Section III · Location 3 of 5
Section 3 · Open to readFrom The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo
Edition: The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925)
Books XI–XIV: The Origin of the Two Cities, Creation and the Fall of Angels and Man, Death, and the Two Loves
The City of God (De Civitate Dei) · Chapter 3 summary
In Books XI–XIV, Augustine traces the origin of the Two Cities to the angelic division at Creation and the Fall of Adam. Every created nature bears the image of the Trinity and is good. Moral evil has no efficient cause but only a 'deficient cause' in the proud will falling away from God. The entire history of angels and humanity is divided by two opposite loves—love of self to the contempt of God and love of God to the contempt of self.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Books XI–XIV: The Origin of the Two Cities, Creation and the Fall of Angels and Man, Death, and the Two Loves” Summary of The City of God (De Civitate Dei), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/city-of-god/chapters/3#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
With Book XI, Augustine opens the second great division of The City of God (Books XI–XXII), which sets forth the positive Christian theology of history in three four-book stages:
*Books XI–XIV: The origin* of the Two Cities (Heavenly and Earthly).
*Books XV–XVIII: Their progress and growth* through human history.
*Books XIX–XXII: Their appointed ends* in eternity.
In Book XI, Augustine traces the first origin of the Two Cities back beyond human history to the *angels, when God said, "Let there be light, and there was light; and God divided the light from the darkness"* (Genesis 1:3–4). The holy angels, illuminated by the Eternal Word and cleaving to God in love, formed the first citizens of the City of God. The rebel angels, turning away from God's light into their own pride, became darkness. Augustine answered scoffers who ask why God created the world "at that moment and not earlier". Then he demonstrates that there was no "time" before creation. This is because time itself is the measure of changing creatures. By contrast, God dwells in an unchanging eternal present.
Every creature in the universe (from the highest angel to the smallest grain of sand) is good by nature. In addition, he bears a threefold trace (vestigium) of the *Blessed Trinity. It is (answering to the Father, the Principle of being). It has a distinct form or species (answering to the Son, the Eternal Wisdom). It has a Tendency or order of love and weight* (answering to the Holy Spirit). In Book XI, chapter 26, answering the Academic skeptics, certainty begins from self-knowledge:
Even if the skeptics say, "What if you are mistaken?" Augustine replies: *"If I am mistaken, I exist (Si fallor, sum). For he who does not exist can certainly not be mistaken; and therefore I exist, if I am mistaken."*
In Book XII, Augustine asks why, if two rational creatures are created equally good in body and mind, one wills to remain faithful to God. At the same time, the other turns to sin. What is the efficient cause of that first evil choice of the will? Augustine replies that *an evil will has no efficient cause at all, but only a "deficient cause" (causa deficiens)*:
Evil is not a positive substance created by God. It is a falling away from the Supreme Being toward what has less being.
Asking to find a positive efficient cause of an evil will is like *asking to see darkness or to hear silence. We know light by seeing and sound by hearing. We know darkness and silence only by not seeing and not* hearing.
Augustine then refutes two rival pagan and heretical cosmologies:
*The Stoic and Pagan Theory of Eternal Cycles.* Pagans argued that history repeats itself endlessly in identical cosmic circles. As a result, Plato will teach the same disciples in the Athenian Academy infinite times over. Augustine replies that if a soul in heaven knew it must inevitably fall back into mortal misery and sin again, it could never be truly blessed. Christ died once for all, and the wicked walk in a circle. At the same time, the righteous walk a straight path to eternal rest.
*Origen's Theory of Pre-Existent Souls.* The context is set against Origen's speculation that souls sinned in a previous spiritual world and were thrust into material bodies as prisons according to the degree of their guilt. In this setting, Augustine points out that if heavily guilty souls needed heavy bodies, the devil (the worst sinner of all) would have been locked in the grossest body of clay rather than left with an aerial spiritual nature!
Finally, God created the entire human race from *one single man, Adam, not because He wanted Adam to be lonely. However, so that all human beings might be bound together not merely by similarity of nature, but by the warm bond of family kinship*.
In Book XIII, Augustine examines *death*, which entered human history through Adam's sin. Three forms of death are distinguished:
*Spiritual death (death of the soul*): occurs when God forsakes the soul through mortal sin.
*Bodily death (the first death*): occurs when the soul forsakes the body.
*Eternal death. (the second death*): occurs after the final resurrection when the soul, separated from God, is forcibly bound to the body in eternal punishment.
Why, if Christian Baptism forgives the guilt of original sin, does God not immediately restore immortality to the bodies of the baptized? Augustine demonstrates that if Baptism conferred instant bodily immortality on earth, people would flock to the font out of cowardly love for earthly life rather than faith in unseen eternal goods, and the heroic victory of the *Christian martyrs (who conquer the fear of death out of love for Christ) would be impossible. The context is set against the Platonists, who despised the body as the source of all evil. He also mocked the resurrection of the flesh. In this setting, Augustine proves that what weighed down the soul was not the body's nature. Rather, it was its corruption through sin ("the corruptible body weigheth down the soul,"* Wisdom 9:15).
In Book XIV, Augustine completes his account of the origin of the Two Cities. He does this by contrasting life *"according to the flesh" (secundum carnem) with life "according to the spirit" (secundum spiritum). In Holy Scripture, "flesh" does not mean only bodily lusts; it designates the whole fallen human person living for self rather than for God. The proof is decisive. St. Paul lists hatreds, heresies, envy, and pride among the "works of the flesh" (Galatians 5:19–21), and the devil* has no bodily flesh at all, yet lives supremely according to self-will and pride.
Consequently, Christians do not agree with the Stoics in trying to uproot all human emotions (love, fear, grief, and gladness) into cold apathy. Instead, human emotions are movements of the will: *if the will's love is rightly ordered toward God, those emotions are good. If its love is perverse, they are bad. In Paradise before the Fall, Adam and Eve enjoyed tranquil love without fear, sorrow, or rebellious bodily lust (concupiscentia*). Only after man proudly rebelled against his Divine Master did his own lower flesh rebel against his rational mind—a just penalty in which disobedience was punished by internal disobedience.
Why did Adam and Eve eat the forbidden fruit? Because *inward pride ("Ye shall be as gods") had already corrupted their hearts before their hands touched the tree: "The wicked work did not make them wicked, but came from their being already wicked"* through secret self-exaltation.
Augustine therefore closes Book XIV (chapter 28) with the famous passage that summarizes the entire City of God:
*"Two loves therefore have built two cities: the love of self to the contempt of God has built the earthly city; the love of God to the contempt of self has built the heavenly city."*
The earthly city glories in itself; the heavenly city glories in the Lord. In the earthly city, its rulers and the nations it conquers are ruled by the *lust of dominion (libido dominandi*). In the heavenly city, rulers and subjects serve one another in charity.
The story inside
Philosophers ask what efficient cause produced the first evil choice in an angel or human whom God created wholly good. In response, Augustine replies in Book XII that they are looking for something that does not exist. Moral evil is not a positive nature created by an evil god. It is a falling away of the free will from the Supreme Being toward lesser things. Therefore, an evil will has no 'efficient cause', but only a 'deficient cause' (causa deficiens). Trying to discover a positive efficient cause for an evil choice is like trying to see darkness with the eyes or trying to hear silence with the ears. We know light by seeing and sound by hearing. By contrast, we know darkness and silence only by the failure of sight and sound.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Against Academic skepticism, Augustine proves indubitable self-knowledge in Book XI, chapter 26. 'If I am mistaken, I exist (Si fallor, sum), for he who does not exist cannot be mistaken.'
- 2
Moral evil has no positive efficient cause in God or nature. However, only a 'deficient cause' (causa deficiens) when a free creature deserts the Supreme Good for itself.
- 3
'Two loves have built two cities: the love of self to the contempt of God has built the earthly city; the love of God to the contempt of self has built the heavenly city' (Book XIV, ch. 28).
Test your recall
How does Augustine explain the 'cause' of the first evil choice of the will in Book XII, and what are the 'two loves' that built the Two Cities in Book XIV, chapter 28?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
2 notesFrom The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 2475–2515
“pleased him as a work of art to do, not that God’s knowledge”
- 2.Lines 3040–3100
“Adam’s disobedience was punished in him and his”
