Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Confessions (Books I–IX)

Section 2 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section II · Location 2 of 9

Section 2 · Open to read

From Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907)

The Sixteenth Year at Thagaste, Youthful Lust, and the Theft of Pears (Book II, Chapters I–X)

Confessions (Books I–IX) · Chapter 2 summary

In Book II of the Confessions, Augustine examines his sixteenth year of enforced idleness at Thagaste. This shows how unrestrained adolescent lust, parental ambition, and peer pressure ('unfriendly friendship') culminated in a midnight theft of pears committed solely for the thrill of shared wrongdoing.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of Confessions (Books I–IX) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Sixteenth Year at Thagaste, Youthful Lust, and the Theft of Pears (Book II, Chapters I–X)” Summary of Confessions (Books I–IX), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/confessions/chapters/2#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Recalling the past vileness and carnal corruption of youth is bitter. Yet Augustine undertakes that self-examination not because he loves looking back at sin. However, for love of God's love. By retracing his wicked ways before God, he asks the Lord to become his fearless, unfailing joy and to gather him back from the scattering in which he was torn limb from limb. When he turned away from the One true God, he melted away into the Many—chasing scattered earthly desires. In his youth he roamed passionately like a wild beast after wandering loves. At the same time, his inner beauty wasted away and he sought only to please himself and human eyes.

At that age nothing pleased him except to love and to be loved. Yet he could not stay within the bright realm where friendship binds soul to soul. From the mud of bodily desire and the well of puberty rose a thick mist that clouded his heart. As a result, he could no longer tell the difference between the clear light of affection and the darkness of lust. Both stormed together inside him, sweeping his thoughtless youth over cliffs of desire into a whirlpool of shame. Deafened by the clanking chains of his own pride, he boiled over in fornications and wandered into a barren field of sorrow, proud in his misery and restlessly discontented.

No one stepped in to ease his distress by setting the boundary of lawful marriage around the fleeting charms of earthly beauty, so that having children might calm the storm of youth as God's law ordains. Nor did he heed the Apostle Paul's higher counsel to remain unmarried and care only for the things of the Lord. In doing so, he made himself a eunuch for the Kingdom of Heaven. Even so, when he broke God's law in the sixteenth year of his life, God remained close at hand in wrathful pity. God spoiled every lawless pleasure by mixing it with bitter vexations. Through this, it guides him to look for a joy that has no bitterness—a joy found only in God, who strikes in order to heal. Meanwhile, his relatives took no care to save him from falling by arranging a marriage. Their only concern was that he should learn to make a powerful, persuasive speech.

During that sixteenth year, Augustine's schooling was interrupted. He had been called home from the neighboring city of Madaura. There he had lived while studying literature and rhetoric. His father—a poor town citizen (burgess) of Thagaste whose ambition reached far beyond his small purse—was saving up money to send him to the more distant university at Carthage. Everyone praised his father for sacrificing out of slender means to give his son a university education, doing far more than many wealthier citizens did for their children. Yet this devoted father cared nothing about how his son grew toward God or whether he remained chaste, so long as the boy became a man of worldly culture, even while his heart remained an uncultivated vineyard before God.

Augustine spent that entire sixteenth year at home in enforced idleness because of the family's tight finances. At the same time, the thorns of lust grew higher than his head and no one rooted them out. One day at the public baths, his father noticed the first signs of restless manhood in the youth. Moreover, he went home gladly to tell his mother, bragging about his hopes of grandchildren. In his mother's heart, however, God had already begun to build a holy temple. By contrast, his father had only recently become a catechumen—a beginner preparing for baptism. His mother trembled with godly fear, dreading lest her son fall into crooked ways. In private talks she warned Augustine with deep anxiety to flee fornication and, above all, never to corrupt another man's wife. To the sixteen-year-old boy, her earnest warnings sounded like mere womanly prudery that a young man should be ashamed to obey. He did not realize that God was speaking to him through his mother's lips. Furthermore, by despising her advice he was despising God.

Blinded by pride, Augustine roamed the streets of that moral "Babylon" with shameless companions. He heard his peers bragging loudly about their vices. In response, he felt ashamed to fall behind them in disgrace, sinning not only for pleasure but for applause. He could not match the real exploits of that wicked crowd. In response, he even made up false stories about sins he had never committed, afraid that his companions would scorn him as cowardly or weak if he seemed slightly more innocent or chaste. Even his devout mother (who had fled from the heart of Babylon in spirit but still limped along its outskirts) did not act on her husband's bathhouse remark by arranging a marriage. Augustine looked back on his parents' character. Then he judged that both parents feared the burden of a wife would hinder his hopes of literary fame—his father thinking hardly at all of God. His mother supposing that the usual classical education would actually help her son find God. As a result, the reins were slackened and he was left to follow his own loose desires.

Both God's law and the moral law written on human hearts (which not even sin can erase, since no thief tolerates being robbed by another thief) strictly forbid stealing. Yet in that sixteenth year Augustine resolved to steal and carried it out, driven not by hunger or poverty. However, by contempt for justice and a bloated insolence of sin. Just beyond his family's vineyard stood a neighbor's pear tree heavy with fruit. Even so, the pears were tempting neither in appearance nor in taste. Rioting until midnight through the open squares of Thagaste according to their destructive habit. In response, Augustine and a band of young profligates marched off to shake and strip the tree. They carried away huge loads of pears, not to feast on them (for Augustine had plenty of much better fruit at home) but to fling them to the hogs, even if they ate a few. He loved his own transgression not for the thing he stole, which he threw away, but solely for the pleasure of doing wrong.

Normally, no human being commits a crime without seeking some lower earthly good or fearing to lose one. Gold, silver, pleasant touch, earthly honor, power, life, and human friendship all possess a real. Even so, lowest, degree of beauty created by God. People sin when they abandon the highest good (God, His truth, and His law) to chase those inferior goods. When a judge investigates a murder, he looks for a motive. The killer coveted a man's wife or estate, and robbed for a living. In addition, he feared being robbed himself, or sought revenge for an injury. Even Catiline, the Roman conspirator famous for practicing seemingly pointless cruelty, had an ulterior motive. He wanted to keep his hand and will in practice. As a result, he could sack Rome and seize office, power, and wealth.

What, then, could Augustine have loved in a midnight theft that lacked even the shadowy beauty of ordinary vices? Every human vice is a twisted, bad imitation of a true perfection belonging to God alone. Pride apes God's loftiness; ambition seeks God's honor and glory. The cruelty of the powerful wants to be feared like the almighty God. Wantonness craves love, though nothing is sweeter than God's charity; curiosity mimics God's omniscience. Ignorance hides behind the name of simplicity. Sloth seeks rest, though true peace is in the Lord; luxury mimics divine abundance; prodigality apes God's generosity. Avarice wants to possess all things; envy argues for excellence; anger demands just vengeance. Fear tries to guard what it loves. In addition, he grieves over losing what it wished to keep forever. By defying the law through fraud in stealing the pears, Augustine was acting like a runaway slave playing at freedom inside a prison-house. In doing so, he grasped at a shadowy phantom of God's omnipotence by doing what was forbidden simply. This is because it was forbidden.

Looking back without fear, Augustine thanked God whose grace melted his sins away like ice. He confessed that he owed to God's grace not only the sins that were forgiven him. However, also all the evil deeds he was kept from committing. No one who considers human weakness dare credit his own natural strength for his chastity or innocence. Anyone who escaped such sins owes his health to the same divine Physician who healed Augustine.

Augustine dug one level deeper into the memory of that night. Then he uncovered the final key to the pear theft: alone, he never would have done it. He had cared for the pears themselves. In that case, he could have stolen them single-handed without rubbing like a hog against his comrades to inflame his desire. The real thrill lay not in the fruit, nor even in the solitary act, but in the companionship of fellow sinners. Laughter tickled their hearts because they were secretly duping owners who would have been furious had they known. An "unfriendly friendship" cast a strange spell over him. Out of sport and shared laughter sprang the eager wish to inflict wrong without gain or revenge. When friends say, "Come, let us do it", a youth becomes ashamed not to be shameless. Augustine turned away from that ugly, tangled knot. Then he longed for God's Justice, Innocence, and unruffled peace. In doing so, he confessed that by straying from God in his sixteenth year he had become to himself a dry and barren land.

The story inside

During his sixteenth year at Thagaste, his schooling was paused so his father could save money to send him to Carthage. At the same time, Augustine roamed the town squares until midnight with a band of rowdy companions. Just beyond his family's vineyard stood a neighbor's pear tree loaded with fruit. The pears were neither attractive to look at nor sweet to taste. Augustine had plenty of much better fruit at home. Even so, the youths marched out in the dark, and shook and stripped the tree. Moreover, he carried away huge loads of pears—not to eat them, save perhaps a few, but to throw them to the hogs. Why did he steal fruit he did not want? Even a hardened criminal like Catiline practiced cruelty in order to win power and wealth. Every ordinary vice imitates some divine perfection in a distorted way. In stealing the pears, Augustine acted like a runaway slave playing at a phantom of God's omnipotence. He does this by breaking the law with impunity. Yet he also realized that he never would have stolen the pears alone. What drew him was "unfriendly friendship"—the shared laughter of duping the owners and the fear of seeming cowardly when comrades cried, "Come, let us do it."

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Worldly ambition can blind even loving parents to moral danger. Augustine's father saved beyond his means for Carthage and rejoiced at hopes of grandchildren. At the same time, both parents delayed arranging a marriage lest a wife hinder their son's rhetorical career.

  2. 2

    Every human vice is a perverse, shadowy imitation of a divine perfection—pride mimicking God's loftiness, ambition His glory, cruelty His power, and lawless defiance a phantom of His omnipotence.

  3. 3

    Peer complicity ('unfriendly friendship') drives people to commit wrongs they would never do alone. In doing so, he made a youth so afraid of social scorn that he is ashamed not to be shameless and even invents false sins to win applause.

Test your recall

Why did Augustine conclude that he never would have stolen the neighbor's pears if he had been alone that night?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

6 notes

From The Confessions of St. Augustine (Books I–IX), trans. Charles Bigg, D.D. (1907). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 4067–4073
    “I had been called home from”
  2. 2.
    Lines 4160–4164
    “making myself more vicious to escape”
  3. 3.
    Lines 4245–4250
    “We carried off huge loads, not to”
  4. 4.
    Lines 4356–4357
    “Even Catiline then loved not”
  5. 5.
    Lines 4504–4508
    “which might seem a phantom of omnipotence?”
  6. 6.
    Lines 4651–4665
    “Alone I should never”

Location: section 2 of 9 · 22%

Display settings