Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Confessions (Books I–IX)

Section 6 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section VI · Location 6 of 9

Section 6 · Open to read

From Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907)

Monnica at Milan, Ambrose's Preaching, Alypius, and Worldly Ambition vs. Continence (Book VI, Chapters I–XVI)

Confessions (Books I–IX) · Chapter 6 summary

In Milan, Monnica's obedience and Bishop Ambrose's preaching show Augustine the spiritual truth and authority of Catholic Scripture. At the same time, a drunken beggar, Alypius's trials, a failed commune plan, and the dismissal of his concubine expose his slavery to ambition and lust.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 6 of Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Monnica at Milan, Ambrose's Preaching, Alypius, and Worldly Ambition vs. Continence (Book VI, Chapters I–XVI)” Summary of Confessions (Books I–IX), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/confessions/chapters/6#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Wandering along a dark and slippery road in Milan while seeking God outside himself, Augustine found that his mother Monnica had followed him across land and sea. During a fierce storm on the voyage, she had even comforted the sailors. In doing so, she promised them that they would reach land safely. This is because God had assured her of this in a vision. Augustine told her that he was no longer a Manichee, though not yet a Catholic Christian. In response, she did not leap for joy as if the news were unexpected. Already sure that the first part of her misery was past, she calmly declared that she trusted in Christ that before she left this life she would see her son a faithful Catholic. She poured out still more fervent prayers and tears to God, hastened eagerly to church to hang upon the words of Bishop Ambrose. In addition, she loved Ambrose like an angel of God. This is because he had brought her son out of Manicheism into that present state of wavering that she knew would lead to health.

Monnica brought a basket of cakes, bread, and wine to the memorial chapels of the saints in Milan according to African custom (where she used to taste a single small cup of heavily watered wine and distribute the rest to the poor). In response, the doorkeeper forbade her to carry the offerings inside. She learned that Bishop Ambrose had forbidden the custom both to prevent opportunities for drunkenness. Moreover, this is because those memorial feasts closely resembled the pagan festival called parentalia. In response, she piously and willingly obeyed. Augustine marveled at how readily she gave up her lifelong practice out of love for Ambrose rather than criticizing his command. In doing so, he brought a heart full of pure devotion to the martyrs' tombs instead of a basket of fruits. In addition, he took part with others in the sacrament of the Lord's Body.

Meanwhile, Augustine admired Ambrose as a man honored by the great powers of the world. Moreover, he thought only his celibacy must be a hard burden, having no experience yet of the inner spiritual joy Ambrose tasted in God's bread. Crowds of busy people constantly blocked access to the bishop to seek help in their troubles. Therefore, Augustine could not consult him at length. In the brief moments when Ambrose was free from visitors, he refreshed his body with simple food or his mind with reading. Augustine and his friends entered the open door unannounced. In response, they watched Ambrose reading silently (his eyes moving across the page while his voice and tongue remained completely still) whether to spare his weak voice for preaching or to avoid interruptions from listeners asking about hard passages. They quietly withdrew without disturbing him. Yet from Ambrose's Sunday sermons to the people, Augustine learned to his shame that the Catholic Church does not teach that God the Creator is confined inside a human bodily figure with limbs.

Blushing that he had spent so many years barking against imaginary Catholic errors. At the same time, he treated Manichean fables as certain, Augustine rejoiced to hear Ambrose repeat as a rule that the literal letter kills. By contrast, the spiritual meaning gives life. That spiritual key lifted the veil from passages of the Old Testament that had seemed perverse when read literally. Even so, Augustine still held back from full assent. In doing so, he longed to be as sure of unseen things as he was that seven and three make ten. At the same time, slowly realizing that spiritual sickness can be healed only through faith.

Gradually God led Augustine to prefer Catholic teaching. This is because the Church modestly asked people to believe truths that could not yet be proved to everyone. By contrast, the Manichees mocked faith, promised scientific proof, and then demanded belief in absurd myths. Augustine reflected on ordinary human life. Then he saw how countless things must be believed on trustworthy testimony without having been personally witnessed. This is the history of nations, distant cities, the loyalty of friends, the reports of physicians, and even who one's own parents are. Human society would collapse without such trust. Therefore, he recognized that God had established the supreme authority of Holy Scripture across all nations. In doing so, he offered plain words that welcome the humble alongside deep mysteries that exercise the sharpest minds.

Even while learning these truths, Augustine remained feverish with ambition for promotion, money, and marriage. One day, as he walked through Milan preparing to deliver a panegyric full of lies to the Emperor in order to win applause from listeners who knew he was lying, he passed a poor beggar in the street who was tipsy, joking, and merry. Sighing, Augustine pointed out to his companions how all their painful labors and anxieties aimed only at reaching the carefree temporal happiness that this beggar had already bought for a few pence of alms. The beggar's joy was not the true joy of God. Even so, Augustine's anxious pursuit of glory through dishonest flattery was even farther from the truth. If asked, Augustine would have chosen to remain himself rather than become the beggar only out of perverse pride in a learning that gave him no peace.

In those days Augustine shared his deepest troubles with his two closest friends, Alypius and Nebridius. Alypius came from a leading family in Augustine's own hometown of Thagaste. Moreover, he had studied under him both there and at Carthage. At Carthage, Alypius had fallen into the whirlpool of the Circus and its chariot races. Because of a quarrel with Alypius's father, Augustine could not warn him privately. One day, however, Alypius walked into Augustine's rhetoric classroom, and as the lesson progressed Augustine happened to use a sharp illustration mocking people enslaved to the madness of the Circus, without intending any reference to Alypius. Alypius immediately took the rebuke to heart as meant for himself alone, loved Augustine all the more for it, and tore himself away from the Circus.

Later, when Alypius went ahead of Augustine to Rome to study law, he detested gladiatorial shows. Eventually, a group of fellow-students met him as he was returning from breakfast and dragged him with friendly force into the amphitheatre. Alypius trusted proudly in his own strength rather than in God. Then he boasted that although they could drag his body to the seat, he would keep his eyes shut and remain absent in mind and eyes. A sudden crisis in the fight drew a mighty roar from the crowd. In response, curiosity overcame him and he opened his eyes. At the sight of blood he drank in savagery, and delighted in the wicked contest. Moreover, he left the arena no longer the man who had been dragged in, becoming a fanatical follower who carried others to the games until God later rescued him.

Earlier, while still a student in Augustine's class at Carthage, Alypius had also learned a lesson useful for his future ministry as a Church steward. He walked alone at noon in the market hall with his writing tablets and stylus while memorizing his school exercise. Then he did not notice another student (the real thief) who had brought a hatchet hidden under his cloak to cut away the leaden gratings over the silversmiths' street. Hearing the silversmiths' alarm, the thief dropped the hatchet and fled. The market constables found Alypius alone near the tool and arrested him. Alypius walked quietly toward prison, trusting God. Eventually, they met the architect in charge of public buildings, who recognized Alypius. This is because he had often seen him at the house of a senator whose receptions he used to attend. As they walked along, they saw a young slave-boy standing in front of a house door who had accompanied the guilty student to the market hall. Alypius remembered seeing the boy there and whispered to the architect. He showed the boy the hatchet and asked whose it was. In doing so, he prompted the boy to answer "Ours" and reveal the whole affair, which taught Alypius never to condemn anyone hastily on rash suspicion.

At Rome, Augustine found Alypius serving as Assessor to the Count of the Italian Bounty Office. There his honesty astonished the court. A powerful senator tried by both bribes and threats to gain an illegal favor that everyone else feared to refuse. In response, Alypius scorned the bribe and defied the threats. The presiding Judge himself disliked the request yet did not dare refuse openly, shifting the blame onto Alypius. He did this by claiming his Assessor would not let him give his assent. Indeed Alypius would have left the court if the Judge had made the decree. Only one temptation in that office nearly overcame Alypius through his love of literature (when he was told he could have books copied for himself at government prices) but after consulting justice he decided that the rule forbidding it was sounder than the power allowing it. Nebridius, likewise, left his fine family estate near Carthage and his mother to live with Augustine in Milan for no other reason than to search together for truth and wisdom.

Now in his thirtieth year (eleven years after reading Cicero at nineteen) Augustine anxiously debated with himself why he still delayed giving up worldly hopes. He weighed his morning teaching hours, his visits to powerful friends to obtain a governorship, a marriage bringing a small dowry to cover expenses. His unwillingness to give up the nightly embraces of a woman.

Alypius (who had lived in strict chastity ever since despising a brief trial of sexual pleasure in early youth) urged Augustine not to marry. Specifically, marriage would prevent them from living together in the quiet pursuit of wisdom. Augustine replied by citing married lovers of wisdom, insisted that celibacy was impossible for him. This is because he was a slave to habit rather than a lover of marriage. In addition, he spoke so passionately that even chaste Alypius began to wonder what made marriage seem so indispensable.

Pressed urgently to marry (above all by Monnica, who hoped that once married he would receive saving baptism) Augustine became betrothed to a girl who was still two years too young to wed. At Augustine's request and out of her own longing, Monnica prayed daily for a vision revealing God's purpose regarding the marriage, yet God never answered. She saw only vain fancies of her own eager spirit, which Monnica discerned from true divine visions by a clear inner taste.

Meanwhile, Augustine and about ten friends (including his wealthy fellow-townsman Romanianus, whom urgent business troubles had brought to the imperial court) almost decided to withdraw from the world and pool all their possessions into one common household purse. In doing so, he appointed two managers each year. At the same time, the rest lived free from care. The entire brotherhood plan collapsed, however, as soon as they asked whether the wives whom some already had and others hoped to marry would allow it.

As his sins multiplied, the longtime mistress with whom Augustine had lived (the mother of his natural son) was torn from his side as an obstacle to his planned marriage. She left their boy with Augustine. Then she returned to Africa vowing to God that she would never know another man. At the same time, Augustine's heart was torn and wounded until it bled. Yet weaker than a woman, he could not bear the two-year wait for his promised bride and procured another mistress to feed his unbroken habit of lust. At the same time, the old wound ceased to throb only to fester more dangerously.

Through all those dark days and shifting opinions, nothing held Augustine back from a still deeper pit of carnal pleasure except the fear of death and of God's coming judgment, which never faded from his breast. Augustine debated the supreme good and evil with Alypius and Nebridius. Then he declared that Epicurus would have won the prize in his judgment for placing the highest good in bodily pleasure, if only Augustine had not firmly believed (contrary to Epicurus) that the soul lives on after death and receives the just reward of its deeds.

The story inside

Walking through a street in Milan with his friends. At the same time, he prepares a flattering panegyric full of lies to recite before the Emperor, thirty-year-old Augustine panted under the fever of his worldly ambition. There they passed a poor beggar who had eaten his fill, drunk wine, and was joking and laughing merrily. Turning to his companions, Augustine lamented the heavy load of sorrows that attended their own ambitious schemes. With a few pence tossed to him in alms, the beggar had already secured the carefree temporal happiness that Augustine was painfully chasing down long, crooked paths of court flattery and anxiety. The beggar did not possess true spiritual joy. Even so, Augustine recognized that his own pursuit of vain glory was even less true. The beggar was merry and at peace. By contrast, Augustine was terrified of failure, using his learning not to teach men but merely to flatter them.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Human society and spiritual healing both require faith before proof. Because no one could even know his own parents, history, or distant cities without trusting testimony, the Catholic Church acts more honestly than the Manichees by asking for faith in Holy Scripture before full philosophical demonstration.

  2. 2

    Self-confident virtue collapses when a person exposes himself to temptation instead of trusting God. Alypius boasted that he could sit in the Roman amphitheatre with his eyes shut. Yet a single roar of the crowd drew his gaze to the blood. He also turned him into a fanatical lover of gladiatorial games.

  3. 3

    Slavery to bodily habit can defeat both philosophical ideals and natural affection. Augustine planned a ten-man philosophical brotherhood and bled inwardly when his faithful concubine returned to Africa vowing lifelong continence. Even so, his inability to endure two years without a woman drove him to take another mistress.

Test your recall

Why did the plan of Augustine, Romanianus, and their friends in Milan to form a ten-man household with a single common purse fall to pieces?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

4 notes

From The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 7171–7176
    “He describes the twenty-ninth year of his age, in which he detected the shallowness of Faustus, the Manichean, and abandoned his purpose of going on further in that sect.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 7512–7514
    “This I compared with the doctrines of Manichaeus, who in his voluminous folly wrote many books on these matters.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 7809–7811
    “He was not one of the wordy crew from whom I had endured so much, who engaged to teach me all I wanted to know and said nothing.”
  4. 4.
    Lines 8139–8144
    “Surely not, O Lord. Nay, Thou wast present, and wast listening, and bringing all to pass in the manner Thou hadst predestined.”

Location: section 6 of 9 · 67%

Display settings