Section IV · Location 4 of 8
Section 4 · Open to readFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury
Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)
Humanity's Purpose and the Necessity of a God-Man From Adam's Race (Book II, Chapters I–XI)
Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 4 summary
The aim here is to fulfill His unchangeable plan for rational human nature to enjoy Him forever in soul and body. God freely binds Himself to save humanity through one Person who is both perfect God and perfect man (God the Word born of a virgin of Adam's race) who cannot sin and owes no penalty of death. Yet he can freely lay down His life as an unowed gift greater than all creation.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Humanity's Purpose and the Necessity of a God-Man From Adam's Race (Book II, Chapters I–XI)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/4#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
God created rational human nature upright so that human beings might find eternal happiness in enjoying Him. God gave humanity reason for a clear purpose: to tell right from wrong, good from bad, and a greater good from a lesser good. Without that power of judgment, reason would exist in vain. Even judgment would be useless unless human beings used it to hate evil. Love what is good, and love. Moreover, he would choose the highest good (God Himself) above everything else and for His own sake. An upright creature loved and chose the highest good yet could never reach it. In that case, that creature would be miserable against its will, which is absurd. Therefore, God made human nature rational and upright so that it might be blessed in enjoying Him forever.
It would violate God's wisdom and justice to force an upright creature made for eternal happiness to die without fault. Therefore, human beings would never have died if they had never sinned. From this truth follows the future resurrection of the dead. Humanity is to be completely restored. In that case, human beings must be remade just as they would have been had they never sinned. Had humanity not sinned, it would have been transformed into an imperishable state in the very same body it wore in this life. Therefore, when humanity is restored, the saved will be transformed into eternal happiness in both soul and body with the same body in which they lived here. At the same time, those who persist in wickedness will suffer complete misery in both soul and body.
God made nothing more precious than a rational nature formed to rejoice in Him. Therefore, He cannot allow human nature to perish completely or leave His work unfinished. Yet God cannot complete what He began in human nature without a full satisfaction for sin. No sinner can make that payment.
Does saying that God must complete His plan to avoid inconsistency mean that God saves humanity out of necessity for His own sake rather than out of free grace for ours? Not at all. There are two very different kinds of necessity. When someone helps another person under unwilling compulsion, little or no gratitude is owed. When someone freely binds himself to do a kindness and carries it out willingly, however, he deserves even greater gratitude. Suppose you freely promise today to give someone a gift tomorrow. Tomorrow you must either keep your promise or break your word. Even so, the receiver owes you no less gratitude than if you had never promised. This is because you freely made yourself his debtor. The same is true when someone freely takes a monastic vow to live a stricter life for God. Even though he must keep that vow or be condemned as a deserter, if he keeps it willingly he is more pleasing to God than if he had never vowed, because he gave up not only ordinary life but also his own freedom. Much more, then, must we credit our salvation entirely to God's grace. God created humanity. In response, He foresaw what humans would do. Yet out of pure kindness He freely bound Himself to finish the good work He began. In God, "necessity" is nothing other than His own unchangeable goodness and integrity, which comes from Himself alone.
How, then, can this satisfaction be made? As proved earlier, paying for human sin requires offering to God something greater than everything that exists outside God. Whoever can give God something from his own resources that surpasses all creation must himself be greater than everything that is not God. Nothing is greater than all that is not God except God Himself, so none but God can make this satisfaction. At the same time, none ought to make it except a human being. Otherwise, humanity has not paid its debt. Therefore, if the heavenly city is to be filled from humanity, the satisfaction that only God can make and only man ought to make must be performed by one who is both God and man.
How can God become man? The divine and human natures cannot change into one another. Indeed, then there would be either only God and no man, or only man and no God. Nor can the two natures mix into an altered third nature (the way two animals of different species produce a hybrid offspring that keeps the full nature of neither parent). This is because such a hybrid would be neither God nor man. Nor could a mere partnership between two separate persons accomplish the work. Indeed, God will not do what He ought not, and a mere man cannot do what is beyond his power. Therefore, preserving the fullness of both natures, the divine nature and the human nature must unite in one single Person who is both perfect God and perfect man. In the same way, a body and a rational soul meet in one human being.
From where must God take this human nature? Either He must take it from Adam's race, or He must create a brand-new man from nothing as He first made Adam. He created a new man outside Adam's family. In that case, that man would not belong to the human race descended from Adam and would have no duty to pay its debt. Moreover, God created all humanity in the single man Adam (forming even Eve from Adam alone). In response, He showed that He intended to fulfill His plan for humanity solely through Adam's stock. Adam's race were rescued by someone outside that family. In that case, it would not be restored to the original dignity in which it was meant to stand. Therefore, the Redeemer who restores Adam's race must come from Adam's race.
God can form a human being in four ways: from a man and a woman, as everyday experience shows. From neither man nor woman, as He created Adam. From a man without a woman, as He made Eve from Adam. Or from a woman without a man, which He had not yet done. The aim here is to prove that this fourth way also lay within His power. Nothing was more fitting than for God to take human nature from a woman without a man—and, most worthily of all, from a virgin. This solid truth shines with three clear harmonies. Human sin and ruin began from a woman. In the same way, the remedy for sin and cause of salvation is born of a woman. As a result, women may not lose hope of sharing the lot of the blessed. Just as a virgin was the cause of all evil for the human race, a virgin becomes the occasion of all good. Moreover, just as the woman God made from virgin Adam was formed without a woman, the Man made from a woman is formed from a virgin without a man.
Which Person of the Holy Trinity (who is three Persons in one God) ought to unite human nature to Himself? Several divine Persons cannot take up one and the same human being into a single Person, so the union must take place in one divine Person alone. As explained more fully in the Letter on the Incarnation of the Word addressed to Pope Urban II, if the Father or the Holy Spirit became incarnate, there would be two Sons in the Trinity (the eternal Son of God and the Son born of the virgin) and an inequality of birth would arise among the equal Persons. If the Father became incarnate, there would even be two grandsons in the Trinity. The Father would be the grandson of the virgin's parents through His human nature. The eternal Word would be the virgin's grandson as the Son of her son. Furthermore, it is most fitting for a Son to intercede as a suppliant with the Father. Finally, both fallen humanity and the devil sinned by proudly setting up a false likeness to God by their own will. In doing so, he offended specially against the Person of the Son. He is the true Image of God. Therefore, God the Word alone must unite human nature to Himself in one Person.
Would this God-Man be bound to die like other humans? Even Adam would not have died had he never sinned. In that case, much less is the God-Man bound to suffer death. Indeed, in Him there can be no sin because He is God. Someone might wonder how we can say Christ could not sin when Christ told the Jews in John's Gospel, "If I were to say, I know Him not, I shall be a liar like unto you." Could He not utter the three words "I know Him not"? He could indeed utter those words, and yet He could not sin. All active power depends on the will: when I say I can speak or walk, it means if I will. Christ could not lie against His will, and could never will to lie. Therefore, it is equally true that He could lie if He willed and that He could not lie. This is because He could not will it.
Why, then, does the God-Man—or God, or the good angels—deserve praise for righteousness if they cannot sin? The good angels are praised not because they once had the power to sin. However, because by refusing to throw away their uprightness when they could have done so, they now hold uprightness from themselves, resembling God. He has whatever He possesses from Himself. Where there is neither compulsion nor prohibition, there is no forced necessity. The God-Man is one Person with God. Therefore, He possesses every virtue from Himself freely and unchangeably, and so deserves the highest praise. As for why God did not make angels and the first humans unable to sin from the beginning, it neither could nor should happen that each one of them be identical with God. Indeed, God does nothing without reason.
Can the sinless God-Man die according to His human nature? Ancient philosophers defined man as "mortal" because they never saw a human who did not die. Moreover, he did not believe a whole human being could ever be immortal. In truth, however, mortality belongs to corrupted human nature, not to pure human nature. Unfallen humans and resurrected humans are true humans without being mortal. Instead, the God-Man can die because, as God, He is all-powerful. Moreover, he can freely lay down His life and take it up again whenever He wills. Because every rational creature already owes God lifelong obedience, mere obedience is not an unowed gift. The only gift greater than all creation that the sinless God-Man does not owe as a debt is surrendering His own life to death for God's honor. By freely enduring death (the hardest of all sufferings) He reverses humanity's easy fall into pleasant sin, conquers the devil through supreme difficulty, and lives among weak mortals as both a teacher by word and a living example of steadfast righteousness under insult, suffering, and death.
The story inside
Boso worries that proving God must save humanity to avoid inconsistency implies God acts out of necessity for His own sake rather than out of free grace for ours. In response, Anselm distinguishes between two kinds of necessity. When someone helps another person under unwilling compulsion, little or no gratitude is due. When someone freely binds himself to do a kindness and carries it out willingly, however, he deserves even deeper gratitude. Suppose you freely promise today to give a gift tomorrow, or suppose a monk freely takes a vow to live a stricter life for God. Tomorrow you must keep your promise or break your word. The monk is bound to keep his vow lest he become an apostate. Even so, keeping that promise or vow willingly deserves greater praise because the giver surrendered his own freedom out of love. In the same way, God foresaw human sin at creation yet freely bound Himself out of pure kindness to complete the good work He began in human nature.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
God created human beings rational, upright, and conditionally immortal. In this way, they would enjoy Him forever in soul and body (which proves the future resurrection of the body) and God's unchangeable integrity freely binds Him to complete this plan out of pure grace.
- 2
Only God can offer a payment greater than all creation and only a descendant of Adam ought to pay humanity's debt. Therefore, God the Word (the Son) alone had to unite human nature from a virgin of Adam's race to Himself in one single Person without changing or mixing the two natures.
- 3
Mortality belongs to corrupted nature rather than pure human nature. Moreover, the sinless. Therefore, all-powerful God-Man owes no penalty of death, freely laying down His life for God's honor is the one unowed gift greater than creation by which He both pays humanity's debt and teaches mortals by example.
Test your recall
Why must the Redeemer be one single Person uniting both divine and human natures from Adam's race, and why does the sinless God-Man deserve praise for His righteousness and gratitude for His saving work even though He cannot will to sin?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
13 notesFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 3123–3135
“A. TT is indubitable that the rational nature was by”
- 2.Lines 3171–3177
“A. HP HAT also he was so created as that he was not”
- 3.Lines 3185–3194
“A. \7i 7 HENCE is sometimes clearly proved the future”
- 4.Lines 3244–3258
“A. There is a necessity which takes away or lessens”
- 5.Lines 3282–3303
“For it was not hidden from Him when He made man”
- 6.Lines 3330–3338
“A. If, then, it be necessary (as we have ascertained)”
- 7.Lines 3370–3381
“done. [For God will not do it, because He ought not,”
- 8.Lines 3398–3407
“it. But as it is right that man should make reparation”
- 9.Lines 3450–3462
“A. God can make a human being in four ways: that”
- 10.Lines 3514–3529
“A. If any other Person were to become Incarnate,”
- 11.Lines 3595–3607
“A. All power depends on will. When I say, for”
- 12.Lines 3708–3725
“A. I think that mortality belongs not to pure, but to”
- 13.Lines 3783–3806
“A. Let us see if perhaps this may be: to give his life,”
