Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim)

Section 3 · Saint Bonaventure

Section III · Location 3 of 5

Section 3 · Open to read

From The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) by Saint Bonaventure

Edition: The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), trans. Fr. Sabinus Mollitor, O.F.M. (1920)

The Second and Third Wings: Pity or Compassion and Patience (Chapters III–IV)

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) · Chapter 3 summary

The second and third seraphic wings (Pity and Patience) require a superior to care like a nursing mother for bodily and spiritually weak brothers. At the same time, he bears heavy cares, creeping institutional laxity (and ungrateful subjects like a roof sheltering the house from the storm).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 3 of The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) by Saint Bonaventure. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Second and Third Wings: Pity or Compassion and Patience (Chapters III–IV)” Summary of The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), by Saint Bonaventure. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-virtues-of-a-religious-superior/chapters/3#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The second wing of a religious superior is pity, or fraternal compassion. Just as love for God kindles zeal for justice, love for the brethren fills a shepherd with tender affection. A superior needs both the rod to correct wrongdoers and the staff to support the weak: "Thy rod and thy staff, they have comforted me" (Psalm 23:4; 1 Corinthians 4:21). This parallels the Good Samaritan in the Gospel. In the same way, he must pour both the sharp wine of fervent zeal (and the soothing oil of compassion into the wounds of his flock)(Luke 10:33–34).

A superior is called to be a father and a physician (never a tyrant or taskmaster who treats his brothers like slaves or beasts of burden). Two kinds of infirmity require his compassion: bodily illness and spiritual weakness.

Bodily sickness in a monastery falls into three groups:

The bedridden, who are struck down by acute or dangerous illness.

The chronically afflicted, who can move about their cells and occasionally step out, yet suffer frequent (painful attacks such as gallstones), ulcers, obesity (and similar ailments).

The weak and exhausted, who have no single disease but are worn down by old age, heavy labor (or natural frailty).

Each group must be relieved according to its need through three remedies: medicine where appropriate. Gentler rules for food, clothing, and sleep. Moreover, exemption from workshop labor, household duties, and choir attendance.

Healthy people rarely feel what a sick man endures until sickness strikes them too. Robust friars grumble that the sick exaggerate their weakness. In response, the superior must refuse to treat all invalids as hypocrites. In doing so, he remembers that God was willing to spare a whole city (of wicked men for the sake of a few just souls)(Genesis 18:23–32). The sick need greater care than the strong for three reasons. They cannot procure the necessities of life for themselves (2 Samuel 14:14). They need double help both to keep what little strength remains and to recover what was lost (Luke 19:26). Moreover, they need the comfort of seeing their brothers pity them rather than offering (them the gall of reproach and vinegar of censure)(Psalm 69:20–21; 1 Samuel 23:21).

Nor is it a waste to care for brothers who are hopelessly ill. Calculating whether a patient will recover and pay back his care belongs to worldly utility, not Christian charity. The deeper a brother's misery and helplessness, the purer is the mercy shown to him. Indeed, it is good for a superior to fall sick himself from time to time so that (like Christ our High Priest), he learns from his own pain to pity the weak (Hebrews 4:15).

Spiritual weakness also takes three forms:

Fragile beginners who lack deep devotion and easily slip into faults when tempted (1 Corinthians 11:30).

Devout but sensitive brothers who lose heart, edge toward despair, or flare into sudden (impatience and excitement when given a sharp reprimand)(Romans 15:1).

Wavering, imperfect brothers who want to do good but are buffeted against their will (by gusts of irritation, anger, sloth, lust, or intemperance)(Psalm 6:2).

To heal these souls (a superior must first cut off occasions of sin and forbid weak brothers to roam outside the house). In doing so, he remembers that Jacob's daughter Dinah was ruined when she wandered (out to see the women of the land)(Genesis 34:1–2). Second, he must spare excitable brothers harsh nagging until they calm down. Nagging an agitated man is like provoking a barking dog to bite (Colossians 3:21). Third, like a patient doctor (he must bear with simple brothers' quirks and never overdrive tender beginners beyond their strength) (heeding Jacob's warning that if tender children and ewes with young are driven too hard), the whole flock will die in a single day (Genesis 33:13; 1 Thessalonians 2:7). Against the harsh shepherds rebuked in Ezekiel 34:4, Saint Bernard counsels superiors in his 23rd Sermon on the Canticle. These include be mothers in loving and fathers in correcting, hang up the rod. In addition, he let your breasts give the milk of kindness rather than swelling (with the fever of pride)(Numbers 11:12).

The third wing of the ecclesiastical Seraph is patience. The roof of a house takes the beating of dust, rain, and wind (so the rooms inside stay clean)(and a mother hen throws herself at a hawk to shield her chicks). In the same way, a faithful superior absorbs the storms of trouble to protect his subjects.

A superior needs patience above all in three areas:

Manifold duties and cares. This parallels the Apostles who cared for both preaching and the poor (Galatians 2:9–10), Christ who fed the crowds with both truth and bread (Mark 6:35–44), Moses who could not bear the people's disputes alone (Deuteronomy 1:12–13). In the same way, a superior is weighed down by discourses, vigils, household needs, and outside business.

Slow progress and creeping abuses disguised as good: Often a superior sows much seed and sees almost nothing grow. Worse still, grave abuses creep into a religious order under the outward cloak of good. There he dares not crush them openly lest a greater good be harmed. For example, out of a desire to save more souls, houses admit more novices than they can properly support. That excess of members undermines mendicant poverty. Friars make frequent begging trips, use questionable methods to get supplies, break the Rule in receiving gifts (lose their devotion) (roam outside at will) (form forbidden familiarities) (ask penitents for presents) (flatter the rich) (enlarge landed estates) (build sumptuous palaces) (and leave scandals uncorrected). Similarly, young and inexperienced friars are promoted too early to serve as confessors, preachers, and superiors. Meanwhile, worldly brothers mistake outward respectability for true interior holiness (Psalm 119:139. Psalm 69:9).

The ingratitude and opposition of subjects. Those for whom the superior labors complain that he could do better, judge (his motives rashly, murmur, slander him, and sometimes openly resist or cunningly block him from doing his duty)(Philippians 1:23).

To stand firm, the superior puts on the triple armor of patience:

Gentle speech: He answers everyone with calm deliberation, never betraying anger in voice or face. This parallels Gideon, whose mild reply calmed the angry men of Ephraim (Judges 8:1–3. Proverbs 15:1, 18). In the same way, he knows that anger never cures anger. An impatient superior exalts his own folly (Proverbs 14:29). Becomes hated and feared, frightens timid brothers from speaking of their needs (Job 4:2). In addition, he fills the house with murmuring (Proverbs 11:29). Moreover, he turns into a "son of Belial" whom no one dares to warn or correct (1 Samuel 25:17).

Unvengeful calmness: Instead of hating those who wrong him or trying to transfer difficult (friars elsewhere, he treats them with extra kindness)(Luke 6:35). A doctor does not cure patients by running away from them. Nor does an athlete win a crown by dodging opponents.

Tireless forbearance: He keeps his two hands (eagerness in doing good and patience in bearing burdens) steady without growing weary (2 Chronicles 15:7).

These trials bless the superior in three ways. First, they cleanse him in this life from the daily stains of negligence (so he is not punished in the next)(James 3:2; 2 Samuel 7:14). Second, they humble him against the pride of office. Even King David was humble and devout while steeped in adversity. However, he fell into grave sin when success elated him (Job 33:16–19. Psalm 119:71). Third, they multiply his eternal crown like gold refined in a furnace (Wisdom 3:6. Mark 4:26–27). Even when few subjects improve, the superior must not lose heart. Each worker is rewarded according to his labor, not according to the visible harvest (1 Corinthians 3:7–8). A teacher works harder with an unruly pupil than with a docile one (and a farmer sweats harder in a stony), barren field than in rich soil. Moreover, a just Judge pays more for what costs greater toil.

The story inside

A storm hits a house, the roof catches the wind, dust, and rain so the rooms below stay dry. When a hawk dives at a brood. In response, the mother hen throws herself in its path to save her chicks. A religious superior stands in that same exposed place. Inside the cloister, he must be a nursing mother and patient doctor to friars (suffering from gallstones, old age)(or fragile tempers—never overdriving the flock as Jacob warned) (and never nagging an agitated brother like someone poking a barking dog). At the same time, he must bear the grief of seeing abuses creep in (under the name of good)(when houses admit too many novices) (beg from penitents) (flatter the rich) (and build sumptuous palaces). Yet just as a farmer who sweats in a stony field deserves higher pay (than one who reaps easy soil)(God rewards a patient shepherd for his labor rather than his visible success).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Refusing care to incurably sick brothers turns charity into worldly utility. The deeper a patient's helplessness, the purer is the mercy shown to him.

  2. 2

    Nagging an agitated brother is like provoking a barking dog to bite, and driving (weak beginners beyond their strength kills the flock in a day)(Genesis 33:13).

  3. 3

    Admitting too many members under the cloak of saving souls erodes religious poverty, multiplies (begging trips, flatters the rich)(builds sumptuous palaces) (and promotes inexperienced youths too soon).

  4. 4

    God rewards a superior according to his labor rather than his visible harvest (1 Corinthians 3:8). In doing so (he pays the farmer of a stony field and the teacher of a difficult pupil for their toil).

Test your recall

How does admitting too many members under the appearance of saving souls corrupt religious poverty, and why does God reward a superior like a farmer working a stony field?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

4 notes

From The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), trans. Fr. Sabinus Mollitor, O.F.M. (1920). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 1213–1217
    “The first class of sufferers comprises those who, because of lack of devotion or under the influence of temptations, are prone to commit faults and incur imperfections, are easily led astray by temptations, and apt to fall into sin.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 1166–1169
    “For those who are much afflicted it is a solace to see others having compassion upon them and faithfully assisting them in the endeavor to recover their health.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 1426–1429
    “is easily subverted, and how, on account of the many difficulties and obstacles impeding spiritual progress, his labors seem to be fruitless, just as when one has sown much seed and sees only a few plants growing.”
  4. 4.
    Lines 1604–1607
    “‘“‘ You shall be the sons of the Highest,” says our Lord, “ for he is kind to the ungrateful and to the evil.” 7 Since to instruct in virtue is a duty of the superior, shall he teach his vicious subjects by having them removed?”

Location: section 3 of 5 · 60%

Display settings