Section IV · Location 4 of 9
Section 4 · Open to readFrom Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo
Edition: The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907)
Nine Years Teaching Rhetoric, Astrology, the Death of a Friend, and First Writings (Book IV, Chapters I–XVI)
Confessions (Books I–IX) · Chapter 4 summary
From age nineteen to twenty-eight, Augustine sold rhetorical skill, consulted astrologers. In addition, he mourned the death of a newly baptized boyhood friend at Thagaste. Moreover, he recorded On the Beautiful and the Fit, and mastered the liberal arts without finding spiritual rest.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Nine Years Teaching Rhetoric, Astrology, the Death of a Friend, and First Writings (Book IV, Chapters I–XVI)” Summary of Confessions (Books I–IX), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/confessions/chapters/4#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
For nine full years, from his nineteenth to his twenty-eighth year, Augustine was both deceived himself and busy deceiving others. Openly, he pursued worldly fame through the liberal arts—chasing applause in the theater. In doing so, he records prize poems, and competing for perishable crowns of hay. Secretly, he practiced the false Manichean religion, carrying food to men called "elect saints". As a result, in the workshop of their stomachs they might manufacture angels and gods to redeem him. Even if proud men mock his confession, he retraces those tangled wanderings before God. In doing so, he knows that without God a human being is only a guide to his own ruin.
During those years Augustine worked as a teacher of rhetoric. Unable to master his own greed, he sold the art of winning arguments in court. Even so, he preferred honest students and taught them tricks of speech not to ruin innocent people. However, sometimes to save the guilty. In that same period he lived with one woman who was not joined to him in lawful marriage. Although his wandering passion had settled on her, he remained faithful to her alone. Through that relationship he learned firsthand the difference between lawful marriage (entered into for the sake of having children) and a pact of restless passion. There children are not wanted beforehand, even though parents cannot help loving them once they are born.
Augustine decided to compete for a prize in a theatrical poetry contest. In response, a pagan fortune-teller (augur) sent word asking what fee Augustine would pay to be guaranteed victory. Detesting those filthy rites, Augustine answered: "If it were a crown of immortal gold, not a fly should be sacrificed to buy my victory." The augur would have slaughtered living creatures to bribe demons on his behalf. Yet Augustine did not refuse that blood sacrifice out of pure love for the true God, whom he still imagined as nothing more than a bright physical body. In truth, he was already sacrificing his own soul to demons through his Manichean superstitions.
Astrologers (who were then called "mathematicians") offered no animal sacrifices and addressed no prayers to spirits when casting horoscopes. Therefore, Augustine saw no reason to stop consulting them. Yet true Christian piety rightly condemns astrology because it destroys moral responsibility. By claiming that the sky makes sin unavoidable. Furthermore, Venus, Saturn, or Mars caused a person's crime, astrology acquits proud human beings of all guilt and throws the blame on God, the Creator and Ruler of the stars.
At that time a wise old man, famous for his skill in medicine, happened to be serving as proconsul. Moreover, he placed the poetry crown upon Augustine's disordered head with his own hand. Becoming acquainted with Augustine, who delighted in his weighty, unpretentious conversation, the aged physician noticed that the young professor was studying astrology books. With fatherly kindness he urged Augustine to throw them away and stop wasting valuable time on nonsense. The old doctor explained that in his own youth he had studied astrology thoroughly, intending to earn his living by it. Added that since he had mastered the medical writings of Hippocrates, he was certainly capable of understanding horoscopes. Yet he had abandoned astrology and turned to medicine. This is because he discovered that astrology was completely false, and as an honest man he refused to earn his bread by deceiving people. Augustine asked why astrological predictions so often come true. In response, the physician answered that it happens through the power of chance spread throughout nature. In the same way, a person who opens the pages of a poet at random looking for an oracle often hits upon a line that fits his problem by sheer coincidence rather than art. God used the old doctor to plant doubts in Augustine's memory, neither the physician nor Augustine's prudent friend Nebridius (who laughed at all divination). Even so, could persuade him to give up astrology yet.
Soon after Augustine began teaching rhetoric in his hometown of Thagaste, he formed an intense bond with a young man of his own age with whom he had grown up, attended school, and played games. True friendship exists only when God binds souls together through the love poured into hearts by the Holy Spirit. Still, their companionship was sweet, and Augustine even drew his friend away from a shallow youthful hold on the Christian faith into the Manichean fables for which Monnica wept. Their close friendship had lasted a full year, however. In response, the young man fell dangerously ill with a fever and lay long unconscious in a deadly sweat. Despairing of his life, his family had him baptized while he could neither think nor feel. Augustine paid little attention, confident that his friend's mind would keep the Manichean views they had shared rather than a rite performed on an unconscious body. Yet the friend was spiritually reborn and healed. He rallied enough to speak. In response, Augustine (who had never left his bedside) tried to make a joke about the baptism he had received while insensible. Already informed of his baptism, the friend shrank back from Augustine as if from an enemy and, with sudden, astonishing courage, warned Augustine never to speak to him that way again if he wished to remain his friend. Stunned and confused, Augustine held back, planning to argue with him once his health returned. Within a few days, however, while Augustine was away, the fever came back and his friend died, snatched safely out of reach of Augustine's madness.
Darkness crushed Augustine's heart. Everywhere he looked he saw only death; his hometown became a torture and his father's house a misery. Because his phantom Manichean god offered no real support, tears became his only comfort. Why are tears sweet to the miserable? Every soul chained to perishable things feels its hidden wretchedness as soon as those things are torn away. Unlike the legendary friends Orestes and Pylades, who were ready to die together, Augustine felt a strange contradiction inside himself. He was sick of living, yet terrified to die. He quoted the poet Horace's words calling a friend "half of my soul". Then he felt that his soul and his friend's had been one soul in two bodies. Life seemed horrible because he was cut in two. Yet perhaps he feared to die lest the remaining half of the friend he loved should perish altogether.
Augustine carried a torn, bleeding soul that found no peace in groves, games, songs, banquets, or books. Then he could not flee from his own heart. Yet he fled from Thagaste to Carthage so his eyes would no longer look for his friend in familiar places. Time gradually eased his pain, and the companionship of new friends at Carthage refreshed him. What welded their souls together into one was talking and laughing together. In doing so, he showed courteous deference to one another, read eloquent books side by side, disagreeing gently without bitterness. Took turns teaching and listening.
Such human friendship brings black mourning whenever death strikes because a mortal has been loved as though he were immortal. Blessed is the person who loves God, loves his friend in God, and loves his enemy for God's sake. He alone never loses a dear one. This is because all are dear to him in the One who can never be lost. Outside of God, all earthly things are born, grow, age, and die, hurrying toward non-being. Created things are only passing parts that cannot exist all at once, just as spoken words and syllables must pass away one after another. As a result, a complete sentence can be heard. Bodily sense cannot stop their flight.
Therefore, if bodies or souls delight us, we must praise God for them and love them in their Maker. Our Life Himself (Christ) came down to earth, entered the Virgin's womb to unite our mortal human nature to Himself, and killed our death by the abundance of His life. He cries aloud to us through His words, deeds, death, resurrection, and ascension. Then he withdrew from our bodily eyes. As a result, we might return to our own hearts and find Him there. Proud human beings have fallen by trying to climb high against heaven. They must come down in humility so that they may truly ascend to God.
Not knowing this at the time, around age twenty-six or twenty-seven Augustine reflected on why we love beautiful things. He noticed two distinct kinds of beauty in bodies. These include the "Beautiful", which is pleasing in itself as a whole composite, and the "Fit", which charms by suiting something else, as a shoe fits a foot. From these reflections Augustine composed two or three books On the Beautiful and the Fit. He had forgotten the exact number, as the copies had since gone astray.
He dedicated those books to Hierius, a famous professor of rhetoric at Rome. Augustine had never seen Hierius, who was a Syrian by birth trained first in Greek eloquence and later celebrated as a Latin orator and philosopher. However, Augustine loved him simply because other people praised him. Why did Augustine wish to become like a praised orator. By contrast, he praised a famous charioteer, matador, or stage actor. In response, he would have hated to become an actor himself? His love for Hierius was blown about by the wind of human opinion. The very same speakers had described the very same talents in a tone of contempt. In that case, Augustine would have felt cold toward him.
In writing On the Beautiful and the Fit, Augustine's mind was still trapped in physical shapes, colors, and bulks. He sees that virtue brings peaceful unity while vice brings discordant division. Then he called rational unity the "monad" (imagining it as a sexless mind and the supreme good) and called division the "dyad". In doing so, he imagines angry violence and lust as an irrational substance and the supreme evil existing independent of God. He did not yet know that no substance is evil, nor that the human mind is not the unchangeable Light itself. However, needs to be enlightened by God from above. Worse still, in his pride he preferred to claim that God's unchangeable substance was forced to err, rather than confess that his own changeable soul had sinned by free choice.
Around age twenty, when Aristotle's Ten Categories fell into his hands (a work his Carthaginian rhetoric master used to mention with cheeks puffed out in pride) Augustine read and understood it completely by himself without a teacher. Fellow students told him they had barely grasped it with learned tutors drawing diagrams in the sand. Yet they could tell him nothing he had not already seen on his own about substance (such as a man) and its nine classes of attributes (quality, quantity, relation, place, time, posture, having shoes or arms, action, and being acted upon). Yet this solo mastery actually hindered him. Assuming everything that exists must fit those ten categories, he tried to place God under them too, as if God were a bodily subject possessing greatness and beauty as separate qualities, whereas God is His own greatness and beauty. In the same way, Augustine mastered all the books he could find on rhetoric, logic (dialectic), geometry, music, and arithmetic without human help. In doing so, he discovered how hard they were only when he tried to explain them to his own brightest students. Yet all that quickness of mind did him no good. At the same time, he kept his talents in his own proud keeping like the prodigal son. In doing so, he imagined God as a vast, shone physical body and himself as a piece broken off from it. By contrast, humble believers with far slower minds stayed safe in the nest of the Church, growing the wings of charity.
The story inside
Shortly after beginning to teach rhetoric in his native town of Thagaste, Augustine grew inseparable from a boyhood schoolmate of his own age. Augustine shares the same studies. Then he drew his friend away from a weak youthful hold on the Christian faith into Manichean fables. Their close friendship had completed a single year, however. In response, the young man was struck by a violent fever and lay long unconscious in a deadly sweat. When all hope seemed lost, his family had him baptized while he was completely insensible. Augustine stayed constantly by his side and cared nothing about the rite, convinced that his friend's mind would keep the Manichean teachings he had learned from Augustine rather than a ceremony performed on an unconscious body. Yet the baptism transformed him. The friend rallied enough to speak. In response, Augustine tried to joke with him about the baptism he had received. At the same time, unable to think or feel. Having already been told what had been done, his friend shrank back from Augustine as if from an enemy and, with sudden, remarkable courage, warned Augustine never to speak to him that way again if he wished to remain his friend. Silenced and astonished, Augustine resolved to wait until his friend regained his strength before arguing further. Instead, a few days later while Augustine was absent, the fever returned and his friend died in the Christian faith.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Astrology destroys moral responsibility by blaming human sins on Venus, Saturn, or Mars—and thus on the Creator of the stars—whereas its occasional true predictions happen by chance, like opening a poet's book at random.
- 2
Loving a mortal friend as though he would never die turns bereavement into crushing despair. Only those who love their friends in the eternal God never lose a dear one.
- 3
Unaided intellectual brilliance cannot save a proud soul: mastering Aristotle's Ten Categories and the liberal arts alone at age twenty hindered Augustine. This is because he treated God as a bodily substance with separable qualities. At the same time, simpler Christians stayed safe in the nest of the Church.
Test your recall
How did the wise old proconsular physician explain why the predictions of astrologers sometimes turn out to be true?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
7 notesFrom The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 5904–5906
“those vile mysteries that I answered, “If it were”
- 2.Lines 6030–6036
“true, he replied, as well he might, ‘* Because of”
- 3.Lines 6140–6144
“shrank from me as from an enemy, and, with a”
- 4.Lines 6429–6432
“Blessed is he who loves Thee, and his”
- 5.Lines 6673–6676
“Come down that ye may ascend, and ascend to”
- 6.Lines 6724–6737
“so I came to write two or three books about the”
- 7.Lines 6992–7043
“understood the Ten Categories of Aristotle”
