Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The City of God (De Civitate Dei)

Section 2 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section II · Location 2 of 5

Section 2 · Open to read

From The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925)

Books VI–X: Varro's Civil Theology, Platonist Philosophy, Demons Versus Angels, and the One True Sacrifice

The City of God (De Civitate Dei) · Chapter 2 summary

Neither Roman civil religion (Varro) nor Neo-Platonic daemon-worship and theurgy (Apuleius and Porphyry) can lead the soul to eternal blessedness. Supreme worship (latria) belongs to the one Creator alone. Union with God is achieved only through Jesus Christ, the humble Mediator and Universal Way, in whose Eucharistic sacrifice the whole redeemed City is offered to God.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Books VI–X: Varro's Civil Theology, Platonist Philosophy, Demons Versus Angels, and the One True Sacrifice” Summary of The City of God (De Civitate Dei), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/city-of-god/chapters/2#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Augustine had proved in Books I–V that the pagan gods could not even secure earthly happiness or save Rome from temporal disaster. Therefore, he turns in Books VI–X to the second plea of pagan apologists. That the state gods must be worshipped in order to obtain eternal life after death.

In Book VI, Augustine examines the monumental Antiquities of Marcus Terentius Varro, universally acclaimed as the most learned of the Romans. Dividing his work into "Things Human" and "Things Divine", Varro distinguished three kinds of theology:

*Mythical (or fabulous) theology*, used by poets in the stage plays.

*Physical (or natural) theology*, debated by philosophers who ask what the gods are made of.

*Civil theology*, administered by priests and citizens in the state temples.

Varro openly condemned mythical theology for attributing theft, adultery, incest, and filth to the gods. Yet Augustine demonstrates from Varro's own pages that the *civil theology of the Roman state temples (which Varro urged citizens to maintain) commanded the very same obscene stage plays and shameful rites to propitiate the state deities, alongside an absurd rabble of minor gods presiding over every petty detail of marriage and childbirth. Augustine likewise quotes the lost treatise On Superstition* by the Stoic philosopher Annaeus Seneca. He mocked the degrading fanaticism of the Roman Capitol (where men gashed themselves and actors mimed love-sick gods) yet concluded that a wise man should perform all these rites outwardly as a matter of legal custom without believing in them.

In Book VII, Augustine inspects Varro's twenty *"select gods"* (twelve males and eight females: Janus, Jupiter, Saturn, Genius, Mercury, Apollo, Mars, Vulcan, Neptune, Sol, Orcus, Father Liber, Tellus, Ceres, Juno, Luna, Diana, Minerva, Venus, and Vesta). Varro tries to rescue these deities by explaining them physically as symbols of the sky, earth, seeds, or a pantheistic "world-soul". In response, Augustine replies that worship belongs to the transcendent Creator alone, never to mutable parts of matter.

In Books VIII and IX, Augustine turns to the *natural theology of the philosophers and selects the Platonists* (Plato, Plotinus, Porphyry, and Apuleius of Madaura) as the noblest thinkers of antiquity. They excelled all other schools in three branches of philosophy:

*Natural philosophy*: they saw that no material body is God. Furthermore, the one unchangeable Spirit is the primary Author of all beings.

*Rational philosophy (logic)*: they recognized that God is the uncreated Light of all human understanding.

*Moral philosophy (ethics)*: they saw that the supreme good is to cleave to God in love.

Yet despite knowing the true God so closely, these Platonists still defended polytheistic worship. He does this by appealing to *demons (daemones) as middle beings between the high gods and mortals. Examining Apuleius's treatise On the God of Socrates, Augustine quotes Apuleius's five-point definition of demons. They are animal in genus, passion-tossed in soul*, rational in mind, aerial in body, and eternal in duration. Apuleius relied on Plato's maxim that "no god mingles directly with men". Then he argued that aerial demons must carry human prayers and sacrifices to the gods.

Augustine refutes this daemon-mediation across Books VIII and IX:

Spirits who are enslaved to pride, anger, and lust—and who demand filthy theatrical shows as their price—are not friends of the holy God, but fallen angels who envy human salvation.

A mediator between the *immortal and blessed God and mortal and wretched man must not be immortal in body and wretched in soul (like the demons). Rather, He must become mortal in body while remaining blessed and righteous in soul*.

That one true Mediator is *Jesus Christ, the Word made flesh*, who shared our mortality to lift us to His blessed immortality.

In Book X, Augustine demonstrates that supreme worship (called in Greek **latria*) belongs to the one true God alone. The holy angels in heaven do not wish us to offer sacrifice to them. Instead, they love us as fellow citizens and desire that we offer sacrifice with* them to God alone.

Augustine then formulates his classic definition of sacrifice:

*True sacrifice is every work done to unite us in a holy fellowship with God*, directed toward that supreme good and end in which alone we can be truly blessed.

Mercy shown to ourselves or our neighbor for God's sake is a spiritual sacrifice. Visible sacrifices are sacred signs (sacramenta) of the invisible sacrifice of a humble, contrite heart.

In the *daily Sacrament of the altar*, the whole redeemed City (the congregation and fellowship of the saints) is offered as a universal sacrifice to God through the Great High Priest, Jesus Christ. As a result, the Church learns that in what she offers, she herself is offered as His mystical Body.

Finally, Augustine exposes the tragic inconsistency of the Neo-Platonist *Porphyry. In his Letter to Anebo and his work On the Return of the Soul (De Regressu Animae), Porphyry half-admitted that theurgy (magic rites used to purify the lower soul through spirits) was fraudulent and subject to envious powers. Porphyry even confessed that neither the truest philosophy nor the moral discipline of the Indians nor the magic of the Chaldeans had yet brought to light any "universal way for the deliverance of the soul."* Augustine shows that Christ Himself is that very Universal Way for all nations, which Porphyry missed only because intellectual pride kept him from bowing before the humble Cross of the Incarnate Word.

The story inside

In his treatise On the Return of the Soul, the Neo-Platonist philosopher Porphyry candidly admitted that he had searched the truest Greek philosophy, the moral discipline of the Indians, and the magic of the Chaldeans without finding any 'universal way for the deliverance of the soul.' Augustine points out that the very Universal Way Porphyry was looking for was already shining before his eyes in Jesus Christ (who purifies the whole human person, body, soul, and spirit, for people of every nation) yet Porphyry shrank back from Christ. This is because philosophical pride made him despise the humility of the Cross.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Augustine honors the Platonists above all other pagan philosophers. This is because they recognized an incorporeal Creator who is the source of our being, the light of our reason, and the goal of our love.

  2. 2

    Intermediate spirits enslaved to pride and passion cannot mediate between God and mortals. True mediation required the Word made flesh, who shared our mortality while remaining righteous and blessed.

  3. 3

    True sacrifice is every work done to unite us to God in holy fellowship, visibly expressed when the Church offers herself as the Body of Christ in the Sacrament of the altar.

Test your recall

Why does Augustine reject Apuleius's claim that aerial demons are mediators between God and humanity, and how does Augustine define 'true sacrifice' in Book X?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

2 notes

From The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 1970–2036
    “Such are the shadowy forms that are seen there in”
  2. 2.
    Lines 2045–2150
    “greater in all together than he is in each; he is not susceptible”

Location: section 2 of 5 · 40%

Display settings