Section XLII · Location 42 of 80
Section 42 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — Chastity, Perpetual Virginity, Lust, and the Six Species of Lust (Questions 151–154)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 42 summary
Chastity orders sexual power according to right reason. At the same time, spiritual chastity preserves the soul's fidelity to God against delight in forbidden things. Perpetual virginity consecrated to God is more excellent than marriage not because marriage is evil. However, because virginity frees the heart for undivided contemplation of divine things.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 42 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Chastity, Perpetual Virginity, Lust, and the Six Species of Lust (Questions 151–154)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/42#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Questions 151 through 154 examine the moderation of venereal pleasures through chastity and perpetual virginity, contrasted with the capital vice of lust (`luxuria`) and its six species. Chastity chastens the venereal appetite so that it obeys right reason, either within faithful marriage for the rearing of children or in continence. At the same time, spiritual chastity keeps the mind from delighting in unlawful union with creatures against God's order. Perpetual virginity (Question 152) is a distinct special virtue related to chastity as magnificence is related to liberality. It is the firm purpose, sealed by vow, of abstaining perpetually from all venereal pleasure in order to have leisure for contemplating divine truth. Virginity does not condemn marriage (which is good) but prefers the better spiritual good of undivided devotion to God. Conversely, lust (Questions 153–154) violates the right order of human generation and produces blindness of mind, rashness, self-love, and hatred of God across its six species. These include simple fornication, adultery, incest, seduction, rape, and the unnatural vice.
In Questions 151–152, Thomas Aquinas teaches that virginity resides formally in the soul's perpetual resolution to abstain from venereal pleasure for the sake of divine contemplation. As a result, bodily violence suffered without consent never destroys a virgin's crown. In Question 152, the formal essence of virginity resides in the unbroken purpose of the soul rather than mere bodily integrity alone. In Question 153, Aquinas demonstrates that lust is a capital vice whose vehement bodily pleasure absorbs the soul's attention and generates blindness of mind, rashness, thoughtlessness, inconstancy, self-love, and hatred of God.
Question 154 distinguishes the six species of lust according to the ways they violate right reason and justice. In Question 154, Aquinas proves that simple fornication is a mortal sin. This is because it injures the common good of human children who require the determinate, lifelong care of both father and mother in marriage. Question 154 analyzes why adultery sins doubly against both chastity and the fidelity of marriage required for the good of offspring. Unbridled lust darkens practical prudence more than any other bodily passion, breeding blindness of mind, rashness, inconstancy, and hatred of God.
The story inside
During the Roman persecutions, pagan magistrates threatened Christian virgins such as Saint Agnes and Saint Lucy with forced violation in brothels. In doing so, he hopes to rob them of their virginity. In Question 152, Article 1, Aquinas cites Saint Augustine and the famous reply of Saint Lucy to the tyrant Paschasius: 'If you cause me to be violated against my will, my chastity will win for me a double crown.' Aquinas explains the moral truth behind her words. Bodily integrity is only the material side of virginity. By contrast, its formal soul is the firm, unyielding resolution of the will never to consent to unlawful pleasure. What happens to the body by external violence without any inward consent cannot stain the soul or take away its virtue. Virtue and sin reside in the free consent of the will. No external violence can rob an unyielding soul of its purity before God.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Chastity orders sexual power according to right reason. At the same time, spiritual chastity preserves the soul's fidelity to God against delight in forbidden things.
- 2
Perpetual virginity consecrated to God is more excellent than marriage not because marriage is evil. However, because virginity frees the heart for undivided contemplation of divine things.
- 3
Simple fornication is always a mortal sin because human children require the stable, lifelong partnership of father and mother for their nourishment and moral education.
- 4
Unbridled lust darkens practical prudence more than any other bodily passion, breeding blindness of mind, rashness, inconstancy, and hatred of God.
Test your recall
Why does Aquinas argue from natural reason that sex outside of marriage (simple fornication) is a grave moral wrong even when neither partner is married to someone else?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 4616–4619
“We must next consider chastity: (i) The virtue itself of chastity: (2) virginity, which is a part of chastity: (3) lust, which is the contrary vice. Under the first head there are four points of inquiry: (i) Whether chastity is a virtue?”
- 2.Lines 5555–5558
“We must next consider the vice of lust which is opposed to chastity: (i) Lust in general; (2) its species. Under the first head there are five points of inquiry: (i) What is the matter of lust? (2) Whether all copulation is unlawful?”
- 3.Lines 6508–6512
“Obj. 2. Further, Fornication is stated to be a mortal sin as being prejudicial to the good of the future child's begetting and upbringing. But these are not affected by kisses and touches or blandishments. Therefore there is no mortal sin in these.”
