Section I · Location 1 of 8
Section 1 · Open to readFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury
Edition: Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909)
Why God Became Man: Unbelievers' Objections, the Devil's Claim, and Christ's Free Obedience (Preface and Book I, Chapters I–X)
Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Chapter 1 summary
Anselm and Boso reasoned as though nothing were known of Christ. Then they clear the ground for proving the necessity of the Incarnation by showing that poetic parallels fail without rational necessity. No creature could redeem humanity. The devil held no just claim over sinners. The sinless Christ died freely through steadfast righteousness.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Why God Became Man: Unbelievers' Objections, the Devil's Claim, and Christ's Free Obedience (Preface and Book I, Chapters I–X)” Summary of Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, by Saint Anselm of Canterbury. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/cur-deus-homo-of-saint-anselm/chapters/1#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Anselm began investigating the question "Why was God made man?" in England amid great distress of soul and finished the work. At the same time, he lived as an exiled wanderer in the Italian province of Capua. Eager readers had copied out the early sections before the work was finished and fully weighed. Therefore, he had to complete it faster and more briefly than he wished. As a result, this left out many points he would have added in a time of quiet. He divided the inquiry into two books and asked future copyists to place his brief preface and the full list of chapters at the front. In this way, every reader could see the plan at a glance. Both books use a bold method. They set Christ aside (reasoning as though nothing were known of Him) to prove by necessary logic first that no human being can be saved without Him. Furthermore, human nature, created to enjoy blessed immortality in body and soul, can reach that goal only through one who is both God and Man.
Both learned and unlearned believers often asked Anselm by word and letter to write down his rational explanations of the Christian faith. They asked not so that reason might lead them to believe. However, so that they might delight in understanding what they already believed and be ready to answer anyone who asked for a reason for their hope. Unbelievers mocked Christian simplicity, and believers themselves wondered, why an all-powerful God became man and gave life to the world by dying, when He could have saved humanity through an angel, a mere man, or a single word of His will. The early Church Fathers had written richly on the subject. Even so, Anselm chose the clear form of a question-and-answer dialogue with his friend and pupil Boso.
Boso opens their inquiry with a rule of right order. A Christian must first believe the deep mysteries of faith before presuming to test them by reason. Yet once settled in faith, it is careless and blameworthy not to seek to understand what one believes. Even if reason could never grasp how redemption works, Boso declares that nothing could tear him from his firm faith. Anselm still hesitates for three reasons. First, he fears that if his weak mind fails to satisfy a reader, that reader might blame the truth itself rather than Anselm's limited skill. Second, the inquiry requires untangling the closely linked ideas of power, necessity, and will, none of which can be understood apart from the others. Third, just as Anselm feels indignant when clumsy painters depict the Lord with a crooked, ugly shape, he fears dishonoring a beautiful mystery with crude arguments. Yielding at last to Boso's pleas and promised prayers, Anselm sets one strict condition on every argument he offers. Even if an argument seems logically proved, unless a higher Church authority confirms it, it must be received only as how the matter appears to him for now until God shows him better.
Boso then states the scoffs of unbelievers. They accuse Christians of insulting God by claiming that the Almighty entered a virgin's womb, was born of a woman, nursed on milk and ordinary food, grew tired, and suffered hunger, thirst, and whipping. Moreover, he died on a cross between thieves. Anselm answers that God's redemption displays wise and fitting harmony. Just as death entered the human race through a man's disobedience, life returned through a man's obedience. Just as sin began from a woman, Eve, the author of salvation was born of a woman, Mary. Moreover, just as the devil conquered humanity through the fruit of a tree, a man conquered the devil. He did this by dying on the wood of the cross.
Boso replies that while such parallels are beautiful to believers, unbelievers treat them as mere pictures painted on water or clouds. A painter must first choose a solid board or wall so his painting will last. Without a solid foundation of rational necessity proving why God had to stoop to such weakness, poetic harmonies look like inventions. Moreover, Boso notes, human reason would much more easily accept redemption if God had sent an angel or created a new sinless man, as He first created Adam, to rescue humanity. Anselm refutes that proposal at once. Whoever rescues a human being from eternal death rightly becomes that person's master. Humanity was created to serve God alone and to share full equality with the good angels. An angel or a mere created man had redeemed humans from eternal death. In that case, redeemed people would have become the slaves of a creature (one whom the angels do not serve). In addition, he would never have recovered their original dignity.
Unbelievers press a still sharper dilemma against calling salvation "redemption", which means buying back a captive. In whose prison, they ask, was humanity locked that God could not free people by a single word. In the same way, He created the universe by His word? Hell, the devil, and the kingdom of heaven all lie under God's irresistible power. If God could not save humanity by His will alone, He lacks all-power. If He could have done it easily by a word but chose to endure heavy labor and bloodshed without need, He lacks wisdom. Nor can Christians reply that God suffered merely to show His love. Indeed, He shows His love to the good angels without suffering for them, and an all-present God had no need to come down from heaven to defeat the devil.
Furthermore, Boso demolishes the common Christian argument that God had to proceed against the devil by legal fairness rather than by power. This is because humanity had voluntarily yielded to the devil's temptation. In doing so, he gave the devil just ownership over sinners until the devil forfeited that right by killing the sinless Christ. Neither the devil nor humanity belongs to anyone except God. Both the devil and the first human were fellow slaves of one Lord. One thief persuaded his fellow slave to desert their common Master and welcomed the runaway with the stolen property. God, the supreme Judge, took His human servant back from the fellow thief who held him (whether to punish or to pardon the human). In that case, the devil could suffer no injustice. True, sinful humans deserved punishment, and it was fitting for them to suffer at the hands of the tempter they had obeyed. Yet the devil earned no legal right or merit by tormenting humanity. This is because he acted out of spiteful malice rather than love of justice. At the same time, God merely permitted it in His wisdom to bring good out of evil.
To show how one and the same act can be both just and unjust from different sides, Boso gives an everyday example. Suppose a man wrongfully strikes an innocent person who is forbidden by law or duty to strike back. The innocent person hits his attacker in return. In that case, the blow is unjust on the part of the one who strikes back against orders. Yet just toward the attacker who deserved to be hit. In the same way, humanity suffers justly by God's righteous judgment, while the devil torments humanity unjustly out of malice. Nor does Saint Paul's phrase "the handwriting of the ordinance that was against us" (Colossians 2:14), which Christ blotted out on the cross, mean a legal debt note owned by the devil allowing him to collect sin and punishment like interest on a loan. That ordinance belonged to God, not the devil. It was God's just decree that a rational spirit who freely steps into sin cannot retrace that step or escape punishment by his own power unless divine mercy frees him. A fallen angel has no inner goodness left at all. Therefore, nothing in the devil prevented God from using His power against him to free humanity.
Anselm next answers the objection that human suffering dishonors God. The Divine Nature is impassible (incapable of suffering pain, weakness, or change). Moreover, he can never be pulled down from its majesty. Jesus Christ is true God and true Man, two natures united in one Person. Therefore, when Christians say God suffered weakness and death, they mean that the one Person suffered in His human nature. At the same time, human nature itself was lifted up. Boso accepts this distinction, but asks how God the Father could justly condemn that innocent Man (whom the Father called His beloved Son) in order to let guilty sinners go free. Anselm replies that the Father never forced Christ to die against His will. In response, Boso points to a series of biblical passages. These include Christ "became obedient unto death" (Philippians 2:8), "learned obedience by the things which He suffered" (Hebrews 5:8), "came not to do Mine own will" (John 6:38), drank "the cup which My Father hath given Me" (John 18:11), prayed "let this cup pass from Me; nevertheless not what I will, but what Thou wilt" (Matthew 26:39), and "the Father spared not His own Son" (Romans 8:32). Do not all these texts show that the Father compelled the Son to die through a command of obedience?
Anselm solves the difficulty by distinguishing what Christ did under the duty of obedience from what happened to Him. This is because He stayed faithful to that duty. The Jewish leaders persecuted Jesus to death solely because in His life and speech He held firmly to truth and righteousness. God requires every rational creature to uphold truth and righteousness, and Christ as Man owed that obedience to the Father. Yet if humanity had never sinned, God would never have required an upright rational creature (made for joyful blessedness) to suffer the misery of unwilling death. Therefore, God did not command the sinless Christ to die. Rather, Christ freely endured the death that befell Him. This is because He refused to abandon righteousness. The Father is said to have commanded it only because the Father commanded the righteous mission through which Christ incurred death.
Read in this light, every biblical text harmonizes with Christ's freedom. Saying that Christ "learned obedience" means either that Christ showed others how far obedience should go, or that He experienced in action what He already knew beforehand. Scripture says Christ was humbled unto death, "wherefore God also hath highly exalted Him" (Philippians 2:9). In response, it does not mean Christ could gain exaltation only as a reward for dying. Indeed, the Father had already given all things into His hand. Rather, because the Son, Father, and Holy Spirit had decreed to reveal the height of His power to the world only through and after His death, His exaltation is said to happen "because" of His death. In everyday speech, if a man can cross a river either on horseback or by boat, and decides to wait until a boat is ready, people rightly say, "The boat was ready, therefore he crossed." Or if a priest waits to eat until after he has said Mass that day, once Mass is finished he is told, "Now take food, because you have done that on account of which you were putting off eating." Likewise, Christ said "I came not to do Mine own will" just as Christ declared "My doctrine is not Mine". This is because a human being's upright will and true teaching come from God rather than from oneself.
Christ prayed in Gethsemane, "let this cup pass from Me". In response, His "own will" meant the natural human desire for survival by which His flesh shrank from pain. The "will of the Father" did not mean that the Father preferred the Son's death to His life. However, that the Father willed not to restore the human race unless a human being performed a deed as great as that death. We often say someone wills an outcome when he refuses to prevent it. This is as when we say a person wishes to blow out a lamp. This is because he refuses to shut the window against the wind. The Son loved human salvation so deeply that He preferred to die rather than leave the world unsaved. He received that steadfast. Therefore, righteous human will from "the Father of lights" (James 1:17), the Father is rightly said to have drawn Him, given Him the cup, and not spared Him, without any trace of coercion. True and free obedience exists precisely when a rational creature freely clings to the good will received from God. In the same way, someone who approves and does not forbid another's brave sacrifice is said to will that sacrifice. As Christ Himself declared, "No one taketh it from Me, but I lay it down of Myself" (John 10:18).
Boso agrees that Christ died of His own free will. Yet he points out that everything still depends on proving why neither the Father nor the Son could save humanity without so great a deed. To test that question strictly, Anselm and Boso seal a formal pact to govern the rest of their inquiry. First, they will never admit even the smallest hint of unworthiness or inconsistency in God. They will accept every rational proof, however small, unless a stronger reason overturns it. Second, they will set the Incarnation and everything believed about Christ completely aside as though it had never happened. In doing so, he took as their starting point only what all agree. That human beings were created for blessedness, and cannot attain that blessedness in this mortal life. He also cannot reach it without the forgiveness of sins. In addition, he cannot pass through this life without sin.
The story inside
For centuries before Anselm, many Christian teachers explained the cross as a legal contest with the devil. The first humans had willingly obeyed the devil rather than God. Therefore, the devil supposedly held a just right of ownership over humanity. God would have committed unjust violence against the devil if He had rescued humans by sheer power rather than letting the devil forfeit his claim. He did this by killing the sinless Christ. In Book I, Chapter VII, Boso dismantled this entire argument. Neither the devil nor humanity exists outside God's ownership; both are fellow slaves of one Creator. The devil persuaded humanity to rebel. In response, one thief persuaded his fellow slave to desert their common Lord and welcomed the fugitive with stolen goods. Although sinful humans justly deserved to suffer—and fittingly at the hands of the tempter they had obeyed—the devil acted out of spiteful malice rather than a love of justice. A man who is forbidden to retaliate acts wrongfully if he strikes back at an attacker who deserves to be hit. In the same way, the devil tormented humanity unjustly even while God justly permitted the punishment. Nor was Saint Paul's "handwriting of the ordinance" (Colossians 2:14) a debt contract owned by Satan. It was God's own judicial decree that a creature who freely steps into sin cannot retrace that step alone.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Poetic parallels between Eden and Calvary (such as matching Eve to Mary or the forbidden tree to the cross) cannot convince unbelievers unless theology first establishes a solid foundation of rational necessity. No sinless angel or newly created man could redeem humanity without making redeemed humans the servants of a creature rather than equals of the good angels under God alone.
- 2
The devil held no valid legal claim over sinful humanity. This is because both the devil and humans are fellow slaves belonging entirely to God. Meanwhile, humans suffered justly under God's righteous permission, the devil tormented them unjustly out of malice, and the 'handwriting of the ordinance' (Colossians 2:14) was God's judicial decree rather than a bond owed to Satan.
- 3
God the Father did not unjustly force an innocent Son to die for the guilty. A sinless human owes no duty to die. Therefore, the Father required of Christ only steadfast obedience to truth and righteousness. Christ freely endured the death that followed from keeping that righteousness. This is because He loved human salvation.
Test your recall
Why would redeeming humanity through a sinless angel or a newly created sinless man like Adam have prevented human beings from recovering the original dignity for which God created them?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
9 notesFrom Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters, trans. Anonymous (Ancient and Modern Library of Theological Literature; introductory life signed R. C.) (1909). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 371–374
“He remained unfollowed by the schoolmen; his method was like that of more modern thinkers; and he is for the devout of all ages: prayer and intellectual effort intermingle in his " Proslogion " especially.”
- 2.Lines 303–306
“Herlwin, who was of noble Danish and Flemish descent, though unlearned, welcomed the learned Italian Lan franc; and Normandy, which was really only beginning to assimilate Christianity, soon had in Bee a centre of intellectual energy which worked wonders beyond its narrow limits.”
- 3.Lines 342–345
“Only those who know his prayers and medita tions1 can appreciate the devotional side of his char acter: the intellectual side is to be studied in his theological treatises, one of which is included in this volume.”
- 4.Lines 382–385
“When he came to England, he brought these " customs " with him: novelties they were in that realm, but his power bore down everything, and he generally used it in the cause of right and order.”
- 5.Lines 460–463
“<source_page ref="page 20" capture="20"> xvi Life of St Anselm. trust him as his father.”
- 6.Lines 499–502
“Anselm asked the great assembly how he was to keep his obedience to the Apostolic See without breaking his faith to the king.”
- 7.Lines 577–580
“Pope Urban died July 1099; King William, August iioo, while Anselm was working in the diocese of Lyons: his return was urgently desired by Henry and the barons, and on 23rd September iioo he landed: met the king at Salisbury.”
- 8.Lines 655–658
“Paschal wrote courteously to the king, gave Anselm his blessing, and confirmed him in the primacy of Canter bury.”
- 9.Lines 694–697
“In September 1106 Henry by the victory at Pinchebrai became master of Normandy, and in August 1107 an assembly was held at London.”
