Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim)

Section 2 · Saint Bonaventure

Section II · Location 2 of 5

Section 2 · Open to read

From The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) by Saint Bonaventure

Edition: The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), trans. Fr. Sabinus Mollitor, O.F.M. (1920)

The First Wing: Zeal for Justice and the Fourfold Duty of Correction (Chapter II)

The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) · Chapter 2 summary

The first seraphic wing, Zeal for Justice (requires a superior to leave private spiritual comfort for twice-dyed love of God and neighbor). In doing so, he enforces divine law, Church canons, vows (and monastic discipline in right proportion while never leaving sin unpunished).

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 2 of The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim) by Saint Bonaventure. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “The First Wing: Zeal for Justice and the Fourfold Duty of Correction (Chapter II)” Summary of The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), by Saint Bonaventure. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/the-virtues-of-a-religious-superior/chapters/2#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The first spiritual wing of a director of souls is zeal for justice. This is an inward fire that cannot bear to see wrong done to God (or neighbor without protesting and seeking a remedy). A person's goodness is measured by how deeply he hates evil. In religious orders and across the Church, four classes of people are commonly called "good". Yet only the fourth is truly fit to govern souls:

Peaceful but sluggish brothers. Some do no harm, give no scandal, and live pleasantly with everyone (1 Samuel 25:15). Yet they are slow to practice active virtue (much like baptized infants who are innocent of evil without yet laboring in good works).

Moderate practitioners. A better class avoids sin and regularly practices fasting, vigils, almsgiving, prayer, chastity, and humility. Yet rests content with a fixed measure of good works without reaching for higher holiness (Ecclesiastes 3:22).

Self-contained contemplatives. A third, still better class hates sin, counts its outward works as little (1 Timothy 4:8). In addition, he longs for interior sweetness and the felt experience of God's love. Yet when these souls see others falling into bad habits and spiritual ruin, they feel no sharp grief. Like the fig tree in Jotham's parable that refused to leave its sweetness (and delicious fruit to rule over the other trees)(Judges 9:11) (they care more for their own spiritual comfort than for rescuing their brothers). In doing so, he made them unfit for office.

Apostolic shepherds aflame with twice-dyed charity: The best class burns with zeal for justice, innocence (and the salvation of souls). Like the "scarlet twice dyed" of the tabernacle (Exodus 26:1) (colored with love of God and love of neighbor) they take no comfort in their own progress unless they draw others to God with them, imitating Christ. They left His heavenly glory and took the form of a servant to save many by deed and word.

A superior acts as God's representative and must love justice while hating iniquity (Psalm 45:7). In a religious house, "justice" covers four distinct layers of obligation:

The eternal law: Pure virtues required of everyone for salvation (humility, chastity, charity, and mercy) on which hang the whole law and the prophets (Matthew 22:40).

Positive Church law. Canons, sacramental rites, and general laws enacted by Church authority for the common good (which bind clerics and laypeople according to their state).

Voluntary religious vows. Promises that no one was forced to make before entering religion (chastity, obedience, the renunciation of property, and the precepts of the Order's Rule) which become strictly binding before God once spoken aloud (Deuteronomy 23:21–23).

Monastic practices of spiritual progress: Daily customs regarding the Divine Office, work schedules, hours (of silence, food, clothing, and vigils). Salvation does not strictly depend on these customs in themselves. Even so, neglecting them mars the beauty of religious life, blocks spiritual growth, and robs neighbors of good example.

True zeal possesses a sense of spiritual proportion that grieves far more over grave sins than over minor slips. Foolish superiors turn things upside down. They see a speck in a brother's eye as a wooden beam, strain out a gnat. At the same time, they swallow a camel (Matthew 7:3. Matthew 23:24), and tithe mint and rue. At the same time, they pass over judgment and the love of God (Luke 11:42). Guided by self-will rather than the Spirit of God (such superiors punish a friar more harshly for missing a bow in choir or slipping in a minor liturgical rubric than for repeatedly slandering a brother or starting a scandalous quarrel).

To keep right proportion, a superior must guard six priorities in strict order:

The commandments of God, which come first above all else.

The inviolable precepts of holy Church.

Vowed obligations of the Rule, especially matters bound under precept.

Rooted habits of malice (avarice, pride, envy, gluttony, anger, suspicious familiarity, and disobedience) which destroy the good name of religious life and cause the faithful to blaspheme God's name (Romans 2:24). A single serious secret sin is easier to heal through private penance (than a public evil habit that has taken hold of the heart).

Fervent prayer, which feeds the religious spirit like oil in the wise virgins' lamps (Matthew 25:8). Moreover, he holds the wall of virtues together like mortar between stones. Whenever devotion cools, the whole building of religious virtue begins to crack.

External discipline and uniformity, which prevent brothers from living as they please and disturbing the house. In customs that are indifferent in themselves, a superior should encourage steady observance (without anxious scrupulosity over small exceptions)(clamping down only when habitual laxity threatens to breed broader neglect).

A superior imbued with true zeal follows five practical rules: (1) he neither does nor teaches anything wrong. (2) he never yields to pestering or deceit. (3) he never winks at unauthorized actions done behind his back. (4) he never pretends not to notice abuses when duty requires him to speak and warn. Moreover, (5) he never leaves faults unpunished. Just punishment deters the sinner from worse falls (John 5:14), cleanses him now so he escapes heavier divine wrath later (Proverbs 23:14). He also shows weak beginners to be cautious (Proverbs 19:25). He also saves the superior himself from the doom of the high priest Eli. He perished with his sons. This is because he failed to restrain them (1 Samuel 4:11–18).

No community on earth is completely free of sin—depravity appeared even among the angels (before their confirmation in grace and among Christ's own Apostles)(John 13:10). A well-ordered house differs from a lax one not because no brother ever sins. However. This is because sin is never left unpunished or allowed to spread. Secret, curable offenders may be tolerated while they are corrected with the rod of penance. In addition, he healed with the balm of prayer and encouragement. Their presence even gives good brothers occasions to grow in compassion, vigilance, humility, and patience (Galatians 6:8). However, incorrigible offenders whose malice contaminates others must be expelled so they do not ruin the community.

A superior who neglects to stop spreading abuses must answer to God under three terrible judgments:

For his own omission of duty: "A most severe judgment shall be for them that bear rule" (Wisdom 6:5).

For the sins of his subjects. Because he failed to warn and correct them, God will require their blood at his hand (Ezekiel 33:8).

For abusing his office. He used his pastoral dignity for personal honor and ease rather than for God's household. Therefore, the unprofitable servant will have his talent taken away and be cast into outer darkness (Matthew 25:28–30).

The story inside

In Jotham's ancient parable, the fig tree refused to become king of the trees. This is because it did not want to leave its own sweetness and delicious fruit. Many devout contemplatives make the same mistake when called to govern a monastery. They love quiet prayer in their cell, yet feel no grief when brothers around (them slip into slander, pride, or ruin). Others fall into the opposite folly—straining out a gnat while swallowing a camel. He does this by punishing a friar more severely for missing a bow in (choir than for tearing a brother's reputation apart). True zeal for justice keeps strict spiritual proportion, and holds the community together with the mortar of prayer. He also heals curable sinners, expels contagious rebels. In addition, he remembers that the high priest Eli perished. This is because he saw his sons' sins and stayed silent.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Personal contemplative sweetness is not enough for leadership. A superior needs twice-dyed scarlet charity that grieves over others' sins and labors for their salvation.

  2. 2

    True zeal never strains out a gnat while swallowing a camel. These include God's commandments, Church laws, vows (and public habits of malice must be weighed far above minor liturgical slips). At the same time, prayer serves as the mortar that holds all virtues together.

  3. 3

    A negligent superior who leaves spreading abuses uncorrected faces three divine judgments. For omitting his duty (Wisdom 6:5). Indeed, the blood of his subjects (Ezekiel 33:8), and for turning his office to personal comfort (Matthew 25:28–30).

Test your recall

Why is a contemplative of the third class compared to the fig tree in Judges 9:11, and what are the three judgments awaiting a superior who fails to correct his subjects?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

4 notes

From The Virtues of a Religious Superior (De Sex Alis Seraphim), trans. Fr. Sabinus Mollitor, O.F.M. (1920). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 667–670
    “God. Such are the laws that have been laid down by the Church for the general welfare, the rites for the administration of the Sacraments, and other regulations of positive law.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 540–543
    “They are, however, not kindled with fervent zeal against evil habits and against the danger of others falling into sin.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 826–829
    “allowed to live differently, but for the reason that it is more conducive to conformity of virtue and uniformity of life, lest any one live and act as he likes and thus prove a cause of disturbance to others.”
  4. 4.
    Lines 929–934
    “The good may have to suffer persecution from the wicked. They may be confounded and humbled in considering the evil ways of the bad, because they are not like them, and prompted to render thanks to Him who has protected them from becoming like the wicked.”

Location: section 2 of 5 · 40%

Display settings