Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters

Section 6 · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Section VI · Location 6 of 8

Section 6 · Open to read

From Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)

Letters From the Cloister: Friendship, Monastic Counsel, and Service at Bec (Letters, Parts I–II, Nos. 1–16)

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 6 summary

Anselm's letters as monk and Abbot of Bec reveal his spiritual theology of friendship, gentle monastic pedagogy, Augustinian defense of Latin and Greek Trinitarian terms. Urgent calls to renounce worldly warfare and harsh severity for humble obedience and perceptible kindness.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 6 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Letters From the Cloister: Friendship, Monastic Counsel, and Service at Bec (Letters, Parts I–II, Nos. 1–16)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/6#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Writing as a simple monk of Bec to his former master and spiritual father Lanfranc (newly raised to the Archbishopric of Canterbury) Anselm praises God for setting the light of Lanfranc's faith and wisdom on a high candlestick to shine upon the English nation. No unexpected change of place or circumstance can pull Anselm's clinging soul away from his teacher. Anselm had learned through Master Hernostus that Lanfranc would like to have back a precious cup he had once given to Anselm. Therefore, he gladly returns it—not to lessen his debt of gratitude. However, freely offering back the most precious earthly thing he possessed.

In a joint letter to Odo and Lanzo, Anselm tells them that their visit stamped a clear image of their brotherhood upon his soul through charity. In doing so, he kept them present to him even when far apart. Lanzo had begged Anselm to stir up his zeal by letter. Therefore, Anselm answers that although it seems strange for a cold man to warm the fervent, even a cold blast of wind fans a burning fire. He urges Lanzo first to study Holy Scripture and then to guard his heart with all diligence. In the spiritual life, it is harder to win back a virtue lost through carelessness than to gain one never yet possessed. Truth teaches that many are called and few are chosen. Even so, Truth remains silent about who those few are and how small their number is. Therefore, no Christian should look backward to count how many people he is ahead of on the road to heaven. Instead, he must look anxiously forward to see whether he matches the saints whose salvation is certain. Foolish people imagine they have more time to live the longer they survive. In doing so, he forgets that every day lived brings them closer to death and judgment. When the world smiles with its favors, Odo and Lanzo must shrink back from its smile. The world puts gold on the tip of its horn, but hides a wound in its tail.

Master Hernostus falls gravely ill. In response, Anselm writes that he would gladly transfer all that bodily pain into his own body. Yet because God scourges every son whom He receives, outward blows wash away sins and renew the inward spirit day by day. This holds provided that the sufferer submits with thanksgiving. Anger strikes only against an enemy; when a sinner agrees with God's chastising judgment, God's anger subsides. This is because He finds no adversary to strike, allowing the sufferer to echo Job's consolation in trial.

Nowhere does Anselm's theology of friendship shine more warmly than in his twin letters to Gondulph and Henry at Canterbury. Anselm assures Gondulph (meaning Gondulph the monk, not Anselm's father Gondulph the layman) that he holds him first among his friends, stamped upon his heart like a seal upon wax. Even when they are silent, each knows the other loves him. Anselm sends greetings to Archbishop Lanfranc's young nephew, Master Lanfranc. In doing so, he offers him his service and friendship, and greets the living Master Osbern at Canterbury for the sake of Anselm's dearly loved deceased brother Osbern. Wherever dead Osbern is, Anselm declares, "his soul is my soul", begging Gondulph to offer prayers for Osbern now—and if praying for both seems too heavy a burden, to forget Anselm and remember Osbern. Anselm recorded at the same time to Henry via Master Herluin. Then he reminds him that whether we live or die we belong to the Lord, so friends separated on earth must align their longing with God's will until they are gathered from their separate places of exile into God's presence. Conveying thanks from the abbot and monks of Bec for Gondulph's and Henry's gifts and scholarship, Anselm again pleads for dead Osbern as his own "second self."

The monk Hugo writes for counsel because he cannot hold his monastic office in peace with his superior. In response, Anselm gives clear, practical rules for life under difficult authority. Hugo should first humbly ask his superior for permission to step down from the office rather than let both men irritate each other under the burden. If the superior refuses leave, however, Hugo must bear the office in obedience rather than cast it off in disobedience. Hugo's good advice only provokes the superior's anger. In that case, Hugo should keep silence even from good words and live peaceably. This is because God entrusted the headship of the flock to the superior, not to Hugo. He also will not blame Hugo for the shepherd's fault. Above all, so long as the superior does not force him to turn from good to evil, Hugo must never break his promised vow of stability. He does this by leaving his monastery without permission. It is far better to live humbly without sin under fewer spiritual blessings than to grasp after greater ones through mortal sin.

Another brief note assuring Gondulph that their intertwined spirits need no paper to prove their love. In response, Anselm writes to his honoured uncles and kind guardians, Lambert and Folcerald. Time and distance separate them. Even so, his gratitude never lessens, and out of the abundance of his heart he warns them of his deepest fear. That they may sleep on until the end in love of a worldly life and wake after death with empty hands despite their rich possessions. In a playful second letter to Archbishop Lanfranc, Anselm notes that just as the prophet Zechariah repeats "Thus saith the Lord", Anselm stamps every letter to Lanfranc with "Lord and Master" and "His own because his own". Moreover, he begs Lanfranc not to invert their relationship by addressing his servant and son as "lord and father."

Writing to his beloved pupil Maurice (who had moved to Canterbury and was studying under Master Arnulph) Anselm rejoices that Arnulph excels in grammar. With disarming candor, Anselm confesses that teaching boys grammar had always been tiresome to him. As a result, Maurice had actually fallen behind in parsing (analyzing Latin word forms and sentence structure) while studying under him. Anselm begs Maurice not to be ashamed to go back to basics like a beginner and parse everything he reads from start to finish. In doing so, he studied Virgil and other classical authors he had not read with Anselm, "except those in which there is anything shameful."

In a second letter to Prior Henry at Canterbury, Anselm intercedes for Master Osbern. He is returning to Henry after a deep change of heart at Bec. Anselm had seen Osbern detest his past perversity and burn with love for a holy life. Therefore, he reminds Henry that kindness is never needed more urgently than in an early, unfinished conversion from a bad life to a good one. Austere harshness can crush young virtues, whereas "the milk of perceptible kindness" nourishes them to full growth. Moreover, he proves that earlier severity hid love beneath it; as Anselm sums up his pastoral rule, "no one ought to be driven into the way of living virtuously, save he who cannot be attracted into it."

Abbot Rainald begs Anselm to send him his new theological treatise from afar. In response, Anselm complies reluctantly, fearing it may fall into the hands of quarrelsome people who rush to condemn whatever they have not heard before. Hasty critics had already blamed Anselm for following Saint Augustine on the Person and Substance of God. In truth, human speech lacks a literal word for the plurality in the Holy Trinity. Therefore, the Latins faithfully confess three Persons in one Substance. At the same time, the Greeks just as faithfully confess three Substances in one Essence. Anselm asks Rainald to show the book only to sensible, peaceful readers and to report any reasoned objection. As a result, both charity and truth may be preserved.

After a tearful letter to his friend Gilbert (telling him as tears fall onto his fingers that no perfumes, gold, or gems can heal the wound of losing the other half of his soul) Anselm writes to the Lady Adelide, honoured for the nobility of her royal birth and even more for her virtuous life. At her request, Anselm sends a booklet containing "garlands of psalms" followed by seven prayers. The first piece is a meditation in which the sinner's soul contemplates, despises, and humbles itself in fear of the Last Judgment until it breaks into groans and tears. At the same time, the prayers to Saint Stephen and Saint Mary Magdalene are meant to stir up quiet love in the heart at leisure. He urges her to despise all earthly rank and wealth that must be left behind. Moreover, he must strive humbly for what can be kept forever.

Anselm becomes Abbot of Bec in 1078. Then he records while visiting England to plead with a young layman named William. He is rushing across stormy seas into the bloody confusion of war to help his brother win rule among the Greeks around Constantinople and Babylon. Anselm quotes the Psalm that he who loves iniquity hates his own soul. Then he warns William that worldly ambition, war, and false riches are iniquity. William protests that he is going only out of love to protect his brother. In response, Anselm asks how one mortal "worm of earth" can protect another under the crashing ruins of the world. At the same time, he scorns Christ's call at home. William objects that he fears his own weakness if he begins to follow Christ. In response, Anselm points to the young, handsome, wealthy, noble treasurer of a nearby church who recently visited Bec while Anselm was in England. Moved by sudden grace, the young nobleman took the monastic tonsure and habit on the spot. In doing so, he declared he had never been happier in his life. Anselm begs William to abandon the bloody earthly Jerusalem and take the road to the heavenly Jerusalem at Bec.

Anselm recorded as Abbot of Bec to Prior Henry and the monks of Canterbury. Then he also intercedes for Brother Moses, a young monk who through youthful folly and another's deceit had deserted Canterbury (like a son of Eve), drawn an attendant along with him. Carelessly spent borrowed money. Moses sinks to feeding swine like the prodigal son. Then he put into Bec as a safe harbor. In doing so, he begs to be taken back at Canterbury even as a hired servant. He also offers to bear any punishment due to his attendant. He also asks permission to raise funds to repay the debt. Anselm invoked Christ's words that no man has greater love than to lay down his life for his friends. Then he assures Canterbury that Moses and his attendant are clothed from head to foot in Anselm's own skin and mouth. Anyone strikes Moses. In that case, he strikes Anselm's skin. Moreover, if Canterbury spares Moses and helps settle the debt, Anselm himself will be grateful.

The story inside

The young layman William prepares to sail across stormy seas into the bloody wars of the East to help his brother win power among the Greeks around Constantinople and Babylon. In response, Abbot Anselm confronts both of William's excuses. William first claims that he does not love war or riches. However, only wants to help and protect his brother. Anselm replies that rushing under the crashing ruins of the world. As a result, one mortal 'worm of earth' may protect another (while turning his back on Christ calling him in peace at home) only provokes God's anger. He does this by loving a brother more than Christ. William then protests that if he begins to follow Christ, he fears his own weakness may cause him to fail. Anselm exposes the contradiction. Worldly people never fear failure when chasing earthly things that always fail. Yet shrink from following God, who never fails and promises His help. Anselm points to a wealthy, handsome young church treasurer who had just visited Bec and joyfully taken the monastic habit on the spot. Then he begs William to leave the bloody earthly Jerusalem and seek the heavenly Jerusalem at Bec.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Christian friendship stamps the beloved friend's image on the heart like a seal on wax. In doing so, he binds friends to obey God's placement during earthly separation and to pray unceasingly for a departed brother's soul as their own second self.

  2. 2

    In monastic life and teaching, a subordinate under an irritable superior must keep silent peace and vow stability so long as no sin is commanded. At the same time, superiors and teachers must nourish young converts with the milk of perceptible kindness rather than austere harshness.

  3. 3

    True theology requires peaceful readers who understand that Latins (three Persons in one Substance) and Greeks (three Substances in one Essence) confess the same Trinity. At the same time, true conversion refuses to delay for worldly wealth or foreign wars.

Test your recall

Why does Anselm counsel Prior Henry to receive the repentant Master Osbern with 'the milk of perceptible kindness,' and how does that differ from the counsel he gives Hugo regarding an irritable superior?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

14 notes

From Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 4946–4953
    “Glory be to God on high, who has set the light of your”
  2. 2.
    Lines 5048–5063
    “thereto. For that among many called, few are chosen,”
  3. 3.
    Lines 5108–5127
    “despise that which is of God. Should the world, now”
  4. 4.
    Lines 5159–5173
    “giving, submits freely to the chastising hand. For as”
  5. 5.
    Lines 5195–5206
    “my mouth " if I have not held Gondulph first among”
  6. 6.
    Lines 5223–5239
    “service and ask for his friendship. Salute Master”
  7. 7.
    Lines 5315–5341
    “much. If you are really unable to hold your office”
  8. 8.
    Lines 5399–5405
    “fitable for you. But yet, — if I may say somewhat out of”
  9. 9.
    Lines 5440–5467
    “and that never more than now. I have also heard that”
  10. 10.
    Lines 5495–5514
    “doubt easily to be transformed. And it is known to”
  11. 11.
    Lines 5545–5561
    “For they did not know that it cannot, in the literal”
  12. 12.
    Lines 5629–5647
    “given with faithful love. After the garland of psalms are”
  13. 13.
    Lines 5701–5736
    “let not the enemy draw Thy servant away! Thou tellest”
  14. 14.
    Lines 5850–5871
    “to intercede for him. Therefore, since there is no more”

Location: section 6 of 8 · 75%

Display settings