Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 72 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section LXXII · Location 72 of 80

Section 72 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume II, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896)

Second Part of the Second Part (Moral Compendium) — Questions CLXI–CLXXXIX: Humility, Pride, Studiousness, the Contemplative and Active Lives, Bishops, and Religious Life

Summa Theologica · Chapter 72 summary

Humility and Magnanimity work together—Humility bowing before God while considering our own defects. Magnanimity attempting great works by God's gifts. By contrast, Pride is the queen of vices and the root of Adam's first sin. Modesty governs studiousness, cheerful recreation (eutrapelia), and dress.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 72 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part (Moral Compendium) — Questions CLXI–CLXXXIX: Humility, Pride, Studiousness, the Contemplative and Active Lives, Bishops, and Religious Life” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/72#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

The final questions of the Secunda Secundae (Questions CLXI–CLXXXIX) bring Saint Thomas Aquinas's moral theology to its summit. In doing so, he examines Humility, Studiousness, Modesty, the Contemplative and Active Lives, and the States of Perfection in the Church. Why do we need the virtue of Humility alongside Magnanimity? "R. There is this about arduous good, that it has" (lines 17156..17156) both an attraction that draws the spirit and a difficulty that tempts either to despair or to overreaching presumption. Magnanimity strengthens the mind against despair so that it aims at great works. At the same time, Humility restrains the mind from presuming immoderately above its measure. There is no contradiction between the two virtues. Humility makes a person think little of himself when he looks at his own nothingness and failings. Yet Magnanimity makes him attempt great things when he looks at the gifts of God, while honoring every neighbor because of the gifts of God he sees in them. Next to the theological virtues, the intellectual virtues, and Justice, Humility is the greatest of the moral virtues. This is because it clears the ground for all the others by casting out Pride. This is the inordinate appetite for one's own excellence, which resists subjection to God and was the root of Adam and Eve's first sin in Paradise.

Under the general virtue of Modesty (Questions CLXVI–CLXIX), Aquinas examines three everyday areas of life: the desire for knowledge, playful recreation, and outward dress. Studiousness rightly directs the desire for truth, whereas Curiosity sins when someone studies to puff himself up with pride, studies useless things to the neglect of his obligatory duties, seeks knowledge from forbidden demonic sources, or pries into truths beyond his capacity. In Question CLXVIII, Aquinas defends the moral necessity of playful recreation and wit—the Aristotelian virtue of Eutrapelia. A tired body needs physical rest because its strength is finite. In the same way, the human soul grows weary when stretched continuously in intense intellectual study and contemplation. Repeating the famous story of Saint John the Evangelist playing with a tame partridge (who asked a scandalized hunter why he did not carry his bow always strung, and explained that the human mind too would snap if never unbent) Aquinas shows that moderate, decent play and cheerful conversation are virtuous and necessary for human life. This holds provided that they avoid coarseness, buffoonery, and improper times. Similarly, outward dress should follow the decent custom of those with whom one lives. In doing so, he avoids both vain ostentation and slovenly affectation.

In Questions CLXXIX–CLXXXII, Aquinas compares the Active Life and the Contemplative Life. Both are holy forms of Christian life—signified in Scripture by Leah and Rachel, and by Martha and Mary—and both are directed to "God, to the end that His will may be fulfilled, and" (lines 18669..18669) His glory manifested. The Active Life uses the moral virtues to serve our neighbors in their outward necessities through works of justice and mercy. The Contemplative Life uses those same moral virtues to quiet the stormy passions of the soul. As a result, the intellect, kindled by charity, may gaze peacefully upon divine truth. Considered in itself, the Contemplative Life is simply higher and more meritorious than the purely Active Life for eight reasons given by Aristotle and ratified by Christ when He declared, "Mary hath chosen the best part, which shall not be taken away from her" (Luke 10:42). Contemplation exercises the highest faculty in us (the intellect). Deals with the highest objects (divine truths), is more continuous, more delightful, more self-sufficient, loved for its own sake, consists in divine rest. Directly loves God Himself rather than merely relieving earthly woes that will pass away. Nevertheless, in urgent necessity charity compels us to leave the quiet chamber of contemplation for a time to feed the hungry or teach the ignorant—and as Aquinas declares later in Question CLXXXVIII, Article 6, even higher than pure contemplation that keeps truth to itself is the apostolic life that contemplates divine truth and pours out the fruits of that contemplation to enlighten others. He does this by preaching and teaching (contemplata aliis tradere). In the same way, it is greater to illuminate others than merely to shine oneself.

Finally, Questions CLXXXIII–CLXXXIX examine the diversity of offices and states in the Church. Just as the human body needs eyes, hands, and feet, the spiritual beauty of the "Church from the diversity of states and conditions" (lines 19204..19204) shines forth across clergy and laity, active workers and contemplatives. Christian perfection consists essentially in Charity (loving God with our whole heart and our neighbor as ourselves, which all Christians are bound to seek) and secondarily in the evangelical counsels, which act as instruments that clear away the three great obstacles that divide the heart's affection from God. These include the craving for exterior wealth (removed by the vow of Poverty), the absorbing care of sensual pleasure and family management (removed by the vow of Perpetual Chastity), and the restless anxiety of managing one's own life (removed by the vow of Obedience, which is the greatest of the three vows because it offers to God man's highest possession—his own free will—and turns all of life into a continuous holocaust). Bishops must already possess interior perfection as shepherds who bind themselves to lay down their lives to perfect their flock. At the same time, Religious are not required to be already perfect when they enter the monastery. Rather, the Religious State is a school and hospital of spiritual training where even imperfect beginners and converted sinners can advance more surely toward charity through the rule and vows. Therefore, against critics of the Mendicant Orders (such as the Dominicans and Franciscans), Aquinas proves that religious orders devoted to study, preaching, and hearing confessions hold the highest place among all religious institutes, may lawfully live on alms. At the same time, he preached the Gospel. In addition, he may wisely welcome young aspirants into the school of Christ without endless worldly delay.

The story inside

Humility is a moral virtue annexed to temperance (modesty) that restrains the appetite from aiming immoderately at high things above one's measure, grounded in the reverent knowledge of God's majesty and our own defects. Magnanimity and Humility do not contradict each other. Magnanimity urges the soul to great works according to the gifts received from God. At the same time, Humility makes a man think little of himself in view of his own weakness and honor others according to the gifts of God in them. The theological virtues. In response, the intellectual virtues, and Justice, Humility is the greatest of the moral virtues. This is because it removes the chief obstacle to divine grace—Pride, which is the inordinate appetite for one's own excellence and the 'queen and mother of all vices.' Adam's first sin in Paradise was Pride (coveting a spiritual likeness of knowledge by his own natural power apart from God's rule) though he did not believe the serpent's literal promise of equality with God's nature. Studiousness moderates the desire for knowledge, while Curiosity sins by studying to grow proud. In doing so, he studies forbidden magic, neglecting one's duty, or studying above one's capacity. Modesty also governs bodily recreation (eutrapelia—cheerful, moderate play and wit that gives rest to the wearied mind, as Saint John the Evangelist compared to unbending a bow) and simplicity of outward dress.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Humility and Magnanimity work in harmony—Humility bowing before God. At the same time, Magnanimity attempts great works by His gifts. Moreover, Modesty governs studiousness, cheerful recreation (eutrapelia), and dress.

  2. 2

    The Contemplative Life is in itself higher and more meritorious than the purely Active Life. At the same time, the highest apostolic vocation contemplates divine truth and hands on the fruits of contemplation to others.

  3. 3

    Christian perfection consists essentially in Charity and is trained in the Religious State through the three vows of poverty, chastity, and obedience. Here preaching and teaching orders hold the highest rank among religious institutes.

Test your recall

Why is the contemplative life inherently more excellent than the active life, while the mixed apostolic life of preaching and teaching from contemplation surpasses simple action?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume II, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 17315–17319
    “But if you do what you ought to do, and others take thence occasion to sin, that is not imputable to your humble behaviour: because you have given no scandal, however much another may be scandalized.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 18151–18155
    “And therefore, when the mind exerts itself beyond its measure, it labours and is fatigued thereby, especially because in the operations of the soul the body labours also, inasmuch as the intellectual soul uses powers that work by means of bodily organs.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 19532–19535
    “Now in him who is working towards an end, it is not a necessary condition that he should have already reached the end: what is requisite is that he should be taking some way that leads to the end.”

Location: section 72 of 80 · 90%

Display settings