Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues)

Section 4 · Pope Saint Gregory I the Great

Section IV · Location 4 of 4

Section 4 · Open to read

From The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great

Edition: The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880)

Chapters XXX–XXXVIII: Raising the Dead, Last Colloquy with Saint Scholastica, the Cosmic Vision, the Rule, and Holy Death

The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) · Chapter 4 summary

The cruel Goth Zalla brought a peasant bound with tight cords to the monastery demanding treasure. In response, a single look from Benedict caused the ropes to unwind more quickly than human hands could untie them. At his last meeting with his sister Saint Scholastica, her tearful prayer brought down a sudden storm from a clear sky. As a result, their holy conversation about heaven could continue all night. This shows that in God's sight, greater love has greater power.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Chapters XXX–XXXVIII: Raising the Dead, Last Colloquy with Saint Scholastica, the Cosmic Vision, the Rule, and Holy Death” Summary of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-life-of-saint-benedict-dialogues-book-ii/chapters/4#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The final chapters (XXX–XXXVIII) crown Pope Gregory's portrait of Saint Benedict with his greatest miracles of charity, his last earthly meeting with his sister Saint Scholastica, his mystical vision of the whole creation in God's light, his Rule for Monks, and his holy death standing in prayer. After curing a monk possessed by a demon with a single tap and loosing a bound peasant by a single glance before the cruel Goth Zalla, Benedict restored a grieving farmer's dead child to life. He did this by praying prostrate over the boy's body like Elijah and Elisha. In Chapter XXXIII, during his annual spiritual visit with his sister Scholastica near Monte Cassino, Benedict refused to stay past nightfall. This is because his monastic rule forbade sleeping outside the abbey. Scholastica bowed her head in tearful prayer, and a sudden thunderstorm made it impossible for Benedict to leave. As Gregory observes, this proves that because 'God is charity', she who loved more prevailed. Three days later, Benedict saw Scholastica's soul ascend to heaven as a white dove. Benedict stood at a tower window by night before matins while Deacon Servandus slept below. Then he beheld the whole world gathered together under a single ray of sunlight. In addition, he saw angels bearing the soul of Bishop Germanus of Capua to heaven in a globe of fire. Having written his Rule for Monks (famous for its discretion and clarity) Benedict foretold his death. Had his grave opened six days in advance. He also received the Body and Blood of the Lord in the oratory. In addition, he breathed his last standing upright with his hands lifted toward heaven in prayer. At the same time, two monks saw a carpet-strewn path of lamps stretching from his cell into the eastern sky.

In Chapters XXX–XXXII, Benedict healed a possessed monk whom Bishop Constantius of Aquino's clerics could not free. In addition, he loosed with a single glance the cords binding a peasant tortured by the greedy Goth Zalla and brought Zalla to repentance. Moreover, he raised a farmer's dead child to life at the monastery gate after praying prostrate over the boy. Chapter XXXI introduces the miracle by which a single look from Benedict loosed the cords binding an innocent peasant tormented by the Goth Zalla. In Chapters XXXIII–XXXIV, Benedict refused his sister Saint Scholastica's plea to remain through the night speaking of the joys of heaven. This is because he would not sleep outside his monastery. In response, Scholastica prayed in tears and a sudden storm forced him to stay. Pope Gregory concludes that she could do more. This is because she loved more, and three days later Benedict saw her soul ascend to heaven in the form of a dove.

In Chapter XXXIV, the morning after their night-long spiritual colloquy, Scholastica returned to her convent and Benedict to his abbey, three days before he saw her soul rise to heaven like a dove. In Chapters XXXV–XXXVIII, Benedict prayed at a tower window before matins with Abbot Servandus nearby. Then he saw the whole world gathered under a single ray of light and the soul of Bishop Germanus of Capua carried to heaven in a fiery globe. Gregory praises Benedict's Rule for Monks as a mirror of his life, recounts how Benedict died standing in prayer after receiving the Body and Blood of Christ. At the same time, a shining road of lamps reached from his cell to heaven. He also records post-mortem miracles at his tomb and the Subiaco cave. In Chapter XXXV, Deacon Peter asks Pope Gregory how the entire world could be seen by Benedict gathered under a single ray of the sun. Gregory shows that to a soul enlarged by seeing the Creator, all creation appears small. Benedict wrote a Rule for Monks renowned for its discretion and luminous style. Died standing in the oratory supported by his disciples, fortified with the Body and Blood of Christ and praying with his hands raised to heaven.

The story inside

Once a year, Benedict's sister Scholastica (consecrated to God from childhood) came to a house near the foot of Monte Cassino to speak with her brother about the things of God. On what proved to be their final earthly meeting, they spent the day praising God and conversing on spiritual matters until evening fell and they shared supper. As night grew late, Scholastica begged him: 'Brother, do not leave me, I pray you, this night; let us speak until morning of the joys of heaven.' Shocked, Benedict replied: 'Sister, what do you say? I cannot on any account remain out of my monastery.' The sky overhead was completely clear without a single cloud. Scholastica heard her brother's refusal. Then she folded her hands on the table, and bowed her head upon them. In addition, she wept in silent prayer to the Lord. The very moment she lifted her head, such violent thunder, lightning, and torrential rain burst forth that neither Benedict nor his monks could set a foot outside the door. 'May God forgive you, sister!' Benedict cried. 'What have you done?' Scholastica answered simply: 'I asked a favor of you, and you refused me; I asked it of my Lord, and He has granted it.' They spent the whole night in sacred conversation. Three days later Benedict saw her soul rise to heaven like a dove. As Pope Gregory remarks, we should not wonder that her prayer prevailed over her brother's will: since in 1 John 4:16 'God is charity', by a very just judgment she who loved more was able to do more. When charity and a routine custom come into conflict without sin, the deeper love of God prevails in God's sight.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    The cruel Goth Zalla brought a peasant bound with tight cords to the monastery demanding treasure. In response, a single look from Benedict caused the ropes to unwind more quickly than human hands could untie them.

  2. 2

    At his last meeting with his sister Saint Scholastica, her tearful prayer brought down a sudden storm from a clear sky. As a result, their holy conversation about heaven could continue all night. This shows that in God's sight, greater love has greater power.

  3. 3

    By night in the abbey tower, Benedict saw the whole created world gathered into a single ray of light. Moreover, he beheld the soul of Germanus, Bishop of Capua, carried to heaven by angels in a fiery sphere.

  4. 4

    Benedict wrote a Rule for Monks renowned for its discretion and luminous style. Died standing in the oratory supported by his disciples, fortified with the Body and Blood of Christ and praying with his hands raised to heaven.

Test your recall

Why did Pope Gregory the Great say that Saint Scholastica's prayer prevailed over Saint Benedict's desire to return to his monastery?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 4169–4172
    “It shall now be seen, from the fact I am going to relate, how great a miracle the saint obtained of God through the merits of his prayers.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 4261–4265
    “It is evident, dear Pater, that on this occasion he had no power of his own to work the miracle, since, prostrating himself, he prayed to God to accord him this favor.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 4315–4319
    “He had a sister named Scholastica, who was, from her infancy, consecrated to the service of God, and was accustomed to come to see him once a year to Monte Cassino.”

Location: section 4 of 4 · 100%

Display settings