Catholic Saints · Aosta
- Canonized Saint
- Feast 21 April
- d. 21 April 1109, Canterbury
- 4 sources

Saint Anselm of Canterbury (1033–1109)
Also known as Anselm of Aosta, Anselm of Bec, Doctor Magnificus
How did Saint Anselm of Canterbury defend liberty under William Rufus and Henry I?
Saint Anselm of Canterbury (1033/34–21 April 1109), born at Aosta, was Prior and Abbot of Bec before becoming Archbishop of Canterbury in 1093. Declared a Doctor of the Church in 1720, he composed the Proslogium and Cur Deus Homo and defended liberty under William Rufus and Henry I.12345
Life and remembrance
Traditional account
Saint Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury and Doctor of the Church, was born at Aosta in 1033 or 1034. Aosta was a Burgundian town on the border of Lombardy, and Anselm died on 21 April 1109. His father Gundulf was born in Lombardy and settled as a citizen of Aosta. His mother Ermenberga came from an old Burgundian family and taught him his earliest Christian devotion. In Vita S. Anselmi (I, i), his student and biographer Eadmer preserved a childhood dream shared by Anselm himself. Imagining that Heaven rested on the Alpine peaks around Aosta, young Anselm dreamed he climbed up to God's court. On the plain he scolded the King's lazy servants for reaping the autumn harvest carelessly. God welcomed the boy and had the royal cupbearer feed him soft white bread. Before turning fifteen, Anselm asked to join a local monastery, but the abbot refused out of fear of Gundulf. Hoping the monks would admit him if he seemed dying, the boy even prayed for an illness. After Ermenberga died and Gundulf treated him harshly, Anselm crossed the Mont Cenis pass on foot with one servant. Weak on the mountain pass, he revived himself with snow and a scrap of bread found in the baggage. After nearly three years in Burgundy and France, he came through Avranches to Normandy's Abbey of Bec under Lanfranc.1
Studying and teaching beside Lanfranc at Bec, Anselm weighed three possible paths for his life. His father Gundulf had recently died after becoming a monk. Anselm could enter Bec, use his family inheritance to help the poor, or live alone as a hermit. Advised by Lanfranc and Archbishop Maurilius of Rouen, Anselm became a Benedictine monk at Bec in 1060 at age twenty-seven. Canon Adolphe Porée proved the timeline from Anselm's letters (Epistolae, III, vii) and the Bec chronicle compiled by 1136. Anselm wore the monastic habit for forty-nine years in all. He spent three years as a simple monk without office (1060–1063). When Lanfranc became Abbot of Caen, Anselm served fifteen years as Prior, or second-in-command, of Bec (1063–1078). Succeeding Bec's founder Herluin, he served fifteen years as Abbot, or head, of Bec (1078–1093). Finally, he served sixteen years as Archbishop of Canterbury (1093–1109). Older monks at Bec at first resented the young newcomer's rise to prior, yet his steady gentleness won them over. As prior he composed the Monologium and Proslogium. At Archbishop Maurilius's order, he kept his office instead of retiring to solitude.2
In 1078 the monks elected Anselm Abbot of Bec. Weeping face down on the floor, he begged release, while the monks lay face down begging him to accept. In 1079 Anselm visited Bec's lands in England, where Archbishop Lanfranc welcomed him at Canterbury. Eadmer, then a young Canterbury monk, recorded their meeting. Historian Edward Augustus Freeman later praised it (History of the Norman Conquest, IV, 442). Lanfranc doubted whether Anglo-Saxon Archbishop Alphege (Aelfheah) was truly a martyr. Danish raiders had killed Alphege because he refused a ransom that would strip his poor people, not directly over creed. Anselm answered that a man who died rather than wrong his people would still more gladly die for the Faith. Since Christ Himself is truth and justice, whoever dies for truth and justice dies for Christ. Respected across Normandy and England, Anselm was called in 1087 to the deathbed of King William the Conqueror.2
After Lanfranc died in 1089, King William Rufus left the See of Canterbury empty for four years and seized its income. Anselm avoided England so no one would think he wanted the archbishopric. In 1092, however, the sick Hugh, Earl of Chester, begged him to cross over. Anselm spoke plainly to the king about the abuses hurting England. At the bishops' request, he also composed a prayer read in English churches asking God to give Canterbury a shepherd. Early in 1093, William Rufus fell gravely ill at Gloucester and repented, naming Anselm Archbishop of Canterbury. Anselm resisted hard, yet bishops and barons dragged him to the royal bed and forced the staff against his fist. Chanting the Te Deum hymn, they carried him into the church. Once healthy again, the king resumed his demands, yet Anselm refused to approve royal seizures of Canterbury's lands. When the king scorned a freewill gift of five hundred marks, Anselm refused to raise it. On 4 December 1093, Anselm was consecrated only after stating his prior loyalty to Pope Urban II against Antipope Clement III (Guibert).3
Anselm asked royal leave to visit Rome for the pallium, the white wool band worn by archbishops as a sign of office. William Rufus answered that no subject in England could recognize any pope without the king's leave. At the Council of Rockingham in March 1095, Anselm firmly defended Pope Urban II as Saint Peter's successor (Eadmer, Historia Novorum, lib. I; cf. W. F. Hook, Lives of the Archbishops of Canterbury, II, 183). William Rufus secretly sent envoys to Rome who recognized Urban II. They returned with Cardinal Walter, Bishop of Albano, carrying the pallium. However, the king could not persuade the papal envoy to remove Anselm from office. Facing rebellions in Wales and northern England, the king made peace, yet Anselm refused the pallium from the king's hand. Instead, Anselm lifted it himself from the altar of Canterbury Cathedral on 10 June 1095. In 1097 the king accused him of sending poor soldiers for the Welsh war. Blocked from appealing to Rome until a final meeting at Winchester, Anselm blessed the king and went into exile.3
On the continent, Anselm confirmed crowds at Saint-Omer and spent Christmas at Cluny and winter at Lyons. In spring 1098 he crossed Mont Cenis dressed as a simple monk, and Pope Urban II welcomed him warmly at Rome. As guest of the Abbot of Telese, Anselm spent the summer at the mountain village of Liberi (Schlavi). There he finished Cur Deus Homo, begun in England, on why God became man to save sinners. At the Council of Bari in October 1098, Urban II called on Anselm. He answered Greek bishops' objections on how the Holy Spirit comes forth from Father and Son (later De Processione Spiritus Sancti). When the council moved to excommunicate—cut off from the sacraments—William Rufus over Canterbury, Anselm pleaded to stop the sentence. At Easter 1099 in the Lateran Council, Anselm heard papal laws renewing excommunication against lay investiture, where rulers hand out spiritual posts.3
Back at Lyons in August 1100, Anselm learned of William Rufus's sudden death in the New Forest. England's new king, Henry I, soon called Anselm home. At Salisbury, Anselm refused fresh lay investiture or feudal homage to the king, citing the 1099 Lateran decrees. While royal envoys asked Rome for a special exemption, Anselm gave King Henry two crucial services. First, at a Lambeth council, he proved that Edith (Matilda), daughter of Saint Margaret of Scotland, had never taken nuns' vows. She had worn a convent veil only for safety, so she could marry the king, and Anselm blessed their wedding. Second, Henry's older brother Duke Robert of Normandy invaded at Portsmouth in 1101. Anselm's moral authority kept the wavering barons loyal to Henry.4
Pope Paschal II refused Henry's request for an exemption on investitures and denied the royal envoys' claim of an oral promise. Anselm held a reform council at Westminster in 1102 and refused to consecrate bishops appointed with royal symbols. At the king's request, he traveled a second time to Rome in 1103. Henry barred him from returning unless he accepted royal customs, so Anselm stayed at Lyons until 1105. Paschal II then excommunicated Henry's advisers over lay investiture. Anselm visited Henry's recovering sister, Countess Adela of Blois, who arranged a meeting at Laigle in July 1105. At the Council of London in August 1107, both sides reached a lasting settlement. King Henry gave up handing bishops and abbots the spiritual ring and staff. Meanwhile, the Church let prelates pledge homage for earthly lands, paving the way for Germany's Concordat of Worms in 1122. Anselm spent his last two years in peace and writing until his death at Canterbury on 21 April 1109.4
Pope Clement XI named Anselm a Doctor of the Church in 1720. Alongside Athanasius, Augustine, and Thomas Aquinas, he stands as a founder of Scholastic theology and medieval philosophy. Against Roscelin's extreme Nominalism—treating general ideas as mere words—Anselm defended Augustinian and Platonic Realism on Universals. His treatises explored the Trinity (De Processione Spiritus Sancti), Christ's saving work (Cur Deus Homo), free will, and predestination. In philosophy he is famed for the Proslogium's ontological argument for God's existence, reasoned from the very idea of God. Defining God as 'that than which nothing greater can be thought' (id quo majus cogitari nequit), Anselm compared mind and reality. Existing in reality is greater than existing in the mind alone, so God necessarily exists in reality. Eadmer relates that Anselm lost sleep and appetite at Bec until this proof flashed clearly into his mind. Written first on wax tablets that vanished and next on tablets found smashed, it was pieced together onto parchment. The monk Gaunilo of Marmoutiers disputed it (answered in Liber Apologeticus), as did Thomas Aquinas and Immanuel Kant later. Yet Alexander of Hales, Duns Scotus, René Descartes, G. W. F. Hegel, and Johann Adam Möhler adopted forms of it.5
Alban Butler's biography (drawn from Eadmer) and later saint lives preserve further details of Anselm's youth, teaching, and firmness. His father Gundulph was a Lombard nobleman, and Ermenberga's family came from Saint-Pourçain in Auvergne with lands near Mount Cenis. In Aosta the boy dreamed he climbed the Alps to the Great King's court. After scolding careless harvesters below, he received shining white bread from the King. Turned away at fifteen by Abbot Maurus out of fear of Gundulph, he spent three years at Burgundy's independent Abbey of Dijon. At Bec he began his logic book (*De grammatico*) and composed his sermon on *Intravit Jesus in quoddam castellum*. There he also started *De concordia praescientiae et praedestinationis et gratiae Dei cum libero arbitrio*, finishing it at Canterbury. At Bec he gently corrected a neighboring abbot whose constant beatings failed to reform schoolboys. He compared such harshness to cramping a young tree until its branches grow crooked. He also convinced Lanfranc that Saint Elphege was a true martyr for justice and truth. Elphege had died rather than tax Canterbury's poor tenants to pay his ransom. As archbishop, rather than aid royal extortion, Anselm gave the poor a large sum demanded by William Rufus at his installation. Tradition also recalls that he put out a Winchester fire with the Cross and opened a healing spring on Mount Liberi near Capua.67
Remember
- Born at Aosta in 1033 or 1034 to Gundulf and Ermenberga, Saint Anselm entered the Norman Abbey of Bec under Lanfranc in 1060, serving fifteen years as Prior (1063–1078) and fifteen years as Abbot (1078–1093).12
- Forced at Gloucester in 1093 to accept the Archbishopric of Canterbury under King William Rufus, he defended Pope Urban II at the Council of Rockingham (1095) and went into exile (1097–1100).3
- During his first Italian exile he finished Cur Deus Homo at Liberi, defended the Procession of the Holy Spirit at the Council of Bari (1098), and interceded to spare William Rufus from excommunication.3
- Under King Henry I he confirmed Queen Matilda's freedom to marry at Lambeth, endured a second exile (1103–1106) over lay investiture, and secured the 1107 London concordat ending royal investiture with ring and crosier.4
- Declared a Doctor of the Church by Pope Clement XI in 1720 (feast 21 April), he formulated the ontological argument for God's existence in the Proslogium and answered Gaunilo's critique.5
Check yourself
How does Saint Anselm's Proslogium formulate the ontological argument for the existence of God, what happened twice to the wax tablets on which it was first written at Bec, and how did the 1107 Council of London resolve the English investiture dispute?
Writings and words
- MonologiumComing soon · Written by this author
- Proslogium (and Liber Apologeticus contra Gaunilonem)Coming soon · Written by this author
- Cur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his Letters · Written by this author · 1098 (Letters 1060–1109; 1909 Edinburgh edition)
- Treatise on the Procession of the Holy Spirit (De Processione Spiritus Sancti)Coming soon · Written by this author · 1098
- Prayers and Meditations (Orationes et Meditationes) and LettersComing soon · Written by this author
- Commentaries on the Epistles of Saint PaulComing soon · Not written by this author
“that than which nothing greater can be thought”
“You have not yet considered of what weight sin is.”
“To sin is nothing else than not to render to God His due.”
“Let his whole body be clothed from the crown of his head to the sole of his foot with the skin of your Anselm, and his mouth is mine.”
Decisions and stakes
- The King's Request at Windsor
Since Lanfranc died a year after William the Conqueror, King William Rufus has left Canterbury empty for over three years. During that gap, the king seized Canterbury's income, gave church lands to his knights, and let disorder spread. Falling dangerously ill at Gloucester in March 1093, the frightened king named you Archbishop of Canterbury. Courtiers forced the bishop's staff into your hand against your protests. Formal release from Bec still required consent from Normandy's duke, Rouen's archbishop, and Bec's monks. Once recovered, however, the king broke his promises of reform. Before consecration, you set three firm conditions. You required all Lanfranc's Canterbury lands back, a voice as royal spiritual adviser, and loyalty to Pope Urban II against Antipope Clement. Now letters from Normandy have freed you from Bec, and William Rufus summons you to Windsor. He asks as a personal favor that his knights keep the Canterbury church lands granted after Lanfranc's death.
Choice: According to R. C.'s introductory biography, Anselm refused the king's request at Windsor. Consenting would have caused a lasting loss to the Church, which Anselm knew he had no right to allow.
- The Assembly at Rockingham
Since your consecration in December 1093, King William Rufus has clashed with you again and again. He scorned a money gift as too small and angrily refused your February 1094 plea for a council against moral abuses. After his return from Normandy, you asked leave to visit Rome for your pallium. The pallium is the white wool band with four crosses given by the Pope to new archbishops. William Rufus refused, claiming no one in England could recognize Pope Urban II—contested by Antipope Clement—without royal leave. Yet before consecration in 1093, you had already stated your prior recognition of Urban II as Abbot of Bec. You had warned the king that you could never drop that obedience. At your request, England's great council meets at Rockingham in Derbyshire on 11 March 1095. You ask how to keep obedience to Rome without breaking faith with the king. Afraid of the king's anger, the English bishops press you with threats to drop Urban II and submit to the king.
Choice: Anselm stood firm against the bishops' pressure and threats, refusing to give up his obedience to Pope Urban II.
- The Runaway Monk of Canterbury
As Abbot of Bec, you share close friendship with Prior Henry, Gondulph, Archbishop Lanfranc, and the monks of Canterbury. Earlier you advised Prior Henry not to crush stumbling young monks with harshness, but to win their trust with kindness first. Now Brother Moses, a Canterbury monk misled into running away in youthful folly, arrives weeping at Bec with a servant. Like the prodigal son, Moses longs to return to Canterbury, even as a hired worker, yet two fears terrify him. First, though ready for bodily punishment himself, he dreads seeing Canterbury severely punish the servant whom he misled. Second, he carelessly spent borrowed money; owning nothing as a monk, he needs Canterbury's help and leave to repay it. Moses begs you to plead with Prior Henry and get a written answer before he starts back.
Choice: In a heartfelt letter to Prior Henry and the Canterbury monks, Abbot Anselm pleaded for Moses and his servant. Declaring both men clothed in his own skin ('skin for skin'), he begged Canterbury to spare them harsh blows. He also asked leave and help for Moses to repay the borrowed money, requesting a written answer before Moses set out.
- The Secret Message From Rome
Called home from three years of exile after William Rufus died, you published Pope Urban II's Roman decree in England. No layman may grant bishoprics or abbeys (lay investiture), no churchman may swear homage for them, and violators face excommunication. When King Henry of England refused to give up royal investitures, both sides agreed to consult Pope Paschal II. Now you hold a written letter from Paschal II upholding the ban, yet Henry refuses to read yours or show his. Instead, the king's envoys—the Archbishop of York and two bishops—claim the Pope gave them a secret spoken message. They claim Paschal orally allowed Henry to grant investitures without excommunication so long as he rules well otherwise. They add that the Pope kept it unwritten only lest other princes complain, and ordered you to follow their counsel. Meanwhile, the king threatens immediate investitures and exile if you enforce the written ban.
Choice: Anselm stood caught between the Pope's written letter and the three bishops' sworn spoken report. He secured a truce until messengers could bring an unmistakable written answer from Paschal II. Meanwhile, he approved nothing against the Roman decree and refused to plead against the law, yet called no one disobedient.
- The Priests Who Chose Their Wives Over the Altar
With King Henry's agreement, you and England's bishops held the Council of London, strictly forbidding priests to marry or keep wives. Now Bishop Herbert of Thioford urgently reports a wide revolt across his diocese. Refusing to part from their wives, many married parish priests are giving up all priestly duties in protest. They refuse to say Mass, consecrate the Lord's Body, hear confessions, or bury the dead. Because chaste parish priests are scarce, the rebels expect fear of leaving laypeople without sacraments will force bishops to yield. Few chaste parish priests live locally, though monasteries in the region have professed monks, including elderly ones. Meanwhile, the rebel priests still hold church buildings and lands with their women and may attack chaste replacements.
Choice: Anselm instructed Bishop Herbert not to soften a single point of the Council of London. Those priests had chosen their wives over the altar, so Herbert had to replace them with chaste priests. Where chaste parish priests were lacking, Herbert was to order monks—even elderly ones—to say Mass for the people. Chosen clergy would bring the Eucharist to the sick, hear confessions, and bury the dead, while laypeople helped remove resisting rebels.
Feast days and patronage
- 21 April — General Roman Calendar (Doctor of the Church, 1720) (Universal · memorial)
Virtues
Facts and sources
Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.
The Church status of Saint Anselm of Canterbury is Saint and Doctor of the Church (declared by Pope Clement XI in 1720).
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91288–91289, 91725–91726)
Born at Aosta in 1033 or 1034 to the Lombard Gundulf and the Burgundian Ermenberga, Anselm became a monk at the Abbey of Bec under Lanfranc in 1060, Prior of Bec in 1063, and Abbot of Bec in 1078.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91288–91293, 91375–91394, 91413–91415)
During his 1079 visit to Canterbury, Anselm defended the martyrdom of the Anglo-Saxon Archbishop Alphege (Aelfheah) before Lanfranc, arguing that he who dies for truth and justice dies for Christ.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91424–91447)
Forcibly invested as Archbishop of Canterbury at King William Rufus's sickbed in 1093 and consecrated on 4 December 1093, Anselm defended Pope Urban II at the Council of Rockingham (March 1095), took his pallium from the altar at Canterbury (10 June 1095), and went into exile in 1097.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91483–91571)
In Italy in 1098 Anselm completed Cur Deus Homo near Telese, defended the Procession of the Holy Spirit at the Council of Bari while interceding against William Rufus's excommunication, and attended the Easter 1099 Lateran Council condemning lay investiture.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91578–91602)
Under King Henry I, Anselm refused lay investiture, confirmed Edith's (Matilda's) freedom to marry the king at Lambeth, endured a second exile (1103–1105), and achieved the 1107 Council of London concordat whereby the king relinquished investiture with ring and crosier while prelates did homage for temporalities.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91604–91700)
Anselm died at Canterbury on 21 April 1109 (his feast day); his works include the Monologium, the Proslogium (containing the ontological argument for the existence of God), Cur Deus Homo, De Processione Spiritus Sancti, Prayers and Meditations, and Letters.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91290, 91401–91403, 91726–91727, 91749–91868)
Primary sources and editions cited for Saint Anselm include his Letters, Eadmer's Vita S. Anselmi and Historia Novorum (ed. Martin Rule, Rolls Series), John of Salisbury, editions by Raynaud (1630) and Gerberon (1675, 1721; Migne P.L.), and studies by d'Aguirre, Ocsényi, Rule, Ragey, Möhler, Hasse, Rémusat, Hook, Church, Freeman, and Bainvel.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assizevol. I, pp. 546–550 (clean-text lines 91848–91900)
Before and during his monastic years at the exempt Abbey of Dijon and at Bec, Saint Anselm began his treatise on logic, composed his homily on Intravit Jesus in quoddam castellum, and commenced his treatise on the Harmony of Foreknowledge, Predestination, and Free-will with Grace, which he completed at Canterbury.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal SaintsAlban Butler, Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal Saints (1866), April 21, St. Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury, lines 10722-10755
When summoned by King William Rufus to pay a large sum of money upon his installation as Archbishop of Canterbury, Saint Anselm refused lest he appear to countenance royal extortion of Church property and distributed the money among the poor.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidencePictorial Lives of the Saints, with Reflections for Every Day in the YearJohn Gilmary Shea (ed.), Pictorial Lives of the Saints (1889), April 21, St. Anselm, Archbishop, lines 8846-8871
At Windsor in 1093, Archbishop-designate Anselm refused King William Rufus’s request that royal military vassals retain Canterbury church lands granted since Lanfranc’s death, forcing the king to restore the see’s estates before Anselm’s enthronement on 5 September 1093.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceCur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his LettersIntroductory Life of St. Anselm (R. C.), pp. xv–xvi (lines 469–483)
At the Council of Rockingham on 11 March 1095, when English bishops urged Anselm to renounce his obedience to Pope Urban II and submit to King William Rufus, Anselm stood firm, winning the support of the lay barons and later taking his pallium from the altar at Canterbury on 10 June 1095.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceCur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his LettersIntroductory Life of St. Anselm (R. C.), pp. xvi–xvii (lines 483–527)
When the runaway Canterbury monk Brother Moses took refuge at Bec in fear of punishment for his attendant and an unpaid money debt, Abbot Anselm wrote to Prior Henry offering his own ‘skin for skin’ to spare both men and help settle the debt.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceCur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his LettersSelection from his Letters, Part II, Letter 16 to Prior Henry, pp. 133–135 (lines 5810–5878)
When three royal bishops claimed Pope Paschal II had given King Henry I a secret verbal exemption permitting lay investiture contrary to the Pope’s written letter, Anselm obtained a truce to seek written certainty from Rome while refusing to consent to any breach of the Roman Council’s decree.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceCur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his LettersSelection from his Letters, Part III, Letter 39 to Pope Paschal II, pp. 179–181 (lines 7527–7595)
When married priests in Bishop Herbert of Thioford’s diocese resigned their priestly ministry rather than their wives after the Council of London, Archbishop Anselm directed Herbert not to relax the decree, to deploy chaste priests or monks to celebrate Mass, and to call on lay Christians to expel defiant priests from church lands.
Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceCur Deus Homo, to which is added a Selection from his LettersSelection from his Letters, Part III, Letter 87 to Bishop Herbert, pp. 239–240 (lines 9805–9838)
Sources
W. H. Kent, “Anselm, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. I, pp. 546–550. About this source
Notes and sources
- The Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume I: Aachen–Assize · Charles G. Herbermann, Edward A. Pace, Condé B. Pallen, Thomas J. Shahan, John J. Wynne (eds.) · New York: Robert Appleton Company (Original Edition) (1907) · Read the edition
- The Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal Saints · Alban Butler · Dublin: James Duffy (1866) · Read the edition
- Pictorial Lives of the Saints, with Reflections for Every Day in the Year · John Gilmary Shea (ed.) · Compiled from Butler's Lives and Other Approved Sources (New York, Cincinnati, and Chicago: Benziger Brothers) (1889) · Read the edition
1. Covers his birth at Aosta (1033–34) to Gundulf and Ermenberga, death (21 April 1109), Eadmer's account (Vita S. Anselmi, I, i) of his childhood dream of climbing the mountain to God's court and eating white bread, early request to enter a monastery, departure across Mont Cenis after his mother's death, and arrival at the Abbey of Bec under Lanfranc.
1. Birth at Aosta (1033/34), boyhood dream of the court of Heaven, crossing of Mont Cenis, and arrival at Bec under LanfrancLines 91288–91361
Original passage
“Anselm, S.atnt, Archbishop of Canterbury, Doctor of the Church, b. at Aosta, a Burgundian town on the confines of Lombardy, 1033-34; d. 21 April, 1109. His father, Gundidf . was a Lombard who had become a citizen of Aosta, and his mother, Ermenberga, came of an old Burgundian family. Like many other saints, Anselm learnt the first lessons of piety from his mother, and at a very early age he was fired with the love of learning. In after life he still cherished the memories of cliildliood, and his biographer, Eadmer, has preserved some incidents whicli he had learnt from the saint's own lips. The cliild had heard his mother speak of God, Who dwelt on high, ruling all things. Living in the mountains, he thought that Heaven must be on their lofty summits. "And while he often revolved these matters in his mind, it chanced that one night he saw in a vision that he must go up to tlie summit of the mountain and hasten to the court of God, the great King. But before he began to ascend the mountain, he saw in the j^lain through which he had passed to its foot, women, who were the King's handmaidens, reaping the corn; but they were doing this very negligently and slothfuUy. Then, gricvitig for their sloth, and rebuking them, he bethought him that he would accuse them before their Lord and King. Thereafter, having climbed the mountain ho entered the royal court. There he found the King with only his cupbearer. For it seemed that, as it was now Autumn, the King had sent his household to gather the harvest. As the boy entered he was called by the Master, and drawing nigh he sat at his feet. Then with cheery kindliness he was asked who and whence he was and what he was seeking. To these questions he made answer as well as he knew. Then at the Master's command some moist white liread was brought him by the cu|v bearer and he feasted thereon in his presence, wherefore when morning came and he brought to mind the things he had .seen, tis a simnle and innocent child he Jaclieved that he liad truly been fed in heaven with the bread of the Lord, and this he publicly atfirmea in the presence of others". (Eadmer, Life of St. Anselm, I, i.) Eadmer adds that the boy was beloved by all and made rapid progress in learning. Before he was fifteen he sought admission to a monastery. But the abbot, fearing the father's displeasure, refused him. The boy then made a strange prayer. He asked for an illness, thinking this would move the monks to jaeld to his wishes. The illness came, but his admission to the monastery was still denied him. None the less he determined to gain his end at some future date. But ere long he was drawn away by the pleasures of youth and lost his first ardour and his love of learning. His love for his mother in some measure restrained him. But on her death it seemed that his anchor was lost, and he was at the mercy of the waves. At this time his father treated him with great harshness; so much so that he resolved to leave his home. Taking a single companion, he set out on foot to cross Mont Cenis. At one time he was fainting with hunger and was fain to refresh his strength TOth snow, when the servant found that some bread was still left in the baggage, and Anselm regained strength and continued the journey. After passing nearly three years in Burgundy and France, he came into Normandy and tarried for a while at Avranches before finding his home at the Abbey of Bee, then made illustrious by Lanfranc's learning, .\nselm profited so well by the lessons of this master that he became his most familiar disciple and shared in the work of teaching. After spending some time in this”
2. Covers his monastic profession at Bec in 1060, Canon Porée's chronological verification from Epistolae III, vii and the Bec chronicle (3 years monk, 15 prior, 15 abbot, 16 archbishop), composition of the Monologium and Proslogium, election as Abbot in 1078 after Herluin's death, 1079 visit to Lanfranc at Canterbury (quoted from Freeman, History of the Norman Conquest, IV, 442), defense of the martyrdom of Archbishop Alphege (Aelfheah), first meeting with Eadmer, and attendance on William the Conqueror's deathbed.
2. Monk (1060), Prior (1063), and Abbot (1078) of Bec, 1079 visit to Canterbury, defense of Saint Alphege, and William the ConquerorLines 91361–91457
Original passage
“work of teaching. After spending some time in this labour, he began to think that his toil \iould have more merit if he took the monastic habit. But at first he felt some reluctance to enter tlie Abbey of Bee, where he would be overshadowed by Lanfranc, After a time, however, he saw that it would profit him to remain where he would be surpassed by others. His father was now dead, ha\'ing ended his days in the monastic habit, and Anselm had some thought of living on his patrimony and relieving the needy. The life of a hermit also presented itself to him as a third alternative. Anxious to act with prudence, he first asked the adWce of Lanfranc, who referred the matter to the Archbishop of Rouen. This prelate decided in favour of the monastic life, and Anselm became a monk in the Abbey of Bee. This was in 1060. His life as a simple monk lasted for three years, for in 1063 Lanfranc was appointed Abbot of Caen, and Anselm was elected t o succeed him as Prior. There is some doubt as to the date of this appointment. But Canon Poree points out that Anselm, writing at the time of his election as Archbishop (1093), says that he had then lived thirtythree years in the monastic habit, three years as a monk without preferment, fifteen as prior, and fifteen as abbot (Letters of Anselm, III, vii). This is confirmed by an entry in the chronicle of the Abbey of Bee, which was compiled not later than 1136 Here it is recorded that Anselm died in 1109, in the forty-ninth year of his monastic life atid the seventysixth of his age, having been three years a simple monk; fifteen, prior; fifteen, abbot; and sixteen, archbishop (Por<;e, Histoire de I'abbaye de Bee III, 173). At first his promotion to the office vacated by Lanfranc gave offence to some of the other monks who considered they had a better claim than the young stranger. But Anselm overcame their opposition by gentleness, and ere long had won their affection and obedience. To the duties of prior he added those of teacher. It was likewise dming this period that he composed some of his philo,>-ophical and theological works, notably, the ".Moiiologium" and the " Proslogivun ". Besides giving good counsel to the monies imder his care, he foimd time to comfort others by his letters. Rememl)ering his attraction for the solitude of a hermitage we can hardly wonder that he felt oppressed by this busy Ufe and longed to lay aside his office and give himself up to the delights of contemplation. But the Archbishop of Kouoii bade him retain his office and prepare for yet greater burdens. This advice was prophetic, for in 1078, on tlic death of Herhiin, founder and first Abbot of Bee, Anselm was elected to succeed him. It wjis with difficulty that the monks overcame his reluctance to accept the ofiicc. His biographer, Kadiiicr, gives us a picture of a strange scene. The Al)l)<)t-clect fell prostrate l>efore the brethren and with tears besought them not to lay this burden on him, while they prostrated themselves and earnestly begged him to accept the office. His election at once brought Anselm into relations with England, where the Norman abbey had several possessions. In the first year of his office, he visited C'anterbury where he was welcomed by Lanfranc. "The converse of Lanfranc and Anselm", says Professor Freeman, ".sets before us a remarkable and memorable pair. The lawyer, the secular scholar, met the divine and the philosopher; the ecclesiastical statesman stood face to face with the saint. The wisdom, conscientious no doubt but still hard and worldly, which could guide churches and kingdoms in troublous times was met bj' the boundless love which took in all God's creatures of whatever race or species" (History of the Norman Conquest, IV, 442). It is interesting to note that one of the matters discus.sed on this occasion related to a Sa.xon archbishop. Klphage (.I'^lfheah), who had been put to death by the Danes for refusing to pay a ran.som which would iin|)overish his people. Lanfranc doubted his claim to the honours of a martyr since he did not die for the Faith. But Anselm solved the difficulty by saying that he who died for this lesser reason would nuich more be ready to die for the Faith. Moreover, Christ is truth and justice, and he who dies for truth and justice dies for Christ. It was on this occasion that .\nsolm first met Eadmer, then a young monk of Canterbury. At the same time the saint, who in his childhood was loved by all who knew him, and who, :us Prior of Bee, had won the affection of those who resisted his authority, was already gaining the hearts of Knglishinen. His fame had spread far and wide, and many of the great men of the age prized his friendship and sought his coun-sel. Among these wxs William the Conqueror, who desired that Anselm might come to give him consolation on his death-bed.”
3. Covers William Rufus's four-year vacancy of Canterbury, Anselm's 1092 visit at the request of Hugh, Earl of Chester, the forced investiture at the sick king's bedside in early 1093, consecration on 4 December 1093, the Council of Rockingham in March 1095 upholding Pope Urban II (quoting Dean Hook, Lives of the Archbishops of Canterbury, II, 183), Cardinal Walter of Albano's legation and Anselm taking the pallium from the altar on 10 June 1095, the 1097 departure into exile, completion of Cur Deus Homo at Telese's mountain village, the Council of Bari in October 1098 on the Procession of the Holy Spirit, and the Easter 1099 Lateran Council decrees against lay investiture.
3. Forced election to Canterbury (1093), conflicts with William Rufus, Council of Rockingham (1095), the pallium, and first exile (1097)Lines 91459–91602
Original passage
“When Lanfranc died, William llufus kept the See of Canterbury vacant for four years, seized its revenues, and kept the Church in England in a state of anarchy. To many the .^blxit of Bee seemed to be the man best fitted for the archbishopric. The general desire was so e\'ident that Anselm felt a reluctance to visit England lest it should appear that he was seeking the office. .\t length, however, he yielded to tiie entreaty of Hugh, Earl of Chester and came to England in 1092. Arriving in Canterbury on the eve of the NatiWty of the Ble,ssed Virgin, he was hailed by the people as their future archbishop; but he hastened away and would in no wise consent to remain for the festival. At a private interview with the King, who received him Kindly, he spoke freely on the evils by which the land was made desolate. Anselm's own affairs kept him in England for some months, but when he wished to return to Bee the King objected. .Meanwhile the people made no secret of their desires. With the King's pomii.ssion, prayers were offered in all the churches that God would move the King to deliver the Church of Canterbury by the an[x>intment of a pxstor, and at the request of the l)ishops .\n.selm drew up the form of prayer. The King fell ill early in the new year (1093), and on his sick-bed he was moved to repentance. The prelates and barons urged on him the necessity L— 35 of electing an archbishop. Yielding to the manifest desire of all he named Anselm, and all joyfully concurred in the election. Aaselm, however, firmly refu.sed the honour, whereupon another scene took place still more strange than that which occurred when he was elected aljlwit. He Wius dragged by force to the King's bedside, and a pastoral staff was thrust into his closed hand; he was borne thence to the altar where the "Te Deum" was sung. There is no rciison to suspect the sincerity of this resistance. Naturally drawn to contemplation, Anselm could have little liking for such an office even in a period of peace; still less could he desire it in those stormy days. He knew full well what awaited him. The King's repentance passed away with his sickness, and An.selm soon saw signs of trouble. His first offence was his refusal to consent to the alienation of Church lands which the King had granted to his followers. Another difficulty arose from the King's need of money. Although his see was impoverished by the royal rapacity, the Archbishop was expected to make his majesty a free gift ; and when he offered five hundred marks they were scornfully refused as insufficient. As if these trials were not enough, Anselm had to bear the reproaches of some of the monks of Bee who were loath to lose him; in his letters he is at pains to show that he did not desire the office. He finally was consecrated Archbisho]) of Canterburj', 4 December, 1093. It now remained for him to go to Rome to obtain the pallium. But here was a fresh occasion of trouble. The Antipope Clement was disputing the authority of Urban II, who had been recognized by France and Normandy. It does not appear that the English King was a partisan of the .'Vntiiiopo, but he wished to strengthen his own position oy ;i.s.scrting his right to decide between the rival claimants. Hence, when Anselm asked leave to go to the Pope, the King said that no one in England sho\ild acknowledge either Pope till he, the King, had deciilcd the nuitter. The .\rcnbishop insisted on going to Vo\>v I'rban, whose authority he had already acknowledged, and, as he had told the King, this was one of the conditions on which alone he would accept the archbishopric. This grave question was referred to a coimcil of the realm held at Rockingham in March, 109.5. Here Anselm boldly asserted the authority of Urban. His speech is a memorable testimony to the doctrine of papal supremacy. It is significant that not one of the bishops could call it in question (Eadmer, Historia Novorum, lib. I). Regarding Anselm's l>elief on this point we may cite the frank words of Dean Hook: "Anselm was .sunply a papist; He believed that St. Peter was the Prince of the .\postles; that as such he was the source of all ecclesiastical authority and power; that the pope was his successor; and that consequently, to the pope was due, from the bishops and metropolitans as well as from the rest of mankind, the obedience which a spiritual suzerain has the right to expect from his vassals" [Lives of the Archbishops of Canterbun,-. (London. lS()0-75), II, 1S,3]. William now sent envoys to Rome to get the palliimi. They found Urban in possession and recognized him. Walter, Bishop of .Albano, came back with them as legate bearing the pallium. The King pubhcly acknowledged the authority of Urban, and at first endeavoured to get .\n.sclm deposed by the legate. Eventually a reconciliation was occasioned by the royal difficulties in Wales and in the north. Tlie King and the -Vrchbishop met in peace, .\nsclm would not take the pallium from the King's hand; but in a solemn service at Canterbury, on 10 June. 109.'), it was laid on the altar by the legate, whence .\nselm took it. Fresh trouble arose in 1097. t)n returning from his ineffectual Welsh campaign William brought a charge against the .\rchbishop in regard to the contingent ho had furnished and required him to meet this cliarge in the King's court. Ansehn dechncd ami asked leave to go to Rome. This was refused, but after a meeting at Winchester Anselm wa.s told to be ready to sail in ten days. On parting with tlie King, the Archbisliop gave iiim his blessing, which WiUiam received with bowed head. At St. Omcr's Anselm confirmed a multitude of persons. Cliristmas was spent at Cluny, and the rest of the winter at Lyons. In the spring he resumed his journey and crossed Mont Cenis with two companions, all travelling as simple monks. At tlie monasteries on their way they were frequently asked for news of Anselm. On his arrival in Rome he was treated with great lionour by the Pope. His case was considered and laid before the council, but nothing could be done beyond sending a letter of remonstrance to William. During his stay in Italy Anselm enjoyed the hospitality of the Abbot of Telese, and passed the summer in a mountain village belonging to this monastery. Here he finished liis work, " Cur Deus Homo", wliich he had begun in England. In October, 1098. Urban held a council at Bari to deal with the difTiculties raised by the Greeks in regard to the procession of the Holy Ghost. Here Anselm was called by the Pope to a place of honour and bidden to take the cliief part in the discussion. His arguments were afterwards committed to writing in his treatise on this subject. His own case was also brought before this council, wliich would have excommunicated William but for Anselm's intercession. Both he and his companions now desired to return to Lyons, but were bidden to await the action of another council to be held in the Lateran at Easter. Here Anselm heard the canons passed against Investitiu'es, and the decree of excommunication against the offenders. Tliis incident had a deep influence on his career in England.”
4. Covers his return after William Rufus's death in 1100, refusal of lay investiture at Salisbury before Henry I, the Council of Lambeth confirming Edith's (Matilda's) freedom to marry Henry I, support for Henry against Duke Robert of Normandy at Portsmouth, the Council of Westminster, second journey to Rome and exile at Lyons, meeting with Countess Adela of Blois and Henry I in July 1105, the 1107 Council of London settlement (citing Lingard and Schwane), and peaceful death on 21 April 1109.
4. Accession of Henry I (1100), Queen Edith's marriage, Westminster Council, second exile, Laigle (1105), and the Concordat of London (1107)Lines 91604–91707
Original passage
“While still staying in the neighbourhood of Lyons, Anselm heard of the tragic death of William. Soon messages from the new king and chief men of the land summoned him to England. Landing at Dover, he hastened to King Henry at Salisbury. He was kindly received, but the question of Investitures was at once raised in an acute form. Henry required the Archbishop liimself to receive a fresh investiture. Anselm alleged the decrees of the recent Roman council and declared that he had no choice in the matter. The difficulty was postponed, as the King decided to send to Rome to ask for a special exemption. Meanwhile, Anselm was able to render the King two signal services. He helped to remove the obstacle in the way of his marriage with Edith, the heiress of the Saxon kings. The daughter of St. Margaret had sought shelter in a convent, where she had worn the veil, but had taken no vows. It was thought by some that this was a bar to marriage, but Anselm had the case considered in a coimcil at Lambeth, where the royal maiden's liberty was fully established, and the Archbishop himself gave his blessing to the marriage. Moreover, when Robert landed at Portsmouth and many of the Norman nobles were wavering in their allegiance, it was An- Bclra who turned the tide in favour of Henry. In the meantime Pope Paschal had refused the King's request for an exemption from the Lateran decrees, yet Henry persisted in his resolution to compel Anselm to accept investiture at his hands. The revolt of Robert de Bellesme put off the threatened rupture. To gain time the King sent another embassy to Rome. On its return, Anselm was once more required to receive investiture. The Pope's letter was not made public, but it was reported to be of the same tenor as his previous reply. The envoys now gave out that the Pope had orally consented to tlie King's request, but could not say so in writing for fear of ofTeiiding otiicr sovereigns. Friends of Anselm who had been at Rome, disputed this assertion. In this crisis it was agreed to send to Rome again; meanwhile the King would continue to invest bishops and abbots, but Anselm should not be required to consecrate them. During tliis interval Anselm held a council at Westminster. Here stringent canons were passed against the evils of the age. In spite of the compromise about investiture, Anselm was required to consecrate bishops invested by the King, but he firmly refused, and it soon became evident that his firmness was taking effect. Bishops gave back the staff they had received at the royal hands, or refused to be consecrated by another in defiance of Anselm. When the Pope's answer arrived, repudiating the story of the envoys, the King asked Anselm to go to Rome liimself. Though he could not support the royal request he was willing to lay the facts before the Pope. With this understanding he once more betook himself to Rome. The request was again refused, but Henry was not excommunicated. Understanding that Henry did not wish to receive liim in England, Anselm interrupted his homeward journey at Lyons. In this city he received a letter from the Pope informing him of the excommunication of the counsellors who had ad\ised the King to insist on investitures, but not decreeing anything about the Kng. Anselm resumed his journey, and on the way he heard of the illness of Henrj''s sister, Adela of Blois. He turned aside to visit her and on her recoverj' informed her that he was returning to England to excommunicate her brother. Slie at once exerted herself to bring about a meeting between Anselm and Henry, in July, 1105. But though a reconciliation was effected, and Anselm was urged to return to England, the claim to invest was not relinquished, and recourse had again to be made to Rome. A papal letter authorizing Anselm to absolve from censures incurred by breaking the laws against investitures healed past offences but made no provision for the future. At length, in a council held in London in 1107, the question foimd a solution. The lung relinquished the claim to invest bishops and abbots, while the Church allowed the prelates to do homage for tlieir temporal possessions. Lingard and other writers consider this a triumph for the King, saying that he had the substance and abandoned a mere form. But it was for no mere form that this long war had been waged. The rite used in tlie investiture was the symbol of a real power claimed by the English kings, and now at last abandoned. The victory rested with the Archbishop, and as Schwano says (Kirchenlexicon, s. v.) it prepared the way for the later solution of the same controversy in Germany. Anselm was allowed to end his days in Eeace. In the two years that remained he continueil is pastoral labours and composed the last of his writings. Eadmer, the faitliful chronicler of tlicse contentions, gives a pleasing picture of his peaceful death. The dream of his childhood was come true; he was to climb the mountain and taste the brcail of Heaven.”
5. Covers his declaration as Doctor of the Church by Clement XI (1720), theological commentaries by Cardinal d'Aguirre (Salamanca, 1678–81) and Dom Anselm Ocsényi (Brünn, 1884), Realism against Roscelin (citing Stöckl, I, 4–5), the ontological argument in the Proslogium and Gaunilo's reply, Eadmer's story of the lost and broken wax tablets, reception by Aquinas, Alexander of Hales, Duns Scotus, Descartes, Kant, Hegel, and Möhler, and Freeman's tribute (IV, 444). Bibliography cited for Pass 2 retrieval: Editions by Th. Raynaud, S.J. (Lyons, 1630) and Dom Gabriel Gerberon, O.S.B. (Paris, 1675, 1721; Venice, 1744; Migne P.L. CLVIII–CLIX, 1845); Hugo Hurter, Opuscula SS. Patrum; Haas (Tübingen); Archbishop William Laud's English translation of the Devotions (1638); S. N. Deane (Chicago, 1903); Eadmer, Historia Novorum in Anglia and Vita S. Anselmi (ed. Nutt, London, 1886; ed. Martin Rule, Rolls Series, 1884); John of Salisbury; Martin Rule, Life and Times of St. Anselm (London, 1883); Père Ragey, Histoire de St. Anselme (Paris, 1890), Vie de St. Anselme (1877), and St. Anselme Professeur (1890); J. A. Möhler, Gesammelte Schriften (Ratisbon, 1839; Eng. tr. Rymer, London, 1842); F. R. Hasse (Leipzig, 1843; abr. Eng. tr. Turner, London, 1850); Charles de Rémusat (Paris, 1853); A. Charma (Caen, 1853); J. Croset-Mouchet (Paris, 1859); W. F. Hook, Lives of the Archbishops of Canterbury (London, 1860–75); R. W. Church, Life of St. Anselm (London, 1873); W. R. W. Stephens in Dictionary of National Biography; Schwane in Kirchenlexikon; J.-V. Bainvel in Dictionnaire de théologie catholique (1901), V, 1327–60; Allies and Raymond-Barker in Catholic World, XXXVII (1883).
5. Doctor of the Church (1720), Scholastic theology, Realism vs. Roscelin, the ontological argument in the Proslogium, editions, and bibliographyLines 91709–91903
Original passage
“His active work as a pastor and stalwart champion of the Church makes Anselm one of the chief figures in religious history. The sweet influence of his spiritual teacliing was felt far and wide, and its fruits were seen in many lands. His stand for the freedom of the Church in a crisis of medieval history had far-reaching effects long after his own time. As a writer and a tliinker he may claim yet higher rank, and his influence on the course of philo.sophy and Catholic theology was even deeper anil more enduring. If he stamls on the one hand with tiregory VTl, and Innocent III, and Thomas Hecket, on the otlier he may claim a place beside .-Vthanasius, -Vugustine, and Thomas .-Vqumas. His merits in the field of theology have received official recognition; lie li:is been declared a Doctor of the Church by Cleiiioiit XI, 1720, and in the office read on his feast <l:iy (21 April) it is said tliat his works are a pattern for all theologians. Yet it may be doubted whether liis position is generally appreciated by students of divinity. In some degree his work has been hidden by the fabric reared on his fountlations. His books were not adopted, like tliose of Peter Lombard and St. Thomas, as the usual text of commentators and lecturers in tlicologj', nor was he constantly cited as an authority, like St. -Augustine. This was natural enough, since in the next century new methods came in with the rise of the Arabic and Aristotelean pliilosophy; the "Books of Sentences" were in some ways more fit for regular theological reading; .\nselm was yet too near to have the venerable authority of the early Fathers. For these rea.sons it may be said that his writings were not properly appreciated till time had brought in other changes in the schools, and men were led to study the history of theology. lUit though his works are not cast in the systematic form of t he " Summa " of St. Thomas, they cover the whole field of Catholic doctrine. There an? few pages of our theology that have not been illustrated by the labours of .A.nselm. His treatise on the procc.s.sion of the Holy Spirit has helped to guide scholastic speculations on the Trinity, his "Cur Dcus Homo" throws a flood of light on the theology of the .Vtonement. and one of his works anticipates much of the later controversies on Free Will and Predestination. In the seventeenth century, a Spanish Benedictine, Cardinal d'Aguirre, made the writings of Anselm the gromulwork of a course of theology, " S. .\nsclmi Thcologia " (Salamanca, 1678-81). Unfortunately the work never got beyond the first three folio \olumes, containing the commentaries on the " .Monologium ". In recent years Dom .\nselm Ocs<"nyi, O.S.B. has accomplished the task on a more modest scale in a little Latin volume on the theology of St. Anselm, "De Tlicologia S. Anselmi" (Briinn, 1884). Besides being one of the fathers of schola.stic theology, .A.nsclm fills an important place in the historj' of pliilosophic speculation. Coming in the first phase of tlie controversy on Universals, he had to meet the extreme Nominalism of Roscelin; partly from this fact, partly from his native Platoni.sm, his Realism took what may be considered a somewhat extreme form. It was too soon to find tlie golden mean of moderate Realism, accepted by later philosophers. His position was a stage in the process, and it is significant that one of his biographers, John of Salisbury, was among the first to find the true solution (Stockl, History of Media;val Philosophy, I. 4-.'5). .\nselm's chief achievement in philosophy was the ontological argument for the existence of God put forth in his " Proslogium". Starting from the notion that God is " that than which nothing greater can be thought", he argues that what exists in reality is greater than that which is only in the mind; wherefore, .since "God is that than which nothing greater can be thought ", He exists in reality. The validity of the argument was disputed at the outset by a monk namcil Gaunilo, who wrote a criticism on it to which .\n.selni replied. Eadmer tells a curious storj' about St. .\nselm's anxiety while he was trying to work out this argument. He couKl think of nothing else for days together. And when at last he saw it clearly. heWas filled with joy, and made haste to commit it to writing. The waxen tablets were given in charge to one of the monks, but when thev were wanted they were missing. .\nselm managed to recall the argument; it was written on fresh tablets and given into safer keeping. But when it was wanted it was found that the wax wius broken to pieces. Anselm with some difficulty put the fragments together and had the whole copied on parchment for greater security. The story sounds like an allegory of tlie fate which awaited this famous argument, which was lost and found again, pulled to pieces and restored in the course of controversy. Rejected by St. Thomas and his f()llf>wers, it was revived in another form by Descartes. After being a.ssailed by Kant, it was defended by Hegel, for whom it had a peculiar fascination; he recurs to it in many parts of his writings. In one place he says that it is generally used by later philosopliei's, "yet always along with the other proofs, although it alone is the true one" (German Works, XII, 547). As.sailants of this argument should remember that all minds are not cast in one mould, and it is easy to understand how some can feel the force of arguments that are not felt by others. But if this proof were indeed, as some consider it, an absurd fallacy, how could it appeal to such minds as those of Anselm, Descartes, and Hegel? It may be well to a<ld th:it the argument was not rejected by all the groat SiIiohIimcm. It was accepted by Alexander of Hales (.Sununa, Pt. I, Q. iii, memb. 1, 2), and supported by Scotus. (In I, Dist. ii, Q. ii.) In modern times it is accepted by Mohler, who quotes Hegel's defence with approval. It is not often that a Catholic saint wins the admiration of German philosophers and English historians. But Anselm lias this singular distinction. Hegel's appreciation of his mental ])owers may be matched by Freeman's warm words of praise for the great Archbishop of Canterbury. "Stranger as he was, he has won his place among the noblest worthies of our island. It was something to be the model of all ecclesiastical perfection; it was something to be the creator of the theologj" of Christendom; but it was something higher still to be the very embodiment of righteousness and mercy, to be handed down in the annals of humanity as the man who saved the hunted hare and stood up for the holiness of JE\- fheah" (History of the Norman Conquest, IV, 444). Collections of the works of St. Anselm were issued soon after the invention of printing. Ocsdnyi mentions nine earlier than the sixteenth century. The first attempt at a critical edition was that of Th. Raynaud, S.J. (Lyons, Ifi.'iO), which rejects many spurious works, e. g. the Commentaries on St. Paul. The best editions are those of Dom Gcrberon, O.S.B. (Paris, 1G75, 1721; Venice 1744; Migne, 184.5). Most of the more important works have also been issued separately; thus the " Monologium " is included in Hurter's "Opuscula S.S. Patrum" and published with the "Proslogium" by Haas (Tubingen). There are numerous separate editions of the "Cur Dcus Homo" and of Anselm's "Prayers and Meditations"; these last were done into English by Archbi-shop Laud (1038), and there are French and German versions of the "Meditations" and the "Monologium". "Cur Deus Homo" has also been traiLslated into English and German; -see also the translations by Deano (Chicago, 1903). For Anselm's views on education, see Bec, Abbey of. Tlie chief sources for Anselm's life are his own letters and the two biographical works of his friend, disciple, and serretar.v. Eadmer, monl< of Canterbury, and Bishop-elect of .St. Andrews. Kaomkr's Uistoria X tvoriim may be called the "Life and Times of St. Anselm"; his Vita S. Antclmi gives the inner of the works of St. Anselm. The second work of Eadmer has been many times reprinted: an edition wa-s published by Nutt (London. ISSIJ), together with Cur Drut Homo. Both have been e<lited in the Rolla SrrUs by Martin Rui.k. Besides, there is a brief account of the miracles of St. Anselm which is also ascribed to Eadmer. but its authorship is doubtful. Pbnr. l{\r.r.y, in his valuable French monograph on Eadmer, ha-s vindicated the veracity of the medieval chronicler, whose methods have much in common with those of the best modern biographers. Other early writers on Anselm. such as John or Sai.isbchy. add some new details, but their account of the Saint 18 largely drawn from Eacimer. See also Rule, Lije and Timts of St. Anselm (London, 1883): Kagev, Histoire de St. Amelme (Paris. 1890); Idem, Vie de St. Anselme (Paris, 1877); Idem, St. .insehic Profeaaeur (Paris, 1890). German lives by MoHLER, in Oeaammehe Schriften (Ratisbon, 1839), Rymer, tr. (London, 1842), and Hasse (Leipzig, 1843), Turner, abr. tr. (London, 1850); French lives by Remusat (Paris, 1853); Cihrma (Caen, 1853), and Croset-Mouchet (Paris, 1859); Hook, Lii'ea of the Archbishops of Canterbury (London. 1S60-75); Chdrch in The British Critic; Idem, Life of St. Anselm (London. 1873); Stephens in Diet. Nat. Biog.; Schwane in Kirchentcr.; Bainvel, in Diet, de thiol. cath (1901) V, 1327-60; Allies and Raymond-Barker in Catholic World, XXXVII (1883). W. H. Kent.”
6. Details Anselm's three-year stay at the exempt monastery of Dijon and his early works at Bec—his logic, the homily on Intravit Jesus in quoddam castellum, and the Harmony of Foreknowledge, Predestination, and Free-will with Grace (finished at Canterbury)—alongside his childhood dream at Aosta, his defense of Saint Elphege's martyrdom before Lanfranc, and his miracles at Winchester and Liberi.
6. Butler's account: childhood dream at Aosta, three years at Dijon, composition of logic and De concordia, and defense of Saint ElphegeLines 10722–10755
Alban Butler, Lives of the Fathers, Martyrs, and Other Principal Saints (1866), April 21, St. Anselm, Archbishop of Canterbury, lines 10722-10755
Original passage
“own country, where he had made a successful beginning in his studies : ami. after a diligent application to them for thr->a Digitized by Google April 21.] ST. ANSELM, II. C years in Burgundy (then a distinct government), and in France, invited by the great fame of Lanfranc, prior of Bee in Nor- mandy, under the abbot Ilerluin, he went thither and became his scholar.* On his father's death, Anselm advised with him about the state of life he was to embrace ; as whether he should”
7. Records Anselm's refusal to pay the large sum demanded by King William Rufus at his installation into the See of Canterbury—distributing the money instead among the poor—as well as his childhood vision of the King of Heaven's white bread and his counsel against harsh corporal punishment in monastic schools.
7. Refusal of King William Rufus's pecuniary demand on installation, distribution of the sum to the poor, and counsel on gentle educationLines 8846–8871
John Gilmary Shea (ed.), Pictorial Lives of the Saints (1889), April 21, St. Anselm, Archbishop, lines 8846-8871
Original passage
“my faith tp my king because I will not reject the authority of the Holy See of Rome, let him stand forth and in the name of God I will answer him as I ought.” No one took up the challenge ; and to the disappointment of the king, the barons sided with the Saint, for they respected his courage, and saw that his cause was their own. Sooner than yield, the archbishop went again into exile, till at last the king was obliged to submit to the feeble but inflexible old man. In the midst of his harassing cares, St. Anselm found time for writings which have made him celebrated as the father of scholastic theology ; while in metaphysics and in science he had”
Found an error? Report a correction.
