Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II

Section 4 · Saint Teresa of Ávila

Section IV · Location 4 of 4

Section 4 · Open to read

From The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II by Saint Teresa of Ávila

Edition: The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II, trans. Benedictines of Stanbrook (with notes by Monsignor Benedict Zimmerman, O.C.D.) (1921)

Return to Ávila, the Death of Nuncio Ormaneto, and the Storm Over the Reform (Letters 178–206, June–December 1577)

The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II · Chapter 4 summary

Nuncio Ormaneto dies on June 18, 1577. In response, Teresa appeals directly to King Philip II to defend Father Gracián and the honour of the Discalced convents against slander. She completes the transfer of St. Joseph's in Ávila from episcopal obedience to the Order of Mount Carmel with Bishop Álvaro de Mendoza's consent.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II by Saint Teresa of Ávila. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Return to Ávila, the Death of Nuncio Ormaneto, and the Storm Over the Reform (Letters 178–206, June–December 1577)” Summary of The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II, by Saint Teresa of Ávila. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/letters-of-saint-teresa-vol-2/chapters/4#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In June 1577, just as the papal nuncio Nicholas Ormaneto dies in Madrid and leaves the Discalced Carmelites exposed to their fiercest adversaries, Teresa leaves Toledo and returns to Ávila. There she transfers St. Joseph's Convent from the jurisdiction of the bishop to the Carmelite Order, rallies King Philip II's intervention against defamatory reports written by Father Miguel de la Columna and Father Baltasar Nieto. Moreover, she endures the tumultuous prioress election at the Incarnation Convent—where fifty-five nuns who voted for her are excommunicated by the Calced provincial Tostado and St. John of the Cross is seized and imprisoned in December 1577. Through every blow, Teresa writes to King Philip II, Bishop Álvaro de Mendoza, and Mary of St. Joseph with unshaken courage.

In Letter 189 (September 18, 1577) to King Philip II, Teresa defended Father Jerome Gracián and the Discalced nuns against defamatory memorials circulated by Father Miguel de la Columna. In doing so, she urged the king to protect the reform. Teresa reflects on governance and community peace in her summer 1577 correspondence from Ávila. In Letters 193–206 (October–December 1577), Teresa recounts how fifty-five nuns of the Incarnation Convent in Ávila were excommunicated for electing her prioress. Moreover, she appeals again to King Philip II after Calced friars kidnapped and imprisoned St. John of the Cross on December 3, 1577.

Teresa weighs the disposition of officials and religious superiors amid the growing storm following Nuncio Ormaneto's death. The Vicar General Tostado excommunicates fifty-five nuns at the Incarnation for voting for Teresa as prioress. In response, she begs that the nuns be absolved even if she never sets foot there as superior. Teresa greets Mother Mary of St. Joseph affectionately while guiding the Seville community through financial and ecclesiastical trials. St. John of the Cross and Father Germán are seized at the point of the sword in December 1577. In response, Teresa writes to King Philip II warning that the prisoners' lives are in danger.

The story inside

In October 1577, the Provincial of the Calced Carmelites came to the Convent of the Incarnation in Ávila determined to block the nuns from re-electing Teresa as prioress. Despite threats of excommunication, fifty-five nuns courageously cast their written ballots for Teresa. As each ballot was read aloud, the Provincial cursed the nuns, struck their voting papers with his fist, burned the ballots, and locked the fifty-five sisters inside the house under excommunication. On the night of December 3, armed men burst into the chaplains' cottage at the Incarnation, seized St. John of the Cross and Father Germán, beat them. Moreover, he carried them away into secret captivity. The very next day, Teresa wrote directly to King Philip II. In doing so, she declared she would rather see the friars among the Moors than in such hands. In addition, she begged royal justice to save John's life. True charity never abandons innocent friends when power abuses its authority.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Nuncio Ormaneto dies on June 18, 1577. In response, Teresa appeals directly to King Philip II to defend Father Gracián and the honour of the Discalced convents against slander.

  2. 2

    She completes the transfer of St. Joseph's in Ávila from episcopal obedience to the Order of Mount Carmel with Bishop Álvaro de Mendoza's consent.

  3. 3

    The Vicar General Tostado excommunicates fifty-five nuns at the Incarnation for voting for Teresa as prioress. In response, she begs that the nuns be absolved even if she never sets foot there as superior.

  4. 4

    St. John of the Cross and Father Germán are seized at the point of the sword in December 1577. In response, Teresa writes to King Philip II warning that the prisoners' lives are in danger.

Test your recall

Why did Teresa write directly to King Philip II in September and December 1577?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From The Letters of Saint Teresa, Volume II, trans. Benedictines of Stanbrook (with notes by Monsignor Benedict Zimmerman, O.C.D.) (1921). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 10969–10972
    “I think this illness will be good for me, as people will become accustomed to my using a secretary. I might have done so before in unimport ant matters and shall continue to use one.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 12026–12027
    “You will see what can be managed for it would not be right that they should give no portion.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 12976–12979
    “They tell me that, though the nuncio is dead, our Father's commission has not expired but he is still Visitor, for which in one way, I am exceed ingly sorry.”

Location: section 4 of 4 · 100%

Display settings