Decision case · Saint Bonaventure
The Starving Friar in the Night
Context
Imitating your strict life, your friars have taken up harsh fasting. Late one night while the house sleeps, a friar who fasted beyond his strength cries out that he is dying of hunger. Left without food, he faces real harm, yet eating alone while everyone else fasts will crush him with shame. Scolding him breaks his spirit, while dropping fasting rules without explanation breeds carelessness. How will you answer the starving brother's cry?
Options
- Gather the friars, set out bread, and eat first yourself beside the hungry brother so he feels no shame. Afterward, instruct the community on wise moderation.
- Order the hungry brother to go to the table and eat alone while you and the other friars keep fasting.
Choice
Francis immediately had bread set before the friars and ate first himself. He invited the others to join so the hungry brother felt no shame, and afterward spoke on wise moderation.
Consequence
The brother regained strength in body and soul. Meanwhile, the community learned that God desires merciful good sense rather than reckless self-harm.
Virtues: charity, prudence, humility
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceFrancis immediately had bread set before the brethren and began to eat first himself, inviting the others to join so the starving brother would not blush with shame, and afterward gave them a discourse on the virtue of discretion. The brother was strengthened in both body and spirit, and the community learned that God desires mercy and discreet charity rather than indiscreet self-destruction.
