Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli)
Complete 3-chapter primary-source distillation of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) (1914 Ernest Gilliat-Smith edition).
- Who wrote it
- Written by this author
- Date
- c. 1220
- Edition
- Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914) · Public domain
Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) · Book summary
Book overview
In Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (1914) (Ernest Gilliat-Smith critiques late sixteenth- and seventeenth-century legends to reconstruct from contemporary thirteenth-century records the lives of Saint Clare and her younger sister Saint Agnes of Assisi and their forty-year constitutional struggle for the Privilege of Poverty). In Chapter 1 (Part I, Chapters I–X), contemporary witnesses (Celano, Alexander IV, Ugolino, and Niccolò di Carbio) establish that Clare renounced the world on Palm Sunday night in 1211 (took sanctuary at San Paolo at Bastia and Sant'Angelo di Panzo with Bishop Guido's support), was joined by her younger sister Agnes (who withstood Uncle Monaldo's armed assault)and navigated the Franciscan Rule crisis down to her death on 11 August 1253 (with Agnes beside her bed). In Chapter 2 (Part II, Chapters I–VI). It also traces the rules observed by the Poor Ladies and the correspondence with Blessed Agnes of Prague (Gilliat-Smith shows how Francis gave San Damiano a brief Formula Vitae) (how Cardinal Ugolino imposed his Benedictine-based constitutions), and how only San Damiano and Perugia (June 1229) held the Privilegium Paupertatis under Gregory IX while houses such as Monticelli, Faenza, Milan (and Prague accepted landed endowments or alms indulgences until Agnes of Prague won (her own Privilege of Poverty in 1238)). In Chapter 3 (Part II, Chapters VII–XIII and Appendix) (after protesting Gregory IX's 1230 bull Quo elongati by dismissing the bread-questing friars (when the preaching friars were withdrawn and rejecting the property clauses of Innocent IV's 1247 Rule)) (Clare incorporates Francis's Formula Vitae and Last Will into Chapter VI of her own Twelve-Chapter Rule) (receives Innocent IV's bull Solet annuere on 9 August 1253 just two days before (her death on 11 August 1253)), and leaves the original Privilegium Paupertatis (17 September 1228) and the Solet annuere parchment kissed repeatedly by her own lips.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli): book overview” Summary of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli), by Saint Agnes of Assisi. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/letter-to-saint-clare#atlas-answer
Section guide
Choose a section.
- 01
Part I (Chapters I–X): The Life of Saint Clare, Her Sister Saint Agnes of Assisi, the Flight to Sant'Angelo di Panzo, and the Early Franciscans
Part I (Chapters I–X) critiques late Wadding legends to establish Clare's true chronology (Palm Sunday 1211 to 11 August 1253). It also situates her and Agnes's flight to San Paolo and Sant'Angelo di Panzo within thirteenth-century religious movements. It also traces Clare's role through the Franciscan Rule crisis to her death.
- 02
Part II (Chapters I–VI): Blessed Agnes of Prague, the Primitive Rule, the Ugolino Rule, and the Privileges of Exemption and Sublime Poverty
In Part II, Chapters I–VI (lines 5831–10054), Ernest Gilliat-Smith traces Blessed Agnes of Prague's struggle with Pope Gregory IX over corporate poverty (culminating in her April 1238 Privilege of Poverty and his May 1238 bull 'Angelis gaudium') reconstructs Saint Francis's Primitive Rule for San Damiano. It also examines the making, harshness, and 1239/1245 recensions of Cardinal Ugolino's Benedictine-based Rule (alongside the July 1219 'Litterae tuae' exemptions for Monticelli)(Florence), Perugia, Siena, and Lucca.
- 03
Part II (Chapters VII–XIII) and Appendix: The Friars and the Poor Ladies, the Rule of Innocent IV, the Rule of Saint Clare, and Parallel Latin Rule Texts
In Part II, Chapters VII–XIII and the Latin Appendix (lines 10055–15933), Ernest Gilliat-Smith traces the Poor Ladies' constitutional struggle from Pope Gregory IX's bull *Quo elongati* (28 September 1230) (when Clare dismissed the alms-questing friars after the preaching friars were withdrawn) through Innocent IV's 1247 Rule (*Cum omnis vera religio*)to Clare's own Twelve-Chapter Rule approved by Innocent IV's bull *Solet annuere* on 9 (August 1253 just two days before her death on 11 August 1253). It concludes with critical analyses of the *Privilegium Paupertatis* and the *Solet annuere* parchment (alongside the complete Latin text of the *Regula Sanctae Clarae*).
Whole-book summary
Across Parts I and II and the Latin Appendix of Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (Ernest Gilliat-Smith separates contemporary thirteenth-century documents from later Franciscan legend to trace one coherent institutional and spiritual struggle). *Contemporary Biography and the Sisterhood of Clare and Agnes (Chapter 1). Grounded in Thomas of Celano, Pope Alexander IV's canonization bulls. Bishop Guido's patronage (the historical record shows Clare and her younger sister Agnes of Assisi forsaking noble rank in 1211–1212), enduring family violence at Sant'Angelo di Panzo (and establishing San Damiano as the motherhouse of the Poor Ladies until Clare's death in 1253 and Agnes's death shortly thereafter). Ugolino's Constitutions and the Rare Privilege of Poverty (Chapter 2). Whereas later chroniclers imagined that every Damianite monastery observed absolute corporate poverty (from the start, papal bulls prove that Cardinal Ugolino's Benedictine-based Rule was designed for endowed convents)(such as Monticelli, Faenza, Milan, and initially Prague). Meanwhile, only San Damiano, Perugia (1229). Finally Agnes of Prague (1238) secured papal exemptions forbidding common possessions. From 'Quo Elongati' to 'Solet Annuere' and the 1253 Rule (Chapter 3). Defending her sisters' bond with the Friars Minor after Gregory IX's Quo elongati (1230) and refusing Innocent IV's 1247 property concessions, Clare drafts her own Twelve-Chapter Rule (combining Francis's Formula Vitae and Last Will with the 1223 Regula Fratrum Minorum and non-property clauses of 1247) and obtains Innocent IV's personal autograph confirmation (Ad instar fiat S.) on Solet annuere* on 9 August 1253.
Edition and source notes
- Saint Clare of Assisi, Saint Agnes of Assisi, and Ernest Gilliat-Smith, *Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation* (London and Toronto: J. M. Dent & Sons, 1914), Parts I–II and Latin Appendix.
