Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Anselm of Canterbury

The Secret Message From Rome

Context

Called home from three years of exile after William Rufus died, you published Pope Urban II's Roman decree in England. No layman may grant bishoprics or abbeys (lay investiture), no churchman may swear homage for them, and violators face excommunication. When King Henry of England refused to give up royal investitures, both sides agreed to consult Pope Paschal II. Now you hold a written letter from Paschal II upholding the ban, yet Henry refuses to read yours or show his. Instead, the king's envoys—the Archbishop of York and two bishops—claim the Pope gave them a secret spoken message. They claim Paschal orally allowed Henry to grant investitures without excommunication so long as he rules well otherwise. They add that the Pope kept it unwritten only lest other princes complain, and ordered you to follow their counsel. Meanwhile, the king threatens immediate investitures and exile if you enforce the written ban.

Options

  • Ask for a truce until messengers bring back an unmistakable written ruling from Pope Paschal II. Meanwhile, approve no royal investitures, yet avoid calling anyone disobedient until Rome answers.
  • Accept the solemn word of the Archbishop of York and the two bishops, follow their counsel, and ask Rome to soften the decree.
  • Enforce Pope Paschal's written letter at once with excommunications without checking the bishops' spoken claim with Rome.

Choice

Anselm stood caught between the Pope's written letter and the three bishops' sworn spoken report. He secured a truce until messengers could bring an unmistakable written answer from Paschal II. Meanwhile, he approved nothing against the Roman decree and refused to plead against the law, yet called no one disobedient.

Consequence

During the truce, King Henry appointed bishops and abbots under the claimed oral permission. Anselm sent envoys back to Rome declaring he feared neither exile, poverty, torture, nor death, but needed written certainty from Rome.

Virtues: Obedience, Justice

Evidence