Section I · Location 1 of 4
Section 1 · Open to readFrom The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great
Edition: The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880)
Introduction and Chapters I–VI: Youth at Rome, Solitude at Subiaco, the Broken Poisoned Cup, and Twelve Monasteries
The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) · Chapter 1 summary
Pope Gregory grounds his biography of Saint Benedict on the direct testimony of four of Benedict's own disciples: Constantine, Valentinian, Simplicius, and Honoratus. Benedict flees the moral corruption of the Roman schools while still a youth. Then he withdrew to a cave at Subiaco for three years of hidden prayer and penance.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues) by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Introduction and Chapters I–VI: Youth at Rome, Solitude at Subiaco, the Broken Poisoned Cup, and Twelve Monasteries” Summary of The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), by Pope Saint Gregory I the Great. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-life-of-saint-benedict-dialogues-book-ii/chapters/1#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In the Second Book of his Dialogues, Pope Saint Gregory the Great recounts the life and miracles of Saint Benedict of Nursia (c. 480–547). Specifically, this cites four of Benedict's own disciples as eyewitness authorities. These include Constantine (who succeeded him as abbot), Valentinian, Simplicius, and Honoratus. Born of noble parents at Nursia and sent to Rome for liberal studies, young Benedict saw his fellow students swept away by vice and withdrew from the world. In doing so, he chose to be 'knowingly ignorant and wisely unlearned.' He mended his nurse Cyrilla's broken earthenware sieve by prayer at Enfide. Then he lived for three years hidden in a narrow cave at Subiaco. There he was fed by the monk Romanus and visited on Easter Day by a priest sent by Christ. He overcame a fierce temptation of the flesh by rolling in nettles and briars. Then he shattered a poisoned cup of wine with the sign of the Cross when unruly monks at Vicovaro tried to kill him. He also founded twelve monasteries of twelve monks each at Subiaco. He also cured a distracted monk of wandering during prayer. He also brought forth water from a dry cliff. In addition, he raised a Goth's lost iron billhook from the bottom of the lake.
In the Introduction and Chapters I–II, Pope Gregory the Great names his four eyewitness sources (Constantine, Valentinian, Simplicius, and Honoratus). He also recounts how Benedict left his studies in Rome to preserve his soul. He also healed his nurse's broken sieve at Enfide. In addition, he lived for three years in the cave of Subiaco aided by the monk Romanus. Moreover, he conquered a violent carnal temptation by rolling naked in thorns and nettles. In Chapter I, Benedict's nurse Cyrilla borrowed an earthenware sieve that broke in two on a table. Benedict's tearful prayer made it whole. In Chapter III, the monks of a nearby monastery begged Benedict to be their abbot and then plotted to poison his wine. This is because he forbade their disorders. In response, Benedict made the sign of the Cross over the glass pitcher and it shattered to pieces. Forgiving them, he calmly reminded them that he had foretold their incompatibility and returned to Subiaco. In doing so, this showed his deacon Peter why even a shepherd must leave an incurably rebellious flock.
In Chapter III, the poisoned cup shatters at his sign of the Cross. In response, Benedict calmly asks the murderous monks why they did not listen when he warned them that their ways and his would not agree. In Chapters IV–VI, Benedict established twelve monasteries of twelve monks each at Subiaco. He also received the noble Roman boys Maurus and Placidus from their fathers Equitius and Tertullus. He also freed an unsteady monk who wandered during prayer. In addition, he brought forth a lasting spring of water on a dry mountain peak to spare three monasteries a dangerous climb. Moreover, he caused a Goth novice's lost iron billhook to rise from the bottom of the lake and reattach to its handle. In Chapter IV, Benedict teaches the abbot Pompeianus and Maurus how to discern the demon who was pulling an unsteady monk out of prayer. At Subiaco, Benedict organized twelve monasteries, and healed a monk whom a devil kept drawing out of the oratory during prayer. In addition, he called forth spring water on a dry mountain rock. Miraculously restored a Goth's iron tool from the deep lake.
The story inside
When the abbot of a neighboring monastery died, the monks begged Benedict to become their superior. Benedict refused at first, warning them frankly that his strict monastic discipline and their lax habits would never agree. Overcome by their pleas, he finally consented. Immediately afterward, the monks grew so angry at his efforts to reform their daily life that they mixed poison into his wine. The glass pitcher was presented to him at table for the customary blessing. In response, Benedict raised his hand and made the sign of the Cross: instantly, the vessel shattered into pieces as if struck by a heavy stone. Benedict understood at once that it held the drink of death. Then he rose with a serene face, gathered the brothers, and said: 'May God forgive you, brethren. Why have you resolved to treat me thus? Did I not tell you at first that my manner of life and yours would not agree? Go, seek a superior with whom you may be able to live in peace.' He then returned quietly to his beloved solitude at Subiaco. True spiritual strength meets betrayal without bitterness, forgiving the wrongdoer while refusing to compromise God's truth.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Pope Gregory grounds his biography of Saint Benedict on the direct testimony of four of Benedict's own disciples: Constantine, Valentinian, Simplicius, and Honoratus.
- 2
Benedict flees the moral corruption of the Roman schools while still a youth. Then he withdrew to a cave at Subiaco for three years of hidden prayer and penance.
- 3
Rebellious monks tried to poison him because his strict rule rebuked their loose lives. In response, Benedict blessed the cup with the sign of the Cross and it shattered as if struck by a stone. Immediately afterward, he calmly returned to his solitude.
- 4
At Subiaco, Benedict organized twelve monasteries, and healed a monk whom a devil kept drawing out of the oratory during prayer. In addition, he called forth spring water on a dry mountain rock. Miraculously restored a Goth's iron tool from the deep lake.
Test your recall
Who were the four disciples of Saint Benedict from whom Pope Gregory the Great learned the events of Benedict's life?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom The Life of Saint Benedict, Patriarch of the Western Monks (Second Book of the Dialogues), trans. P. W. [1608] (1880). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 626–628
“After the meal a short discourse followed, which being ended, the priest returned to his church.”
- 2.Lines 800–804
“Peter. What thou sayest pleases me greatly, but having explained this passage of Scripture, 1 beseech thee to proceed with the life of this holy man.”
- 3.Lines 1119–1124
“Peter. I am delighted with what you say, but I beseech you to solve still another difficulty. Ought this holy man to have abandoned thus those monks whose guidance he had undertaken?”
