Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Bonaventure

Solitary Contemplation or Apostolic Preaching?

Context

Having tasted quiet prayer in mountain retreats, you face a deep question about your calling. Silent prayer unites the soul directly with God, whereas preaching exposes an unschooled man to worldly dust and distraction. Yet God's own Son came down from the Father to save sinners, showing that Christians must not live for themselves alone. Hiding in a hermit's cell leaves towns without Gospel preaching, while rushing out by self-will risks losing prayerful union. How will you decide between solitary prayer and public preaching?

Options

  • Distrust your own judgment, send friars to ask Brother Sylvester and Saint Clare to seek God's will in prayer, and obey the Spirit's answer.
  • Follow your natural love for quiet solitude and bind yourself and your friars to a strictly hermit life of silent prayer.

Choice

Distrusting his own judgment, Francis sent Brother Masseo to consult Brother Sylvester on Mount Subasio and Saint Clare at St. Damian's. Both independently received the same answer from God: Francis was chosen to go out and preach for the salvation of souls. Rising at once, Francis set out with glowing zeal toward Bevagna.

Consequence

Obeying promptly, Francis preached his famous sermon to the birds near Bevagna and launched the worldwide preaching of the Friars Minor.

Virtues: humility, prudence, charity

Evidence