Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

The Priests Who Chose Their Wives Over the Altar

Context

With King Henry's agreement, you and England's bishops held the Council of London, strictly forbidding priests to marry or keep wives. Now Bishop Herbert of Thioford urgently reports a wide revolt across his diocese. Refusing to part from their wives, many married parish priests are giving up all priestly duties in protest. They refuse to say Mass, consecrate the Lord's Body, hear confessions, or bury the dead. Because chaste parish priests are scarce, the rebels expect fear of leaving laypeople without sacraments will force bishops to yield. Few chaste parish priests live locally, though monasteries in the region have professed monks, including elderly ones. Meanwhile, the rebel priests still hold church buildings and lands with their women and may attack chaste replacements.

Options

  • Relax nothing from the council's law, and assign chaste priests or—where lacking—monks, even elderly ones, to say Mass. Have chosen clergy bring Communion, hear confessions, and bury the dead, while laypeople help remove resisting rebels from church lands.
  • Relax or pause the Council of London's law for these married priests so they resume parish worship.
  • Keep the married priests suspended without calling in monks or laypeople, leaving parishes without Mass until new chaste clergy are trained.

Choice

Anselm instructed Bishop Herbert not to soften a single point of the Council of London. Those priests had chosen their wives over the altar, so Herbert had to replace them with chaste priests. Where chaste parish priests were lacking, Herbert was to order monks—even elderly ones—to say Mass for the people. Chosen clergy would bring the Eucharist to the sick, hear confessions, and bury the dead, while laypeople helped remove resisting rebels.

Consequence

Anselm assured Herbert that firm perseverance would soon overcome the rebels' stubbornness with God's help. He also reminded Herbert that in emergencies anyone may baptize, because it is Christ Himself who baptizes.

Virtues: Courage, Justice

Evidence