Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

The Assembly at Rockingham

Context

Since your consecration in December 1093, King William Rufus has clashed with you again and again. He scorned a money gift as too small and angrily refused your February 1094 plea for a council against moral abuses. After his return from Normandy, you asked leave to visit Rome for your pallium. The pallium is the white wool band with four crosses given by the Pope to new archbishops. William Rufus refused, claiming no one in England could recognize Pope Urban II—contested by Antipope Clement—without royal leave. Yet before consecration in 1093, you had already stated your prior recognition of Urban II as Abbot of Bec. You had warned the king that you could never drop that obedience. At your request, England's great council meets at Rockingham in Derbyshire on 11 March 1095. You ask how to keep obedience to Rome without breaking faith with the king. Afraid of the king's anger, the English bishops press you with threats to drop Urban II and submit to the king.

Options

  • Stand firm against the bishops' pressure and refuse to give up your obedience to Pope Urban II. Uphold both your prior pledge and your loyalty to the king.
  • Follow the bishops' advice, drop your obedience to Pope Urban II without royal leave, and submit entirely to royal custom.
  • Offer to resign as Archbishop of Canterbury on the spot and return to Normandy to avoid clashing with royal custom.

Choice

Anselm stood firm against the bishops' pressure and threats, refusing to give up his obedience to Pope Urban II.

Consequence

Seeing Anselm stand firm, the lay barons at Rockingham backed him and public opinion turned against the fearful bishops. During a truce until Pentecost, William Rufus secretly sent envoys to Rome for the pallium and asked Urban II to remove Anselm. Urban refused to depose him, and England recognized Urban II as pope. On 10 June 1095, Anselm took the pallium from Canterbury's altar rather than from the king's hand.

Virtues: Courage, Obedience

Evidence