Section VII · Location 7 of 9
Section 7 · Open to readFrom Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo
Edition: The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907)
The Origin of Evil, the Books of the Platonists, and the Humility of Christ the Mediator (Book VII, Chapters I–XXI)
Confessions (Books I–IX) · Chapter 7 summary
The context is set through Nebridius's dilemma, Firminus's birth story, the books of the Platonists, and the writings of St. Paul. In this setting, Augustine overcomes materialist dualism and astrology. Sees that evil is a perversity of will rather than a substance. In addition, he discovers Christ the humble Mediator.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 7 of Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “The Origin of Evil, the Books of the Platonists, and the Humility of Christ the Mediator (Book VII, Chapters I–XXI)” Summary of Confessions (Books I–IX), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/confessions/chapters/7#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
With his shameful youth dead and middle age beginning, Augustine no longer imagined God in the shape of a human body. In doing so, he rejoices to find that the Catholic Church rejected that error too. With all his heart he believed that God is incorruptible, inviolable, and unchangeable. This is because he saw beyond doubt that what cannot be corrupted or changed is better than what can. Yet because he still thought that anything without length, breadth, or spatial bulk was nothing at all (failing even to notice that his own mind forming these images had no spatial measurements) he imagined God as a vast bodily substance stretched out through infinite space and permeating the world like sunlight filling the air. That false fancy meant that a larger portion of earth would hold a larger portion of God. As a result, there would be more of God in an elephant than in a sparrow.
Even so, Augustine already possessed a complete refutation of the Manichees in the dilemma that Nebridius had used long before at Carthage. What could the imaginary people of darkness have done to God if God had refused to fight them? If the Manichees answered that darkness could have hurt God, they made God corruptible and subject to injury. They answered that darkness could not have harmed Him. In that case, there was no reason at all for God to fight and mix up a portion of His own substance (human souls) with hostile powers. As a result, they became enslaved and needed rescue.
Augustine heard that free will is the cause of our sinning and God's just judgment is the cause of our suffering. Even so, he still could not see clearly how a soul made by the wholly good God could choose evil. He refused any Manichean solution that blamed God's nature. Then he held fast to the principle that God is the supreme and best Good, above whom nothing better can ever be conceived. Moreover, its incorruptible will and substance can never be forced or stained.
Trying to picture all creation at once (earth, sea, air, stars, angels, and spiritual beings arranged as if they were bodies) Augustine imagined the universe as one vast finite mass, like a huge sponge floating inside an infinite sea of God that filled and surrounded every part of it. Inside that wholly good creation made by a wholly good God. There could evil come from, and what was its root or seed? Even while this puzzle tormented him, his Catholic faith anchored his heart and kept him from being swept away.
By this time Augustine also abandoned the lying predictions of the astrologers through a story told by his friend Firminus, a well-educated young rhetoric student who came to consult him about his horoscope. Firminus explained that his father and a close friend had studied astrological books together so eagerly that they even recorded the birth-moments of the dumb animals around their houses. When Firminus's mother was expecting him, a female slave belonging to his father's friend was pregnant at the same time. Both masters carefully watched for the day and hour of labor and stationed messengers ready to run between the two houses as soon as each child was born. The two messengers met at the exact midpoint on the road. This proves that both boys were born at the identical instant under the exact same stars down to the smallest fraction of time. Yet Firminus, born in a wealthy family, walked the brighter paths of the world with growing riches and high rank. By contrast, the baby slave continued to serve his masters under the unchanged yoke of slavery. Augustine saw that identical horoscopes accompanied opposite lives. Then he realized that when astrologers predict true events after inspecting different horoscopes, they speak by chance rather than by any real science. He tried to turn Firminus away from that curiosity as well. Foreseeing that astrologers might try to evade this story by claiming Firminus or his father had been mistaken, Augustine also reflected on the universal case of twins (such as Esau and Jacob) who are born so closely together that no human observation can record different constellations. Yet whose lives and characters differ widely.
Augustine was freed from the chains of astrology. Then he groaned in silent anguish over the origin of evil while clinging firmly to his core beliefs. That God exists, that His substance never changes. Moreover, He cares for and judges mankind. Furthermore, He has placed the way of salvation in His Son Christ and in the Holy Scriptures guaranteed by the Catholic Church. Because pride still swelled his face and closed his eyes, crowds of bodily images blocked his mind whenever he tried to think of spiritual things. Eventually, God's secret healing hand humbled his pride with the sharp salve of wholesome grief.
God wished first to show Augustine how God resists the proud and gives grace to the humble through the Word made flesh. Then he procured for him (through a man puffed up with enormous vanity) certain books of the Platonists translated from Greek into Latin. In those books Augustine found, expressed in different words and supported by many arguments, the same truth taught at the beginning of John's Gospel. That in the beginning was the Word. Moreover, the Word was with God and was God. Moreover, all things were made by Him, that His life is the light of men. Furthermore, the soul, though bearing witness to the Light, is not the Light itself but must be enlightened by Him. Yet he did not find in those Platonist books that the Word was made flesh and dwelt among us, nor that in due time He died for the ungodly, emptied Himself, took the form of a servant, and humbled Himself unto the death of the Cross. He also read there how those philosophers changed the glory of the incorruptible God into idols and images of men, birds, four-footed beasts (like the likeness of a calf that eats hay in Egypt) and creeping things. This parallels Israel carrying off the gold of the Egyptians at the Exodus. In the same way, Augustine took the true insights God had placed among the pagans while rejecting their idolatrous dishes.
Augustine was warned by those Platonist books to return from outward things into himself. Then he entered the secret chamber of his own soul under God's guidance. There, with the mysterious eye of his soul, he saw above his mind the unchangeable Light—not ordinary physical light or a larger brightness filling space. However, a higher Light because it made him, and he was lower because he was made by it. Trembling with love and awe while still far off in a region of unlikeness, he heard a voice from on high saying that God is the food of the full-grown. Furthermore, unlike bodily food, which changes into our flesh, the soul that feeds on God is changed into Him. Moreover, hearing God's voice cry from afar, "I AM THAT I AM", sooner could he doubt his own existence than think that Truth is not, since it is clearly seen and understood through the things that are made.
Looking next at all created things below God, Augustine saw that they neither wholly exist nor wholly fail to exist. They are real because they come from God. Yet they are unreal compared with Him because they change and are not what He is. At the same time, it became clear to him that all things that can be corrupted are good. If they were the supreme Good, they could not be corrupted. They were not good at all. In that case, there would be nothing in them that corruption could harm by diminishing their goodness. Corruption only takes away good. Therefore, whatever exists is good, and the evil whose origin he had long sought is not a substance at all. Indeed, if it were a substance it would be good.
He saw too that to God there is no evil at all, nor to God's creation taken as a whole. There even things that seem evil because they clash with one part harmonize with other parts and with the lower order of fire, hail, snow, and stormy wind. As a result, higher and lower creatures together make a universe that is very good. Cured in mind, Augustine saw the folly of his old Manichean complaints against parts of God's world, which had led him to invent two warring substances and a spatial phantom-God.
Augustine beheld how all finite things exist in God because He holds them in the hand of His truth. Then he saw that everything is true in so far as it exists, that falsehood is merely thinking that what is not is. Furthermore, just as wholesome bread pains a sick palate and light hurts diseased eyes, so God's justice displeases the wicked. He asked what wickedness itself is. In response, he found that it is not a substance. However, a perversity of the will turning aside from God, the supreme Substance, toward lower things.
Marveling that he now loved the true God rather than a phantom, Augustine still could not stand firm to enjoy Him. Swept upward by God's beauty, he was dragged back down with a groan by the weight of his own carnal habit. He questioned how his mind was able to judge changeable bodies accurately. Then he traced his power of judgment from bodily senses through the inner sense and reasoning power up to the unchangeable Truth above his mind. In doing so, he arrived in the flash of a trembling glance at That Which Is before his weakness cast him back into ordinary life.
Augustine sought strength to enjoy God. Then he could find none until he embraced the Mediator between God and man, the Man Christ Jesus. He mingled eternal Wisdom with flesh. As a result, the Word made flesh might become milk for infants. Yet because Augustine was not yet humble enough to receive the humble Jesus as his Master, Christ's weakness had seemed a stumbling block.
At that time Augustine thought of Christ only as a man of matchless wisdom born miraculously of a Virgin to give us an example of despising worldly things for immortality. From the Gospel accounts that Christ ate, slept, walked, rejoiced, and sorrowed, Augustine knew that Christ had a full human body, soul, and mind. Even so, he did not yet understand the sacramental mystery of the Word made flesh or how Catholic truth differs from the error of Photinus. Alypius, on the other hand, had supposed that Catholics believed Christ had only Godhead and flesh without a human soul or mind. Eventually, he discovered that this view was actually the heresy of the Apollinarians and gladly embraced the Catholic faith.
Augustine had read the Platonist books first. Therefore, he had learned to seek incorporeal truth. Yet he prated like a wise man puffed up with knowledge rather than weeping on the foundation of Christ's humility. He recognized God's providence in this order. This is because if he had first been instructed in Scripture. He also met the Platonist books afterward, they might have swept him away from solid piety.
With eager desire Augustine then seized upon the holy writings of the Spirit, above all the Apostle Paul. All his old suspicions that Paul contradicted himself or disagreed with the Law and the Prophets vanished. He saw the one face of pure Scripture exalting God's Grace. In Paul (unlike the Platonist books) he found the tears of confession, the sacrifice of a contrite heart, the grace that rescues a man dragged captive by the law of sin in his members, and the Cup of our Ransom. The Platonists only see the homeland of peace from a wooded mountaintop without finding the road. By contrast, struggling through pathless wilds beset by the ambushes of runaway spirits with their prince, the lion and the dragon, Christ the heavenly Emperor has built the humble highway where no deserters from the heavenly army can rob the traveler.
The story inside
The educated young rhetoric student Firminus came to consult Augustine about his horoscope. In response, Firminus shared a family story that finally cured Augustine of his lingering trust in astrology. Firminus's father and a close friend had studied astrological books so obsessively that they even cast horoscopes for the animals born around their houses. Firminus's mother was pregnant with him. In response, a female slave belonging to his father's friend was pregnant at the same time. Both masters counted the days and stationed messengers ready to run between the two houses the instant each child was born. Both women gave birth. In response, the two messengers met at the exact midpoint on the road. This proves that the two boys had been born at the very same instant under the exact same planetary positions. Yet Firminus, born in a rich house, rose in wealth and honor. At the same time, the baby slave remained under the yoke of slavery without relief. Identical horoscopes produced opposite lives (just as twins like Esau and Jacob are born under the same stars yet live very different lives). Therefore, Augustine saw that whenever astrologers predict true events from different horoscopes, they hit the truth by chance rather than science.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Identical birth-times with opposite destinies refute astrological determinism. The simultaneous birth of wealthy Firminus and the baby slave under the exact same horoscope (reinforced by the case of twins) proved to Augustine that astrological predictions succeed only by chance, not by a science of the stars.
- 2
Evil is not a created substance, but a privation of good and a perversity of free will. Because corruption harms things only by diminishing their goodness, whatever exists is good. Wickedness is no substance at all, but the free will turning away from God the supreme Substance toward lower things.
- 3
Platonist philosophy can point out the distant homeland of incorporeal truth, but only Christ's humility and grace provide the road. In the Platonist books Augustine found the eternal Word of John 1, yet only in St. Paul and the Gospel did he find the Word made flesh who heals the divided will through grace.
Test your recall
How did the simultaneous birth of Firminus and the slave-boy on his father's friend's estate prove to Augustine that astrology is not a true science?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
4 notesFrom The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 8590–8593
“Augustine is neither Manichee nor Catholic. O THOU, who hast been my hope from my youth upwards, where wast Thou, and whither hadst ‘Thou gone from me?”
- 2.Lines 9151–9155
“Yet there is a difference in the source of joy; I know it well, and the joy of faithful hope is worlds apart from vanity such as his; but at that time the beggar was better than I.”
- 3.Lines 9435–9437
“Hearing the outcry the thief made off, leaving behind his weapon, lest he should be caught with it in his hands.”
- 4.Lines 9704–9706
“When am I to find refreshment, and relax my mind from the strain of work?”
