Section V · Location 5 of 8
Section 5 · Open to readFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury
Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)
The Infinite Worth of Christ's Voluntary Death and the Harmony of Mercy and Justice (Book II, Chapters XII–XXII)
Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 5 summary
The sinless God-Man's voluntary death is a good infinitely outweighing all human sins. Therefore, it pardons even His ignorant executioners, and purifies the Virgin Mary beforehand through faith without compulsion. In addition, she earns a reward from the Father that the Son freely transfers to humanity, uniting mercy and justice.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 5 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “The Infinite Worth of Christ's Voluntary Death and the Harmony of Mercy and Justice (Book II, Chapters XII–XXII)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/5#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Sharing human mortality and bodily weaknesses does not make the God-Man wretched. Just as an advantage forced on someone against his will does not make him happy, wisely accepting hardship of one's own free will rather than by compulsion is not wretchedness. Nor does the God-Man share human ignorance as He shares our other bodily weaknesses. The union of humanity with God is carried out by supreme wisdom. Therefore, God adopts nothing useless or harmful to the work that Man has to do. Ignorance is never useful and always harmful, except when it restrains an evil will that could never exist in Christ. Moreover, nothing can be loved unless it is known. No one knows good perfectly unless he can tell it apart from evil. Therefore, even in infancy (when it is not yet the fitting time to display wisdom openly among human beings) the humanity of the God-Man is filled with the fullness of God. He is never without God's power, strength, and wisdom.
How can the death of this one Man outweigh the many great sins of all humanity, when even the smallest sin against God is so heavy that one ought not commit it to save infinitely many worlds? Suppose that Man stood before you, and you knew who He was, and someone told you, "Unless you slay that man, the whole world will perish, with all which is not God." You ought not kill Him even to save an infinite number of worlds. What if you were told, "Either kill him, or all the sins of the world shall be laid upon you"? You ought rather to take upon yourself all other sins (past, present, and future, and all others that could even be imagined) than commit that single crime, or even do the smallest harm to Him. Why? Because a sin committed directly against the Person of God is incomparably worse than all sins that do not touch His Person. Now, if destroying His bodily life is an evil incomparably greater than all other sins, then His bodily life is a good incomparably greater than all those sins are evil. Sins are hateful in proportion to their evil, and His life is lovable in proportion to its goodness. Therefore, freely yielding up that life (accepting death) is a good that infinitely outweighs all the sins of the whole world.
If killing Him is an evil as great as His life is good, how can His death blot out the sin of the very people who killed Him? The Apostle Paul solved this puzzle in 1 Corinthians 2:8: "if they had known, they would not have crucified the Lord of glory." There is a vast difference between a sin committed knowingly and one committed in ignorance. No human being could ever knowingly wish to kill God. Those who crucified Christ acted in ignorance. Therefore, they did not fall into that infinite, unforgivable crime of knowingly murdering God (the theoretical crime against which we measured the infinite worth of His life) and so their sin could be pardoned through His death.
How did God take a sinless human nature from the sinful mass of fallen humanity, like unleavened dough taken from fermented dough? Christ's own conception was pure and free from carnal pleasure. Even so, His Virgin Mother herself was conceived in original sin and sinned in Adam. In truth, God remade human nature even more wonderfully than He first created it. Man existed. In response, he had not sinned so as to forfeit creation. By contrast, after sinning he deserved punishment and was restored contrary to his deserts. Not enough people could be alive at the moment of Christ's death to fill the heavenly city (for there are more fallen angels to be replaced than there were people living on earth at that hour). Therefore, the power of Christ's death extends to those absent in both place and time.
Suppose an entire city (except for one innocent citizen of the same race) has rebelled against a king and earned the death penalty. Out of love for the guilty, that one innocent man performs a service on an appointed day so pleasing to the king that the king grants pardon to everyone who before or after that day trusts in that service and keeps the covenant—with one condition. No one may enter the royal palace until the service has actually been performed. In the same way, God never left the created world empty of human beings belonging to His saving plan even for a single moment. Therefore, Adam and Eve themselves shared in Christ's redemption through faith. Even so, no soul could enter the heavenly Paradise before Christ died. The Virgin Mary belonged to those who were cleansed from sin by faith in His future death before He was born of her. Thus Christ did not receive His purity from His mother. Rather, because His mother's purity came through Him alone, He was pure by and from Himself.
If the Virgin could only be pure through true faith that Christ would die, did that mean Christ had to die of necessity after being born of her, lest her true faith turn out false? Not at all. Christ had the ability to utter a lie yet could not will to lie. In the same way, He always had the power to keep His life. Yet freely and unchangeably willed to lay it down. The Son of God and the son of the Virgin are one and the same Person. Therefore, His unchangeable decision to die was His own free divine will.
Strictly speaking, all necessity and impossibility are subject to God's will, while God's will is subject to none. When we say that God "cannot" lie, it does not mean He lacks power. It means His faithfulness to truth is so invincible that nothing can make Him lie, just as saying "this man cannot be conquered" means no one has power over him. Furthermore, the Virgin Mary believed the prophet Isaiah's words, "He was offered up because He willed it." The truth of her faith did not cause Him to die willingly. Rather, because He was going to die willingly, her faith was true. Here we must distinguish between two kinds of necessity: antecedent necessity, which precedes a fact and causes it to happen (as natural forces cause the earth to revolve around the sun), and consequent necessity, which causes nothing at all but merely follows the existence of the fact (as when we say that because you are speaking, you are necessarily speaking—the necessity Aristotle discusses regarding singular and future statements). Only by this harmless consequent necessity was it "necessary" that Christ die, because He Himself freely willed it. As He Himself said, no one took His life from Him. However, He laid it down of Himself and took it up again. Leaving a deeper investigation of how original sin spreads from our first parents for a separate work, Anselm and Boso turn to the final question. This shows how Christ's death atones to God for human sins.
Christ patiently endured insults, sufferings, and crucifixion alongside thieves for the sake of righteousness. In response, He gave weak mortals a supreme example never to turn aside from righteousness because of pain or death. John the Baptist and earlier martyrs bravely died for the truth. However, as mortal sinners they owed their lives to death anyway. Christ alone freely gave up to the Father a life He never had to lose and owed to no one. Nor was Christ bound as a debtor to die simply because dying was the best and most pleasing work. God leaves a creature free between two lawful choices. In response, neither is required as a debt, and choosing the better path earns a reward. In the same way, virginity is better than marriage. Yet neither is required as a debt. Someone who freely chooses virginity looks for a reward for a free gift. Moreover, we say that God or the Lord Jesus "ought" to do what He wills. In response, it means only that what He wills ought to happen, not that He owes anything to anyone. Christ offered His humanity to His divinity (the whole Trinity). Even so, we rightly say that the Son freely offered Himself to the Father, both because it expresses the personal truth most clearly and because naming the Father and the Son stirs deep devotion in the hearts of hearers.
From this offering follows the unbreakable proof of human salvation. The Father must reward the Son for so great a gift, or else seem unjust or powerless. Yet someone who rewards another either gives him what he lacks or forgives what he owes. The Son performed this great work. In response, everything the Father had already belonged to the Son. The Son never owed any debt that could be forgiven. So great and just a reward cannot be paid to the Son Himself and cannot be left unpaid. Therefore, it must be paid to someone else. Whom could the Son more justly make heirs of the reward due to Him (which He Himself does not need) than His own human kinsmen and brethren, whom He sees weighed down by debt and wasting away in misery. As a result, their sins may be forgiven and eternal happiness given to them? God rejects no human being who comes to Him in Christ's Name in the right way taught throughout Holy Scripture, which rests on solid truth as on a rock. To the devil, neither God nor humanity owed anything except punishment and defeat. Everything required of man was owed to God, not to the devil.
Thus God's mercy, which seemed to vanish when we looked at God's strict justice and human sin in Book I, turns out to be so great and so completely in harmony with justice that nothing more merciful or more just can be imagined. What could be more merciful than for God the Father to say to a sinner condemned to eternal torment with nothing to pay his ransom, "Take my Only-Begotten Son, and offer Him for thyself". At the same time, the Son Himself says, "Take me, and redeem thyself"? And what could be more just than for God, upon receiving a payment greater than the entire debt owed to Him, to cancel the whole debt?
By contrast, the devil and the fallen angels cannot be saved. The value of Christ's death is great enough to outweigh all the sins of angels and humans combined. Even so, revealed truth forbids extending salvation to the fallen angels. Reason shows why. Unlike humans, who all descend from one man (Adam), angels do not descend from a single parent angel, so no angel or God-angel could redeem them as a kinsman. Moreover, just as they fell without anyone tempting them from outside, they would have to rise without outside help, which is impossible for them. By solving this single question of why God became man, reason confirms the truth of everything contained in both the Old and the New Testaments. In doing so, he satisfied not only Jews but pagans as well. Moreover, whatever truth has been uncovered belongs not to human cleverness, but to God, who is blessed forever.
The story inside
The aim here is to explain how Christ's death could cleanse the Virgin Mary. In addition, he could save Adam, Eve, and the Old Testament saints centuries before the Crucifixion. To that end, imagine a kingdom whose entire population (except for one innocent citizen of the same race) has rebelled against the king and earned the death penalty. High in the king's favor and filled with love for the guilty citizens. Moreover, one innocent man agrees to perform a great service on an appointed day that will deeply please the king. Not everyone who needs pardon can be present on that day. Therefore, the king grants a covenant: anyone who, either before or after that appointed day, professes faith in that service and keeps the covenant is absolved from all past offenses. This holds on the single condition that no one may enter the king's palace until the service has actually been performed. In the same way, the power of Christ's death reached backward across time to cleanse the Virgin Mary and save Adam and Eve through faith. Even so, no soul could enter the heavenly Paradise until Christ actually died on the Cross.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
A sin against the Person of God is incomparably worse than all other sins combined. Therefore, the bodily life and voluntary death of the sinless God-Man is a good that infinitely outweighs all the sins of the world. He also can forgive even His executioners. This is because they acted in ignorance rather than knowingly killing God.
- 2
This parallels a king's covenant that pardons rebels both before and after an innocent citizen's appointed day of service. In the same way, Christ's death purified the Virgin Mary and saved Adam and Eve beforehand through faith. Moreover, Mary's true faith did not force Christ to die by antecedent necessity. However, rather His free, unchangeable will to die made her faith true by consequent necessity.
- 3
The Son owed no debt to die and already possessed everything the Father has. Therefore, the Father justly pays the reward merited by the Son's sacrifice to the human kinsmen whom the Son names as His heirs. In doing so, he harmonized supreme mercy with strict justice while leaving the fallen angels irredeemable. This is because they do not form a single biological race.
Test your recall
Why must the Father reward the Son for laying down His life, and why does that reward necessarily pass to Christ's human brethren while never extending to the fallen angels?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
13 notesFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 3843–3851
“A. By no means; for just as that enjoyment which”
- 2.Lines 3900–3906
“Him, is restricted in its consequences. And even if”
- 3.Lines 3966–3977
“A. What doth it seem to thee is the worth of him,”
- 4.Lines 4003–4012
“A. This difficulty was solved by the apostle, who said”
- 5.Lines 4117–4139
“that time, but for others also. For, let us suppose”
- 6.Lines 4200–4211
“A. But that virgin of whom was born that Man of”
- 7.Lines 4481–4506
“istence of the fact involves the necessity. For there is”
- 8.Lines 4623–4636
“A. No man except Himself ever by dying gave to”
- 9.Lines 4663–4675
“For, though virginity may be greater than marriage,”
- 10.Lines 4761–4779
“A. He who recompenses another, either gives what”
- 11.Lines 4849–4864
“A. OO, the mercy of God, which whilst we were con-”
- 12.Lines 4875–4895
“For as mankind could not be reconciled save by one”
- 13.Lines 4910–4924
“B. A LL that you say appears to me most reasonable”
