Section V · Location 5 of 5
Section 5 · Open to readFrom The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo
Edition: The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925)
Books XXI–XXII: Eternal Punishment, the Resurrection of the Body, Contemporary Miracles, and the Beatific Vision
The City of God (De Civitate Dei) · Chapter 5 summary
In Books XXI–XXII, Augustine contrasts the just eternal punishment of the Earthly City with the bodily resurrection and eternal Sabbath of the Heavenly City. In doing so, he confirms Christian faith through twenty-five contemporary miracles culminating at St. Stephen's Shrine in Hippo.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 5 of The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Books XXI–XXII: Eternal Punishment, the Resurrection of the Body, Contemporary Miracles, and the Beatific Vision” Summary of The City of God (De Civitate Dei), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/city-of-god/chapters/5#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Augustine had traced the Last Judgment in Book XX. Therefore, he devotes Book XXI to the final destiny of the Earthly City and the justice of eternal punishment. Sceptics object that no living body can burn forever without being consumed. Furthermore, no crime committed in a brief moment of time deserves an everlasting penalty.
To the first objection, Augustine answers that God the Creator (who gave wonderful properties to natural things) can easily preserve a risen body in pain without allowing it to dissolve. In his own experiments and observations (Book XXI, Chapters 4–7), Augustine tested cooked *peacock flesh at Carthage. In addition, he found that it remained sweet and uncorrupted after thirty days and even after a full year. He watched a loadstone (magnet) hold up a hanging chain of iron rings one attached to another. He heard from his fellow-bishop Severus of Milevis how Count Bathanarius moved a piece of iron across the top of a silver plate. He does this by moving a magnet underneath. Moreover, he noted how quicklime boils in water yet stays cold in oil. Carefully distinguishing facts he had verified by experience from unverified book stories (such as the claim that a diamond neutralizes a magnet), Augustine points out that when pagans cannot explain a wonder, they simply say "It is the nature of the thing"*. In doing so, he forgot that the Will of the Almighty Creator is the true nature of every created thing.
To the second objection—that eternal punishment is disproportionate to a short-lived sin—Augustine replies that not even human law measures punishment by the clock (Book XXI, Chapter 11). A murder or an adultery takes only a few minutes to commit, yet human courts justly punish the offender with lifelong chains, permanent exile, or execution—cutting him off forever from the city of the living. By sinning against the eternal God, Adam made the whole clay of fallen humanity a condemned clay (massa damnata). Through this, no one is delivered except by unmerited grace (Book XXI, Chapter 12). Augustine affirms that believers who die with lesser. At the same time, venial faults undergo temporary purifying punishments before the Last Judgment (Book XXI, Chapters 13, 24), he refutes both Origen's universalism (which imagined even the devil would eventually be saved) and *six laxist theories current among Christians who promised eternal salvation to unrepentant sinners merely because they had been baptized. He also belonged to the Catholic Church. He also received the Body of Christ, or gave alms. At the same time, he continued in wickedness (Book XXI, Chapters 17–27). In Christ's sentence in Matthew 25:46, "punishment eternal" and "life eternal"* stand on the exact same footing. To claim that eternal punishment will end is to undermine the certainty that eternal life will never end (Book XXI, Chapter 23).
The twenty-second book crowns the entire work with the eternal destiny of the City of God and the *resurrection of the body. Against Platonist philosophers like Porphyry (who claimed that supreme happiness requires the soul to escape every body forever) Augustine points out that the whole Roman world has already come to believe in the bodily resurrection of Christ, preached not by armed legions. However, by a handful of unlearned fishermen. Even if someone refused to believe that any miracles occurred when the Apostles preached, this one grand miracle would suffice. that the world has come to believe without any miracles at all* (Book XXII, Chapter 5).
Yet miracles have not ceased in the Christian Church. In Book XXII, Chapter 8 , Augustine demonstrates that contemporary miracles are less famous than biblical ones only because Scripture is read aloud everywhere. By contrast, modern cures are known only locally unless bishops require written depositions (libelli) to be read to the congregation—a practice Augustine himself instituted at Hippo. Augustine then records *twenty-five contemporary miracles* that he personally witnessed or verified:
*Miracle I (Milan, 386). Augustine was in Milan. At the same time, a blind butcher known to the whole city touched the bier of the martyrs Protasius and Gervasius* before Bishop Ambrose and immediately received his sight.
*Miracles II–III (Carthage). Augustine stayed in the house of the former official Innocentius. He was cured of a deep surgical fistula after desperate prayer on the eve of a dreaded second operation. In the same city, a devout woman named Innocentia, afflicted with an incurable breast cancer that physicians wanted to amputate, was warned in a dream to ask the first newly baptized woman who met her at the women's baptistery on Easter to sign the tumour with the sign of the Cross*. She obeyed and was instantly healed—Whereupon her physician, instead of rejoicing, looked disappointed that she had not discovered some new medical drug!
*Miracles IV–XXIV. Include the conversion of the proud physician Dioscorus after his daughter was healed. Blind women healed at Aquae Tibilitanae under Bishop Projectus. Bishop Lucillus cured of a fistula while carrying a reliquary. The Spanish priest Eucharius at Calama cured of stone. He also raised from death by the tunic laid on St. Stephen's Shrine. The pagan nobleman Martialis converted at Calama when his son-in-law prayed in tears at St. Stephen's altar. He also brought back a flower from the shrine. Moreover, the poor tailor Florentius of Hippo, who prayed to the Twenty Martyrs* for clothes after losing his cloak. He also was mocked by youths as if he had asked for fifty pence, bought a gasping big fish on the beach from a cook named Catosus. He also found a gold ring inside the fish's stomach to buy wool for his wife to spin.
*Miracle XXV (Paul and Palladia at Hippo). On Easter Sunday morning in Augustine's own basilica at Hippo, two siblings from Caesarea in Cappadocia (Paul and Palladia, two of ten children afflicted with a violent, ceaseless trembling of all their limbs after their widowed mother cursed them for an injury) prayed at the Memorial Shrine of St. Stephen*. Holding the altar rails before the crowded congregation, Paul fell asleep without trembling and rose completely healed. Augustine was preaching on Paul's written deposition and Palladia went back to touch the rails of the shrine. At the same time, a roar of joy interrupted the sermon. Palladia too had fallen asleep at the rails and risen completely cured. In doing so, he left the congregation weeping and shouting praises to Christ.
Augustine turns to anatomical objections against the bodily resurrection (such as what happens to aborted infants, hair clippings, or bodies eaten by cannibals). Then he answers that God the *Divine Artist restores every human body to the mature stature of Christ's manhood without any deformity (Book XXII, Chapters 12–20). Only one exception remains. The glorious wound-scars of the martyrs will shine in their risen bodies not as defects or losses of limb. However, as badges of honour and testimonies of their love for Christ—"for in that case it will not be a deformity, but a dignity"* (Book XXII, Chapter 19).
Augustine contrasts the heavy miseries of mortal life and childhood schooling (Book XXII, Chapter 22) with the breathtaking marvels of human art, language, music, and bodily beauty that God still lavishes on fallen humanity (Book XXII, Chapter 24). Then he closes Book XXII with the *Beatific Vision and the eternal Sabbath of the Heavenly City (Chapters 29–30). In the new heaven and new earth, the saints will behold God's governance of the universe even with their glorified bodily eyes—so clearly that God will be "all in all" (1 Corinthians 15:28). Their free will, far from being lost, will reach its highest perfection. Adam's first freedom was the power to be able not to sin (posse non peccare). By contrast, the last and highest freedom of the blessed will be not to be able to sin (non posse peccare*). In doing so, he shares in God's own inability to sin.
There, in that everlasting eighth day that knows no evening, the citizens of the City of God will keep true Sabbath rest:
> "There we shall rest and see, we shall see and love, we shall love and praise. Behold what shall be in the end without end! For what else is our end, than to arrive at the kingdom of which there is no end?" (Book XXII, Chapter 30).
The story inside
On Easter Sunday morning in Augustine's cathedral at Hippo (Miracle XXV), a young man named Paul from Caesarea—afflicted along with his sister Palladia and eight siblings by a ceaseless bodily trembling after their widowed mother's curse—gripped the rails of St. Stephen's Shrine, fell prostrate as if asleep, and rose completely healed. Minutes later, while Augustine was preaching to the congregation on Paul's written deposition, Palladia touched the same rails. In addition, he walked back into the basilica cured, choking the whole church with tears of joy.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
People cannot explain a wonder of creation. In response, they exclaim 'It is the nature of the thing'—forgetting that the Will of the Almighty Creator is the true nature of every created thing.
- 2
In the bodily resurrection, the martyrs will retain the scars of their wounds not as deformities. However, as shining badges of honour and love.
- 3
The highest perfection of free will in heaven is not the ability to choose evil. However, the blessed inability to sin (non posse peccare), where 'we shall rest and see, we shall see and love, we shall love and praise.'
Test your recall
How does Augustine distinguish Adam's first freedom in Paradise from the final freedom of the saints in heaven in Book XXII, Chapter 30?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 4228–4261
“for ever, he became deserving of evil to last for ever.”
- 2.Lines 4635–4699
“wonderful truths shall fire rational minds with delight at their”
- 3.Lines 5581–5650
“Miracle XXV.\—There was one miracle wrought amongst.”
