Section I · Location 1 of 3
Section 1 · Open to readFrom Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi
Edition: Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914)
Part I (Chapters I–X): The Life of Saint Clare, Her Sister Saint Agnes of Assisi, the Flight to Sant'Angelo di Panzo, and the Early Franciscans
Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) · Chapter 1 summary
Part I (Chapters I–X) critiques late Wadding legends to establish Clare's true chronology (Palm Sunday 1211 to 11 August 1253). It also situates her and Agnes's flight to San Paolo and Sant'Angelo di Panzo within thirteenth-century religious movements. It also traces Clare's role through the Franciscan Rule crisis to her death.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Part I (Chapters I–X): The Life of Saint Clare, Her Sister Saint Agnes of Assisi, the Flight to Sant'Angelo di Panzo, and the Early Franciscans” Summary of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli), by Saint Agnes of Assisi. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/letter-to-saint-clare/chapters/1#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Examining the earliest thirteenth-century witnesses to the life of Saint Clare and her younger (sister Saint Agnes of Assisi)(Thomas of Celano (Pope Alexander IV's canonization bull), and Cardinal Ugolino) Chapters I and II strip away the sixteenth- and seventeenth-century fabrications of Peter Rodolfi and Luke Wadding. Those late writers invented the family surname 'Offreduccio', the father's name 'Favorino', and castle (fiefs unknown to contemporary records, which name only Clare's devout mother Ortolana)(who made pilgrimages to Jerusalem (Sant'Angelo on Monte Gargano), and Rome) (her violent uncle Monaldo) (and her younger sister Agnes). From Bishop Niccolò di Carbio's biography of Pope Innocent IV and Alexander IV's bull (Chapter II establishes that Clare was born about 1193), fled the world on Palm Sunday night in 1211 (not 1212) (entered San Damiano in the summer or autumn of 1211 after forty-two years (of monastic life before her death on 11 August 1253)). Chapter III surveys the twelfth- and thirteenth-century lay and monastic movements (the Hospitalers of St. Anthony, Crutched Friars, Robert d'Arbrissel's Fontevrault, Norbert's White Canons, the Beguines, and the Lombard Umiliati) that shaped the religious world of central Italy.
Chapters IV–VI compare Celano's dramatic narrative of Clare's profession with the more sober (canonical account in Pope Alexander IV's bull). This shows that Francis and Clare acted in concert with Bishop Guido of Assisi (when Clare sold her inheritance for the poor)(received the tonsure at the Portiuncula on Palm Sunday night 1211) (and took sanctuary with the wealthy Benedictine nuns of San Paolo at Bastia (under Papal privilege before moving to the semi-monastic women's house of Sant'Angelo di Panzo)). Shortly after Clare reached Sant'Angelo, her younger sister Agnes fled home to join her. When Uncle Monaldo and armed retainers beat Agnes and dragged her by the hair down Mount Subasio (Clare's tearful prayer left Agnes's body immovable on the hillside and paralyzed Monaldo's uplifted arm). Afterward, Francis shore Agnes's hair and settled both sisters at San Damiano.
Chapters VII–X trace how the struggle inside the Franciscan Order after 1219 shaped Clare's community down to her death. While Francis was in the East in 1219 (his vicars Brother Matthew of Narni and Brother Gregory of Naples tightened fasts for the friars and obtained from Cardinal Ugolino a strict Benedictine observance for the women's houses) (prompting Brother Stephen to hurry overseas and bring Francis back with Peter Catani and Brother Elias of Cortona). Through the stormy chapters over the 1223 Rule, Brother Leo's whipping after breaking the marble alms-bowl at Assisi (the generalates of John Parenti and Brother Elias) (and the return of the zealots under John of Parma) (Clare remained a loyal friend both to Leo's Spirituals and to Brother Elias). Part I closes in Chapter X by defending the historicity of Clare's repulse (of Frederick II's Saracen archers at San Damiano with the Blessed Sacrament)(refuting the late fifteenth-century legend of Clare's meal with Francis at the Portiuncula) (and recounting Pope Innocent IV's deathbed visit and absolution before Clare died on 11 (August 1253 with her sister Agnes at her side)).
The story inside
Shortly after Clare moved from the Benedictine abbey of San Paolo at Bastia (to the women's community of Sant'Angelo di Panzo in the spring of 1211)(her younger sister Agnes escaped from Assisi to share her life of penance). Their uncle Monaldo rode up Mount Subasio with armed retainers, seized Agnes by the hair (and beat her as they dragged her away). At Clare's prayer (Agnes's body grew too heavy for the soldiers to lift and a sudden pain struck Monaldo's raised arm). Francis then cut Agnes's hair and soon settled both sisters at San Damiano.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Contemporary thirteenth-century witnesses know Clare's mother Ortolana, uncle Monaldo, and sister Agnes. By contrast, 'Offreduccio' and 'Favorino' are late 16th/17th-century inventions. Clare professed on Palm Sunday 1211.
- 2
After taking sanctuary at San Paolo at Bastia and moving to Sant'Angelo di Panzo with Bishop Guido's support (Clare was joined by Agnes) (who withstood Uncle Monaldo's armed assault before both settled at San Damiano).
- 3
Chapters VII–X trace the Franciscan Rule crisis from Francis's return from the East (through Peter Catani, Brother Elias, John Parenti)(and John of Parma). It concludes with the Saracen siege and Clare's death on 11 August 1253.
Test your recall
Why do contemporary sources place Clare's Palm Sunday flight in 1211 rather than 1212, what happened when Agnes joined her at Sant'Angelo di Panzo, and how did Clare navigate the conflict between Brother Elias and the Spirituals?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 463–464
“Pietro Rodolfi of Tossignano. Concerning the fables of Wadding and of his disciples ancient and modern.”
- 2.Lines 2256–2258
“unwonted worship." Which, I suppose, is Celano's poetical way of saying that in moments of excitement Saint Francis always spoke the language which he had first learnt : his mother, accord-”
- 3.Lines 4051–4053
“sub beato Francisco bonae memoriae incipit et mirabiliter profecit . . . dignum providimus et conveniens ut pro ipsius patris reverentia specialis aedificetur ecclesia in qua ejus corpus debeat”
