Skip to content
Atlas of Saints

Summa Theologica

Section 43 · Saint Thomas Aquinas

Section XLIII · Location 43 of 80

Section 43 · Open to read

From Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas

Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)

Second Part of the Second Part — Continence, Incontinence, Clemency, Meekness, Anger, Cruelty, and Modesty (Questions 155–160)

Summa Theologica · Chapter 43 summary

Continence is the virtue by which the rational will resists vehement disordered passions. By contrast, full temperance brings peace even to the sensitive appetite. A person who sins from weakness (incontinence) is less wicked than one who sins from deliberate malice (intemperance). This is because the incontinent person repents as soon as the passion passes.

Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 43 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.

Cite this summary

Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Continence, Incontinence, Clemency, Meekness, Anger, Cruelty, and Modesty (Questions 155–160)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/43#atlas-answer

Section breakdown

Questions 155 through 160 turn to the potential parts of temperance—virtues that observe the moderation of temperance in secondary matters that are less difficult to master than the pleasures of touch. First, continence (Questions 155–156) resides in the rational will when a person still experiences vehement disordered desires in the sensitive appetite yet stands firm by reason and refuses to yield to them. Though less perfect than full temperance (which has already quieted the sensitive appetite), continence is a real virtue, while incontinence sins through weakness when passion overwhelms practical judgment. Second, clemency and meekness (Questions 157–159) moderate the impulse to punish. Meekness curbs the inner passion of anger. At the same time, clemency softens external punishment according to right reason, opposed to sinful wrath and cruelty (savagery that exceeds just measure in punishing). Question 160 introduces modesty, which moderates four lesser desires. These include the desire for personal excellence (humility), the desire for knowledge (studiousness), bodily movements and recreation, and outward dress.

In Questions 155–156, Thomas Aquinas locates continence in the rational will that stands firm against vehement concupiscence. Moreover, he proves that the intemperate person who chooses evil on principle is worse than the incontinent person who yields to sudden passion. Question 155 distinguishes the continent person (who resists strong evil desires by the power of the will) from the fully temperate person. In Questions 157–159, Aquinas distinguishes meekness (which moderates internal anger) from clemency (which mitigates external punishment). Defends righteous anger directed against vice. Moreover, he condemns cruelty as hardness of heart in punishing beyond fault.

In Question 157, meekness and clemency restrain anger and harsh punishment while making the soul master of itself. In Question 160, Aquinas classifies modesty as a potential part of temperance governing four spheres. These include movement of the mind toward excellence (humility), desire for knowledge (studiousness), bodily actions and play, and outward apparel. Question 158 examines the passion of anger and distinguishes righteous indignation from the vice of wrath. Anger is lawful and praiseworthy ('zealous anger') when it serves right reason against sin. However, he becomes sinful when it seeks unjust vengeance or exceeds due measure.

The story inside

Wait—did not Jesus declare 'Learn of Me, because I am meek and humble of heart'? Some readers concluded from those words that any movement of anger is always a sin. Following Saint John Chrysostom, Aquinas corrects that mistake in Question 158, Article 8. The sensitive appetite should follow reason in desiring what is good. In the same way, it should also rise up to resist what is contrary to reason. Someone sees God's honor outraged or a neighbor unjustly harmed and feels no indignation at all. In response, his lack of anger comes from a lax, defective will that does not care passionately about justice. Chrysostom warns that unreasonable patience sows the seeds of vice and invites the wicked to do worse. True meekness never extinguishes righteous zeal, but keeps anger wholly obedient to reason's measure. True meekness is not indifferent passivity toward evil. It is strength that harnesses indignation under the rule of reason and justice.

Lessons worth keeping

  1. 1

    Continence is the virtue by which the rational will resists vehement disordered passions. By contrast, full temperance brings peace even to the sensitive appetite.

  2. 2

    A person who sins from weakness (incontinence) is less wicked than one who sins from deliberate malice (intemperance). This is because the incontinent person repents as soon as the passion passes.

  3. 3

    Meekness moderates the internal passion of anger according to right reason. At the same time, clemency moderates external punishment through sweetness of affection.

  4. 4

    Anger is lawful and praiseworthy ('zealous anger') when it serves right reason against sin. However, he becomes sinful when it seeks unjust vengeance or exceeds due measure.

Test your recall

What is the difference between a continent person and a fully temperate person?

Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.

Notes & sources

3 notes

From Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.

  1. 1.
    Lines 7490–7494
    “We must next consider the potential parts of temperance, (i) continence; (2) clemency; (3) modesty. Under the first head we must consider continence and incontinence. With regard to continence there are four points of inquiry: (i) Whether continence is a virtue? (2) What is its matter?”
  2. 2.
    Lines 8464–8468
    “Obj. 2. Further, Virtue is destroyed by excess and decrease. But both clemency and meekness consist in a certain decrease; for clemency decreases punishment, and meekness decreases anger. Therefore neither clemency nor meekness is a virtue.”
  3. 3.
    Lines 8908–8911
    “Obj. 2. Further, In every sin there is conversion to some mutable good. But in anger there is conversion not to a mutable good, but to a person's evil. Therefore anger is not a sin.”

Location: section 43 of 80 · 54%

Display settings