Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

The King's Request at Windsor

Context

Since Lanfranc died a year after William the Conqueror, King William Rufus has left Canterbury empty for over three years. During that gap, the king seized Canterbury's income, gave church lands to his knights, and let disorder spread. Falling dangerously ill at Gloucester in March 1093, the frightened king named you Archbishop of Canterbury. Courtiers forced the bishop's staff into your hand against your protests. Formal release from Bec still required consent from Normandy's duke, Rouen's archbishop, and Bec's monks. Once recovered, however, the king broke his promises of reform. Before consecration, you set three firm conditions. You required all Lanfranc's Canterbury lands back, a voice as royal spiritual adviser, and loyalty to Pope Urban II against Antipope Clement. Now letters from Normandy have freed you from Bec, and William Rufus summons you to Windsor. He asks as a personal favor that his knights keep the Canterbury church lands granted after Lanfranc's death.

Options

  • Refuse the king's favor outright and insist on the full return of all Canterbury lands held by Lanfranc before becoming archbishop.
  • Grant the king's personal favor and let his knights keep those church lands so you can take office in peace.
  • Offer a lifetime compromise letting the knights rent the estates during their lives, returning them to Canterbury at death.

Choice

According to R. C.'s introductory biography, Anselm refused the king's request at Windsor. Consenting would have caused a lasting loss to the Church, which Anselm knew he had no right to allow.

Consequence

Though angry at first, William Rufus bowed to public outcry and restored all Canterbury estates as Lanfranc had held them. Anselm was enthroned on 5 September 1093 and consecrated on 4 December 1093 by the Archbishop of York. Even so, the king soon quarreled with him again over money, reform councils, and the papal pallium.

Virtues: Justice, Courage

Evidence