Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 70 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section LXX · Location 70 of 80

Section 70 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume II, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896)

Second Part of the Second Part (Moral Compendium) — Questions LXXX–CXXII: Religion, Prayer, Sacrifice, Vows, Oaths, Obedience, Gratitude, Truth, and Liberality

Summa Theologica · Chapter 70 summary

Religion is the highest of the moral virtues, uniting interior devotion and prayer with exterior adoration, sacrifice, and vows. Moreover, doing a good work under a vow is more meritorious. This is because it consecrates both the faculty of the will and the act to God, like giving both the tree and its fruit.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 70 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part (Moral Compendium) — Questions LXXX–CXXII: Religion, Prayer, Sacrifice, Vows, Oaths, Obedience, Gratitude, Truth, and Liberality” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/70#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

In Questions LXXX–CXXII of the Secunda Secundae, Saint Thomas Aquinas examines the family of virtues annexed to Justice. A virtue annexed to justice agrees with justice in paying a debt due to another person, but falls short of strict commutative justice in one of two ways. Either because the debt is so great that we can never return an equal equivalent—as in our debt to God (Religion), and to our parents and country (Piety). Above all, this applies to those in authority (Observance and Obedience). Or, because the debt is a moral duty of decency rather than a strict legal claim, as in Gratitude, Truthfulness, Affability, and Liberality.

At the summit of all moral virtues stands Religion, which renders to God the worship and honor due to Him as the First Principle of the creation and governance of all things. Its chief interior act is Devotion: "R. Devotion ordinarily and in the first place" (lines 6920..6920) signifies a prompt readiness of the will to hand oneself over to whatever belongs to the service of God. Devotion is kindled by meditating on two truths: first, God's infinite goodness and loving benefits (which awaken love), and second, our own human weakness and shortcomings (which banish pride and compel us to lean on God). The second interior act of Religion is Prayer. Through this, we lift our minds to God—not to inform Him of what He does not know or to bend His unchangeable eternal plan. However, to obtain what God from all eternity has decreed to grant specifically through our prayers. From interior devotion and prayer flow the exterior acts of Religion. Bodily kneeling and vocal praise (which we use not because God needs bodily signs, but to stir up our own hearts through the union of body and soul); outward Sacrifice (offered to God alone to signify the interior offering of the contrite spirit); Tithes and Oblations; Vows; and Oaths. In Question LXXXVIII, Article 6, Aquinas explains why doing a good work under a Vow (such as fasting or living in chastity and obedience) is more meritorious than doing the exact same work without a vow. A vow is an act of the highest moral virtue, Religion. It binds the will immovably to the good. Moreover, just as someone who gives a friend a fruit tree with all its fruit gives more than someone who gives only the fruit, so one who vows a good work offers to God not only the deed. However, the very faculty and liberty of his will.

Questions XCII–C examine the sins that corrupt Religion. Superstition sins by offering divine worship either to whom it ought not or in a manner it ought not. Idolatry offers supreme adoration to creatures. By contrast, when Christians honor the crucifix or sacred images, "His image is to be adored with the adoration of" (lines 9018..9018) latria only as referred to the Person of Christ Himself, just as honoring the king's robe honors the king. At the same time, images of the saints receive the lower reverence of dulia. Divination (trying to foretell future events that depend on free will through necromancy, auguries, judicial astrology, or lots) is always a mortal sin because it usurps God's knowledge and involves an explicit or tacit pact with demons. Even so, natural science may lawfully predict eclipses, droughts, or illnesses from physical causes. Perjury (calling God to witness a lie) is always a mortal sin of contempt toward God. Sacrilege profanes consecrated persons, churches, or vessels. Moreover, Simony (buying or selling spiritual graces, sacraments, or church offices for money, political favors, or flattery) is a detestable sin against the Holy Spirit.

Piety turns to our debts toward fellow human beings (Questions CI–CXXII). Then he commands us to honor and assist our parents and our country. Aged or sick parents are in such grave need that they cannot live without their child's personal care. In that case, the child's duty of filial piety takes precedence even over entering religious life. Next comes Obedience to legitimate superiors. Aquinas carefully defines the boundaries of human obedience in Question CIV. A human superior judges only outward actions while God alone beholds the heart. Therefore, a subject is bound to obey his superior in outward duties that belong to the rule of that community (such as military service for a soldier or monastic observance for a religious). However, in what pertains to the interior movement of the will or the natural preservation and marriage of the body, man is not subject to man, but to God alone—thus neither a slave nor a child is bound to obey a master or parent regarding whether to marry or preserve virginity. Moreover, a subject must never obey a command that contradicts God's law or the command of a higher authority.

After Obedience come Gratitude (which repays a benefactor freely and generously with the heart: "R. About the ungrateful person two things are" (lines 10583..10583) to be considered, first that every sin involves ingratitude toward God, and second that forgetting a benefactor's kindness is a special moral fault), Truthfulness (which speaks and lives without falsehood, hypocrisy, or boasting—teaching that every deliberate lie is wrong because speech was instituted by nature to signify what is in the mind, though it is lawful and wise to hide the truth prudently under silence), Affability (courtesy and friendliness in daily companionship), and Liberality (which uses wealth freely for good purposes without falling into Covetousness or foolish Prodigality). Finally, Question CXX crowns the treatise on Justice with Equity (Epikeia). Human lawmakers frame general rules for what happens in the majority of cases. Therefore, an unexpected emergency can arise where keeping the literal wording of a statute would injure the common good (such as refusing to return a madman's sword when he demands it to commit murder, or opening a besieged city's gates against the letter of a peacetime rule to save the city's defenders). In such cases, Equity is a higher rule of justice that sets aside the bare letter of the law in order to fulfill the lawgiver's true intention for justice and the common good.

The story inside

Virtues annexed to justice agree with justice in rendering what is due to another, but fall short either of full equality (because we can never repay all we owe to God, parents, or superiors) or of strict legal debt (as in gratitude, truthfulness, and liberality). First and highest among all moral virtues is Religion, which renders due worship and service to God as the First Principle of creation and government. Its interior acts are Devotion (a prompt readiness of will to give oneself to God's service, kindled by meditation on God's goodness and our own weakness) and Prayer, which lifts the mind to God—not to change His eternal plan. However, to fulfill what God has decreed to grant through our prayers. In doing so, he asked unconditionally for spiritual goods and conditionally for temporal goods, and prayed even for enemies. Its exterior acts are Adoration (using bodily kneeling and vocal praise to stir the interior spirit), Sacrifice (offered outwardly to God alone as a sign of interior self-offering), Oblations and Tithes, Vows (solemn promises made to God concerning a better good, which make a good work more meritorious by consecrating the will itself,like giving the tree with its fruit), and Oaths (calling God to witness in truth, judgment, and justice).

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Religion is the highest moral virtue, uniting interior devotion and prayer with exterior worship, sacrifice, and vows—which consecrate both the will and the deed to God like giving the tree with its fruit.

  2. 2

    Idolatry, divination of free future acts, perjury, sacrilege, and simony violate Religion. At the same time, filial Piety and Obedience have clear moral limits under God's law and natural human dignity.

  3. 3

    Truthfulness forbids every deliberate lie while permitting prudent silence, and Liberality governs the right use of wealth. Equity (epikeia) follows the higher spirit of the law when literal compliance in an emergency would harm the common good.

Test your recall

Why does the highest act of fortitude consist in patiently enduring martyrdom for truth and justice rather than in aggressive attack?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Aquinas Ethicus: The Moral Teaching of St. Thomas, Volume II, trans. Father Joseph Rickaby, S.J. (1896). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 6487–6488
    “Lord for all the things that He has rendered to me?"1 Annexed in this way to justice is religion.”
  2. 2.
    Lines 8188–8192
    “And therefore where the case is plain, the Prelate's dispensation would not excuse from blame; for instance, if a Prelate were to dispense a person from a vow of entering religion, without there being any apparent obstacle in the way of its fulfilment.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 9732–9733
    “St. Thomas quotes from memory, not quite accurately. The sentiment must be checked by what is said below, q. 168. arts. 2. and 4.”

Location: section 70 of 80 · 88%

Display settings