Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

The Runaway Monk of Canterbury

Context

As Abbot of Bec, you share close friendship with Prior Henry, Gondulph, Archbishop Lanfranc, and the monks of Canterbury. Earlier you advised Prior Henry not to crush stumbling young monks with harshness, but to win their trust with kindness first. Now Brother Moses, a Canterbury monk misled into running away in youthful folly, arrives weeping at Bec with a servant. Like the prodigal son, Moses longs to return to Canterbury, even as a hired worker, yet two fears terrify him. First, though ready for bodily punishment himself, he dreads seeing Canterbury severely punish the servant whom he misled. Second, he carelessly spent borrowed money; owning nothing as a monk, he needs Canterbury's help and leave to repay it. Moses begs you to plead with Prior Henry and get a written answer before he starts back.

Options

  • Send a letter to Prior Henry and the Canterbury monks offering your own 'skin for skin' on behalf of Moses and his servant. Ask them to spare both men harsh blows, help settle the debt, and reply in writing first.
  • Send Moses and his servant straight back to Canterbury under strict punishment without asking mercy or help with the debt.
  • Keep Brother Moses permanently at Bec under your own care so he never faces the shame of returning to Canterbury.

Choice

In a heartfelt letter to Prior Henry and the Canterbury monks, Abbot Anselm pleaded for Moses and his servant. Declaring both men clothed in his own skin ('skin for skin'), he begged Canterbury to spare them harsh blows. He also asked leave and help for Moses to repay the borrowed money, requesting a written answer before Moses set out.

Consequence

Anselm's plea joined respect for Moses's home monastery with tender mercy: 'if any should spare him, I will be grateful to him'. Prior Henry's reply does not survive.

Virtues: Mercy, Humility

Evidence