Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues)

Section 3 · Pope Saint Gregory I the Great

Section III · Location 3 of 4

Section 3 · Open to read

From The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great

Edition: The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880)

Chapters XVII–XXIX: Prophecy on Monte Cassino, Discernment of Spirits, Famine Relief, and Miracles of Provision

The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) · Chapter 3 summary

Benedict foresaw the future destruction of Monte Cassino by the Lombards. Yet he consoled Theoprobus that through prayer God had spared the lives of all the brothers. Like Elisha with Gehazi, Benedict read the hidden actions and secret proud thoughts of those around him so as to heal their souls from pride and greed.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Chapters XVII–XXIX: Prophecy on Monte Cassino, Discernment of Spirits, Famine Relief, and Miracles of Provision” Summary of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-life-of-saint-benedict-dialogues-book-ii/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Chapters XVII through XXIX showcase Saint Benedict's prophetic foresight, his penetration into the hidden thoughts of the heart, and his unshakeable trust in God's providence during times of severe famine in Campania. Benedict wept in his cell before the nobleman Theoprobus. Then he foretold that the entire monastery of Monte Cassino would one day be handed over to the barbarians (fulfilled when the Lombards sacked it by night). Yet God had granted him the lives of all the monks residing there. He knew when Totila's servant hid one of two flasks of wine in the woods (warning him not to drink from it because a serpent had crawled inside) and when a monk accepted handkerchiefs from nuns without permission. The son of a proud defender stood holding a lamp before Benedict at supper and silently despised the saint in his heart. In response, Benedict read his secret pride at once and ordered him to make the sign of the Cross over his heart. During a terrible famine in Campania, Benedict rebuked his monks for doubting God when only five loaves remained. In response, two hundred bushels of flour appeared at the abbey gate the next morning. Likewise, the cellarer hesitated to give away the last drops of olive oil. In response, Benedict commanded it to be given to a poor subdeacon. He also prayed with his monks until an empty barrel overflowed with oil across the floor.

In Chapters XVII–XX, Benedict wept as he prophesied to the nobleman Theoprobus that Monte Cassino would be destroyed by barbarians though the monks' lives would be spared, warned a boy who hid a flask of wine that a snake had entered it. Exposed a monk who secretly accepted handkerchiefs from nuns. Moreover, he read the silent proud thoughts of a nobleman's son holding a lamp at supper. Chapter XVIII notes that Benedict's spirit was so united to God that he perceived actions done far away in his absence. In Chapters XXI–XXV, during a famine in Campania when only five loaves remained, Benedict rebuked the monks' lack of faith and the next morning two hundred sacks of flour were found at the gate. He appeared in a simultaneous dream to two monks sent to build a monastery at Terracina. He also reconciled two deceased religious women to the Church through the Eucharistic oblation. He also quieted the grave of a boy monk by placing the Body of the Lord upon his breast. In addition, he halted a runaway monk with the vision of a dragon.

In Chapter XXIII, because Benedict's heart was always recollected in God, even his warnings carried spiritual force unless retracted. In Chapters XXVI–XXIX, Benedict cured a boy of leprosy. He also obtained thirteen gold pieces by prayer on the monastery grain chest to rescue a poor man hounded by a creditor. In addition, he threw a disobedient cellarer's glass bottle of oil out the window onto sharp rocks without its breaking. Caused a covered empty cask to overflow with olive oil across the pavement while the community prayed. In Chapter XXVII, thirteen gold pieces miraculously appear on the corn chest. In response, Benedict tells the distressed debtor to pay his creditor twelve pieces and keep the thirteenth for his family's needs. During the famine in Campania, Benedict insisted on giving away the monastery's last food, oil, and coins to the poor. He trusted that God would multiply their stores. This is as God did with the two hundred bushels of flour and the overflowing cask of oil.

The story inside

During a severe famine in Campania, a pious subdeacon named Agapitus came to Monte Cassino begging for a little olive oil. Only a few drops remained at the bottom of a single glass bottle. Yet Benedict immediately commanded the cellarer to give those last drops to the poor man. Afraid that the monastery would be left with nothing, the cellarer held back and disobeyed the order. Benedict learned what had happened. In response, he had the glass bottle thrown right out the window onto the jagged rocks below—yet the glass did not break or spill a drop. Benedict then called the whole community together. In addition, he rebuked the cellarer before all for his disobedience and lack of faith. Moreover, he knelt down in prayer with his brothers beside an empty covered oil cask. As the saint prayed, the lid of the barrel began to rise, and fresh olive oil welled up. Moreover, he poured out over the stone floor until Benedict ended his prayer. Holding back charity out of fear of scarcity shows a lack of trust in God. He multiplies what is given generously to the poor.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Benedict foresaw the future destruction of Monte Cassino by the Lombards. Yet he consoled Theoprobus that through prayer God had spared the lives of all the brothers.

  2. 2

    Like Elisha with Gehazi, Benedict read the hidden actions and secret proud thoughts of those around him so as to heal their souls from pride and greed.

  3. 3

    Two noble religious women who had sharp tongues died before he lifted his warning of excommunication. In response, Benedict sent an oblation to be offered for them at Mass, freeing their souls from the ban.

  4. 4

    During the famine in Campania, Benedict insisted on giving away the monastery's last food, oil, and coins to the poor. He trusted that God would multiply their stores. This is as God did with the two hundred bushels of flour and the overflowing cask of oil.

Test your recall

Why did Saint Benedict order the last glass bottle of oil to be thrown out the window onto the rocks?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 3012–3014
    “Op a proud thought formed in the mind of a monk, which was discovered by the man of god.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 3190–3195
    “Peter. What you say is founded on a very clear and solid reason which unveils to me its truth, but I must entreat you to unfold what you further know regarding the venerable Father Benedict.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 3283–3288
    “Hearing these things, they were amazed and returned to the grounds on which the monastery was to be built, and laid the foundations according to the design revealed in the vision.”

Location: section 3 of 4 · 75%

Display settings