Section XLI · Location 41 of 80
Section 41 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — The Nature of Temperance, Shamefacedness, Honesty, Abstinence, Fasting, Gluttony, Sobriety, and Drunkenness (Questions 141–150)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 41 summary
Temperance governs the pleasures of touch in food, drink, and sex according to the rule of right reason and the needs of life. Refusing pleasures needed to preserve health and perform one's duties is not virtue, but the vice of insensibility.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 41 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — The Nature of Temperance, Shamefacedness, Honesty, Abstinence, Fasting, Gluttony, Sobriety, and Drunkenness (Questions 141–150)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/41#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
Thomas Aquinas opens the Treatise on Temperance in the Secunda Secundae by defining temperance as the cardinal virtue that moderates the concupiscible appetite regarding the sharpest bodily desires and pleasures—those of the sense of touch in food, drink, and sexual union, which exist to preserve individual life and the human species. Its rule is the true need of human life governed by right reason. By contrast, the opposing vices are insensibility (rejecting pleasures necessary for health and duty) and intemperance (which is peculiarly disgraceful because it subjects human reason to beastly pleasures and extinguishes the light of prudence). Its integral parts are shamefacedness (the praiseworthy recoil from disgraceful acts) and honesty, the spiritual beauty of virtue. Regarding food and drink, temperance unfolds into abstinence and fasting (which bridle the flesh, lift the mind to contemplation, and satisfy for sin, while sparing growing children, the sick, and nursing or pregnant women) against the cinco daughters of gluttony, and sobriety against voluntary drunkenness.
In Questions 141–145, Thomas Aquinas defines temperance as a cardinal virtue moderating pleasures of touch according to the needs of life, and identifies shamefacedness and honesty (spiritual beauty) as its two integral parts. Question 141 investigates how right reason measures temperance according to the true necessities of human life and station. In Questions 146–148, Aquinas teaches that abstinence and fasting bridle concupiscence and satisfy for sin while exempting children, the infirm, and laborers. Moreover, he separates the five ways gluttony disorders appetite (`praepropere, laute, nimis, ardenter, studiose`).
Question 146 transitions from the integral parts of temperance (shamefacedness and honesty) to its species: abstinence, sobriety, and chastity. In Questions 149–150, Aquinas shows that sobriety moderates intoxicating drink so as to preserve the use of reason. That knowing and voluntary drunkenness is a mortal sin. Question 148 analyzes gluttony as a capital vice. Moreover, he traces its five daughters: dullness of mind, unseemly joy, loquacity, buffoonery, and uncleanness. Gluttony consists not merely in the quantity of food. However, in disordered desire (seeking food too sumptuously, too daintily, too much, too hastily, or too eagerly). At the same time, voluntary drunkenness is a mortal sin because it deprives a person of the use of reason.
The story inside
Some overzealous ascetics imagined that the more a person starves or ruins his bodily health, the holier he becomes. In Question 142, Article 1, Aquinas firmly rejects that error by quoting Saint Jerome. It makes no difference whether you take a long time or a short time to kill yourself, and offering God the stolen goods of a ruined body is an offense against reason. The human body is the necessary instrument of the soul for serving God and neighbor. Therefore, refusing the nourishment and care required to keep the body healthy for one's duties is the vice of 'insensibility.' Even when saints practice severe penance, they must preserve the strength required for their vocation. True temperance cares wisely for the body as the servant of the soul, avoiding both luxury and self-destructive neglect.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Temperance governs the pleasures of touch in food, drink, and sex according to the rule of right reason and the needs of life.
- 2
Refusing pleasures needed to preserve health and perform one's duties is not virtue, but the vice of insensibility.
- 3
Ecclesiastical fasting curbs concupiscence, elevates the mind to God, and satisfies for sins. Yet he binds with wise exceptions for age, sickness, and heavy labor.
- 4
Gluttony consists not merely in the quantity of food. However, in disordered desire (seeking food too sumptuously, too daintily, too much, too hastily, or too eagerly). At the same time, voluntary drunkenness is a mortal sin because it deprives a person of the use of reason.
Test your recall
What are the five ways in which gluttony disorders the desire for food according to Gregory the Great and Aquinas?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 141–170: Treatise on Temperance, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 274–277
“For no virtue goes against the inclination of nature, since there is in us a natural aptitude for virtue, as stated in Ethic, ii. I. Now temperance withdraws us from pleasures to which nature inclines, according to Ethic, ii. 3, 8.”
- 2.Lines 2112–2113
“But virtue does not consist in external wealth. Therefore honesty is not the same as virtue.”
- 3.Lines 3538–3542
“Besides this there is another, the sensitive appetite, and it is in the concupiscence of this appetite that the vice of gluttony consists. Hence the first movement of gluttony denotes inordinateness in the sensitive appetite, and this is not without sin.”
