Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Confessions (Books I–IX)

Section 3 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section III · Location 3 of 9

Section 3 · Open to read

From Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907)

Student Years at Carthage, Cicero's Hortensius, the Manichean Snare, and Monnica's Tears (Book III, Chapters I–XII)

Confessions (Books I–IX) · Chapter 3 summary

In Book III of the Confessions, Augustine recounts his student years at Carthage. There stage tragedies and secret lust entangled him, Cicero's Hortensius awakened his desire for wisdom, and his pride against Scripture's humble style led him into the Manichean heresy despite his mother Monnica's tears.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Student Years at Carthage, Cicero's Hortensius, the Manichean Snare, and Monnica's Tears (Book III, Chapters I–XII)” Summary of Confessions (Books I–IX), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/confessions/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

When Augustine arrived as a student at Carthage, shameful passions bubbled all around him like a frying-pan. He was not yet in love, but he loved the very idea of love. Moreover, he hated a quiet path free of snares. Deep inside, his soul was starving for God, its true inward food. Yet because he was spiritually empty he felt no appetite for imperishable bread. Instead, his sick soul rushed outdoors to scrape its sores against physical things. He pollutes the pure stream of friendship with the sewage of lust, and eager to be admired for his style and wit. Then he plunged headlong into a secret love affair. God mercifully mixed bitter gall into that cup of sweetness. Augustine won his wish and bound himself in secret bondage. In response, he was beaten with the red-hot iron rods of jealousy, suspicion, fear, anger, and quarrels.

The theater at Carthage also cast a spell over him, feeding his fire with staged pictures of his own misery. Why do spectators want to feel sad while watching tragic misfortunes that they would never wish to suffer themselves? In the theater, sadness itself becomes the pleasure people seek. If an actor performs imaginary or ancient disasters without drawing tears, the viewer goes home disgusted. If tears flow, the viewer stays riveted and enjoys weeping. Yet no one is asked to help the suffering characters on stage—only to shed tears and applaud the actor. True Christian mercy grieves over those who are wretched (especially pitying a sinner who rejoices in wicked success) yet a truly merciful person would far rather see no suffering at all. In the same way, God's pure pity feels no grief. In those days, however, Augustine loved sorrow for its own sake. In doing so, he lets the imaginary woes of a stage dancer claw his heart and leave a festering sore.

Even while God's mercy watched over him from afar, Augustine followed his restless curiosity into deeper unbelief. He even dared to plan a scheme for gratifying his lust inside the walls of God's church. At the same time, the sacred mysteries were being celebrated. In response, a sin for which God struck him with heavy penalties. Meanwhile, his studies in what were called the liberal arts pointed him toward the law courts. There the craftiest speaker won the highest honor. He reached the top of the rhetoric school. Then he was swollen with pride, yet far quieter in conduct than many of his peers. He refused to take part in the wild, cruel pranks of the student gang known as the "Wreckers"—a devilish name worn as a badge of fashion by students who delighted in ambushing shy freshmen and insulting them for sport. Augustine associated with some of them and felt a perverse shame that he could not match their boldness. Even so, he always detested their bullying.

In his nineteenth year (two years after his father died, while his widowed mother paid for his schooling) Augustine came across a book by Cicero in the regular course of rhetoric. Everyone admires Cicero's eloquent tongue, though not his heart. This treatise, called the Hortensius, praised the study of philosophy—a Greek word meaning the love of wisdom. Reading it changed Augustine's mind, and transformed his very prayers to God. Moreover, he turned his desires away from empty worldly hopes toward the immortality of wisdom. He no longer read Cicero merely to sharpen his tongue for the law courts. The substance of the book itself captured him and began his upward return toward God. Cicero's call not to chase one sectarian school or another. However, to love, seek, and hold fast to Wisdom wherever she might be found, set Augustine's heart ablaze. Only one thing cooled his enthusiasm: the Name of Christ did not appear anywhere in Cicero's book. From infancy, Augustine's heart had drunk in the Name of his Savior with his mother's milk. No book that left out Christ's Name (however polished or profound) could completely win him over.

Determined to see what the sacred Scriptures were like, Augustine opened the Bible. There he encountered a work that hides its mysteries from the proud. Moreover, he reveals them only to the humble, growing deeper as a beginner grows. At that time, however, Augustine was too proud to bow his head or become like a child. To his rhetorical taste, the restrained language of Scripture seemed far inferior to the stately dignity of Tully (Cicero). His blind eyes could not pierce its hidden depths.

He turned away from the Bible. Then he fell straight into the hands of the Manichees—vain, raving, wordy men whose mouths constantly repeated the names of God the Father, the Lord Jesus Christ, and the Paraclete (the Holy Spirit, our Comforter). They cried "The Truth, the Truth" endlessly in huge books, yet their hearts were empty of truth. Augustine hungered for the unchanging God. At the same time, they served him a banquet of delusions on painted dishes. In doing so, they show lies not only about God but even about the sun and moon. Hungry for reality, he fed on materialist fantasies that were like food in a dream, leaving the sleeper starving. Poetic fables taught in grammar school (such as verses about Medea flying through the air) were far less harmful. This is because no one believed Medea's flight was literal truth. By contrast, Augustine actually believed the Manichean myths about five elements transforming themselves to fight five non-existent caves of darkness. This is because he was trying to find God through his bodily senses rather than his mind.

He did not yet know what true spiritual Being is. Therefore, the Manichees easily unsettled him with three stock questions: Where does evil come from? Is God confined within a bodily shape with hair and nails? And how could the Old Testament patriarchs be righteous men if they had several wives at once, killed men, and offered bloody animal sacrifices? Augustine imagined nothing except physical bulk. Then he did not yet understand that evil is not a substance at all. Rather, he is the privation (loss) of good, next door to non-existence. Nor did he understand that God is Spirit, who has no measurable parts or bulk and is wholly present everywhere.

Important, Augustine did not yet grasp that God's true inner righteousness never changes. In the same way, even when it adapts its outward rules to different countries and ages. Foolish critics judged Abraham, Isaac, Jacob, Moses, and David by narrow human custom—like a man ignorant of armor who straps a leg-plate (greave) onto his head. In addition, he puts a helmet on his foot, and then complains that they do not fit. Or like a shopkeeper who riots because he cannot open his shop after noon on a declared half-holiday. Or like a visitor in a great household who complains. This is because servants are allowed to do things in the stable that are forbidden in the dining room. Even in writing poetry, Augustine was not allowed to place every metrical foot in every spot. Yet the single art of poetry governed all those changing lines without changing itself. In the same way, God's eternal justice gave one set of commands to ancient times and another to later times. At the same time, he remained one and the same.

To love God with all one's heart, soul, and mind and to love one's neighbor as oneself is never wrong anywhere. Therefore, sins against nature itself (like the corruptions of Sodom) are detestable and punishable in every time and nation. Offenses against human customs and laws, meanwhile, must be avoided. As a result, a citizen or stranger does not break the lawful compact of the state, unless God (the supreme King over all creation) directly commands an extraordinary act. All other sins of insult or injury—whether committed for revenge, robbery, fear, envy, or pure delight in cruelty like spectators cheering at a gladiatorial show—sprout from pride, unhealthy curiosity, or lust, rebelling against God's Decalogue, the ten-stringed harp of the Ten Commandments (three duties toward God and seven toward neighbors). Human judges often misread motives, beginners in virtue commit "scholars' faults". At the same time, that give promise of future grain like a green blade, and whatever God commands His servants is done either for present need or to foreshadow the future.

Blind to these truths, Augustine mocked God's holy prophets. At the same time, he swallows the absurd Manichean belief that when a fig is plucked, both the fig and its mother tree weep milky tears. Even worse, he believed that if an "Elect" Manichean saint ate a fig that someone else had sinned by plucking, the saint's teeth and stomach juices would set free particles of God trapped in the fruit. In doing so, he allowed the saint to breathe out angels during prayer! As a result, Augustine pitied fruits and vegetables more than human beings. In doing so, he believes it would be a deadly sin to give a single mouthful of food to a hungry beggar who was not a Manichee.

The context is set throughout the nearly nine years that Augustine wallowed in that dark pit. His widowed mother Monnica wept for him more bitterly than mothers weep over a dead child's corpse, watering the ground with her tears at every hour of prayer. At first, horrified by his blasphemous errors, she refused to let him live under her roof or eat at the same table with her. Then God consoled her through a dream. She saw herself standing in tears upon a wooden rule, when a shining young man approached her with a cheerful smile. Moreover, she asked why she wept every day. She answered that she was mourning her son's spiritual ruin. In response, the youth told her to take heart and look closely. Indeed, where she was, there her son was also. Looking up, she saw Augustine standing right beside her on the same wooden rule. Monnica recounted the dream to Augustine and he tried to twist its meaning (claiming it meant she would one day become a Manichee like him). In response, she replied without a moment's hesitation: "No, he did not say where he is you will be, but where you are he will be." Her instant, unshaken reply struck Augustine even more deeply than the dream itself, and from then on she allowed him to live and eat with her again.

Around the same time, Monnica begged a learned Catholic bishop, a man raised in the Church and steeped in Scripture, to talk with Augustine and refute his errors. The bishop wisely refused. Augustine was still too puffed up with the novelty of the Manichean heresy and too proud of tangling simple believers in clever puzzles to listen to argument. "Leave him where he is", the bishop advised her; "only pray the Lord for him; he will learn by his own reading, what an error and an impiety it is." The bishop then told her his own story. He was a little boy. In response, his own misguided mother had handed him over to the Manichees. He had not only read nearly all their books but copied them out by hand. Eventually, simply by reading them he saw for himself without any debate that he had to leave the sect. Monnica still refused to give up and pressed him with floods of tears. In response, the bishop grew impatient and exclaimed: "Go, and God be with you; it cannot be that the son of these tears should be lost." As she often told Augustine afterward, she welcomed those words as a voice straight from heaven.

The story inside

Monnica grieved over her son's fall into the Manichean heresy as though he were spiritually dead. Then she sought out a learned Catholic bishop who had been raised in the Church and was deeply read in Scripture. She begged the bishop to meet with young Augustine, refute his false doctrines, and teach him the truth. In the same way, the bishop often did for willing listeners. The bishop refused her request. Augustine was not yet willing to learn. He was swollen with the novelty of his new sect and had already been confusing simple believers with clever arguments. "Leave him where he is", the bishop told her; "only pray the Lord for him; he will learn by his own reading, what an error and an impiety it is." To reassure her, the bishop revealed that his own misguided mother had handed him over to the Manichees when he was a child. Furthermore, he had read and even copied out nearly all their books before realizing on his own, without anyone arguing with him. Moreover, he must abandon the sect. Monnica still wept and pleaded with him. In response, the bishop finally cried out: "Go, and God be with you; it cannot be that the son of these tears should be lost."

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Reading Cicero's Hortensius at age nineteen reoriented Augustine's ambition from rhetorical vanity to the love of immortal wisdom. Yet the childhood imprint of Christ's Name kept any philosophy lacking Christ from fully satisfying him.

  2. 2

    Intellectual pride blocked Augustine's first reading of the Bible. Its humble style seemed inferior to Cicero's eloquence. Therefore, he fell into materialist Manichean myths that treated evil as a physical substance and God as divisible bulk.

  3. 3

    God's eternal law of righteousness remains unchanging while adapting its commands to different ages. In the same way, armor fits different limbs, a household has different rules for stable and dining room. One art of poetry governs varied meters.

Test your recall

Why did the learned Catholic bishop refuse Monnica's plea to debate young Augustine and refute his Manichean errors?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

7 notes

From The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 4744–4745
    “NEXT I went to Carthage, where debauchery (”
  2. 2.
    Lines 5006–5021
    “It was the Hortensius, a treatise”
  3. 3.
    Lines 5103–5107
    “far inferior to the dignity of Tully.”
  4. 4.
    Lines 5288–5290
    “not know that evil is the privation of good and”
  5. 5.
    Lines 5601–5612
    “pitch of absurdity as to believe that a fig weeps”
  6. 6.
    Lines 5671–5672
    “hesitation: “No, he did not say where he is you”
  7. 7.
    Lines 5744–5763
    “‘“ Leave him where he is,”’ he”

Location: section 3 of 9 · 33%

Display settings