Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The City of God (De Civitate Dei)

Section 4 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section IV · Location 4 of 5

Section 4 · Open to read

From The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925)

Books XV–XX: The Progress of the Two Cities Through Sacred History, the Definition of Peace, and the Last Judgment

The City of God (De Civitate Dei) · Chapter 4 summary

As the Two Cities journey through sacred and secular history toward the Last Judgment, the pilgrim City of God shares. Moreover, he obeys the laws of earthly peace while referring every good to the heavenly peace that is the tranquillity of order.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Books XV–XX: The Progress of the Two Cities Through Sacred History, the Definition of Peace, and the Last Judgment” Summary of The City of God (De Civitate Dei), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/city-of-god/chapters/4#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Augustine had explained how the Two Cities began among the angels and in the Fall of Adam. Therefore, he traces their history from Genesis to the birth of Christ across Books XV through XVIII. Throughout Old Testament history, the two communities appear side by side in paired figures: Cain and Abel, Cham and Sem, Ishmael and Isaac, Esau and Jacob, and the wicked world drowned in the Flood beside Noah's Ark. Every citizen of the City of God begins from the same condemned clay (massa) of fallen humanity as everyone else. Yet he becomes "predestined by grace, elect by grace, by grace a pilgrim below, by grace a citizen above" (Book XV, Chapter 1).

The Earthly City belongs only to this mortal age and is constantly torn apart by wars. Yet even wars aim at earthly peace, and when victory falls to the side with the juster cause, that victory and temporal peace are genuine gifts of God. However, if people neglect the higher goods of the Heavenly City—where victory is secure in everlasting peace—and love temporal peace as the only good, new misery inevitably follows and old wounds break out again (Book XV, Chapter 4). In examining the literal and symbolic history of Genesis, Augustine also calculates the storage capacity of Noah's three-decked Ark (at twenty-one inches to a cubit, roughly 525 feet long, 87 feet wide, and 52 feet high). In Book XVI, he traces the covenant promises given to Abraham. In addition, he questions whether the opposite side of the earth (antipodes) is inhabited since Scripture records no descendants of Adam sailing across the ocean (Book XVI, Chapter 9). Moreover, he highlights Abraham's readiness to sacrifice Isaac as a figure of God the Father not sparing His own Son (Book XVI, Chapter 32).

The seventeenth book follows the era of the Hebrew Kings. Augustine shows how the song of Hannah (1 Kings 2) prophesies the Christian Church and the priesthood of Christ. Moreover, he shows why the glorious promises made to David and Solomon intentionally exceeded anything fulfilled in the earthly kingdom of Israel—so that believers would look beyond the earthly Jerusalem to Christ the true King of Peace. The eighteenth book places Gentile history alongside sacred history. In doing so, he contrasts the rise of Assyria and Rome with the prophetic line of Israel. Augustine asks how the pagan world came to believe that the crucified Jesus is God. Had Christ come as a conqueror with armed legions, the world would have yielded to force. By contrast, He chose unlearned fishermen so that the conversion of nations would manifestly be the work of divine power. He quotes the famous Greek acrostic of the Erythraean Sibyl whose initial letters spell "Jesus Christ, Son of God, Saviour", and concludes Book XVIII by explaining why God permits heresies inside history: heretics sharpen the Church's vigilance. In doing so, he forces Catholic thinkers to study Scripture more carefully and preach the truth more clearly (Book XVIII, Chapter 51).

The nineteenth book examines the ultimate ends of the Two Cities by testing what ancient philosophers taught about the Supreme Good. The Roman scholar Varro counted 288 possible philosophical sects based on different combinations of bodily and mental goods. Yet all of them made the fatal mistake of claiming that human beings can manufacture their own supreme happiness in this mortal life. Against Stoic pride, Augustine points to the inescapable miseries of earthly society—especially the plight of the conscientious human judge (Book XIX, Chapter 6). A judge cannot read the secrets of the heart. Therefore, he often tortures innocent witnesses to extract the truth and sometimes condemns an innocent man to death after torture forces a false confession. In doing so, he cries out to God from his tragic necessity: "Deliver me from my necessities!"

Augustine does not deny that natural virtue (the right ordering of life's goods and evils) is real. However, he insists that virtue becomes true (supernatural) virtue only when a person refers every gift to the eternal peace of God (Book XIX, Chapter 10). This leads to his celebrated tenfold hierarchy of peace in Book XIX, Chapter 13:

*Peace of the body:* the well-ordered arrangement of its parts.

*Peace of the irrational soul:* the well-ordered rest of appetite.

*Peace of the rational soul:* the well-ordered agreement of knowledge and conduct.

*Peace of body and soul:* the well-ordered life and health of the living creature.

*Peace of mortal man with God:* well-ordered obedience in faith under the eternal law.

*Peace among men, in the household, and in the city:* well-ordered concord among members and citizens in command and obedience.

*Peace of the Heavenly City:* a perfectly ordered and harmonious fellowship in enjoying God and one another in God.

*The peace of all things. "the tranquillity of order"*, where order is the arrangement of equal and unequal things, assigning each to its proper place.

Against the Manichees, Augustine adds that there cannot be any nature in which there is no good. Not even the devil's nature is evil insofar as it is a created nature. Only perverse will makes it evil. God created human beings for temporal peace in this life and eternal peace in the next. Therefore, the City of God on pilgrimage does not abolish or despise the customs, laws, and institutions by which earthly peace is maintained. Instead, drawing citizens from all nations and languages, the pilgrim Church obeys and preserves civil laws across every nation. This holds provided that only that those laws do not hinder the worship of the one true God (Book XIX, Chapter 17). Finally, discussing Cicero's De Republica, Augustine argues that if a commonwealth (res publica) requires true justice—giving each his due—then pagan Rome was never a true commonwealth. This is because it withheld worship from the true God and gave it to demons. Yet under a broader definition of a people united by a shared object of love, any state can be judged by what it loves (Book XIX, Chapters 21, 24).

The twentieth book turns to the Last Judgment. Why does God allow wicked epicures to prosper while devout believers suffer in this life? If God punished every sin openly right now, nothing would appear to be reserved for the Last Judgment. On the other hand, God never punished any sin openly on earth. In that case, people would deny divine providence altogether (Book XX, Chapters 1–2).

Commenting on Christ's words in John 5:25–28, Augustine distinguishes *two resurrections*:

*The first resurrection, which takes place now* in this life through faith and baptism, when dead souls rise from the death of sin into spiritual life.

*The second resurrection*, which will take place at the end of the world, when all bodies (both good and wicked) rise from the grave for judgment.

Augustine uses this distinction. Then he rejects crude literalist theories of an earthly thousand-year banquet and interprets the binding of Satan and the thousand-year reign of the saints in Revelation 20 as the *entire present age of the pilgrim Church between Christ's first and second comings (Book XX, Chapters 7–9). When he reaches St. Paul's obscure statement in 2 Thessalonians 2:7—"only till he that restraineth now, be put out of the way"—Augustine models scholarly honesty by writing bluntly: "I own my utter ignorance of the meaning" (ego prorsus quid dixerit me fateor ignorare, Book XX, Chapter 19). Augustine reports others' conjectures (that the restraining power is the Roman Empire and the mystery of iniquity is Nero, or that it refers to bad men multiplying inside the Church) without pretending certainty where Scripture is silent. Similarly, on 1 Thessalonians 4:15–17, Augustine conjectures that believers found alive at Christ's return will pass with wonderful swiftness through death to immortality in the very instant they are caught up in the clouds. At the same time, he insisted that even if we cannot grasp the exact how*, our faith in the bodily resurrection is never in vain (Book XX, Chapter 20).

Augustine closes Book XX by listing the great events that Sacred Scripture foretells around the Last Judgment. The coming of the prophet Elias the Thesbite to expound the law. As a result, the Jews come to believe in Christ (Malachi 4:5–6), the final persecution of Antichrist, the descent of Christ as Judge, the bodily resurrection of the dead, the eternal separation of the good and the wicked, and the conflagration and renewal of the material world. We must firmly believe that all these events will come to pass. Even so, experience at the end of time will teach their exact manner. In addition, he will order better than human intelligence can presently conceive (Book XX, Chapter 30).

The story inside

In Book XIX, Chapter 6, Augustine exposes the illusion of Stoic self-sufficiency through the tragic figure of the upright Roman judge. Forced by law to torture witnesses and defendants. This is because he cannot read human hearts, the judge sometimes tortures. He also executes an innocent person who confesses falsely to stop the pain. This proves that mortal social life is full of darkness that only cries out to God for deliverance.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Peace is 'the tranquillity of order', where order arranges equal and unequal components in their proper place.

  2. 2

    Not even the devil's nature is evil insofar as it is a created nature. Only perverse will corrupts a good nature.

  3. 3

    The pilgrim Church on earth preserves and obeys the civil laws of every nation whenever those laws do not hinder the worship of the one true God.

Test your recall

How does Augustine distinguish the two resurrections in Book XX, and how does that distinction explain the thousand-year reign in Revelation 20?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 3104–3108
    “Then one Book (XVII) on the time of the Hebrew Kings, and one (XVIII) on the history of the Gentile world. Universal history is not apt to be a happy.undertaking, as St Augustine found.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 3446–3448
    “But he argues that the Seventy were inspired to depart from the literal and substitute a mystical number.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 3805–3808
    “The leisure (ottum, oyodn) of a student—not a student working for an examination, but one who enjoys learned leisure—is set over against the activity of business or political life.”

Location: section 4 of 5 · 80%

Display settings