Section II · Location 2 of 4
Section 2 · Open to readFrom The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great
Edition: The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880)
Chapters VII–XVI: Maurus Rescuing Placidus, Florentius's Poisoned Loaf, Foundation of Monte Cassino, and King Totila
The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) · Chapter 2 summary
Maurus walked on water to save the drowning boy Placidus. In response, Benedict and Maurus engaged in a humble contest of virtue, each attributing the miracle to the other. The envious priest Florentius tried to ruin his monks' souls after failing to poison Benedict. In response, Benedict humbly left Subiaco rather than fight for prestige. Wept with grief when he heard of Florentius's sudden death.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Chapters VII–XVI: Maurus Rescuing Placidus, Florentius's Poisoned Loaf, Foundation of Monte Cassino, and King Totila” Summary of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-life-of-saint-benedict-dialogues-book-ii/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Chapters VII through XVI recount the dramatic turning points that led Saint Benedict from Subiaco to Monte Cassino. Moreover, he established his prophetic authority across Italy. The boy Placidus fell into the deep lake while drawing water. In response, Benedict saw the danger in spirit from his cell. He also sent Maurus running across the water as if on dry land to pull him out by his hair. This is a miracle that Benedict attributed to Maurus's prompt obedience. At the same time, Maurus attributed it to Benedict's command. Soon afterward, a neighboring priest named Florentius, consumed by envy at Benedict's holiness, sent him a poisoned loaf of bread (which a tame raven carried away at Benedict's command). Moreover, he sent seven wicked women into the monastery garden to corrupt the young monks. Benedict realizes that Florentius's malice was aimed at him personally. Then he humbly yielded place to envy and led a small band of disciples south to the mountain stronghold of Cassinum. Even when Maurus hurried after him to report that Florentius had just been killed by a collapsing balcony, Benedict wept bitterly over his enemy's dreadful death. Moreover, he imposed a penance on Maurus for rejoicing. At Monte Cassino, Benedict demolished the ancient idol and grove of Apollo, built the chapels of Saint Martin and Saint John the Baptist, dislodged an immovable boulder that Satan was sitting upon, and dispelled a diabolical illusion of a burning kitchen. He also raised to life a young monk crushed by a collapsing wall. Detected monks who ate secretly outside the monastery. In addition, he unmasked the Gothic King Totila's disguised armor-bearer Riggo. Moreover, he foretold Totila's capture of Rome, voyage to Sicily, and death in the tenth year.
In Chapters VII–VIII, Benedict saw in spirit the boy Placidus drowning in the lake. In addition, he sent Maurus (who ran across the water without realizing it until afterward) to rescue him. The envious priest Florentius sent Benedict a poisoned loaf and then tried to corrupt his disciples' chastity. In response, Benedict commanded a raven to hide the poisoned bread and humbly departed for Monte Cassino. He wept when Florentius died in a balcony collapse. In Chapter VIII, the spreading fame of Benedict's holiness drew crowds to give glory to God, awakening the bitter envy of the priest Florentius. In Chapters IX–XIII, Benedict arrived at Monte Cassino. Then he overturned the idol of Apollo, converted the surrounding countrypeople, freed a stone held down by the devil, and dispelled a phantom fire. He also restored to life a young monk crushed by a falling wall. In addition, he knew by prophetic spirit when monks ate unlawfully outside the abbey.
In Chapter XI, Benedict's prayer restores to life the young monk crushed in a sack by a falling wall. In response, the youth returns immediately to finish building the wall with his brothers. In Chapters XIV–XVI, Benedict immediately recognized the Gothic King Totila's sword-bearer Riggo disguised in royal robes. He also rebuked Totila in person while predicting that he would enter Rome, cross to Sicily, and die in his tenth year. In addition, he prophesied to Bishop Sabinus of Canosa that Totila would not destroy Rome. Healed a possessed cleric who later fell back into bondage by breaking his promise not to seek holy orders. In Chapter XIV, Totila, King of the Goths, heard that Benedict possessed the spirit of prophecy. Moreover, he devised a trick to test whether the saint was truly a man of God. The Gothic King Totila tried to test Benedict's prophetic gift by dressing his sword-bearer Riggo in royal purple. In response, Benedict saw through the disguise immediately and rebuked Totila's cruelty. In doing so, he foretold his capture of Rome and his death ten years later.
The story inside
Few enemies in monastic history acted with worse malice than the priest Florentius. Envious of the crowds who visited Benedict for spiritual guidance. At the same time, his own church stood empty, Florentius first sent Benedict a loaf of poisoned bread as if it were a blessed gift. When Benedict had a wild raven carry the poisoned bread away to a place where no human could find it, Florentius sank even lower. He sent seven shameless women to dance in the garden of Benedict's monastery to ruin the souls of his young monks. Recognizing that Florentius hated him personally, Benedict chose not to fight back. Instead, he appointed priors for the twelve monasteries at Subiaco and quietly departed with a few monks. Hardly had Benedict left when Maurus sent word in triumph: 'Return, for the priest who persecuted you is dead!'—killed when his own balcony collapsed. Instead of rejoicing, Benedict burst into bitter tears (both because his enemy had died in his sins and because his own disciple had rejoiced at another man's ruin). Moreover, he imposed a penance on Maurus to expiate that joy. A true follower of Christ never rejoices at an enemy's downfall, but mourns for the sinner's soul.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Maurus walked on water to save the drowning boy Placidus. In response, Benedict and Maurus engaged in a humble contest of virtue, each attributing the miracle to the other.
- 2
The envious priest Florentius tried to ruin his monks' souls after failing to poison Benedict. In response, Benedict humbly left Subiaco rather than fight for prestige. Wept with grief when he heard of Florentius's sudden death.
- 3
At Monte Cassino, Benedict converted the local pagans from the worship of Apollo. In addition, he replaced the pagan altar with Christian chapels. Moreover, he raised to life a young monk crushed while building the abbey wall.
- 4
The Gothic King Totila tried to test Benedict's prophetic gift by dressing his sword-bearer Riggo in royal purple. In response, Benedict saw through the disguise immediately and rebuked Totila's cruelty. In doing so, he foretold his capture of Rome and his death ten years later.
Test your recall
Why did Benedict impose a penance on his faithful disciple Maurus after Florentius died?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 1589–1591
“Maurus having asked and received the blessing, ran to the lake to execute the order of his Abbot.”
- 2.Lines 1644–1646
“As for me, the more you relate of the miracles of this holy man, the more I love to listen.”
- 3.Lines 2069–2071
“IT seemed good to the man of God to dig deeper in the very spot which the stone had occupied.”
