Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Catholic Saints · Bagnorea (Bagnoregio), Italy

  • Canonized Saint
  • Feast 14 July
  • d. 15 July 1274 at Lyons, France
  • 9 sources
Mosaic portrait of Saint Bonaventure

Saint Bonaventure (1221–1274)

Also known as Giovanni di Fidanza, John of Fidanza, Seraphic Doctor, Doctor Seraphicus, Doctor Devotus

How did Saint Bonaventure govern the Friars Minor and serve at the Council of Lyons?

Saint Bonaventure (1221–1274) was Minister General of the Friars Minor, Cardinal-Bishop of Albano, and the Seraphic Doctor of the Church. A master at Paris alongside Saint Thomas Aquinas, he codified Franciscan law at Narbonne (1260) and guided the Second Council of Lyons (1274).123

Life and remembrance

Traditional account

Saint Bonaventure was born at Bagnorea near Viterbo in 1221 to Giovanni di Fidanza and Maria Ritella. At baptism he received the name John. In the prologue to his Legenda S. Francisci, Bonaventure recalled being saved from childhood death through Saint Francis of Assisi's prayers. A popular tale traces his name to Francis crying 'O buona ventura' ('O good fortune'). Yet that story rests only on a late fifteenth-century tradition. He entered the Franciscan Order of Friars Minor in the Roman Province either in 1238 or in 1243. Sbaralea, Bonelli, Panfilo da Magliano, and Jeiler support 1238, while Wadding and the Brussels Acta Sanctorum editors hold 1243. Around 1242 he studied at the University of Paris under Alexander of Hales. Licensed as a teaching master (Magister regens) in 1248, he lectured with high praise until 1255. That year, diocesan professors campaigning against mendicant, or begging, friars forced his lectures to pause.1

In 1255 Guillaume de Saint-Amour attacked the begging friars in The Perils of the Last Times. Bonaventure defended Franciscan poverty in his treatise De paupertate Christi. Meanwhile, Blessed John of Parma pleaded the Franciscan cause before Pope Alexander IV at Anagni. The pope condemned Saint-Amour's book. Bonaventure and Saint Thomas Aquinas then received the Doctor of Theology degree together at Paris on 23 October 1257.1

Earlier that year, on 2 February 1257, John of Parma retired as head of the Franciscans. Though not yet thirty-six, Bonaventure was elected Minister General of the Friars Minor. He steered a firm middle path between two opposing groups within the order. On one side stood the Relaxati, who wanted softer rules. On the other stood extreme Spirituales, many of whom followed the prophetic Joachimite book Evangelium aeternum. Bonaventure brought the Joachimite leaders before a Church court at Città della Pieve, where two received life imprisonment. John of Parma went free through the help of Cardinal Ottoboni (later Pope Adrian V). At the same time, Bonaventure sent an official letter across the order to reform the Relaxati.2

At the General Chapter, or order-wide meeting, of Narbonne in 1260, Bonaventure issued the revised Constitutiones Narbonenses. He grouped these laws under twelve headings matching the twelve chapters of the Franciscan Rule. The friars also asked him to compose a new official biography of Saint Francis. Bonaventure visited the order and attended the chapel dedication on Mount La Verna. He also witnessed the solemn moving of the sacred remains of Saint Clare and Saint Anthony. In 1263 he called the General Chapter of Pisa. It approved his Legenda Major and its shorter choir version, the Legenda Minor. The Pisa chapter also set province borders and ordered an evening bell honoring Mary's Annunciation, originating the Angelus prayer. In 1264, at Cardinal Cajetan's request, Bonaventure resumed guiding the Poor Clare nuns. That year he also founded Rome's Society of the Gonfalone honoring Our Lady. On 23 November 1265, he humbly declined Pope Clement IV's papal bull, an official letter naming him Archbishop of York.2

In 1266 the General Chapter of Paris ordered all biographies of Saint Francis written before Bonaventure's work destroyed. This measure aimed to end bitter party disputes built on older texts. In 1269 Bonaventure held his fourth general chapter at Assisi, establishing a weekly Saturday Mass honoring the Blessed Virgin. He next composed his Apologia pauperum against Gerard of Abbeville's fresh attack on the begging orders. The papacy had stood vacant for nearly three years when cardinals met at Viterbo. On 1 September 1271, Bonaventure's advice persuaded them to elect Teobaldo Visconti as Pope Gregory X there. At his second Chapter of Pisa in 1272, he set a yearly remembrance on 25 August for King Saint Louis IX of France. Earlier, he had composed his Office of the Passion for that saintly king and friend.2

On 23 June 1273, Pope Gregory X named Bonaventure Cardinal-Bishop of Albano. Papal messengers reportedly found him washing dishes outside a convent near Florence. They hung the cardinal's hat on a tree until his hands were free. On 20 May 1274, Bonaventure handed over Franciscan leadership to Jerome of Ascoli (later Pope Nicholas IV). He then guided the Fourteenth Ecumenical Council—the Second Council of Lyons—preaching on 18 May and 29 June. Through talks with Greek Church delegates, he helped achieve the reunion of East and West on 6 July 1274. Bonaventure died during the council on Sunday, 15 July 1274. His secretary Peregrinus of Bologna's chronicle claims poison caused his death. That evening he was buried in the Franciscan church at Lyons, where Dominican Cardinal Pietro di Tarantasia (later Innocent V) preached. His undecayed head was moved at Lyons in 1434, and Pope Sixtus IV canonized him on 14 April 1482. French Protestant Huguenots burned his shrine in 1562, and his head vanished during the French Revolution. Pope Sixtus V named him a principal Doctor of the Church on 14 March 1587 (feast 14 July).3

Known at Paris as Doctor Devotus, Bonaventure was first called the 'Seraphic Doctor' by Dominican Rayner of Pisa in 1333. Seraphic means burning with love like the seraphim angels. Fidelis a Fanna and Ignatius Jeiler edited his ten-volume Quaracchi Opera Omnia (1882–1902). Across these works, he united Saint Augustine's tradition with careful use of Aristotle. He set out his philosophy and theology in his four-book Commentary on the Sentences, written at age twenty-seven. He developed it in the Breviloquium, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum (La Verna, 1259), and De reductione Artium ad Theologiam. He held hylomorphic composition—union of form and matter—in both angels and bodies, plus rationes seminales, or seed-principles, in basic matter. He also defended multiple substantial forms in one creature and argued that reason can prove creation began in time. He rejected ontologism, the claim that humans directly see God's essence on earth, and held moral causality for the sacraments. His mystical works include De Triplici Via, Soliloquium, Lignum vitae, De sex alis seraphim, and Vitis mystica. He also composed De Perfectione vitae for Blessed Isabella of France. His Bible commentaries cover Ecclesiastes, Wisdom, Luke, and John, alongside Collationes in Joannem and the 1273 Paris Collationes in Hexaemeron. Nearly five hundred sermons and Franciscan spiritual and legal works are genuine. However, Centiloquium, Speculum Disciplinae, Philomela, Stimulus Amoris, Speculum B. M. V., Meditationes vitae Christi, and Biblia pauperum are not his.45

Devotional biographies for his 14 July feast preserve two famous meetings with his friend Saint Thomas Aquinas. One day Thomas asked from what books Bonaventure drew the learning, beauty, and warmth of his teaching. Pointing to his crucifix, Bonaventure answered, 'Behold the great book that teaches me everything'. On another visit, Thomas found him lost in ecstatic prayer while writing the life of Saint Francis of Assisi. Thomas quietly stepped back, remarking, 'Let us leave a Saint to write of a Saint'. In France, Bonaventure advised King Saint Louis IX and served as spiritual director to the king's sister Blessed Isabella. When he first heard plans to make him a cardinal, he fled to France to avoid the honor. Later, Pope Gregory X's envoys caught up with him near Florence while he was washing the friars' dishes. Bonaventure asked them to hang the red hat on a bush and walk in the garden until he finished.67

Remember

  • Born Giovanni di Fidanza at Bagnorea in 1221, Bonaventure entered the Friars Minor, studied under Alexander of Hales at Paris, and received the Doctorate with Saint Thomas Aquinas on 23 October 1257.1
  • Elected Minister General on 2 February 1257, he governed the Franciscans for seventeen years, promulgating the Constitutions of Narbonne (1260) and composing the official biography of Saint Francis (1263).2
  • He defended the mendicant orders against Guillaume de Saint-Amour in De paupertate Christi (1255) and against Gerard of Abbeville in Apologia pauperum (c. 1269).12
  • Created Cardinal-Bishop of Albano by Gregory X in 1273 after declining York in 1265, he directed the Second Council of Lyons and the Greek reunion (6 July 1274) before dying on 15 July 1274.23
  • Author of the Commentary on the Sentences, Breviloquium, and Itinerarium Mentis in Deum, he was canonized by Sixtus IV in 1482 and named the Seraphic Doctor by Sixtus V on 14 March 1587.3467

Check yourself

At which general chapter in 1260 did Saint Bonaventure promulgate his revised Franciscan constitutions distributed under twelve heads?

Writings and words

“It is one thing to submit humply to a rule and live in peace with the brethren, and quite another to be able to guide subjects usefully.”

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), Chapter I, §1 (lines 201–204)

“Cast discretion to the winds, and virtue becomes a vice.”

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), Chapter VI, §1 (lines 2137–2139; quoting Saint Bernard, Serm. 49 in Cant.)

“It is that unction of the Spirit which, when it abides in our soul, teaches us concerning all things necessary for salvation.”

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), Chapter VII, §1 (lines 3036–3039)

“I give Thee thanks, O Lord God, for all these my pains, and I beseech Thee, my Lord, that, if it please Thee, Thou wilt add unto them an hundredfold; for this will be most acceptable unto me if laying sorrow upon me Thou dost not spare, since the fulfilling of Thy holy will is unto me an overflowing solace.”

The Life of Saint Francis (Legenda Maior), Chapter XIV, §2 (lines 6836–6841, 6853)

All writings and excerpts

Decisions and stakes

  • Before the Bishop's Tribunal in Assisi

    Praying before the Crucifix in the crumbling church of St. Damian outside Assisi, you heard a voice speak three times. It commanded, 'Francis, go and repair My House, which, as thou seest, is falling utterly into ruin'. Thinking this meant the stone building, you rode to Foligno and sold cloth and your horse. You offered the coins to St. Damian's poor priest, who refused them out of fear of your parents. You tossed the coins onto a window ledge like dust. Your furious father dragged you home through Assisi's mocking streets, beat you, and chained you. Your mother freed you while he was away, and your father later recovered the money from the window ledge. Now he brings you before the Bishop of Assisi's public court to make you legally give up your inheritance. Fighting in court tangles you in worldly property, while giving up everything leaves you penniless. How will you answer before the Bishop?

    Choice: Waiting for neither speeches nor legal delays, Francis stripped off all his clothes, showing a rough hairshirt against his skin. He handed the clothes back to his father and declared that from then on he could boldly pray, 'Our Father, Which art in heaven'.

  • The Starving Friar in the Night

    Imitating your strict life, your friars have taken up harsh fasting. Late one night while the house sleeps, a friar who fasted beyond his strength cries out that he is dying of hunger. Left without food, he faces real harm, yet eating alone while everyone else fasts will crush him with shame. Scolding him breaks his spirit, while dropping fasting rules without explanation breeds carelessness. How will you answer the starving brother's cry?

    Choice: Francis immediately had bread set before the friars and ate first himself. He invited the others to join so the hungry brother felt no shame, and afterward spoke on wise moderation.

  • Solitary Contemplation or Apostolic Preaching?

    Having tasted quiet prayer in mountain retreats, you face a deep question about your calling. Silent prayer unites the soul directly with God, whereas preaching exposes an unschooled man to worldly dust and distraction. Yet God's own Son came down from the Father to save sinners, showing that Christians must not live for themselves alone. Hiding in a hermit's cell leaves towns without Gospel preaching, while rushing out by self-will risks losing prayerful union. How will you decide between solitary prayer and public preaching?

    Choice: Distrusting his own judgment, Francis sent Brother Masseo to consult Brother Sylvester on Mount Subasio and Saint Clare at St. Damian's. Both independently received the same answer from God: Francis was chosen to go out and preach for the salvation of souls. Rising at once, Francis set out with glowing zeal toward Bevagna.

  • The Simple Brother's Plea for Milder Suffering

    For two years after leaving Mount La Verna, constant sicknesses have worn your body down to skin and bone. Hardly a single limb is free from sharp pain. Watching a fierce wave of agony strike you, a simple-hearted friar speaks out of pity. 'Brother, pray the Lord that He deal more gently with thee', he pleads. 'For meseemeth that His hand is laid more heavily on thee than is right'. Accepting his words allows complaint against God's just will, while harshly driving him away bruises his simple heart. How will you answer him?

    Choice: Groaning aloud, Francis warned the brother that only his simple innocence kept Francis from shunning him for blaming God's judgments. Francis then threw himself from his straw mat onto the hard floor, kissed the ground, and thanked the Lord for all his pains.

  • The Roman Preacher's Secret Doubt of the Stigmata

    You are a respected Franciscan scholar and preacher in Rome. You know the sworn witnesses and papal bulls, or official letters from popes, confirming Saint Francis's Stigmata. The Stigmata were the wounds of Christ impressed on Francis's hands, feet, and side. Still, you secretly nurse a proud, rationalist doubt in your heart, measuring the miracle by purely natural reason. At night Francis appears in a vision with muddy feet and humble sternness. Asking why your secret unbelief stains his glory with mud, he bids you look at his pierced hands and open side. Hiding your doubt protects your scholarly fame in Rome, while open confession humbles your pride before the people. What will you do upon waking?

    Choice: Struck with sorrow and awe by the vision, the learned Friar Minor wept bitterly to wash away his unbelief. He then openly confessed his fault before the people in Rome.

  • Preparing for a Holy Death Every Day at the Foot of the Cross

    Many believers recite spoken prayers out of habit. Meanwhile, they put off serious repentance, forgiving enemies, and preparing for death until their last illness. How can you shape a weekly devotion to the Blessed Virgin so daily prayer prepares the soul to live holily and die in peace?

    Choice: Guide the believer to start each day humbly before God, picturing his own deathbed beneath Jesus crucified and His sorrowful Mother on Calvary. Each day of the week at Jesus's Wounds then prepares the soul for judgment, confession, Viaticum, Extreme Unction, forgiveness, and commending the soul.

Feast days and patronage

  • 14 July — General Roman Calendar (1907) (Universal Church · double)

Virtues

Facts and sources

Each fact names its source. The label shows how sure we can be.

  1. The Church status of Saint Bonaventure is Saint and Doctor of the Church.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106561–106564)

  2. Born Giovanni di Fidanza at Bagnorea near Viterbo in 1221 to Giovanni di Fidanza and Maria Ritella, Bonaventure entered the Order of Friars Minor in 1238 or 1243 and studied at Paris under Alexander of Hales.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106561–106617)

  3. Bonaventure lectured at Paris from 1248 to 1255, defended the mendicants against Guillaume de Saint-Amour in De paupertate Christi, and received the Doctorate with Saint Thomas Aquinas on 23 October 1257.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106618–106647)

  4. Elected Minister General of the Friars Minor on 2 February 1257, Bonaventure curbed both the Joachimite Spirituales and the Relaxati, promulgated the Constitutiones Narbonenses at Narbonne in 1260, and presented his standard biography of Saint Francis at Pisa in 1263.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106648–106732)

  5. Bonaventure declined the Archbishopric of York in 1265, defended the friars against Gerard of Abbeville in Apologia pauperum, and helped persuade the cardinals at Viterbo to elect Pope Gregory X on 1 September 1271.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106747–106801)

  6. Created Cardinal-Bishop of Albano on 23 June 1273, Bonaventure directed the deliberations of the Second Council of Lyons and the reunion of the Greeks (6 July 1274) before dying at Lyons on 15 July 1274.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106811–106856)

  7. Canonized by Pope Sixtus IV on 14 April 1482 and declared Doctor of the Church (Doctor Seraphicus) by Pope Sixtus V on 14 March 1587, Saint Bonaventure is celebrated on 14 July.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106880–106892)

  8. Bonaventure's major Scholastic and philosophical writings—the Commentary on the Sentences, Breviloquium, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum (1259), and De reductione Artium ad Theologiam—set forth an Augustinian-Scholastic synthesis.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 106899–107065)

  9. Bonaventure also authored mystical treatises (De Triplici Via, Soliloquium, Lignum vitae, De sex alis seraphim, Vitis mystica, De Perfectione vitae), scriptural commentaries and Collationes, nearly five hundred sermons, and Franciscan works edited in the ten-volume Quaracchi Opera Omnia (1882–1902).

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 107067–107429)

  10. The critical edition of Saint Bonaventure's Opera Omnia was published by the Franciscan editors Fidelis a Fanna and Ignatius Jeiler at Quaracchi in ten folio volumes between 1882 and 1902.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Catholic Encyclopedia, Volume II: Assize–Brownsonvol. II, pp. 648–654 (clean-text lines 107430–107508)

  11. When Saint Thomas Aquinas visited Saint Bonaventure and found him in ecstasy while composing the life of Saint Francis of Assisi, Thomas withdrew saying, 'Let us leave a Saint to write of a Saint'; Bonaventure also served as spiritual adviser to King Saint Louis IX and spiritual director to the king's sister Blessed Isabella.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidencePictorial Lives of the Saints, with Reflections for Every Day in the YearJohn Gilmary Shea (ed.), Pictorial Lives of the Saints (1889), July 14, St. Bonaventure, lines 14308-14320

  12. Asked by Saint Thomas Aquinas whence he drew so much eloquence and unction in his discourses, Saint Bonaventure pointed to his crucifix and replied, 'Behold the great book that teaches me everything!'

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceShort Lives of the Saints; or, Our Birthday BouquetCecilia Mary Caddell, Short Lives of the Saints (1910), July 14, St. Bonaventure, Bishop and Doctor, lines 10796-10806

  13. In The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), Saint Bonaventure patterns pastoral governance on the six wings of the Seraphim (Isaiah 6:2): Zeal for Justice, Fraternal Pity, Patience, an Exemplary Life, Prudent Discretion (modeled on the four rows of three jewels on the high priest's breastplate), and Devotion to Prayer.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim)Prologue, Chapters I–VII, and Conclusion (lines 166–3624)

  14. Without waiting for any speech or legal delay, Francis immediately stripped off all his garments—revealing a hairshirt next to his skin—handed them back to his father, and declared that henceforth he could confidently say 'Our Father, Which art in heaven.' Marvelling at his fervour, the weeping Bishop wrapped Francis in his own cloak and gave him the rough tunic of a farm-servant, which Francis marked with a chalk Cross before going forth free from the world to repair St. Damian's and two other churches.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Life of Saint Francis (Legenda Maior)Legenda Maior, Chapter II, section 4 (lines 946–997)

  15. Francis immediately had bread set before the brethren and began to eat first himself, inviting the others to join so the starving brother would not blush with shame, and afterward gave them a discourse on the virtue of discretion. The brother was strengthened in both body and spirit, and the community learned that God desires mercy and discreet charity rather than indiscreet self-destruction.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Life of Saint Francis (Legenda Maior)Legenda Maior, Chapter V, section 7 (lines 2235–2310)

  16. Humbly distrusting his own judgment, Francis sent Brother Masseo to consult Brother Sylvester on Mount Subasio and Saint Clare at St. Damian's; when both independently returned the unanimous divine answer that God had chosen him not for himself alone but to go forth and preach for the salvation of souls, Francis rose immediately and set out toward Bevagna. Setting out in fervent obedience, Francis preached his famous sermon to the birds near Bevagna and inaugurated the worldwide apostolic preaching mission of the Friars Minor.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Life of Saint Francis (Legenda Maior)Legenda Maior, Chapter XII, sections 1–2 (lines 5568–5740)

  17. Francis groaned aloud, warned the brother that had he not known his simple purity he would have shunned his company for daring to deem God's judgments worthy of blame, flung himself from his pallet onto the hard ground, kissed the floor, and thanked the Lord for all his pains. Francis continued calling his bodily pangs 'sisters' until he died naked on the bare earth at the Portiuncula on October 4, 1226.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Life of Saint Francis (Legenda Maior)Legenda Maior, Chapter XIV, section 2 (lines 6810–6865)

  18. Stricken with remorse and awe by the vision, the learned Friar Minor wept bitterly to wash away his unbelief and publicly confessed his fault before the people in Rome. His public confession confirmed the faith of the Romans in the Sacred Stigmata of Saint Francis.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceThe Life of Saint Francis (Legenda Maior)Legenda Maior, Miracles Part I, section 6 (lines 7680–7745)

  19. Direct the believer to begin each day by humbling himself in faith before God, picturing himself on his deathbed looking up at Jesus crucified on Calvary with His sorrowful Mother beside the Cross, and dedicating each day of the week at the Wounds of Jesus to preparing for judgment, confession, Viaticum, Extreme Unction with full forgiveness of enemies, and the commendation of the soul. Direct the believer to begin each day by humbling himself in faith before God, picturing himself on his deathbed looking up at Jesus crucified on Calvary with His sorrowful Mother beside the Cross, and dedicating each day of the week at the Wounds of Jesus to preparing for judgment, confession, Viaticum, Extreme Unction with full forgiveness of enemies, and the commendation of the soul.

    Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceA Devout Exercise in Honour of the Blessed Virgin Mary and of Saint Joseph, Patron of a Happy DeathA Devout Exercise in Honour of Mary and Joseph (1870 Anderdon translation), lines 188–188

Sources

Paschal Robinson, “Bonaventure, Saint,” The Catholic Encyclopedia (1907), vol. II, pp. 648–654. About this source

Notes and sources

  1. 1. Born at Bagnorea in 1221 to Giovanni di Fidanza and Maria Ritella; preserved from childhood illness through Saint Francis's intercession; entered the Friars Minor in 1238 or 1243, studied at Paris under Alexander of Hales, lectured as Magister regens (1248–1255), defended the mendicants in De paupertate Christi against Guillaume de Saint-Amour, and received the Doctorate with Thomas Aquinas on 23 October 1257.

    1. Birth at Bagnorea, entry into the Friars Minor, Paris studies, and Doctorate (1221–1257)Lines 106561–106647

    Original passage

    “Bonaventure, Saint, Doctor of the Church, Cardinal-Bishop of Albano, Minister General of the Friars Minor, b. at Bagnorea in the vicinity of Viterbo in 1221; d. at Lyons, 15 July, 1274. Nothing is known of Bonaventure's parents save their names: Giovanni di Fidanza and Maria Ritella. How his baptismal name of Jolin came to be changed to that of Bonaventure is not clear. An attempt has been made to trace the latter name to the exclamation of St. Francis, O buona ventura, when Bonaventure was brought as an infant to him to be cured of a dangerous illness. This derivation is highly improbable; it seems based on a late fifteenthcentury legend. Bonaventure himself tells us (Legenda S. Francisci Prolog.) that while yet a child he was preserved from death through the intercession of St. Francis, but there is no evidence that this cure took place during the lifetime of St. Francis or that the name Bonaventure originated in any prophetical words of St. Francis. It was certainly borne bj' others before the Seraphic Doctor. No details of Bonaventure's youth ha\e been preserved. He entered the Order of Friars Minor in 1238 or 1243; the e.xact year is uncertain. Wadding and the Bollandists hold for tlie later date, but the earlier one is support id by Sbaralea, BoncUi, Panfilo da Magliano, and Jeiler, and appears more probable. It is certain that Bonaventure was sent from the Roman Province, to which he belonged, to complete his studies at the I'niversity of Paris under Ali\- ander of Hales, I lie great founder of the Franciscan Schcuil. The latter died m 1245, according to the opinion generally received, though not yet definitely established, and Bonaventure seems to have become his pupil about 1242. Be this as it may, Bonaventure received in 1248 the "licentiate" which gave him the right to teach publicly as. l/ayi'.s/cr rcf/cH.*:, and he continued to lecture at the university with great success until 12.55, when he was compelled to discontinue, owing to the then violent outburst of opposition to the Mendicant orders on the part of the secular professors at the imiversity. The latter, jealous, as it seems, of the academic successes of the Dominicans and Franciscans, sought to exclude them from teaching publicly. The smouldering elements of discord had been fanned into a flame in 1255, when Guillaume de Saint- Amom- published a work entitled "The Perils of the Last Times", in which he attacked the Friars with great bitterness. It was in connexion with this dispute that Bonaventure wTOte his treatise, "De paupertate Christi". It was not, however, Bonaventure, as some have erroneously stated, but Blessed Jolm of Parma, who appeared before Alexander IV at Anagni to defend the Franciscans against their adversary. The Holy See having, as is well known, re-established the Mendicants in all their privileges, and Saint-Amour's book having been formally condemned, the degree of Doctor was solemnly bestowed on St. Bonaventure and St. Thomas Aquinas at the university, 23 October, 1257.”
  2. 2. Elected Minister General on 2 February 1257; curbed Joachimite Spirituales at Città della Pieve and reformed the Relaxati; promulgated the Constitutiones Narbonenses (1260); presented his standard biography of Saint Francis at Pisa (1263) where the evening Annunciation bell was ordained; resumed direction of the Poor Clares and founded the Gonfalone confraternity (1264); declined York (1265); held chapters at Paris (1266), Assisi (1269, followed by Apologia pauperum), and Pisa (1272), and helped bring about the election of Gregory X at Viterbo (1 September 1271).

    2. Generalship, Constitutions of Narbonne (1260), Pisa (1263), Paris (1266), Assisi (1269), and Viterbo election (1271)Lines 106648–106811

    Original passage

    “In the meantime Bonaventure, though not yet thirty-six years old, had on 2 February, 1257, been elected Minister General of the Friars Minor — an office of peculiar difficulty, owing to the fact that the order was distracted by internal dissensions between the two factions among the Friars designated respectively the Spirituales and the Relaxti. The former insisted upon the literal observance of the original Rule, especially in regard to poverty, while the latter wished to introduce innovations and mitigations. This lamentable controversy had moreover been aggravated by the enthusiasm with which many of the ".Spiritual" Friars had adopted the doctrines connected with the name of Abbot Joachim of Floris and set forth in the so-called "Evangelium iseternum". The introduction to this pernicious book, which proclaimed the approaching dispensation of the Spirit that was to replace the Law of Christ, was falsely attributed to Bl. John of Parma, who in 1257 had retired from the government of the orde> in favour of Bonaventure. The new gc'neral lost no time in striking vigorously at both extremes within the order. On the one hand, he proceeded against several of the Joachimite "Spirituals" as heretics before an ecclesiastical tribunal at Citta-clclla-Pieve; two of their loaders were condemned to perpetual imprisonment, and John of Parma was only saved from a like fate through the per- .^oiial intervention of Cardinal Ottoboni, afterwards Adrian V. On the other hand, Bonaventure had, in an encyclical letter issued immediately after his election, outlined a programme for the reformation of the Relaxti. These reforms he sought to enforce three years later at the General Chapter of Narbonne when the constitutions of the order which he had revised were promulgated anew. These so-called "Constitutiones Narbonenses" are distributed under twelve heads, corresponding to the twelve chapters of the Rule, of which they form an enlightened and prudent exposition, and are of capital importance in the history of Franciscan legislation. The chapter which issued this code of laws requested Bonaventure to WTite a "legend" or life of St. Francis which should supersede tliose then in circulation. This was in 1260. Three years later Bonaventure, having in the meantime visited a great part of the order, and having assisted at the dedication of the chapel on La Verna and at the translation of the remains of St. Clare and of St. Anthony, convoked a general chapter of the order of Pisa at which his newly composed life of St. Francis was officially approved as the standard biography of the saint to the exclusion of all others. At this chapter of 1263, Bonaventure fixed the limits of the different provinces of the order and, among other ordinances, prescribed that at nightfall a bell should be rung in honoiu- of the Annunciation, a pious practice from which the Angelas seems to have originated. There are no grounds, however, for the assertion that Bonaventure in this chapter prescribed the celebration of the feast of the Immaculate Conception in the order. In 1264, at the earnest request of Cardinal Cajetan. Bonaventure consented to resume the direction of the Poor Clares which the Chapter of Pisa had entirely renounced the year before. He required the Clares, however, to acknowledge occasionally in \\Titing that the favours tendered them by the Friars were voluntarj' acts of charity not arising from any obligation whatsoever. It is said that Pope Urban IV acted at Bonaventure's suggestion in attempting to establish uniformity of observance throughout all the monasteries of Clares. About this time (1264) Bonaventure founded at Rome the Society of the Gonfalone in honour of the Blessed Virgin which, if not the first confraternity instituted in the Church, as some have claimed, was certainly one of the earliest. In 1265 Clement IV, by a Bull dated 23 November, nominated Bonaventure to the vacant Archbishopric of York, but the saint, in keeping with his singular humility, steadfastly refused this honour and the pope yielded. In 1266 Bonaventure convened a general chapter in Paris at which, besides other enactments, it was decreed that all the "legends" of St. Francis WTitten before that of Bonaventure should be forthwith destroyed, just as the Chapter of Narbonne had in 1260 ordered the destruction of all constitutions before those then enacted. This decree has excited much hostile criticism. Some would fain see in it a deliberate attempt on Bonaventure's part to close the primitive sources of Franciscan history, to suppress the real Francis, and substitute a counterfeit in his stead. Others, however, regard the decree in question as a purely liturgical ordinance intended to secure uniformity in the choir "legends". Between these two conflicting opinions the truth seems to be that this edict was nothing more than anothei' heroic attempt to wipe out the old quarrels and start afresh. One cannot but regret the circumstances of this decree, but when it is recalled that the appeal of the contending parties was ever to the words and actions of St. Francis as recorded in the earlier " legends ", it would be unjust to accuse the chapter of "literary vandalism" in seeking to proscribe the latter. We have no details of Bonaventure's life between 1266 and 1269. In the latter year he convoked his fourth general chapter at Assisi, in which it was enacted that a Mass be sung everj- Saturday throughout the order in honour of the Blessed Virgin, not, however, in honour of her Immaculate Conception as Wadding among others has erroneously stated. It was probably soon after this chapter that Bonaventure composed his "Apologia pauperum", in which he silences Gerard of Abbeville who by means of an anonjTiious libel had revived the old university feud against the Friars. Two years later, Bonaventiu'e was mainly instrumental in reconciling the differences among the cardinals assembled at Viterbo to elect a successor to Clement IV, who had died nearly tliree years before; it was on Bonaventure's advice that, 1 September, 1271, they unanimously chose Theobald Visconti of Piacenza who took the title of Gregory X. That the cardinals seriously authorized Bonaventure to nominate himself, as some A\Titers aver, is most improbable. Nor is there any truth in the popular story that Bonaventure on arriving at Viterbo advised the citizens to lock up the cardinals with a view to hastening the election. In 1272 Bonaventure for the second time convened a general chapter at Pisa in which, apart from general enactments to further regular observances, new decrees were issued respecting the direction of the Poor Clares, and a solemn anniversary was instituted on 25 August in memorj- of St. Louis. This was the first step towards the canonization of the holj' king, who liad been a special friend of Bonaventure, and at whose request Bonaventure composed his " Office of the Passion ". On 23 June, 1273, Bonaventure,”
  3. 3. Created Cardinal-Bishop of Albano on 23 June 1273, handed the generalship to Jerome of Ascoli on 20 May 1274, directed the Second Council of Lyons and Greek reunion (6 July 1274), died on 15 July 1274, was translated at Lyons in 1434, canonized by Sixtus IV on 14 April 1482, and declared Doctor of the Church by Sixtus V on 14 March 1587 (feast 14 July).

    3. Cardinalate, Second Council of Lyons, death (15 July 1274), canonization, and Doctor of the ChurchLines 106811–106892

    Original passage

    “of the Passion ". On 23 June, 1273, Bonaventure, much against his will, was created Cardinal-Bishop of Albano, by Gregorj' X. It is said that the pope's envoys who brought him the cardinal's hat found the saint washing dishes outside a convent near Florence and were requested by liim to hang it on a tree nearby until his hands were free to take it. Bonaventure continued to govern the Order of Friars Minor until 20 May, 1274, when at the General Chapter of Lyons, Jerome of Ascoli, afterwards Nicholas IV.was elected to succeed him. Jleanwhile Bonaventure had been charged by Gregorj' X to prepare the questions to be discussed at the Foiu'teentli Oecumenical Council, which opened at Lyons 7 Mav, 1274. The pope himself presided at the council, but he confided the direction of its deliberations to Bonaventure, especially charging him to confer with the Greeks on the points relating to the abjuration of their schism. It was largely due to Bonaventure's efforts and to those of the Friars whom he had sent to Constantinople, that the Greeks accepted the union effected 6 July, 1274. Bonaventure twice addressed the assembled Fathers, on 18 May, during a session of the Council, when he preached on Baruch, v, 5, and on 29 Jmie, during pontifical Mass celebrated by the pope. While the council was still in session, Bonaventure died, Sunday, 15 July, 1274. The exact cause of his death is unkno'mi, but if we may credit the clu-onicle of Peregrinus of Bologna, Bonaventure's secretary, which has recently (1905) been recovered and edited, the saint was poisoned. He was buried on the evening following his death in the church of the Friars Minor at Lyons, being honoured ^ith a splendid funeral which was attended by the pope, the King of Aragon, the cardinals, and the other memljers of the council. The funeral oration was delivered by Pietro di Tarantasia, O.P., Cardinal-Bishop of Ostia, afterwards Innocent V, and on the following day during the fifth session of the council, Gregorj- X spoke of the irreparable loss the Church had sustained by the death of Bonaventure, and commanded all prelates and priests throughout the whole world to celebrate Mass for the repose of his soul. Bonaventure enjoyed especial veneration even during his lifetime because of his stainless character and of the miracles attributed to him. It was .\lexander of Hales who said that Bonaventure seemed to have escaped the curse of Adam's sin. And the storj' of St. Thomas visitino; Bonaventure's cell while the latter was wTiting tlie life of St. Francis, and finding him in an ecstasy is well known. "Let us leave a saint to work for a saint ", said the Angelic Doctor as he withdrew. When, in 1434, Bonaventure's remains were translated to the new church erected at Lyons in honour of St. Francis, his head was found in a perfect state of preservation, the tongue being as red as in life. This miracle not only moved the people of Lyons to choose Bonaventure as their special patron, but also gave a great impetus to the process of his canonization. Dante, ■nTiting long before, had given expression to the popular mind by placing Bonaventure among the saints in his '' Paradiso ", and no canonization was evermore ardently or universally desired than that of Bonaventure. Tliat its inception was so long delayed was mainly due to the deplorable dissensions within the order after Bonaventure 's death. Finally on 14 April, 1482, Bonaventure was enrolled in the catalogue of the saints by Sixtus IV. In 1562 Bonaventure's shrine was plundered by the Huguenots and the urn containing his body was burned in the public square. His head was preserved through the heroism of the superior, who hid it at the cost of his life, but it disappeared during the French Revolution and every effort to discover it has been in vain. Bonaventure was inscribed among the principal Doctors of the Church by Sixtus V, 14 March, 1587. His feast is celebrated 14 July.”
  4. 4. Major philosophical and dogmatic works (Commentary on the Sentences, Breviloquium, Itinerarium Mentis in Deum, De reductione Artium ad Theologiam), Augustinian-Scholastic doctrines, conciliar authority down to Trent and Vatican I, mystical works (De Triplici Via, Soliloquium, Lignum vitae, De sex alis seraphim, Vitis mystica, De Perfectione vitae), scriptural commentaries and Collationes, nearly 500 sermons, and Franciscan works including the Legenda Major and Legenda Minor.

    4. Philosophical, dogmatic, mystical, exegetical, homiletic, and Franciscan writingsLines 106894–107203

    Original passage

    “Bonaventure, as Hefele remarks, united in himself the two elements whence proceed whatever was noble and sublime, great and beautiful, in the Middle Ages, viz., tender piety and profound learning. These two qualities shine forth conspicuously in his writings. Bonaventure wrote on almost every subject treated by the Schoolmen, and his writings are very numerous. The greater number of them deal with philosopliy and theology. No work of Bonaventure's is exclusively philosophical, but in his "Commentary on the Sentences", his "Breviloquium", his "Itinerarium Mentis in Deum" and his "De reductione Artium ad Theologiam", he deals with the most important and difficult questions of philosophy in such a way that these four works taken together contain the elements of a complete system of philosophy, and at the same time bear striking witness to the mutual interpenetration of philosophy and theology which is a distinguishing mark of the Scholastic period. The "Commentary on the Sentences" remains without doubt Bonaventure's greatest work; all his other writings are in some way subservient to it. It was written, superiorum prceceplo (at the command of his superiors) when he was only twenty-seven and is a theological achievement of the first rank. It comprises more than four thousand pages in folio and treats extensively and profoundly of God and the Trinity, the Creation and Fall of Man, the Incarnation and Redemption, Grace, the Sacraments, and the Last Judgment, that is to say, traverses the entire field of Scholastic theology. Like the other medieval Smnmas, Bonaventiu-e's "Commentary" is divided into four books. In the first, second, and fourth Bonaventure can compete favourably with the best commentaries on the Sentences, but it is admitted that in the third book he surpasses all others. The "Breviloquium", written before 1257, is, as its name implies, a shorter work. It is to some extent a summary of the "Commentary" containing as Scheeben says, the quintessence of the theology of the time, and is the most sublime compendium of dogma in our possession. It is perhaps the work which will best give a popular notion of Bonaventure's theology; in it his powers are seen at their best. Whilst the "Breviloquium" derives all things from God, the "Itinerarium Mentis in Deum " proceeds in the opposite direction, bringing all things back to their Supreme End. The latter work, which formed the delight of Gerson for more than thirty years, and from which Bl. Henry Suso drew so largely, was wTitten on Mount la Verna in 1259. The relation of the finite and infinite, the natural and supernatural, is again dealt with by Bonaventure, in his "De reductione Artium ad Theologiam", a little work written to demonstrate the relation which philosophy and the arts bear to theology, and to prove that they are all absorbed in it as into a natural centre. It must not be inferred, however, that philosophy in Bonaventure's view does not possess an existence of its own. The passages in Bonaventure's works on which such an opinion might De founded only go to prove that he did not regard philosophy as the chief or last end of scientific research and speculation. Moreover, it is only when compared with theology that he considers philosophy of an inferior order. Oansidered in itself, philosophy is, according to Bonaventure, a true science, prior in point of time to theology. Again, Bonaventure's pre-eminence as a mystic must not be suffered to overshadow his labours in the domain of philosophy, for he was undoubtedly one of the greatest philosophers of the Middle Ages. Bonaventure's philosophy, no less than his theology, manifests his profound respect for tradition. He regarded new opinions with disfavour and ever strove to follow those generally received in his time. Thus, between the two great influences which determined the trend of Scholasticism about the middle of the thirteenth century, there can be no doubt that Bonaventure ever remained a faithful disciple of Augustine and always defended the teaching of that Doctor; yet he by no means repudiated the teaching of Aristotle. While basing his doctrine on that of the old school, Bonaventure borrowed not a little from the new. Though he severely criticized the defects of Aristotle, he is said to have quoted more frequently from the latter than any former Scholastic had done. Perhaps he inclined more, on the whole, to some general views of Plato than to those of Aristotle, but he cannot therefore be called a Platonist. Although he adopted the hylomorphic theory of matter and form, Bonaventure, following Alexander of Hales, whose Summa he appears to have had before him in composing his own works, does not limit matter to corporeal lx;ings, but holds that one and the same kind of matter is the substratum of spiritual and corporeal beings alike. According to Bonaventure, materia prima is not a mere indeterniimxtum quid, but contains the raliones seminale.s infused by the Creator at the beginning, and tends towards the acquisition of those special forms which it ultimately assumes. The substantial form is not in Bonaventure's opinion, essentially, one, as St. Thomas taught. Another point in which Bonaventure, as representing the Franciscan school, is at variance with St. Thomas is that which concerns the possibility of creation from eternity. He declares that reason can demonstrate that the world was not created ab ceterno. In his system of ideology Bonaventure does not favour either the doctrine of Plato or that of the Ontologists. It is only by completely misunderstanding Bonaventure's teaching that any ontologistic interpretation can be read into it. For he is most emphatic in rejecting any direct or immediate vision of God or of His Divine attributes in this life. For the rest, the psychology of Bonaventure differs in no essential point from the common teaching of the Schoolmen. The same is true, as a whole, of his theology. Bonaventure's theological writings may be classed under four heads: dogmatic, mystic, exegetical, and homiletic. His dogmatic teaching is found chiefly in his "Commentary on the Sentences" and in his "Breviloquium". Treating of the Incarnation, Bonaventure does not differ substantially from St. Thomas. In answer to the question: "Would the Incarnation have taken place if Adam had not sinned?", he answers in the negative. Again, notwithstanding his deep devotion to the Blessed Virgin, he favours the opinion which does not exempt her from original sin, quia magis consonat fidei pietati el sandnrum auctoritati. But Bonaventure's treatment of this question marked a distinct advance, and he did more perhaps than anyone before Scotus to clear the ground for its correct presentation. His treatise on the sacraments is largely practical and is characterized by a distinctly devotional element. This appears especially in his treatment of tlie Holy Eucharist. He rejects the doctrine of pliysical, and admits only a moral, efficacy in the sacraments. It is much to be regretted that Bonaventure's views on this and other controverted questions should be so often misrepresented, even by recent wxiters. For example, at least three of the latest and best known manuals of dogma in treating of such questions as "De angelorum natura", "De scientia Cliristi", "De natura distinctionis inter caritatem et gratiam sanctifioantem", "De causalitate sacramentorum", and "De statu parvulorum sine baptismo morientiimi", gratuitously attribute opinions to Bonaventure which are entirely at variance with his real teaching. To be siu'e Bonaventure, like all the Scholastics, occasionally put forward opinions not strictly correct in regard to questions not yet defined or clearly settled, but even here his teaching represents the most profound and acceptable ideas of his age and marks a notable stage in the evolution of knowledge. Bonaventure's authority has always been very great in the Church. Apart from his personal influence at Lyons (1274). his WTitings carried great weight at the subsequent councils at Vienne (1311), Constance (1417), Basle (1431), and Florence (1438). At Trent (1546) his \iTitings, as NewTiian remarks (Apologia, ch. v) had a critical effect on some of the definitions of dogma, and at the Vatican Council (1870), sentences from them were embodied in the decrees concerning papal supremacy and infallibility. Only a small part of Bonaventure's WTitings is properly mystical. These are characterized by brevity and by a faithful adiierence to the teaching of the Gospel. The perfecting of the soul by the uprooting of vice and the implanting of virtue is his chief concern. There is a degree of prayer in which ecstasy occiu-s. AVhen it is attained, God is sincerely to be thanked. It must, however, he regarded only as incidental. It is by no means essential to the possession of perfection in the highest degree. Such is the general outline of Bonaventure's mysticism which is largely a continuation and development of what the St. Victors had already laid do«Ti. The shortest and most complete summary of it is found in his "De Triplici Via", often erroneously entitled the "Incendium Amoris", in which he distinguishes the different stages or degrees of perfect charity. What the " Breviloquium " is to Scholasticism, the "De Triplici Via" is to mysticism — a perfect compendium of all that is best in it. Savonarola made a pious and learned commentary upon it. Perhaps the best known of Bonaventure's other mystical and ascetical WTitingsare the "Soliloquium", a sort of dialogue containing a rich collection of passages from the Fathers on spiritual questions; the "Lignum vitae", a series of forty-eight devout meditations on the life of Christ, the "De sex alls seraphim.", a precious opuscule on the \nrtues of superiors, which Father Claudius Acqua\'iva caused to be printed separately and circulated throughout the Society of Jesus; the "Vitis mystica", a work on the Passion, which was for a long time erroneously ascrib)ed to St. Bernard, and "De Perfectione vitce", a treatise which depicts the virtues that make for religious perfection, and which appears to have been written for the use of Blessed Isabella of France, who had founded a monasterj- of Poor Clares at Longchamps. Bonaventure's exegetical works were highly esteemed in the Middle Ages and still remain a treasure house of thoughts and treatises. They include commentaries on the Books of Ecclesiastes and Wisdom and on the Gospels of St. Luke and St. John. In addition to his commentarj' on the Fourth Gospel, Bonaventure composed "Collationes in Joannem", ninety-one conferences on subjects relating to it. His "Collationes in He.xameron" is a work of the same kind, but its title, which did not originate with Bonaventure, is somewhat misleading. It consists of an unfinished course of instructions delivered at Paris in 1273. Bonaventure did not intend in these twenty-one discourses to e.xplain the work of the six days, but rather to draw some analogous instructions from the first chapter of Genesis, as a warning to his auditors against some errors of the day. It is an exaggeration to say that Bonaventure had regard only to the mystical sense of Scripture. In such of his wTitings as are properly exegetical he follows the text, though he also develops the practical conclusions deduced from it, for in the composition of these works he had the advantage of the preacher mainly in view. Bonaventure had conceived the most sublime idea of the ministry of preaching, and notwithstanding his manifold labours in other fields, this ministry ever held an especial place among his labours. He neglected no opportunity of preaching, whether to the clergy, the people, or his own Friars, and Bl. Francis of Fabriano (d. 1322), his contemporary and auditor, bears witness that Bonaventure's renown as a preacher almost surpassed his fame as a teacher. He preached before popes and kings, in Spain and Germany, as well as in France and Italy. Nearly five hundred authentic sermons of Bonaventure have come do\^'n to us; the greater part of them were delivered in Paris before the university while Bonaventure was professor there, or after he had become minister general. Most of them were taken down by some of his auditors and thus preserved to posterit}-. In his sermons he follows the Scholastic method of putting forth the divisions of his subject and then expounding each division according to the different senses. Besides his philosophical and theological writings, Bonaventure left a number of works referring to the religious life, but more especially to the Franciscan Order. Among the latter is his well-known ex)>lanation of the Rule of the Friars Minor; in this work, WTitten at a time when the dissensions ivithin the order as to the observance of the Rule were so painfully marked, he adopted a conciliatory attitude, approving neither the interpretation of the Zelanti nor that of the Rclaxti. His aim was to promote harmony in essentials. With this end in view, he had chosen a middle course at the outset and firmly adhered to it during the seventeen years of his generalship. If anyone could have succeeded in uniting the order, it would have been Bonaventure; but the rm media proved impracticable, and Bonaventure's personality only served to hold in check the elements of discord, subsequently represented by the Conventuals and the Fraticelli. Following upon his explanation of the Rule comes Bonaventure's important treatise emlx)ciying the Constitutions of Narbonne already referred to. There is also an answer by Bonaventure to some questions concerning the Rule, a treatise on the guidance of no\'ices, and an opuscule in which Bonaventure states why the Friars Minor preach and hear confessions, besides a number of letters which give us a special insight into the saint's character. These include official letters wTitten by Bonaventure as general to the superiors of the order, as well as personal letters addressed like that "Ad innominatum magistrum" to private individuals. Bonaventure's beautiful "Legend" or life of St. Francis completes the WTitings in which he strove to promote the spiritual welfare of his brethren. This well-known work is composed of two parts of very unequal value. In the first Bonaventure publishes the unedited facts that he had been able to gather at Assisi and elsewhere; in the other he merely abridges and repeats what others, and especially Celano, had already recorded. As a whole, it is essentially a Icgenda pocis, compiled mainly with a view to pacifying the unhappy discord still ravaging the order. St. Bonaventure's aim was to present a general portrait of the holy founder which, by the omission of certain points that had given rise to controversy, should be acceptable to all parties. This aim was surely legitimate even though from a critical standpoint the work may not be a perfect biography. Of tliis "Legenda Major", as it came to be called, Bonaventure made an abridgment arranged for use in choir and knorni as the "Legenda Minor".”
  5. 5. Comparison with Thomas Aquinas, titles Doctor Devotus and Doctor Seraphicus (Rayner of Pisa, 1333), Franciscan commentators, spurious attributions, and the ten-volume Quaracchi critical edition (1882–1902) prepared by Fidelis a Fanna and Ignatius Jeiler. Pass 2 bibliography cited by Paschal Robinson: Quaracchi Opera Omnia, X (1882–1902), 39–72 (Salimbene, Bernard of Besse, Francis of Fabriano, Angelo Clareno, Ubertino of Casale, Bartholomew of Pisa, Chronicle of the XXIV Generals); Acta SS., July, III, 776–822; Wadding, Annales Min., IV, and Script. Ord. Min.; Sbaralea, Supplementum (1806); Gaspare da Monte Santo (1874); Berthaumier (1858); Mariani (1874); Marangoni (1874); Isidorus a Buscomari (1874); Antonio Maria da Vicenza / Jeiler (1874); Panfilo da Magliano (1874); Skey (1889); Léon de Clary (1886); Prosper de Martigné (1888); Chérancé (1899); Smeets in Dict. de théol. cath., II; Fidelis a Fanna (1870, 1874); Werner (1876); Jeiler (1887); Felder (1904); De Wulf (1905).

    5. Comparison with Aquinas, spurious works, Quaracchi edition (1882–1902), and bibliographyLines 107205–107510

    Original passage

    “Bonaventure was the true heir and follower of Alexander of Hales and the continuator of the old Franciscan school founded by the Doctor Irrefraqabilis, but he surpassed the latter in acumen, fertility of imagination, and originality of expression. His proper place is beside his friend St. Thomas, as they are the two greatest theologians of Scholasticism. If it be true that tlie system of St. Thomas is more finished than that of Bonaventure, it should be borne in mind that, whereas Thoma,s was free to give himself to study to the end of his days, Bonaventure had not yet received the Doctor's degree when he was called to govern his order and overwhelmed with multifarious cares in consequence. The heavy responsibilities which he bore till within a few weeks of his death were almost incompatible with further study and even precluded his completing what he had begun before his thirty-sixth year. Again, in attempting to make a comparison between Bonaventure and St. Thomas, we should remember that the two saints were of a different bent of mind; each had qualities in which he excelled; one was in a sense the complement of the other; one supplied what the other lacked. Thus Thomas was anah'tical, Bonaventure sjTithetical; Thomas was the Christian Aristotle, Bonaventure the true disciple of Augustine; Thomas was the teacher of the schools, Bonaventure of practical life; Thomas enlightened the mind, Bonaventure inflamed the heart; Thomas extended the Kingdom of God by the love of theologj-, Bona\"enture by the theologj- of love. Even those who liold that Bonaventure does not reach the level of St. Thomas in the sphere of Scholastic speciJation concede that as a mystic he far surpasses the .\ngelic Doctor. In this particular realm of theologj-, Bonaventure equals, if he does not excel, St. Bernard himself. Leo XIII rightly calls Bonaventure the Prince of Mystics: "Having scaled the difficult heights of speculation in a most notable manner, he treated of mystical theologj- with such perfection that in the common opinion of the learned he is facile princeps in that field." (Allocutio of 11 October, 1890.) It mast not be concluded, however, that Bonaventure's mj-stical writings constitute his chief title to fame. This conclusion, in so far as it seems to imply a deprecation of his labours in the field of Scholasticism, is opposed to the explicit utterances of several pontiffs and eminent scholars, is incompatible with Bonaventure's acknowledged reputation in the Schools, and is excluded bj- an intelligent perusal of his works. As a matter of fact, the half of one volume of the ten comprising the Quaracchi edition suffices to contain Bonaventure's ascetic and nij-stic wTitings. Although Bonaventure's mj-stical works alone would suffice to place him in the foremost rank, j-et he may justly be called a mystic rather than a Scholastic onljin so far as every subject he treats of is made ultimately to converge upon God. This abiding sense of God's presence which pervades all the wTitings of Bonaventure is perhaps their fundamental attribute. To it we may trace that all-pervading unction which is their peculiar characteristic. As Sixtus V aptljexpresses it: "In WTiting he united to the highest erudition an equal amount of the most ardent pietj-; so that whilst enlightening his readers he also touched their hearts penetrating to the inmost recesses of their souls" (Bull, Triumphantis Jerusalem). St. .\ntoninus, Denis the Carthusian, Louis of Granada, and Father Claude de la Colombiere, among otliers, have also noted tliis feature of Bonaventure's writings. Invariablj' he aims at arousing devotion as well as imparting knowledge. He never divorces the one from the other, but treats learned subjects devoutly and devout subjects learnedlj-. Bonaventure, however, never sacrifices truth to devotion, but his tendency to prefer an opinion which arouses devotion to a drj- and uncertain speculation maj- go far towards explaining not a little of the widespread popularity his wTitings enjoj-ed among his contemporaries and in all succeeding ages. Again Bonaventure is distinguished from the other Scholastics not only by the greater warmth of his religious teaching, but also bj- its practical tendencj- as Trithemius notes (Scriptores Eccles.). Manj' purelj- speculative questions are passed over bj- Bonaventure; there is a directness about all he has T\Titten. No useful purpose, he declares, is achieved bj- mere controversy. He is ever tolerant and modest. Thus wliile he himself accepts the literal interpretations of the first chapter of Genesis, Bonaventure acknowledges the admissibility of a different one and refers with admiration to the figurative explanation propounded by St. Augustine. He never condemns the opinions of others and emphaticallj- disclaims anything like finalitj- for his own \-iews. Indeed he asserts the littleness of liis authoritj-, renounces all claims to originalitj- and calls himself a "poor compiler". No doubt Bonaventure's works betraj- some of the defects of the learning of his daj-, but there is nothing in them that savours of aseless subtlety. "One does not find in his pages", ^Tites Gerson (De Examin. Doctrin.) "vain trifles or u-seless cavils, nor does he mix as do so manj- others, worldly digressions with serious theological discussions". "Tliis", he adds, "is the reason why St. Bonaventure has been abandoned bj- those Scholastics who are devoid of piety of whom the number is alas! but too large". It has been said that Bonaventure's mystical spirit unfitted him for subtle analj-sis. Be this as it may, one of the greatest charms of Bonaventure's writings is their simple clearness. Though he had necessarily to make use of the Scholastic method, he rose above dialectics, and though his argumentation may at times seem too cumbersome to find approval in our time, j-et he wTites with an ease and grace of stj-le which one seeks in vain among the other Schoolmen. To the minds of his contemporaries impregnated with the mj'sticism of the Middle Ages, the spirit that breathed in Bonaventure's wTitings seemed to find its parallel only in the lives of those that stand nearest to the Tlirone. and the title of "Seraphic Doctor" bestowed upon Bonaventure is an undeniable tribute to his all-absorbing love for God. This title seems to have been first given to him in 1333 in the Prologue of the "Pantheologia" bj- Raj-ner of Pisa, O.P. He had already received while teaching in Paris the name of Doctor Devotus. The Franciscan Order has ever regarded Bonaventm-e as one of the greatest Doctors and from the beginning his teaching found many distinguished expositors within the order, among the earliest being his own pupils, John Peckham later Archbishop of Canterbury, Matthew of Aquasparta, and Alexander of Alexandria (d. 1314), both of whom became ministers general of the order. The last named wrote a "Summa qusestionum S. Bonaventurse'. Other well-known commentaries are by John of Erfurt (d. 1317), Vorilongus (d. 1464), Brulifer (d. c. 1-^97), de Combes (d. 1570), Trigosus (d. 1616), Coriolano (d. 1625), Zamora (d. 1649), Bontemps (d. 1672), Hauzeur (d. 1676), Bonelli (d. 177.3), etc. From the fourteenth to the sixteenth century the influence of Bonaventure was undoubtedly somewhat overshadowed by that of Duns Scotus, owing largely to the prominence of the latter as champion of the Immaculate Conception in the disputes between the Franciscans and Dominicans. Sixtus V, howe\-er, founded a special chair at Rome for tlie study of St. Bonaventure; such chairs also existed in several universities, notably at Ingolstadt, Salzburg, Valencia, and Osuna. It is worthy of note that the Capuchins forbade their Friars to follow Scotus and ordered them to return to the study of Bonaventure. The centenary celebrations of 1874 appear to have revived interest in the life and work of St. Bonaventure. Certain it is that since then the study of his WTitings has steadily increased. Unfortunately not all of Bonaventure's WTitings have come dowTi to us. Some were lost before the invention of printing. On tlie other hand, several works have in the course of time been attributed to him which are not his. Such are the "Centiloquium", the "Speculum Disciplinae", which is probably the work of Bernard of Besse, Bonaventure's secretarj^; the rhythmical "Philomela", which seems to be from the pen of John Peckham; the "Stimulus Amoris" and the "Speculum B. M. V.", written respectively by James of Milan and Conrad of Saxony; "The Legend of St. Clare", which is by Thomas of Celano; the "Meditationes vitte Christi" composed by a Friar Minor for a Poor Clare, and the " Biblia pauperum" of the Dominican Nicholas of Hanapis. Those familiar with the catalogues of European libraries are aware that no writer since the Middle Ages had been more widely read or copied than Bonaventure. The earliest catalogues of his works are those given by Salimbene (1282), Henry of Cdient (d. 1293), Ubertino of Casale (1305), Ptolemy of Lucca (1327) and the "Chronicle of the XXIV Cienerals" (1368). The fifteenth century saw no less than fifty editions of Bonaventure's works. More celebrated than any preceding edition was that published at Rome (1588-96) by order of Sixtus V (7 vols, in fol.). It was reprinted with but slight emendations at Metz in 1609 and at Lyons in 1678. A fourth edition appeared at Venice (13 vols, in 4to) 1751, and was reprinted at Paris in 1864. All these editions were ^'ery imperfect in so far as they include spurious works and omit genuine ones. They have been completely superseded by the celebrated critical edition published by the Friars Minor at Quaracchi, near Florence. Any scientific study of Bonaventure must be based upon this edition, upon which not only Leo XIII (13 December, 1885) and Pius X (11 April, 1904). but scholars of all creeds have lavished the highest encomiums. Nothing seems to have been omitted which could make this edition perfect and complete. In its preparation the editors visited over 400 libraries and examined nearly 52,000 MSS. while the first volume alone ^•ontains 20,000 variant readings. It was commenced by Father Fidelis a Fanna (d. ISSl) and ■completed by Father Ignatius Jeiler (d. 1904): ■"Doctoris Seraphici S. Bonaventura; S. R. E. Episcopi Cardinalis Opera Omnia, edita studio et cura P. P. Collegii S. Bonaventura; in fol. ad Claras Aquas [Quaracchi] 1882-1902". In this edition the works of tlie .saint are distributed througli the ten volumes as follows: the first four contain his great "Commentaries on the Book of Sentences"; the fifth comprises eight smaller scholastic works such as the " Brevilonuium " and ' Itinerarium"; the sixth and iloq seventli are devoted to his commentaries on Scripture; the eighth contains his mystical and ascetic writings and works having special reference to the order; the ninth his sermons; whilst the tenth is taken up witli the index and a short sketch of the saint's life and writings by Father Ignatius Jeiler. We do not possess any formal, contemporary biography of St. Bonaventure. That written by the Spanish Franciscan, Zamorra, who flourished before 1300, has not been preserved. The references to Bonaventure's life contained in the works of Salimbene (1282), Bernard of Besse (c. 1380) Bl. Francis of Fabriano (d. 1322), AngeloClareno (d. 1337), Ubertino of Casale (d. 1338), Bartliolomew of Pisa (d. 1399) and the "Clironicle of the XXIV Generals" (c. 1368), are given in vol. X of the Quaracchi Edition (pp. 39-72). Ada SS.. 3d ed., July, III, 776-S22; W.idding, Annales Min. (Rome, 1732), IV, passim: Idem, Script. Ori. Mi7i. (1650 ■). 61-81; Sbar.4LE.\, Supplementum (1806), 142-172, 726; G\SP\RE DA Monte Santo. Gesta e dottrina del seraf. dott. S. Bonaventura (2d ed., Florence. 1874); Berthacmier, Hisloire de S. Bonaventure (Paris, 1858); Mariani, S. Bonaventura (Florence. 1874); Marangoni, Vita di S. Bonaventura (Padua, 1874); IsiDORVS A BnscOMARi, S. Bonaventura, O. F. M. minister generalis (Rome, 1874); Anton. Maria da Vicenza, Vita di S. Bonaventura (Rome, 1874), German tr. Jeiler (Paderborn, 1874); Panfilo da Magliano, Storia compmdiosa di S Francesco e dei francescani (Rome, 1874), I, 619 and passim; Sket, Life of St. Bonaventure (London. 1889); Leo de Clarv, Lives of the Saints and Blessed of the Three Orders of St. Francis (Taunton, 1886), II, 466-490; Prosper de JIar- TiGNE, La scholastique et les traditions franciscaines (Paris, 1888), 77-153; Cherance, S. Bonaventure (Paris, 1899); and Sheets in Diet, de thiol, cath. (Paris, 1904), II, 962-986. Among those who of recent years have written on Bonaventure's doctrine or special points of it are Mahgerie, Essai sur la phUosophie de S. Bonaventure (Paris, 1855); Van Loo, Specimen doctrina: . ... ad mentem S. Bonaventura (Louvam, 1856); Hollenberg, Sludien zu Bonaventura (Berlin, 1862); Fidelis a Fanna, Seraphici Doctoris. Bonaventura, doctnna de Romani Pontificis primatu et infallibilitate (Tiu-in, 1870); Idem, Ratio nova' colleclionis operum S. Bonaventura: (Turin, 1874); Marcellino da Civezza. Delia vera filosofia e delle dottrine del serafico dottore S. Bonaventura (Genoa, 1J74); LuDOVlcus A Castroplanio, Seraphicus Doctor S. Bona- Ventura in (Ecumenids cath. eccl. conciliis (Rome, 18741; FR\NClscrs Maria a Salerno, Delia poesia nel serafico dottore S. Borwvcntura (Genoa, 1874); Werner, Die Psychologie und Erkenntnisslehre des hi. Bonaventura (Vienna, 1876); Ant. M. A ViNCENTIA et Jo. A RuBINO. Lexicon Bonaventunanum philosophico-theologieum (Vienna, 1880); De human(E cognitionis ratione; anecdota qufvdam S. Bonaventurce et nonnullorum ipsius disdpulorum (Quaracchi. 1883); Baroni, La scuola franciscana guidata dal suo serafico dottore S. Bonaventura (Florence, 1886); Canali, Oratio super characteribus doctnna; Bonaventuriance (Piacenza, 1887); Jeiler. S. Bonaventura: prindpia de concursu Dei generali ad actiones causarum secundarum (Quaracchi, 1887); Stateczny, Compendium htslona philosophia (Rome, 1898), 312, passim: Bisogno, S. Bonaventura e Dante (Milan, 1899); Evangeliste de Safnt-Beat, Le scraphin de I'ecole. etudes sur S. Bonaventure (Pans, 1900); ZoRZOLi. La gueslione di S. Bonaventura, De cognitionis humaruF suprema ratione. commentata e difesa (Turin. 1900); \ illanova, S. Bonaventura und das PapsUhum (Bregenz, 1902); RosATl. L'eloquenza cristiana in S. Bonaventura (Florence, 1903); Facin, Dissertatio de studio bonaventuriano (Quaracchi, 1902); S. Bonaventura, Doctor Seraphicus, disdpulorum S. Augustini alter princeps (Venice, 1904); Stockl. Handbook of the History of Philosophi/, tr. Finlat (Dublin, 1903). I. 402- 406; Turner. History of Philosophy (Boston, 1903). 329-335; Felder, Geschichte der uHssenschaftliehen Studien im Frandskanerorden bis urn die Mitte des IS. Jahrhunderts (Freiburg, 1904), 215-227, passim: VlVES, Summula C ommentariorum Seraphid Doctoris, Bonaventura (Rome, 1905); de Wulf, Histoire de la philosophic medievale (2d ed., Louvain and Paris, 1905) 299-308; UEBERWEG-HErNZE, Grundnss der Geschichte der Philosophic (Berlin, 1905, 9th ed.), II, 279-286; Ubald D'ALENfON in Etudes Franciscaines (July, 1905), 91-102; Laurence, The Life and Writings of St. Bonaventure in The Franciscan Montlily (London, 1904-OH). Paschal Robinson.”
  6. 6. Recounts Saint Thomas Aquinas asking Bonaventure whence he drew his learning (answered by pointing to his crucifix) and finding him in ecstasy while writing the life of Saint Francis ('Let us leave a Saint to write of a Saint'), notes his spiritual direction of King Saint Louis IX and Blessed Isabella, and describes the papal envoys hanging the cardinal's hat on a bush while Bonaventure finished washing the convent dishes near Florence.

    6. Saint Thomas Aquinas finding Bonaventure in ecstasy ('Let us leave a Saint to write of a Saint'), direction of Saint Louis IX and Blessed Isabella, and the cardinal's hat hung on a bushLines 14308–14320

    About this source edition

    John Gilmary Shea (ed.), Pictorial Lives of the Saints (1889), July 14, St. Bonaventure, lines 14308-14320

    Original passage

    “ventura !” — good luck. He is known also as the “ Seraphic Doc- tor,” from the fervor of divine love which breathes in his writings. He was the friend of St. Thomas Aquinas, who asked him one day whence he drew his great learning. He replied by pointing to his crucifix. At another time, St. Thomas found him in ecstasy while writing the life of St. Francis, and exclaimed, “Let us leave a Saint to write of a Saint.” They received the Doctor’s cap to- gether. He was the guest and adviser of St. Louis, and the director of St. Isabella, the king’s sister. At the age of thirty- five, he was made general of his Order ; and only escaped another”
  7. 7. Records Bonaventure's flight to France upon learning that he was to be made a bishop and cardinal, his humble service at table when the papal envoys arrived, and his words to Saint Thomas Aquinas while pointing to the crucifix: 'Behold the great book that teaches me everything!'

    7. Reply to Saint Thomas Aquinas ('Behold the great book that teaches me everything!') and withdrawal to France to avoid the cardinalateLines 10796–10806

    About this source edition

    Cecilia Mary Caddell, Short Lives of the Saints (1910), July 14, St. Bonaventure, Bishop and Doctor, lines 10796-10806

    Original passage

    “Lyons. Amid all these honors and dignities, St. Bonaventure preserved a singular spirit of humility. When he first learned that he was to be made bishop he fled away to France; and when the Pope's envoys brought to him the insignia of cardinal, they found him serving his brethren at table. On one occasion St. Thomas Aquinas asked him whence he drew so much eloquence and unction in his discourses; St. Bonaventure pointed to his crucifix and replied, " Behold the great book that teaches me everything!"”

Found an error? Report a correction.