Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters

Section 3 · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Section III · Location 3 of 8

Section 3 · Open to read

From Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury

Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)

The Weight of Sin and Human Inability to Repay God (Book I, Chapters XIX–XXV)

Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 3 summary

Humanity cannot enter heaven without paying full satisfaction for sin. Yet no mere human can ever pay that debt. This is because every good work is already owed to God, a single sin against God's will outweighs infinite created worlds. Human helplessness is self-inflicted guilt. This proves that salvation is impossible without Christ.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Weight of Sin and Human Inability to Repay God (Book I, Chapters XIX–XXV)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

God plans to fill the empty places of the fallen angels with human beings. Because of this, the people who enter heaven must be equal to the good angels who never sinned. A person who has sinned and never paid back God for that sin cannot be equal to a sinless angel, even if that person is let off without punishment. Truth does not allow a sinner who has made no amends to be raised to the same level as the good angels.

Even if we leave the angels out of the picture, God's wisdom still requires satisfaction—which means freely paying back the debt owed to God. Suppose a rich man holds a clean, priceless pearl in his hand. No one can take it unless he allows it, and he plans to store it in his treasure house with his most precious goods. Now suppose he lets a jealous enemy knock that pearl out of his hand into the mud. The rich man picks the pearl out of the mud and puts it straight into his clean treasure box. At the same time, it is still dirty and unwashed. In that case, no one would call him wise.

God kept human beings in Paradise without sin, like a clean pearl in His own hand. He allowed the devil, burning with envy, to persuade humanity to consent and fall into the mud of sin. God took human beings back into Paradise still stained with sin and without any washing of satisfaction. In that case, He would act like that foolish rich man. Either God would seem unable to finish the good plan He started, or He would seem to have given up on His good purpose. Neither is possible for God.

Why, then, do Christians pray, "Forgive us our debts", and why do all nations ask God to forgive their sins? If we have already paid what we owe, why ask God to cancel the debt? And if we have not paid, why pray in vain for something God cannot rightly do? The answer is that a person who does not pay asks for forgiveness in vain. A person who does pay still prays for pardon because humble prayer is itself part of the payment. God owes nothing to anyone, and every creature is His debtor,. In this way, no human may stand before God as an equal. How Christ's death makes this payment possible will become clear later in the inquiry.

The payment for sin must match the size of the offense. Otherwise, sin would remain partly out of order in God's kingdom, which God's perfection cannot allow. What can a human being offer to God to pay for sin? A person might offer repentance, a broken and humble heart, fasting, hard bodily work, mercy in giving alms and forgiving others, and obedience. Yet in all these acts, a human being gives God nothing extra. You give God what you already owed Him even if you had never sinned. In response, you cannot count that payment toward your past debt of sin.

Even without past sin, every person in this mortal life owes God wholehearted love and prayerful longing for the heavenly goal for which humanity was made. Every person already owes sorrow for not yet reaching that goal, fear of losing it, and a refusal to enjoy worldly pleasures except insofar as they help reach heaven. Giving to others is also an existing duty. This is because whatever a person gives comes from God, who is the common Master of both giver and receiver. Forgiving injuries is likewise owed already, because neither you nor the person who wronged you belongs to yourself. Both are servants made by one God out of nothing. Anyone who takes revenge steals a right of judgment that belongs only to the God and Judge of all. Finally, in obedience, you give nothing beyond your duty. Indeed, you already owe God all you are, all you have, and all you can do.

A human being owes God himself and everything he can do even when he does not sin. Therefore, he has nothing left over to pay for sin. Christian faith (which works through love) gives hope of salvation. Scripture promises that if a wicked man turns from his wickedness and does right, his sins will be forgotten. Yet that promise belongs only to those who looked forward to Christ before He came or believe in Him now that He has come. This inquiry set Christ aside to test by reason alone whether His coming was necessary. Therefore, the argument must continue by reason alone.

Suppose, for the sake of argument, that a person did not already owe all those good works and could offer them to pay for sin. Even then, they could not pay for a single sin as small as one look contrary to God's will. At first sight, someone might think one brief feeling of sorrow could wipe out so small a fault. That is only because he has not yet weighed how heavy sin truly is.

Suppose you stood directly in God's sight and someone told you, "Look there". At the same time, God said, "I will that you on no account look." Ought you to give that look even to save your own life? No. What if the whole world and everything that is not God had to perish and turn back into nothing unless you gave that one small forbidden look? Looked at by itself, the glance seems tiny. However, when done against the will of God it is worse than any loss in creation. Among human beings, we sometimes act against a friend's wishes to protect his own good. This is because a human may not know what helps him or cannot replace what he loses. God, however, needs nothing, and if the whole created world perished, He could remake it just as He made it in the beginning.

Therefore, you ought not do the smallest thing against God's will even to save the entire created universe. Even if there were endlessly many worlds as full of creatures as this one, it would still be wrong to give that one forbidden glance to save them all. Yet we commit a sin that heavy every time we knowingly do anything, however small, against God's will. This is because we are always in His sight and He always forbids sin. God requires a payment that matches the sin. Therefore, no sinner makes amends unless he repays something greater than all the worlds for whose sake he ought not to have sinned. No mere creature can ever pay such a price.

There are two more reasons why humanity cannot be reconciled to God by its own power. First, when God created human nature innocent and placed it in Paradise, humanity stood between God and the devil. The devil, who was stronger, had sinned in heaven without anyone tempting him. Human beings, though weaker and living on earth, were meant to honor God. Moreover, he put the devil to shame by refusing the devil's temptation. Humanity could easily have done this, because no force compelled it. Instead, humanity freely yielded to persuasion alone, obeying the devil against God's will and honor.

It would dishonor God to take humanity back after such an insult unless humanity first honored God by defeating the devil. Moreover, that victory must reverse the shame of the first defeat. In Paradise, humanity was strong and able to remain immortal. Yet he yielded easily to sin and justly earned the penalty of death. Therefore, humanity must now (while weak and mortal) defeat the devil through the pain of death without committing any sin at all. Yet no human being conceived and born in the wound of original sin can ever do this.

Second, by letting the devil conquer him, man robbed God of everything God planned to build out of human nature. Strict justice demands that humanity restore the exact thing stolen from God. The devil seized what belonged to God when man was defeated. In the same way, the devil must lose and God must regain His own through man's victory. In defeated Adam, the whole of human nature was spoiled by sin like dough soured by bad yeast. God chooses no one still stained by sin to fill the heavenly kingdom. Therefore, the human victor must cleanse and make righteous as many human beings as are needed to complete the heavenly city. No sinful human being can do this, because one sinner cannot make another sinner righteous.

Someone might object that a debtor is dishonest only if he can pay and refuses, not if he is unable to pay. If a person's lack of power is not his own fault, it may partly excuse him. The lack of power is itself caused by his own fault, however. In response, it neither lessens his sin nor excuses his failure to pay.

Suppose a master gives his servant a task. In addition, he warns him not to throw himself into a deep pit standing right in front of him. Through this, he could never climb out. The servant scorns his master's command and warning and willfully jumps into that pit. In that case, his inability to do the work is no excuse at all. In fact, it doubles his guilt, because he both failed to do what was commanded and did what was forbidden. In the same way, humanity freely took on a debt it cannot pay and threw itself into helplessness. Fallen humanity can neither avoid sin as it owed before the Fall nor pay what it owes because of sin. That helplessness is itself guilt, and humanity remains guilty both for not paying and for being unable to pay.

Because heaven is complete perfection, no guilty debtor can be admitted to eternal blessedness. Nor can God's mercy simply cancel the debt because man cannot pay. God forgives what man ought freely to pay merely because man cannot pay it. In that case, God only gives up what He cannot get—which would turn divine mercy into a mockery. And if God drops the punishment and rewards a guilty, helpless debtor with heaven, He acts against His own justice. God's everyday mercy preserves human beings and animals in this mortal life. However, the final mercy that grants eternal happiness after this life requires that every sin be pardoned through full payment of the debt.

Unbelievers who mock Christian faith and claim that Christ is not needed must therefore explain how any human being can be saved without Christ. They cannot prove any such way. Therefore, they must either stop mocking and join Christians who trust in Christ for salvation, or else despair of human salvation altogether. Even unbelievers admit that human beings can reach happiness in some way. God cannot fail to bring some humans to the happiness for which He created them. Since salvation is impossible outside Christ, it must necessarily come through Christ. Having proved that humanity owes a debt it cannot pay and cannot be saved without paying it, Book I closes. As a result, Book II may build from a fresh foundation and show how God's mercy saves humanity through Christ.

The story inside

The aim here is to show why a sinner cannot be restored to heaven without first making cleansing satisfaction. To that end, imagine a rich man holding a clean, priceless pearl in his hand. No one can take the pearl from him unless he permits it, and he plans to lock it away in his clean treasure box among his dearest possessions. Suppose he allows a jealous rival to knock that pearl out of his hand into the mud. The rich man picks the pearl out of the mud and places it straight into his clean treasure box. At the same time, it is still crusted with dirt and unwashed. In that case, would anyone call him wise? Surely not—it would have been far better to keep the pearl clean. In the same way, God held sinless humanity in Paradise like a clean pearl in His hand. Permitted the envious devil to cast consenting humanity into the mud of sin. God took humanity back into Paradise still stained with sin and without any washing of satisfaction. In that case, He would act like that foolish rich man.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Cleansing satisfaction is required before entering heaven both so redeemed humans are equal to the sinless angels and so God does not store a muddied pearl unwashed in His clean treasury.

  2. 2

    Repentance, fasting, almsgiving, forgiving injuries, and obedience cannot pay for past sin. This is because every creature already owes all of them to God even without sin. At the same time, even a single forbidden glance against God's will outweighs infinitely many created worlds.

  3. 3

    This parallels a servant who willfully jumps into a pit after being warned by his master, fallen humanity's inability to repay God and conquer the devil without sin is self-inflicted guilt. In the same way, proving that human salvation is impossible without Christ.

Test your recall

Why can repentance, fasting, almsgiving, forgiveness of others, and obedience not be counted as payment for past sins, and how does the parable of the servant who jumps into a pit prove that human inability to pay does not excuse the debtor?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

12 notes

From Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 2494–2503
    “A, Men ought, then, to be such in that celestial king”
  2. 2.
    Lines 2528–2542
    “A. Let us suppose a rich man holding in his hand a”
  3. 3.
    Lines 2576–2585
    “A. H<^h&Jb&tk^£&4iaid saith^JULvain^ " forgive;”
  4. 4.
    Lines 2619–2627
    “A. When you render to God something which you”
  5. 5.
    Lines 2680–2688
    “A. This is only said of those who either expected”
  6. 6.
    Lines 2708–2716
    “A. You have not yet considered the exceeding gravity”
  7. 7.
    Lines 2746–2755
    “B. I am constrained to own, that not even in order to”
  8. 8.
    Lines 2788–2799
    “A. TV /TAN, created innocent and placed in paradise,”
  9. 9.
    Lines 2840–2849
    “A. Look at the matter in thejjght of strict justice,”
  10. 10.
    Lines 2896–2905
    “the debt. For if anyone sets his servant a task, and”
  11. 11.
    Lines 2951–2963
    “A. If you mean to say that a merciful God remits to”
  12. 12.
    Lines 3045–3053
    “A. TS it not sufficiently proved that man can be”

Location: section 3 of 8 · 38%

Display settings