Section XL · Location 40 of 80
Section 40 · Open to readFrom Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas
Edition: Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 101–140: Piety, Observance, and the Treatise on Fortitude, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922)
Second Part of the Second Part — Presumption, Ambition, Vainglory, Pusillanimity, Magnificence, Patience, Perseverance, the Gift of Fortitude, and the Precepts of Fortitude (Questions 130–140)
Summa Theologica · Chapter 40 summary
Pusillanimity (faintheartedness) is a sin because it buries the talents God gave a person and refuses to attempt the good works within one's power. Vainglory seeks human applause without referring honor to God's glory or the spiritual profit of one's neighbor.
Atlas of Saints wrote this summary of section 40 of Summa Theologica by Saint Thomas Aquinas. It uses our own words. It is not a quotation from the book.
Cite this summary
Atlas of Saints. “Second Part of the Second Part — Presumption, Ambition, Vainglory, Pusillanimity, Magnificence, Patience, Perseverance, the Gift of Fortitude, and the Precepts of Fortitude (Questions 130–140)” Summary of Summa Theologica, by Saint Thomas Aquinas. https://www.atlasofsaints.com/writings/summa-theologica/chapters/40#atlas-answer
Section breakdown
The final eleven questions of the volume examine the vices opposed to magnanimity and the remaining three potential parts of fortitude: magnificence, patience, and perseverance. Opposed to magnanimity by excess are presumption (attempting works beyond one's God-given power), ambition (desiring honor without reference to God or the common good), and vainglory (seeking empty human praise, a capital vice that breeds disobedience, boasting, hypocrisy, contention, obstinacy, discord, and love of novelties). Opposed by defect is pusillanimity—shrinking like the servant who buried his talent from the noble works one has the power to accomplish. Magnificence (Questions 134–135) directs the execution of great and costly public or sacred works without being deterred by large expense. Patience (Question 136) guards the soul from being broken by sorrow amidst daily adversity. At the same time, perseverance (Questions 137–138) abides steadfastly in a virtuous work through long duration until the end, crowned by the Holy Spirit's Gift of Fortitude (Question 139), which banishes all anxiety through unshakeable confidence in eternal life.
In Questions 130–133, Thomas Aquinas analyzes the four vices opposed to magnanimity. These include presumption, ambition, vainglory (a capital vice), and pusillanimity (shrinking from the great works proportionate to one's God-given ability, like the servant who buried his talent). In Question 131, honor is desired virtuously only when acknowledged as God's gift and used to benefit others. In Questions 134–136, Aquinas defines magnificence as the virtue of executing great and costly works (above all for divine worship and the common good) and patience as the virtue that preserves the good of reason against being crushed by sorrow.
Question 135 refutes the claim that petty stinginess (`parvificentia`) is virtuous, contrasting it with magnificence. In Questions 137–140, Aquinas teaches that perseverance overcomes the weariness of long duration in doing good (contrasted with effeminacy and pertinacity), that final perseverance unto death requires special divine assistance, and that the Gift of Fortitude perfects the soul in the fourth beatitude. In Question 137, while habitual grace gives the power to perform individual virtuous acts, final perseverance until death requires the continual help of God's guiding grace. Patience prevents daily sorrow from breaking the spirit. At the same time, perseverance endures the weariness of a long timeline until the good work is completed, aided by habitual and actual grace.
The story inside
People easily recognize that presumptuous pride (trying to climb higher than one's ability) is a sin. Yet in Question 133, Aquinas warns that the opposite extreme, pusillanimity or 'smallness of soul', can be just as dangerous. God endows a person with wisdom, learning, or leadership capable of accomplishing great good for the Church or the community, and that person shrinks back out of lazy timidity or false modesty. In response, he imitates the wicked servant in the Gospel who hid his master's talent in the earth. Just as refusing to heal a sick neighbor when you have the medicine is a sin against charity, refusing to stretch your soul to the noble works proportionate to the gifts God gave you is a sin against the natural law of growth in virtue. False modesty that buries God-given gifts is not humility. True virtue uses every talent courageously for God and neighbor.
Lessons worth keeping
- 1
Pusillanimity (faintheartedness) is a sin because it buries the talents God gave a person and refuses to attempt the good works within one's power.
- 2
Vainglory seeks human applause without referring honor to God's glory or the spiritual profit of one's neighbor.
- 3
Magnificence belongs to fortitude because it undertakes great and noble works (especially for divine worship and the common good) without shrinking from heavy expense.
- 4
Patience prevents daily sorrow from breaking the spirit. At the same time, perseverance endures the weariness of a long timeline until the good work is completed, aided by habitual and actual grace.
Test your recall
Why is pusillanimity (faintheartedness) a sin if the fainthearted person is merely avoiding high positions and great tasks?
Answer from memory first. Then check the summary and lessons above.
Notes & sources
3 notesFrom Summa Theologica, Second Part of the Second Part, Questions 101–140: Piety, Observance, and the Treatise on Fortitude, trans. Fathers of the English Dominican Province (1922). Line numbers show where each passage appears in the digitized text.
- 1.Lines 11929–11932
“On the contrary, It is written (Ecclus. xxxvii. 3): 0 wicked presumption, whence earnest thou? and a gloss answers: From a creature s evil will. Now all that comes of the root of an evil will is a sin. Therefore presumption is a sin.”
- 2.Lines 12792–12795
“X. 15). But pusillanimity does not proceed from pride, since the proud man sets himself above what he is, while the fainthearted man withdraws from the things he is worthy of. Therefore pusillanimity is not a sin.”
- 3.Lines 13586–13589
“Obj. 3. Further, The fruits differ from the virtues, as stated above (L-IL, Q. LXX., A. i, ad 3). But patience is reckoned among the fruits (Gal. v. 22). Therefore patience is not a virtue.”
