Decision case · Saint Bonaventure
Before the Bishop's Tribunal in Assisi
Context
Praying before the Crucifix in the crumbling church of St. Damian outside Assisi, you heard a voice speak three times. It commanded, 'Francis, go and repair My House, which, as thou seest, is falling utterly into ruin'. Thinking this meant the stone building, you rode to Foligno and sold cloth and your horse. You offered the coins to St. Damian's poor priest, who refused them out of fear of your parents. You tossed the coins onto a window ledge like dust. Your furious father dragged you home through Assisi's mocking streets, beat you, and chained you. Your mother freed you while he was away, and your father later recovered the money from the window ledge. Now he brings you before the Bishop of Assisi's public court to make you legally give up your inheritance. Fighting in court tangles you in worldly property, while giving up everything leaves you penniless. How will you answer before the Bishop?
Options
- Without delay or argument, strip off all your clothes—even your inner garments—and hand them back to your father. Declare that from now on you call only 'Our Father, Which art in heaven' your father.
- Yield to your father's authority, drop the repair of St. Damian's, and return to the family cloth business in Assisi.
- Ask the Bishop to arrange a compromise letting you keep your clothes and a small allowance while living at St. Damian's.
Choice
Waiting for neither speeches nor legal delays, Francis stripped off all his clothes, showing a rough hairshirt against his skin. He handed the clothes back to his father and declared that from then on he could boldly pray, 'Our Father, Which art in heaven'.
Consequence
Moved to tears, the Bishop wrapped Francis in his own cloak and gave him a farm servant's rough tunic. Marking it with a chalk Cross, Francis went out free from the world to repair St. Damian's and two other churches.
Virtues: humility, piety, wisdom
