Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim)

Section 4 · Saint Bonaventure

Section IV · Location 4 of 5

Section 4 · Open to read

From The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) by Saint Bonaventure

Edition: The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), trans. Fr. Sabinus Mollitor, O.F.M. (1920)

The Fourth and Fifth Wings: Edification and Prudent Discretion (Chapters V–VI)

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) · Chapter 4 summary

The fourth and fifth wings (an Exemplary Life and Prudent Discretion) require a superior to teach by shared poverty and kindness rather than dry words. At the same time, he wears the high priest's twelve-jewel breastplate of discernment over observance, correction, business (and his own soul).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 4 of The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) by Saint Bonaventure. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The Fourth and Fifth Wings: Edification and Prudent Discretion (Chapters V–VI)” Summary of The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), by Saint Bonaventure. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-virtues-of-a-religious-superior/chapters/4#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The fourth wing of a religious superior is an exemplary life that edifies everyone who sees it. Teaching by words without a holy life is like daubing a stone wall (with dry mortar that has no lime)(Ezekiel 13:14) (and just as corrupt manuscripts produce corrupt copies), a bad superior forms bad subjects (Ezekiel 34:10. Sirach 10:2).

This parallels Jesus—who first practiced in deed what He later taught and washed His disciples' feet (Acts 1:1. John 13:15)—and like Gideon. He assured his warriors, "What you shall see me do, do ye the same" (Judges 7:17). In the same way, a superior must imprint Christ's likeness on his community through seven practical marks:

Sharing common food, clothing, and work. He must not feast while the brothers eat coarse food, dress better than his equals in profession (or excuse himself from common labor). A healthy superior who lives softly makes his friars effeminate. A sick superior who stubbornly refuses medicine makes sick brothers afraid to be treated. Soldiers fight bravely when their general shares the hardships of the march (1 Corinthians 9:22. Acts 1:21–22).

Humble bearing. Instead of acting like a lord, he treats his subjects as better than himself. In addition, he serves them as the youngest among them (Luke 22:26–27. Sirach 32:1).

Affability and easy access. He listens patiently and cheers the timid, seeking to be loved rather than feared. This is because voluntary obedience born of love wins far higher merit than forced obedience born of fear.

Visible poverty: His habit, books, cell, bed, utensils, and table must shun every trace (of vanity, daintiness, or singularity)(Job 41:25).

Grave and sincere speech. Avoiding vulgar or frivolous joking (which Saint Gregory warns makes a preacher's words despised) he blends gentle sweetness with the dignity that commands respect from the insolent (Psalm 25:8).

Impartial kindness. He guards against light familiarity with women or frivolous people. Moreover, in his outward manner treats every brother as a trusted friend (never showing the favoritism that made Jacob's sons hate Joseph).

Steady yet adaptable counsel. He does not change his orders from day to day on a whim, which destroys trust and obedience (1 Thessalonians 5:21. Philippians 2:14). Yet when real necessity or religious benefit calls for a change (he yields his own opinion to a greater good without obstinacy). In the same way, King Artaxerxes adapted his decrees to the needs of the times (Esther 16:9) and Saint Paul changed his travel plans for the Corinthians' spiritual profit (2 Corinthians 1:15).

A superior who seeks his own glory preaches himself rather than Christ (2 Corinthians 4:5. Galatians 4:17). By contrast, a true shepherd can say with Paul, "Be ye followers of me, as I also am of Christ" (1 Corinthians 11:1. Galatians 2:20; 4:19).

The next wing of the ecclesiastical Seraph (numbered "sixth" in line 2116 of the 1920 text. Yet fifth in order before Chapter VII treats the sixth wing, Devotion) is prudent discretion. King Solomon could ask God for anything. In response, he asked for an understanding heart to discern good and evil (1 Kings 3:9. Wisdom 6:10. Psalm 2:10).

A superior needs twofold prudence: knowing what to do and how to do it (when, where, and why). As Saint Bernard warns in Sermon 49 on the Canticle, "Cast discretion to the winds, and virtue becomes a vice":

Without prudence, zeal turns into blind rashness (Romans 10:2).

Without prudence, compassion sinks into soft sentimentality that spares the rod and ruins the child (Proverbs 13:24).

Without prudence, patience breeds contempt for authority, like timid and inexperienced King Rehoboam who could not resist rebels (2 Chronicles 13:7).

Without prudence, good example is like unsalted food that nobody relishes (Leviticus 2:13. Genesis 4:7).

In Exodus 28:15–20, the high priest entering the Holy of Holies wore upon his breast the "rational of judgment" set with four rows of three precious stones. In the same way, a superior who enters the sanctuary of pastoral care (must wear four rows of prudence on his heart)(governing regular observance, correcting sinners (managing business affairs), and ruling himself) with three jewels in each row.

Like Aaron and his sons assigning each Levite his burden (Numbers 4:19; 1 Corinthians 7:7), the superior distinguishes three grades of observance:

Precepts essential to salvation: Vows of obedience, voluntary poverty, chastity, and rules binding under grave sin. Here the superior has no power to dispense, even under threat of famine or hardship (Romans 8:35). Friars claim they cannot survive without collecting alms in ways that violate the Rule and scandalize the faithful. In response, it is far better to abandon that house altogether than to stay and give scandal (Matthew 18:6).

Heroic counsels of perfection: Extraordinary patience, deep humility, strict abstinence, and lofty prayer. A monastery is a spiritual wrestling school (palaestra) where athletes strip off everything that lets the enemy grip them (1 Corinthians 9:25). Therefore, the superior leads brothers to these heights by warm exhortation and example rather than compulsion.

Auxiliary monastic exercises: Fasting, silence, solemn choir, and bodily penances, which serve like an artist's tools (1 Timothy 4:8). Real need or utility requires. In response, a prudent superior dispenses from them readily. In doing so, he holds the golden mean between harsh rigor that alienates brothers (and careless laxity that lets discipline crumble little by little)(Sirach 19:1).

Contrite sinners. Those who quickly confess and repent after a fall should receive penance tempered with the balm of meekness (Galatians 6:1). In doing so, he satisfied God and repairing scandal without crushing the penitent.

Secretive, unproved sinners: Some conceal and excuse their fault while the poison festers inside them. Because there is neither open proof nor voluntary confession (lancing the wound with public rebuke only stirs up worse anger). The superior follows Christ—who silently tolerated Judas's hidden malice. At the same time, he gives general warnings ("Woe to that man," Matthew 26:24; 13:30. Isaiah 57:11) until Judas's crime exposed itself. Then he keeps his counsel, bars occasions of sin (and prays for God either to convert the brother or bring the truth to light).

Public, obstinate, contagious sinners: When four conditions meet (grievous public sin, obstinate hopelessness of reform, infection of others, and scandal if tolerated) the superior must take mature counsel with wise brethren. Moreover, he must cut off the putrid limb. In addition, he must cast out the leper from the camp so the house is not ruined (Galatians 5:12; 1 Corinthians 5:13. Luke 13:7. Numbers 5:2–3).

Delegating temporal administration. This parallels Christ refusing to divide an inheritance (Luke 12:13–14), Moses following Jethro's counsel (Exodus 18:19–22), and the Apostles leaving table service to deacons (Acts 6:2). In the same way, a superior entrusts temporal business to honest, unavaricious procurators—never (to a thief like Judas who carried the purse)(John 12:6).

Directing the brotherhood like the head of a body. The head does not perform a single limb's manual work but serves (as the nerve center that sees, hears, tastes)(and speaks for the whole body) (the superior watches personally over the Rule), fraternal peace. In the same way, spiritual doubts, and conscience. In doing so, he obeys God rather than men whenever human demands conflict with God's law (Acts 5:29. Hebrews 13:17).

Shunning superfluous occupations. Superiors and friars plunge into needless building projects. In response, writing books, or lawsuits, external cares gather like pus in an uncleaned (wound until they quench heavenly desire and stain the conscience with sin)(Matthew 6:34. Sirach 11:10).

A sound and pure conscience. Lest he lose his own soul while saving others (Matthew 16:26; 2 John 1:8), the superior examines his actions, omissions, and motives daily. In doing so, he seeks only to please God (Matthew 6:22–23; 1 Corinthians 1:31; 11:31). Whoever brushes dust off another inevitably gets dusty himself and must say, "Physician, heal thyself" (Luke 4:23).

The golden mean in personal conduct. He balances gravity and warmth without being a terrifying lion in his household (Sirach 4:35. Ezekiel 34:4). Then he leans toward kindness, imitating Christ whose lovable humanity draws us to His invisible divinity (Preface of the Nativity).

Seeking humble counsel and rejecting flatterers and detractors. Discretion must not be like the bodily eye that sees everything except itself (Romans 12:3). As Saint Gregory notes in his Moralia, subjects are tempted to criticize superiors. At the same time, superiors are tempted to think themselves wiser than everyone else (Proverbs 26:12). New superiors foolishly despise everything their predecessors did. Meanwhile, former superiors carp at their successors (Isaiah 33:1). A superior consults wise brethren—as Moses heeded Jethro (Exodus 18:18) and Paul conferred with Peter, James, and John at Jerusalem (Galatians 2:1–2. Sirach 32:24). Then he avoids deception, and lessens his blame if an error occurs. In addition, he receives deeper light from God. Meanwhile, firmly shutting his ears to flatterers who puff him up (Isaiah 3:12) and detractors who poison his mind against innocent brothers (Esther 16:5–6).

The story inside

Preaching virtue without living it is like daubing a stone wall with dry mortar that has no lime (or copying a book from a corrupt manuscript). Soldiers march cheerfully when they see their general eating the same rations. In doing so, he wears the same cloak, and shares the mud of the campaign. Yet even a holy example is like unsalted food. Otherwise, it is seasoned with prudent discretion—the high priest's breastplate set with four rows of three jewels. Wearing that breastplate, a wise superior knows when to stand immovable (abandoning a house rather than breaking the Rule's poverty by scandalous begging) (when to bear hidden malice in silence as Christ bore Judas until the truth came out), when to cut off a contagious rebel (and how to keep superfluous building projects), book-writing (and lawsuits from gathering like pus in the soul).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Teaching without example is like mortar without lime (Ezekiel 13:14). A superior must share the common food, habit, and labor, and show strict poverty (in his cell, clothes, and books).

  2. 2

    Without prudent discretion, virtue becomes vice: zeal turns into rashness, compassion into ruinous softness (and patience into Rehoboam's cowardly laxity).

  3. 3

    A superior has no power to dispense from essential vows. It is better to abandon a house altogether than to survive by scandalous collecting contrary to the Rule.

  4. 4

    Whoever brushes dust off others gets dusty himself. A superior must examine his own conscience daily. In addition, he must seek humble counsel like Moses and Saint Paul. Moreover, he must reject both flatterers and detractors.

Test your recall

What are the four rows of three jewels on the superior's breastplate of Prudent Discretion, and why did Christ tolerate Judas in silence before his betrayal?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

4 notes

From The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), trans. Fr. Sabinus Mollitor, O.F.M. (1920). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 1892–1894
    “The purpose of the superior’s office is to guide those committed to his care to eternal life and faithfully to lead them to merits of virtue.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 2116–2119
    ““Give therefore,” he prayed, “to thy servant an understanding heart, to judge thy people, and discern between good and evil.”+ “To you, therefore, O kings, are these my words, that you may learn wisdom, and not fall from it.”?”
  3. 3.
    Lines 2334–2337
    “In the palaestra the wrestlers were stripped to the buff and rubbed with oil, so that they could not be gripped by their opponents.”
  4. 4.
    Lines 2709–2712
    “A prudent superior should foresee the consequences of every act and carefully consider what ought to be permitted and what is expedient.”

Location: section 4 of 5 · 80%

Display settings