Section LXXI · Location 71 of 80
Section 71 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume II, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896)
Second Part of the Second Part (Moral Compendium) — Questions CXXIII–CLX: Fortitude, Martyrdom, Magnanimity, Patience, Perseverance, Temperance, Fasting, and Chastity
Summa Theologica · Chapter 71 summary
Fortitude stands firm against the fear of bodily death (with patient endurance as its chief act and Martyrdom as its supreme perfection) supported by Magnanimity, Magnificence, Patience, and Perseverance.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 71 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part (Moral Compendium) — Questions CXXIII–CLX: Fortitude, Martyrdom, Magnanimity, Patience, Perseverance, Temperance, Fasting, and Chastity” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/71#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
In Questions CXXIII–CLX of the Secunda Secundae, Saint Thomas Aquinas treats the third and fourth Cardinal Virtues (Fortitude and Temperance) which govern our strongest passions of fear and bodily pleasure. "R. It belongs to human virtue to make a man" (lines 12332..12332) and his work accord with reason. Where vehement fear of danger would drag the will away from reason, Fortitude steps in to hold the soul steadfast. The greatest of all bodily evils is death. Therefore, Fortitude in its strictest sense deals with the dangers of death—not death in sickness or in a highway robbery sought for private gain. However, death faced in battle or in any public or private struggle undertaken to defend justice, faith, and the common good. Fortitude has two acts: curbing fear so as not to flee (endurance) and moderating daring so as not to rush in rashly (attack). Against those who think attacking is braver, Aquinas proves that steadfast endurance is the chief and harder act of Fortitude. Someone who attacks assumes he is stronger than a future danger. By contrast, someone who stands firm and endures holds his ground calmly under the weight of an already present, stronger danger. Consequently, the supreme perfection of Fortitude is Martyrdom—steadfastly enduring bodily death rather than deny the truth of faith or commit any sin against God.
Around Fortitude stand four companion virtues that deal with lesser hardships. First is Magnanimity (greatness of soul), which stretches the spirit toward great and noble works worthy of high honor, never swelling in prosperity or sinking in adversity. Opposed to Magnanimity are Presumption (attempting works beyond one's strength), Ambition (craving honors without merit or without referring them to God and the profit of others), Vainglory (seeking empty human applause), and Pusillanimity (faintheartedness, when a person refuses to attempt the great good works for which God gave him natural or supernatural talents, like the slothful servant in the Gospel who buried his master's talent in the earth). Second is Magnificence, which executes great and noble public or sacred works generously without stingy meanness. Third is Patience, which bears present sorrows calmly. As a result, grief does not break the spirit's fidelity to reason. Moreover, fourth is Perseverance, which holds fast to a good work through the weariness of a long delay until completion.
Aquinas turned to Temperance (Questions CXLI–CLX). Then he shows how this fourth cardinal virtue bridles the most vehement bodily pleasures—those of taste and touch, which nature attached to the preservation of individual life (food and drink) and the preservation of the human species (generation). The beast follows pleasure blindly. At the same time, the temperate person measures bodily pleasure by the real needs of health, work, and social decency. Temperance has two integral parts. Shamefacedness (which recoils from the disgrace inherent in base pleasures) and Honesty (which loves the spiritual beauty and proportion of a virtuous life). Regarding food, Abstinence regulates nourishment while Fasting (instituted by the Church for three ends: to bridle concupiscence of the flesh, to enable the mind to rise more freely to heavenly contemplation, and to make satisfaction for sin) binds healthy adults. At the same time, he excuses growing children, nurses mothers, the frail, and hard-working laborers whose duties would be crippled by lack of food. "R. Gluttony means inordinate appetite in eating." (lines 15131..15131) As Saint Gregory the Great notes, gluttony tempts in five ways: eating too soon, too expensively, too much, too eagerly, or too daintily. Regarding strong drink, Sobriety guards the clarity of the mind. At the same time, deliberate Drunkenness (knowingly drinking to the point of losing the use of reason) is a mortal sin because a person willfully casts away the rational helm by which he avoids sin.
Regarding the generative powers (Questions CLI–CLVI), Chastity orders the appetite to right reason, while Virginity—the perpetual purpose, sealed by vow, of abstaining from all venereal pleasure in order to devote oneself freely to contemplating divine truth and serving God—is a special virtue that excels married chastity in spiritual dignity, just as Magnificence excels ordinary Liberality. Yet Virginity is a counsel of perfection for the few, not a universal command. This is because human marriage remains honorable, holy, and necessary for the multiplication of the human race and the people of God. Outside lawful, indissoluble marriage, every deliberate act of Lust (including simple fornication) is a mortal sin. Why is even unmarried fornication between consenting persons a grave mortal sin against justice and reason? Aquinas gives a clear natural-law demonstration in Question CLIV, Article 2: unlike animals whose offspring need only mother's milk for a short time, a human child needs many years of bodily nourishment and above all long moral instruction, correction, and paternal guidance from both father and mother living together in a stable, certain bond. Therefore, using the generative faculty outside the permanent bond of marriage acts directly against the good and upbringing of human offspring. Moreover, venereal pleasure is so intense that it absorbs the lower appetite. Therefore, giving oneself over to lust breeds eight spiritual "daughters": blindness of mind, thoughtlessness, rash hastiness, inconstancy, disordered self-love, hatred of God (who forbids unlawful pleasure). In doing so, he clings to this present world, and despair of the world to come. Finally, Continence strengthens the will to resist violent passions, and Meekness calms the heat of anger. Clemency tempers the severity of exterior punishment.
The story inside
Fortitude is the cardinal virtue that strengthens the soul to stand firm against the greatest dangers—above all the danger of bodily death in a good cause. Of the two acts of fortitude—curbing fear so as not to flee (endurance) and moderating daring so as not to attack rashly—endurance is the principal and harder act, because enduring a stronger oncoming evil takes firmer strength than attacking a weaker one. The supreme act of Fortitude is Martyrdom—voluntarily enduring bodily death in witness to the truth of faith and Christian justice. Four virtues are annexed to Fortitude regarding lesser difficulties: Magnanimity (which stretches the spirit toward great and honorable works worthy of high honor, opposed by Presumption, Ambition, Vainglory, and Pusillanimity—like the servant who buried his talent out of faintheartedness); Magnificence (doing great and costly public or sacred works nobly); Patience (bearing present sorrows calmly through grace so that sadness does not break reason); and Perseverance (abiding steadfastly in a good work to the end despite its long duration, which requires the special help of divine grace).
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Fortitude stands firm against the fear of bodily death (with steadfast endurance as its principal act and Martyrdom as its crown) supported by Magnanimity, Magnificence, Patience, and Perseverance.
- 2
Temperance measures the pleasures of food and drink through Abstinence, Fasting, and Sobriety. In doing so, it excuses growing children and hard laborers from fasting when it would hinder their necessary duties.
- 3
Chastity orders generative powers to indissoluble marriage for the upbringing and moral education of children. At the same time, consecrated Virginity excels married chastity by dedicating the whole life to divine contemplation.
Test your recall
How do humility and studiousness restrain pride and disordered curiosity so that the human mind remains ordered to truth?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume II, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 12882–12885
“But his fearing nothing of these ills cannot arise from a total want of love of those goods, but only from his reckoning that the evils opposite to the goods that he loves cannot possibly come upon him.”
- 2.Lines 13686–13690
“R. Because magnanimity is about honour, it is also about glory,1 that one should make moderate use both of the one and of the other; and therefore the inordinate seeking after glory is directly opposed to magnanimity.”
- 3.Lines 15635–15639
“R. The formal and completely constituting element in virginity is the purpose of perpetual abstinence from sexual pleasure; which purpose is rendered praiseworthy by the end in view, inasmuch as it is taken up to find free scope for divine things.”
