Section II · Location 2 of 3
Section 2 · Open to readFrom Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi
Edition: Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914)
Part II (Chapters I–VI): Blessed Agnes of Prague, the Primitive Rule, the Ugolino Rule, and the Privileges of Exemption and Sublime Poverty
Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) · Chapter 2 summary
In Part II, Chapters I–VI (lines 5831–10054), Ernest Gilliat-Smith traces Blessed Agnes of Prague's struggle with Pope Gregory IX over corporate poverty (culminating in her April 1238 Privilege of Poverty and his May 1238 bull 'Angelis gaudium') reconstructs Saint Francis's Primitive Rule for San Damiano. It also examines the making, harshness, and 1239/1245 recensions of Cardinal Ugolino's Benedictine-based Rule (alongside the July 1219 'Litterae tuae' exemptions for Monticelli)(Florence), Perugia, Siena, and Lucca.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Part II (Chapters I–VI): Blessed Agnes of Prague, the Primitive Rule, the Ugolino Rule, and the Privileges of Exemption and Sublime Poverty” Summary of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli), by Saint Agnes of Assisi. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/letter-to-saint-clare/chapters/2#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Part II, Chapter I, Gilliat-Smith chronicles the long contest between King Ottokar I's daughter, Blessed Agnes of Prague. Pope Gregory IX. Having entered the Poor Clare convent of Saint Saviour in Prague (Agnes surrendered the hospital endowments that Gregory IX had attached to her house and petitioned for the same absolute corporate poverty practiced by Saint Clare at San Damiano). In April 1238 Gregory IX finally granted Agnes a formal Privilege of Poverty (Pragenses), yet a month later (on 9 May 1238) (in the bull Angelis gaudium) (he refused her request to substitute Saint Francis's Formula Vitae for the Constitutions of Ostia). Above all, Cardinal Ugolino's Rule had been approved by Saint Francis and observed by Clare herself.
In Chapters II–IV, Gilliat-Smith reconstructs the lost Primitive Rule (Formula Vitae) that Saint Francis gave Clare in 1212 (consisting of the Gospel counsel of absolute poverty together with brief observances for fasting and divine praise)and explains how Cardinal Ugolino drafted his strict legal Constitutions in 1218–1219 while Francis (was away in the East). Basing his legislation formally on the Rule of Saint Benedict so the new sisterhood (would conform to the Fourth Lateran Council's ban on new religious rules)(Ugolino imposed perpetual enclosure), continuous silence (and severe Year-round fasting that moved Brother Philip of Perugia and Saint Francis himself (to weep over its harshness until Francis obtained mitigations)).
In Chapter V ('How Some Poor Ladies Were Mulcted in a Pound of Gold'), Gilliat-Smith examines Cardinal Ugolino's four July 1219 bulls (Litterae tuae) taking the convents of Monticelli near Florence (where Saint Agnes of Assisi was sent as abbess), Perugia, Siena (and Lucca directly under papal protection in exchange for an annual tribute (of a pound of gold—later commuted to a pound of wax)). Unlike San Damiano, these four Ugolino foundations were permitted to hold modest landed estates. Only Perugia later received a Privilege of Poverty on 18 June 1229 (and Gilliat-Smith refutes Wadding's and Lempp's unverified claim that Agnes of Assisi's convent at Monticelli received one on 1 May 1230). Chapter VI closes the section by comparing side by side the two official papal (recensions of Ugolino's Rule: Gregory IX's May 1239 text addressed to the convent of Ascoli Piceno and Innocent IV's 1245 universal bull Solet annuere).
The story inside
In July 1219. Meanwhile, Saint Francis was preaching in the East, Cardinal Ugolino issued four identical papal charters (Litterae tuae) placing the Poor Ladies of Monticelli near Florence, Perugia, Siena (and Lucca under the immediate protection of the Holy See) (exempting them from diocesan bishops) (and requiring each house to pay the Roman treasury one pound of gold (every year—a sum possible only because Ugolino's Constitutions allowed those convents to hold landed endowments)). When Saint Francis returned and saw how Ugolino's Benedictine-modeled code bound the sisters (both to property and to crushing fasts)(he stood firm with Saint Clare to keep San Damiano free from endowments (and later arranged for the gold tribute of the other houses to be commuted to a symbolic pound of wax)).
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
After Blessed Agnes of Prague surrendered her hospital revenues (Gregory IX granted her a Privilege of Poverty in April 1238 but issued 'Angelis gaudium' on 9 May 1238 refusing to replace Ugolino's Rule with Francis's 'Formula Vitae').
- 2
Drafted in 1218–1219 on the legal basis of the Rule of Saint Benedict (Ugolino's Constitutions imposed perpetual enclosure and austere fasts) (preserved in Gregory IX's 1239 Ascoli Piceno text and Innocent IV's 1245 'Solet annuere').
- 3
Ugolino's July 1219 'Litterae tuae' exempted the landed convents of Monticelli (Florence), Perugia, Siena, and Lucca for an annual tribute of one pound of gold (commuted to wax). Perugia received a Privilege of Poverty in June 1229. By contrast, Monticelli had no verified 1230 privilege.
Test your recall
How did Pope Gregory IX respond to Blessed Agnes of Prague in April and May 1238, why did Cardinal Ugolino base his 1219 Constitutions on the Rule of Saint Benedict, and what did Ugolino's July 1219 'Litterae tuae' prescribe for Monticelli, Perugia, Siena, and Lucca?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 5848–5850
“Cardinal Ugolino, with the assistance of Saint Francis, somewhere about the year 1218 and, I think, from notes which Saint Clare herself had supplied.”
- 2.Lines 7251–7253
“let them not therefore be sad, because then are we monks indeed, when we live by the labour of our hands, even as our fathers did and the apostles before them."”
- 3.Lines 8658–8660
“We must not, then, expect to find in the convents exempted in virtue of Honorius's brief the strict observance prescribed in the rule of the Friars Minor, but the milder form of observance of”
