Section V · Location 5 of 9
Section 5 · Open to readFrom Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo
Edition: The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907)
Disillusionment With Faustus the Manichee, Flight to Rome, and Arrival at Milan Under Ambrose (Book V, Chapters I–XIV)
Confessions (Books I–IX) · Chapter 5 summary
Faustus's honest admission of ignorance breaks Augustine's faith in Manicheism. At the same time, a secret voyage to Rome, a near-fatal fever, cheating students, and Bishop Ambrose's spiritual preaching draw him to Milan as a Catholic catechumen.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 5 of Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Disillusionment With Faustus the Manichee, Flight to Rome, and Arrival at Milan Under Ambrose (Book V, Chapters I–XIV)” Summary of Confessions (Books I–IX), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/confessions/chapters/5#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In the twenty-ninth year of his life, Augustine offers God the sacrifice of his confessions. Moreover, he reflects that no wicked soul can flee from God's presence. Every sinner is a runaway slave who cannot escape his Master. Therefore, the only real refuge is to flee from God in His anger to God in His mercy. Wicked people turn away from God's light. In response, they stumble against Him in their blindness and feel His just punishment. Yet they remain blind to His goodness until He wakes them.
During those years, a Manichean bishop named Faustus arrived at Carthage. For nearly nine years, Augustine had listened eagerly to the sect's teachings. At the same time, he waited for Faustus, whom the other members praised as an expert able to solve every question about the sky, the stars, and the movement of the sun and moon. Meanwhile, Augustine had carefully read the books of secular philosophers who studied the natural world. Those thinkers could measure the courses of the stars and predict eclipses of the sun and moon by exact calculation, listing the day, the hour, and how much of the surface would be darkened. Yet because their proud hearts did not seek the Creator who made the universe by number, weight, and measure, they did not know God and could not find Him even when they accurately foretold an eclipse years ahead.
Augustine points out that a humble believer who understands nothing about the circles of the Great Bear or the causes of eclipses is in a far better state than an astronomer who measures the sky while neglecting his own soul. At the same time, a teacher named Manichaeus wrote long, foolish fables about the sky. In response, the stars, the sun, and the moon. At the same time, he claims to be the Holy Spirit, anyone who knew true astronomy could see that his books were full of madness. Augustine compared those Manichean stories with the proven calculations of secular astronomers. Moreover, he saw that the sect's explanations were completely false.
Faustus finally reached Carthage. In response, Augustine found him to be an engaging and pleasant speaker who repeated the same false stories with greater charm. God had already taught Augustine that a book is not true simply. This is because it is written in a fine style, nor false simply because its words are rough. In the same way, wholesome food or worthless food can be served alike on dishes of silver or cheap earthenware. Eager for the truth rather than verbal polish, Augustine brought his astronomical questions to Faustus in a quiet conversation among friends. He soon discovered that Faustus knew no liberal arts except ordinary grammar and had read only a few speeches of Tully, a very few treatises of Seneca, some poetry, and the better-written Latin books of his own sect.
When Augustine raised his questions about the stars and mathematical calculations, Faustus modestly refused to take up the burden. Unlike many noisy talkers who try to teach what they do not know, Faustus openly admitted his ignorance. That honest humility pleased Augustine far more than the knowledge he had hoped to find. Indeed, a mind that knows its own limits is fairer than knowledge of the courses of the stars. Even so, Faustus's confession shattered Augustine's zeal for the Manichean writings. The sect's most famous teacher could not answer these difficulties. Therefore, Augustine gave up hope of making progress in that false teaching. Already teaching a class as a rhetoric professor at Carthage, Augustine stayed on friendly terms with Faustus. In doing so, he read with him the literature that Faustus wished to read or that Augustine judged suitable to his character. At the same time, privately resolving to hold his place in the sect only until something better came along. Without knowing or intending it, Faustus became the instrument God used to loosen the snare that had held Augustine.
Soon afterward, God guided Augustine to leave Carthage and travel to Rome. In the schools of Carthage, students behaved with shameless disorder, bursting into classrooms like madmen to disrupt the lessons in outrages they called wreckings. Friends told Augustine that Roman students studied under stricter discipline and were not allowed to enter another teacher's school or make disturbances. At the same time, Rome also promised higher fees and greater honours. Monnica wept bitterly and followed her son down to the seashore. In doing so, she clung to him to make him either stay or take her along. Augustine deceived his mother by pretending he only wanted to stay with a friend until the wind rose for the friend's ship. He barely persuaded her to spend the night in a chapel dedicated to the blessed martyr Cyprian, which stood close to the ship. That night, while Monnica wept and prayed that God would not let him sail, Augustine secretly departed. In the morning she found the shore empty and went home in deep grief to renew her prayers. In truth, God denied her immediate request so as to answer her lifelong prayer. He did this by using the journey to bring her son to salvation.
At Rome, Augustine fell gravely ill with a fever that brought him close to death and the loss of his soul. He still imagined that the Son of God had no true flesh and that the Cross was only a phantom appearance. Therefore, he felt no desire for the baptism he had once begged for as a sick boy at Thagaste. Had he died then, his mother's heart would never have been healed. Monnica did not know of his sickness at Rome. Even so, she prayed for him continually at home. In doing so, she attended church every morning and evening, gave alms, and served the saints. She also brought her daily offering to the altar without fail. God heard her prayers and restored Augustine's bodily health. As a result, he might live to receive true spiritual healing.
Augustine recovered in the house of a Manichean hearer and continued to associate closely with both the hearers and the elect who lived hidden in Rome. He now chided his host for trusting the fables that filled the Manichean books. Even so, old friendship kept him slow to seek truth elsewhere. He still excused his own sins by claiming that an alien nature sinned inside him. He began to think that the philosophers called Academics were the wisest of all men. This is because the Academics held that human certainty is impossible. He also felt ashamed to return to the Catholic Church of his parents because he could not conceive of any spiritual substance. He pictured God as a vast, bright physical mass bounded on one side by an ugly physical mass of evil. He feared that real human flesh would defile the Saviour.
Meanwhile, he remembered how at Carthage the public debates of a man named Helpidius had already shaken him with arguments from Scripture that the Manichees could not answer. In private, the sect's leaders claimed that someone had tampered with the New Testament to insert the Jewish law. Yet they never produced a single uncorrupted copy. Opening a rhetoric school at his lodgings in Rome, Augustine soon learned why he had fled one set of student troubles only to meet another. Although Roman youths did not riot in class, groups of them regularly conspired to cheat their teacher of his fees by suddenly deserting together to another master.
The city of Milan sent word to Symmachus, the Prefect of Rome, asking for a public professor of rhetoric. In response, Augustine sought the post through his Manichean friends. As a result, he could escape both the cheating students and the sect whose fables he now despised. Augustine sent in a speech on a prescribed subject. As a result, upon due examination he might receive the post. In response, Symmachus approved him and sent him at public expense to Milan. There Bishop Ambrose, a devout servant of God famed throughout the world, welcomed him like a father. Augustine immediately loved him for his kindness. At first Augustine attended Ambrose's sermons not to learn the truth of God. However, merely to judge whether his speaking style matched his reputation, delighted with a style that was more learned than Faustus's though not as exhilarating or soothing in manner. Yet as Augustine listened for the eloquence, the truth entered his mind along with the words. Augustine heard Ambrose explain hard passages of the Old Testament by their spiritual meaning rather than their literal letter. Then he realized that the Catholic faith could be defended without shame. He judged the Manichees inferior even to secular philosophers. At the same time, he refused to trust philosophers who lacked the saving Name of Christ. Then he left the Manichees and resolved to live as a catechumen in the Catholic Church until clear certainty shone upon him.
The story inside
For nearly nine years at Carthage and Thagaste, whenever Augustine noticed contradictions between Manichaeus's books on the sky and the proven eclipse calculations of secular astronomers, the sect's members told him to wait until their famous bishop Faustus arrived to explain everything. Faustus finally came to Carthage in Augustine's twenty-ninth year. In response, crowds admired his charming delivery. However, Augustine had learned that fine speech and rough speech are only like silver and earthenware dishes that can hold either wholesome food or empty fables. Augustine gained a private conversation with Faustus among friends and set forth his astronomical difficulties. In response, he found that Faustus had read only ordinary grammar, a few speeches of Tully, a very few treatises of Seneca, some poetry, and Latin books of his own sect. Rather than pretending to know mathematics he had never studied, Faustus modestly admitted his ignorance and declined the debate. Augustine admired Faustus's honest restraint far more than the knowledge he had sought. Yet that very admission broke the spell of Manichean authority and left him waiting only until a truer guide appeared.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Secular science exposes false religious claims about the physical universe. Proud astronomers miss God when they measure eclipses without seeking the Creator. Even so, their verified calculations immediately prove that a sect leader who writes false astronomical fables. At the same time, he claims to be the Holy Spirit is an impostor.
- 2
Honest ignorance is nobler than false authority and can break a spiritual snare. Faustus's modest refusal to debate astronomical questions he did not understand earned Augustine's respect for his character. At the same time, he destroyed Augustine's faith in the Manichean books.
- 3
God can answer the deeper meaning of a prayer by refusing its immediate request. By denying Monnica's tearful prayer at St. Cyprian's chapel that Augustine not sail to Rome, God carried him through Roman illness and student fraud to Bishop Ambrose's preaching in Milan.
Test your recall
How did Bishop Faustus's response to Augustine's astronomical questions at Carthage affect both Augustine's opinion of Faustus as a man and his trust in the Manichean religion?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
4 notesFrom The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 5847–5850
“Or what am I even when it is well with me but an infant suckled on Thy milk, or feeding on Thee, the meat that perisheth not??”
- 2.Lines 6222–6226
“For I was wretched, and I had lost my joy. Or is weeping mere bitterness, and does it please us only because we loathe the things that once we delighted in, and only so long as we loathe them?”
- 3.Lines 6475–6477
“And when they are born and press towards Being, the swifter their growth the swifter their flight towards Not-Being.”
- 4.Lines 6772–6776
“But now the fame of Hierius was not like that of a notable charioteer or a popular matador; it was far more solid, and such as I should wish to gain myself.”
