Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli)

Section 3 · Saint Agnes of Assisi

Section III · Location 3 of 3

Section 3 · Open to read

From Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi

Edition: Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914)

Part II (Chapters VII–XIII) and Appendix: The Friars and the Poor Ladies, the Rule of Innocent IV, the Rule of Saint Clare, and Parallel Latin Rule Texts

Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) · Chapter 3 summary

In Part II, Chapters VII–XIII and the Latin Appendix (lines 10055–15933), Ernest Gilliat-Smith traces the Poor Ladies' constitutional struggle from Pope Gregory IX's bull Quo elongati (28 September 1230) (when Clare dismissed the alms-questing friars after the preaching friars were withdrawn) through Innocent IV's 1247 Rule (Cum omnis vera religio)to Clare's own Twelve-Chapter Rule approved by Innocent IV's bull Solet annuere on 9 (August 1253 just two days before her death on 11 August 1253). It concludes with critical analyses of the Privilegium Paupertatis and the Solet annuere parchment (alongside the complete Latin text of the Regula Sanctae Clarae).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli) by Saint Agnes of Assisi. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Part II (Chapters VII–XIII) and Appendix: The Friars and the Poor Ladies, the Rule of Innocent IV, the Rule of Saint Clare, and Parallel Latin Rule Texts” Summary of Letter to Saint Clare of Assisi (from Monticelli), by Saint Agnes of Assisi. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/letter-to-saint-clare/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In Part II, Chapters VII–IX (lines 10055–11421), Gilliat-Smith examines the crisis triggered by Pope Gregory IX's bull Quo elongati (28 September 1230) (which declared that the friars were not bound by St). Francis's Testament and restricted the Friars Minor from visiting convents of the Poor Ladies without special papal license (replacing Cardinal Rainaldo's general Visitor Brother Philip of Atri). Outraged that her sisters were being deprived of the preaching friars who nourished (their souls with the Word of God)(Clare immediately sent away the questing lay-brothers who begged bread for San Damiano). Moreover, if she could not have the friars who gave them spiritual bread (she would not keep those who brought bodily bread—a protest that moved Gregory IX to restore the friars' ministry at San Damiano). When Pope Innocent IV subsequently issued his new Rule in 1247 (Cum omnis vera religio) authorizing convents to hold common property and income (Clare firmly rejected its property clauses).

In Chapters X–XI (lines 11422–12705), Clare composes her own Twelve-Chapter Rule (Regula Sanctae Clarae), weaving St. Francis's brief Formula Vitae and his final warning on corporate poverty directly into Chapter (VI while adopting constitutional details from the 1223 Regula Bullata of the Friars Minor and non-property clauses of Innocent IV's 1247 Rule). Visiting the dying Abbess at San Damiano in August 1253 (Pope Innocent IV granted her fervent desire and confirmed her Rule by the bull Solet annuere on 9 August 1253). Two days later, on 11 August 1253, Clare died in peace. At her funeral in Assisi Innocent IV wished to celebrate the festive Office (of Holy Virgins instead of the Office of the Dead until Cardinal Rainaldo persuaded him to await formal canonization)(lines 12046–12065).

In Chapters XII–XIII and the Appendix (lines 12706–15933), Gilliat-Smith defends the authenticity of Gregory IX's 17 September 1228 Privilege of Poverty (Sicut manifestum est, Chapter XII) and describes the original parchment of Solet annuere preserved at Assisi (Chapter XIII, lines 13444–13475), bearing Innocent IV's unusual personal autograph 'Ad instar fiat S.' and the contemporary marginal note: 'Hanc beata Clara tetigit et obsculata est pro (devotione pluribus et pluribus vicibus')('Blessed Clare touched and kissed this bull out of devotion many, many times'). The volume concludes with the Latin Appendix (lines 14065–15933) (printing the full Regula Sanctae Clarae with Clare's original passages in italics alongside a parallel column of 'Corresponding Clauses from Earlier Rules' drawn from both Innocent IV's 1247 Rule and the 1223 Regula Fratrum Minorum).

The story inside

When Pope Gregory IX's bull Quo elongati (28 September 1230) forbade the Friars Minor to enter the convents of the Poor Ladies to preach without special papal leave (Saint Clare answered with an unforgettable act of holy boldness). She dismissed the questing lay-brothers who begged daily bread for San Damiano. Moreover (she would not accept the friars who brought bodily bread if her sisters were denied the friars who broke for them the bread of the Word of God). Twenty-three years later, on 9 August 1253, the dying Abbess held in her hands (Pope Innocent IV's original parchment of Solet annuere)(inscribed with the Pope's own autograph 'Ad instar fiat S.') and kissed the charter of absolute poverty again and again before entering eternal life on 11 August 1253.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    In Part II, Chapters VII–IX (lines 10055–11421), after Gregory IX's bull Quo elongati (28 September 1230) restricts the preaching friars and removes Visitor Brother Philip of Atri (Clare dismisses the bread-questing friars until the Pope restores spiritual ministry). Later rejects the property clauses of Innocent IV's 1247 Rule.

  2. 2

    In Chapters X–XI (lines 11422–12705), Clare inserts Francis's Formula Vitae and Last Will into Chapter VI of her Twelve-Chapter Rule (receives Innocent IV's bull Solet annuere on 9 August 1253) (and dies on 11 August 1253) (when Innocent IV proposes celebrating the Office of Holy Virgins at her funeral).

  3. 3

    Chapters XII–XIII and the Appendix (lines 12706–15933) examine the 1228 Privilegium Paupertatis (the original Solet annuere parchment with Innocent IV's autograph 'Ad instar fiat S.' kissed repeatedly by Clare) (and the Latin Regula Sanctae Clarae printed opposite its 1223 and 1247 source clauses).

Test your recall

How did Saint Clare respond when Gregory IX's bull *Quo elongati* (1230) withdrew the preaching friars, what autograph and contemporary note appear on the original 1253 *Solet annuere* parchment in Chapter XIII, and how does the Latin Appendix display the sources of Clare's Rule?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Saint Clare of Assisi: Her Life and Legislation (with the Letters of Saint Agnes of Assisi and Early Poor Clare Documents), trans. Ernest Gilliat-Smith (1914). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 10065–10067
    “that the Order of Friars Minor and what was later on called the Order of Saint Clare were in the beginning linked together by certain well-defined ties.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 12025–12027
    “says, " when Blessed Clare's most holy body, worn out by long sickness, was attacked by a fresh affliction which betokened that Christ would soon take her to the place of perpetual health, that the”
  3. 3.
    Lines 13985–13987
    “Cardinal. The sisters shall not suffer any one to enter the monastery before sunrise or to remain therein after sundown, unless some manifest, reasonable and inevitable cause require it.”

Location: section 3 of 3 · 100%

Display settings