Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The City of God (De Civitate Dei)

Section 1 · Saint Augustine of Hippo

Section I · Location 1 of 5

Section 1 · Open to read

From The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo

Edition: The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925)

Books I–V: The Sack of Rome, Pagan Gods and Public Morals, Fate, Free Will, and Roman Greatness

The City of God (De Civitate Dei) · Chapter 1 summary

Alaric's sack of Rome in 410 was not caused by abandoning the pagan gods (who demanded obscene stage-plays and failed to prevent worse Republican disasters) but served under divine Providence to manifest the contrast between the Two Cities, and show that holiness resides in the consenting will. This also serves to explain that ancient Rome's natural civic virtues received their just temporal reward in earthly empire.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 1 of The City of God (De Civitate Dei) by Saint Augustine of Hippo. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Books I–V: The Sack of Rome, Pagan Gods and Public Morals, Fate, Free Will, and Roman Greatness” Summary of The City of God (De Civitate Dei), by Saint Augustine of Hippo. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/city-of-god/chapters/1#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In A.D. 410, Rome was taken and sacked (though not destroyed) by Alaric the Goth. Because the Roman Emperors since Constantine (except Julian) had been Christian and pagan worship had been repressed by law, educated pagans and popular crowds alike blamed Christianity for the fall of the Eternal City. Centuries of paganism had seen victorious expansion, whereas one century of Christian rule had ended in barbarian capture.

To answer this reproach, St. Augustine took up his pen in 412 and labored for fifteen years until 427—the same year he recorded his treatise De correptione et gratia. In doing so, he built The City of God (De Civitate Dei) block by block amid his episcopal duties. Originally dedicated to his friend Marcellinus, the Imperial Vicar of Africa who was executed in September 413, the work grew to five books by 415, eleven by 416, fourteen by 420, and twenty-two books at its completion in 427. In the second book of the Retractations, the first ten books refute two false pagan claims. Books I–V answer those who contend that polytheistic worship is necessary for the earthly prosperity of human society. At the same time, Books VI–X answer those who admit that temporal calamities occur in every age yet argue that sacrificing to many gods profits the soul after death. To establish the positive Christian vision, Books XI–XXII treat of the Two Cities (the City of God and the City of this world) dividing into three groups of four books each. Books XI–XIV trace their origin, Books XV–XVIII their historical course, and Books XIX–XXII their appointed ends.

They cannot be identified simply as the visible Catholic Church and the civil State. Indeed, Augustine dates the City of God from the earliest days of mankind. The world is not a single organized corporation. Rather, mystically speaking, the Two Cities are the Elect and the Reprobate: two societies of men, one predestined to reign eternally with God, the other to suffer eternal punishment with the devil (De Civitate Dei, XV.1). On earth, these two societies are blended together like good and bad fishes in the Gospel net (Matthew 13:47–48) until they are parted at the Last Judgment. Against the Donatists, Augustine insists that the Elect and the Reprobate live side by side within the visible Church on earth. God's eye alone infallibly distinguishes them. Their inward division rests on two opposite loves: "These Two Cities are made by two loves: the earthly City by love of oneself even to contempt of God; the heavenly City by love of God even to contempt of oneself" (XIV.28).

Opening with the words "The right glorious City of God", In Book I, Augustine comforts Christians shaken by Rome's capture and exposes pagan ingratitude. Unlike pagan conquerors of old, Alaric was himself a Christian who spared the lives of all who fled into the Christian churches, and his soldiers even escorted fugitives there for safety. As Augustine remarks in Book IV, the Roman Empire had suffered a shock rather than a subversion. In the same way, it had recovered from earlier shocks before Christ's name was preached.

Why, then, do good and evil men share the good and evil things of this life almost indiscriminately? Augustine answers that while all things turn to the good of the devout, good Christians sometimes deserve to share earthly punishment because, through false shame and love of ease, they neglected to rebuke the public wickedness around them. As for Christians whose bodies went unburied during the carnage, funeral pomp comforts the living rather than assisting the dead, whose bodily resurrection is secure in God's hands.

In Chapters 16–18, Augustine answers the cruel pagan taunt that God allowed Christian women and virgins to be violated by barbarians in Alaric's train. Augustine establishes a principle that has remained normative in Catholic moral theology ever since. Then he shows that bodily violence is solely the sin of the perpetrator: "As long as the purpose of the mind holds firm, which is the sanctification also of the body, even the body does not lose its holiness by the violence of another's lust, but the steady will of continence in the mind keeps the body holy." Consequently, it is always sinful for a woman to take her own life to save her earthly honor. Indeed, sin may never be avoided by sin. Augustine refrains from passing hasty judgment on certain early martyrs who took their own lives during persecution. At the same time, he warns Christian women never to copy the pagan example of Lucretia.

At the close of Book I, Augustine condemns the Roman ludi scenici—immodest theatrical stage-plays and pantomimes first introduced at Rome to appease the anger of the gods during a bodily pestilence. Even the pagan Pontifex Maximus Scipio Nasica, esteemed the best man in Rome, was so disgusted by their corruption that he persuaded the Senate to pull down the theater stage to prevent a pestilence of souls. Augustine sums up the contradiction of Roman paganism in a sharp syllogism. The Greeks held that if such gods must be worshipped, the actors who perform their plays must be honored. The Romans held the minor premise that such actors are infamous men who must be disenfranchised and struck off the list of voters. Christians draw the necessary conclusion that gods appeased by lewdness must never be worshipped at all.

In Book II, public pagan worship had been forbidden by imperial edict in 391. Even so, pagan sentiment lingered deeply among the Roman nobility and populace. Yet the pagan peace that critics mourned after 410 was a rotten peace. Augustine quotes the true ideal of its partisans. They wanted a state where the rich could perpetually make money to fund daily debauchery. There the strong could lord it over the weak, and where theaters resounded with cruel and base amusements. At the same time, anyone who rebuked their vices was banished as a public enemy.

Far from teaching chastity, pagan worship openly corrupted public morals. Augustine recounts what he had witnessed in his own youth at Carthage in front of the shrine of the African goddess Coelestis (Venus). There crowds packed together to watch actors exhibit every obscenity in the name of religion. Respectable pagans claimed that temple rites hid high symbolic truths taught privately to a few initiates. In response, Augustine replied: "What is creditable is hidden away, what is discreditable is open to the gaze of all (decus latet et dedecus patet)." Appealing to the noble Roman character (the descendants of the Reguli, the Scaevolas, the Scipios, and the Fabricii) Augustine declares: "Whatever praiseworthy natural qualities distinguish thee, it is only by true piety that they can be purified and made perfect; by impiety they are ruined and laid open to punishment." This clause (si quid in te laudabile naturaliter eminet) directly acknowledges that genuine natural virtues exist.

In Book III, Augustine ransacks Roman annals to prove that terrible temporal calamities afflicted Rome long before Christianity. The civil war between Marius and Sulla nearly a century before Christ shed far more senatorial blood in Rome than the Goths. He spared so many senators that the wonder was they killed any at all. Augustine quoted Book XC of Livy. Then he recalls a pre-Christian plague of locusts in North Africa whose rotting swarms on the beach caused a pestilence that killed 800,000 people in Massinissa's kingdom alone. Augustine then traces the bloody civil war of Pompey and Julius Caesar, Caesar's assassination in the Senate, and the blindness of the orator Cicero. He fostered the rise of the young Octavian (later Augustus) against Mark Antony in the hope of restoring republican liberty, only to have Octavian hand Cicero over to Antony to be murdered as the price of their alliance.

In Book IV, Augustine argues that imperial expansion is no unmixed blessing. Wicked rulers harm themselves, while they cannot spiritually harm good subjects who refuse to consent to iniquity (non nocet nisi iniquitas propria). Augustine then ridicules the swarm of specialized Roman deities catalogued by pagan authors. These include Vaticanus presiding over infants' wailings, Cunina over cradles, Collatina over hills, Vallonia over valleys, Seia, Segetia, Tutilina, and Nodotus over crops, Forculus over doors, Cardea over hinges, Limentinus over thresholds, and Cloacina over sewers. Yet Augustine also cites Varro's Antiquities recording that for the first 170 years after the founding of Rome, the Romans worshipped without any idols or images—a custom Varro judged purer than later image-worship.

In Book V, Augustine examines what caused the greatness of the Roman Empire. First, Augustine dismisses astrological horoscopes by pointing to twins conceived and born under the same stars whose lives diverge completely—such as Jacob and Esau, or a pair of twins personally known to Augustine in North Africa. There the brother served constantly away from home on the provincial governor's staff and raised a large family. At the same time, his twin sister remained at home in the country as a consecrated virgin.

Next, Augustine confronts Cicero's treatise De Divinatione on divine foreknowledge and human free will. Cicero fears that if God foreknows all future events human actions would be bound by fatalistic necessity. Then he denied divine foreknowledge in order to save human freedom. Augustine replies that both truths stand together because human wills are genuine efficient causes within the total order of causes known to God. "It does not follow that, if the order of all causes is known to God for certain, therefore there is nothing left in the power of our free will. Our very wills are in the order of causes, which order is known for certain to God, and is contained in his foreknowledge; for human wills are causes of human works." God alone is the purely active cause (quae facit, nec fit). In addition, he created rational spirits are both active and passive causes. At the same time, bodily things are passive and subject to the wills of spirits and chiefly to the will of God.

Why, then, did the one true God grant world empire to the ancient Romans? Because the early Romans—though lacking the true supernatural piety (latria) that leads to eternal life in the heavenly City—subordinated their private interests to the common weal, resisted avarice, and obeyed their laws. Moreover, he practiced civic self-sacrifice out of an ardent desire for human praise, honor, and glory. God in His justice did not leave their natural civic virtues unrewarded: "Amen, I say unto you, they have received their reward" (Matthew 6:2) in the surpassing earthly glory of the Roman Empire. At the same time, the saints endure earthly reproach for the eternal City of God. The fifth book concludes with contemporary history—Stilicho's crushing defeat in A.D. 406 of the pagan Gothic king Rhadagaisus. He had boasted that his daily sacrifices to the gods made him invincible—and with Augustine's portrait of the true happiness of Christian emperors such as Constantine and Theodosius. He ruled justly, resisted flattery, and practiced mercy not for human ostentation, but for heaven.

The story inside

Cicero examined divine foreknowledge in his treatise De Divinatione. In response, he saw no way to hold both divine foreknowledge and human free will together. Rather than surrender human freedom, he denied that God foreknows future choices. Augustine replies that Cicero's dilemma is false because God sees events in the causes that bring them about, and among those causes are human wills themselves. Our very wills are included in the order of causes known for certain to God. This is because human wills are the causes of human works. Far from destroying freedom, God's infallible foreknowledge guarantees that our wills possess the power to choose.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    The Two Cities (the Elect and the Reprobate) live intermingled on earth until the Last Judgment and are defined by two loves. Love of self unto contempt of God, and love of God unto contempt of self.

  2. 2

    The purpose of the mind holds firm without inward consent. In that case, bodily violence inflicted by another cannot destroy the holiness even of the body. Suicide is always forbidden.

  3. 3

    Divine foreknowledge does not abolish human free will. This is because God foreknows human wills precisely as free causes of human actions within the total order of causes.

  4. 4

    The early Romans suppressed private greed and served the republic out of love for human glory. Therefore, God justly rewarded their natural civic virtues with earthly empire.

Test your recall

How does Augustine define the Two Cities and their two loves, and how does he reconcile divine foreknowledge with human free will against Cicero?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

2 notes

From The City of God (De Civitate Dei), trans. Fr. Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1925). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 296–300
    “These Two Cities are made by two loves: the earthly City”
  2. 2.
    Lines 949–956
    “Our very wills are in the order of”

Location: section 1 of 5 · 20%

Display settings