Decision case · Saint Bonaventure
The Simple Brother's Plea for Milder Suffering
Context
For two years after leaving Mount La Verna, constant sicknesses have worn your body down to skin and bone. Hardly a single limb is free from sharp pain. Watching a fierce wave of agony strike you, a simple-hearted friar speaks out of pity. 'Brother, pray the Lord that He deal more gently with thee', he pleads. 'For meseemeth that His hand is laid more heavily on thee than is right'. Accepting his words allows complaint against God's just will, while harshly driving him away bruises his simple heart. How will you answer him?
Options
- Warn the brother that only his simple innocence spares him from rebuke for blaming God's justice. Throw yourself onto the hard floor, kiss the ground, and thank the Lord for every pain.
- Accept the brother's sympathy and ask the Lord to lighten a burden that feels heavier than is fair.
Choice
Groaning aloud, Francis warned the brother that only his simple innocence kept Francis from shunning him for blaming God's judgments. Francis then threw himself from his straw mat onto the hard floor, kissed the ground, and thanked the Lord for all his pains.
Consequence
Francis kept calling his bodily pains 'sisters' until he died naked on the bare earth at the Portiuncula on 4 October 1226.
Virtues: piety, humility, wisdom
Evidence
- Verified: Directly supported by strong evidenceFrancis groaned aloud, warned the brother that had he not known his simple purity he would have shunned his company for daring to deem God's judgments worthy of blame, flung himself from his pallet onto the hard ground, kissed the floor, and thanked the Lord for all his pains. Francis continued calling his bodily pangs 'sisters' until he died naked on the bare earth at the Portiuncula on October 4, 1226.
