Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Decision case · Saint Bonaventure

The Roman Preacher's Secret Doubt of the Stigmata

Context

You are a respected Franciscan scholar and preacher in Rome. You know the sworn witnesses and papal bulls, or official letters from popes, confirming Saint Francis's Stigmata. The Stigmata were the wounds of Christ impressed on Francis's hands, feet, and side. Still, you secretly nurse a proud, rationalist doubt in your heart, measuring the miracle by purely natural reason. At night Francis appears in a vision with muddy feet and humble sternness. Asking why your secret unbelief stains his glory with mud, he bids you look at his pierced hands and open side. Hiding your doubt protects your scholarly fame in Rome, while open confession humbles your pride before the people. What will you do upon waking?

Options

  • Humble your scholarly pride and wash away your rationalist doubt over the Stigmata—Christ's wounds on Francis's hands, feet, and side—with tears. Publicly confess your former unbelief before the people of Rome.
  • Keep your rationalist doubts hidden inside your heart so your reputation as a learned master stays untouched.

Choice

Struck with sorrow and awe by the vision, the learned Friar Minor wept bitterly to wash away his unbelief. He then openly confessed his fault before the people in Rome.

Consequence

His public confession strengthened the faith of the Roman people in the Sacred Stigmata of Saint Francis.

Virtues: humility, piety, prudence

Evidence