the community of Bec. In doing so, he assures them that no amount of parchment could hold his love for them. He embraces both the older monks he knew and the younger ones added since his departure as sons of the same mother. In doing so, this declares that although absent in body, he always carries his "nest" (the Church of Bec) with all its "chickens" in his heart and prayers. Anselm answers his friend Cuno's request to recall his teaching on the three kinds of pride. Then he separates pride of thought (thinking more highly of oneself than one ought), pride of will (wanting to be treated with more honor than is due, which is worse because it errs knowingly), and pride of deed (treating oneself better than one ought, which is least when done in ignorance). Taken singly, in pairs, or all three together, these three forms yield seven combinations of pride (three single, three double, and one triple) for any one of which a man is called proud. Opposing them are the three parts of humility (thinking, wishing, and acting humbly toward oneself) which are indivisible. This is because just as a man is called sick if even one limb ails and healthy only when sound in every limb, no one is truly humble unless he possesses all three parts together.

The story inside

Archbishop Anselm returned from three years of exile upon the death of King William Rufus. In response, King Henry I demanded that Anselm do homage as his vassal and consecrate bishops and abbots invested by the royal hand. In the same way, Archbishop Lanfranc had done under Henry's father. Anselm had personally heard Pope Urban II excommunicate lay investiture and episcopal homage at the Roman Council. Therefore, he refused and sent envoys with the king's bishops to Pope Paschal II. The envoys returned, however. In response, a bizarre crisis erupted: King Henry refused to look at the Pope's letter to Anselm. At the same time, the Archbishop of York and two bishops publicly testified on their episcopal faith that Paschal had given the king a secret verbal promise allowing royal investitures, kept off parchment only lest other princes complain. Threatened with immediate banishment if he enforced the written letter yet unwilling to violate the Roman council's decree on an unverified oral claim, Anselm refused to consent to the king's investitures. In addition, he sent his envoys back to Rome. In doing so, he assured Paschal that he feared neither exile, poverty, torture, nor death. In addition, he needed an unmistakable written decision.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Anselm resisted the Archbishopric of Canterbury for six months with tears and groans. In addition, he preferred monastic poverty under an abbot to ruling as a prince. Even so, he yielded once Bec, the Archbishop of Rouen, and the Duke of Normandy released him. This is because a monk's vow of obedience belongs first to God.

  2. 2

    Under King William Rufus and King Henry I, Anselm refused to ratify the seizure of Canterbury's military-tenure estates or violate the Roman council's ban on lay investiture and homage. Yet he refrained from excommunicating Rufus himself lest he act as both accuser and judge in his own cause.

  3. 3

    Anselm guides Irish bishops, and rebukes monks who seized St. Edmund's Abbey by lay force. In addition, he counsels his sister Richera and brother-in-law Burgundius. Then he showed Cuno that whereas pride of thought, will, and deed forms seven combinations, true humility is indivisible like bodily health.

Test your recall

Why did Anselm refuse to ratify King William Rufus's military-tenure grants of Canterbury church lands after Lanfranc's death, and why did he refrain from excommunicating Rufus during his exile at Lyons?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

14 notes

From Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 4943–4945
    “BROTHER ANSELM, to his master and father, Lanfranc, Archbishop of Canterbury, who is revered by Catholics with much love, and beloved with reverence.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 5567–5569
    “Brother Anselm to his master, brother, friend, Gilbert: the friend of his beloved one: that which writing cannot express.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 4964–4967
    “Anselm of Bee, sinner by his life, monk by profession, to his masters, friends, best-beloved brethren, Odo and Lanzo: despise temporal for the sake of eternal things: for earthly obtain heavenly.”
  4. 4.
    Lines 5041–5044
    “See, therefore, bestbeloved, that on no account the fear of God which once thou didst conceive, die down; but that as though fanned continually with unremitting attention it may daily burn more glowingly, until changed into eternal confidence it shall give thee light.”
  5. 5.
    Lines 5119–5122
    “The aggravated suffering of your illness, my loving and equally beloved friend, I knew first from the report of others, and then by reading your letter.”
  6. 6.
    Lines 5193–5196
    “<source_page ref="page 150" capture="150"> n8 Selections from the Letters of St Anselm. my mouth " if I have not held Gondulph first among my friends.”
  7. 7.
    Lines 5231–5234
    “But since I suspect that we are beloved by each other in no dis similar degree, so also I do not doubt but that we alike yearn each for the other.”
  8. 8.
    Lines 5306–5309
    “I am answering the letter of your blessedness briefly, because I have just now little opportunities of dictating much.”
  9. 9.
    Lines 5344–5347
    “For what is thy love for me but the image of mine for thee?”
  10. 10.
    Lines 5415–5418
    “Therefore, I exhort and pray, and desire you, as a beloved son, that whatever you read with him, and whatever else you can read, you try to parse most care fully.”
  11. 11.
    Lines 5526–5529
    “These however now know that they blamed inconsiderately, and rejoice to know now, by this means, what formerly they did not perceive.”
  12. 12.
    Lines 5564–5567
    “Since, then, thou art rejoicing in thy consolation, for the wound is gaping in my soul only, perchance they who are enjoying thy society are offended at my saying this to thee.”
  13. 13.
    Lines 5640–5643
    “Magdalene there are some which, if they are said in the inmost heart, when it is at leisure, rather tend to arouse love.”
  14. 14.
    Lines 5674–5677
    “Receive, therefore, most dear one, with a love which I pray God to impart to thee, the sayings of him who loveth thee.”

Location: section 7 of 8 · 88%

Display settings